Opens in a new tab
Back to Sanibel

Sanibel · East Gulf Drive · 33957

Loggerhead Cay Condos for Sale in Sanibel, FL

Loggerhead Cay condos for sale: 168 two-bedroom Gulf-front units in five buildings at 979 East Gulf Drive, 8 recorded county sales in 12 months at a $750,000 median, weekly rental rules, the Ian rebuild, flood zones, taxes and the checks to run before an offer. Updated November 2026.

Aerial view of Loggerhead Cay at 979 East Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957: two rows of long four-story condominium buildings running from East Gulf Drive toward the Gulf beach, with a pool and lawn between them, each building point marked with a white ring

Loggerhead Cay is a 168-unit Gulf-front condominium at 979 East Gulf Drive, Sanibel, ZIP 33957, in the City of Sanibel, Lee County, on the east end of the island. Five four-story buildings stand in two rows that run from the road down to the beach, with a big pool and a lawn between them. It is one of the island condominiums we track for our Sanibel homes for sale guide.

Aerial view of Loggerhead Cay at 979 East Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957: two rows of long four-story condominium buildings running from East Gulf Drive toward the Gulf beach, with a pool and lawn between them, each building point marked with a white ring
Loggerhead Cay from above, north at the top. White rings mark the five building points and white dots the two common-element points from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll; no parcel outline is drawn. Aerial: USDA NAIP via USGS The National Map (public domain); capture date not confirmed.

Lee County recorded 8 qualified Loggerhead Cay sales in the 12 months to October 21, 2026, the newest date in the county sale index, from $660,000 to $950,000 at a $750,000 median. Every one of the 168 units is the same two-bedroom, two-bath flat of 1,184 heated square feet on the county roll, so the spread in price comes from the building, the floor, the view and the finish. Below are those sales and the five decades behind them, the buildings, the costs, the weekly rental rules, the flood and storm record and the checks to run before you write an offer.

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group agents. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.

Key takeaways for Loggerhead Cay condo buyers

These points rest on the Lee County Property Appraiser's November 2026 parcel roll and sale records, the state condominium registry, Lee County map layers, the FEMA flood panel, City of Sanibel records and island news. The sections further down give the detail, and where a fact could not be pinned down we say so.

  • Loggerhead Cay has 168 units in five four-story buildings, every one a two-bedroom, two-bath flat of 1,184 heated square feet on the county roll.
  • Qualified county sales in the 12 months to October 21, 2026 ran from $660,000 to $950,000, with a $750,000 median on 8 sales.
  • Phase I opened in 1974 and the last building was finished in 1976, so every building is about 50 years old.
  • The complex sits in Sanibel's Resort Housing District, where stays shorter than four weeks are allowed; rental listings advertise a seven-night minimum.
  • Hurricane Ian gutted every first-floor unit in 2022, and owners moved back in December 2023.
  • FEMA's panel puts the two Gulf-end buildings in a VE zone; the three buildings nearer the road sit landward of that line.
  • The association does not publish its budget, so the monthly fee is known only from listing text until you read the estoppel certificate.

Loggerhead Cay condos for sale right now

Open the current Loggerhead Cay listings with the links below, filtered to the MLS development name LOGGERHEAD CAY CONDO in Sanibel. With about 8 qualified sales a year among 168 units, a new listing is worth reading against the recorded prices further down the page. Data updated: November 2026.

A unit that shows as active in a feed may already be under contract, since feeds refresh through the day.

What a 979 East Gulf Drive listing tells you

Every unit shares the street number 979, and the unit number follows it. The county places units 101 to 193 in Building 1, 201 to 283 in Building 2, and the lettered units C301 to C383, D401 to D483 and E501 to E593 in Buildings C, D and E. Knowing the building tells you how close to the Gulf the unit sits before you see it.

Reading the last digit

Across the roll the last digit of a unit number runs from 1 to 4: 47 units end in 1, 47 in 2, 47 in 3 and 27 in 4. Units 241 and 431 are marketed as ground level, which fits reading the last digit as the floor. That reading is not confirmed against the condominium plat, so ask which floor a unit is on.

Comparing an ask with the record

Because every unit has the same plan on the roll, the recorded prices here compare unusually well. Set an asking price beside the qualified sales in the same building first, then beside the rest of the complex.

Ready to tour Loggerhead Cay?

Tell us which building you prefer, whether you want a ground-floor or upper-floor unit, whether you plan to rent weekly and the price you would act on. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816, and we will send each match with the recorded sales behind it.

What do Loggerhead Cay condos sell for?

Recorded Loggerhead Cay prices in the 12 months to October 21, 2026 ran from $660,000 to $950,000, with a $750,000 median on 8 qualified sales. The table counts only deeds the Lee County Property Appraiser marks as qualified on the 168 unit parcels, one row per deed, through the newest sale in the county index.

Window to October 21, 2026 Qualified sales Median Low High
12 months, since October 22, 2025 8 $750,000 $660,000 $950,000
24 months, since October 22, 2024 10 $775,000 $660,000 $962,813
36 months, since October 22, 2023 11 $790,000 $660,000 $1,115,000
60 months, since October 22, 2021 16 $764,950 $660,000 $1,115,000
10 years, since October 22, 2016 81 $660,000 $438,000 $1,115,000
20 years, since October 22, 2006 142 $572,500 $350,000 $1,115,000
All qualified sales since July 1974 387 $450,000 $38,900 $1,115,000

Data updated: November 2026. Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and sale records, qualified sales of $10,000 or more on the 168 Loggerhead Cay unit parcels in ZIP 33957, county sale index built November 18, 2026; newest Loggerhead Cay sale September 14, 2026.

Since every unit has the same 1,184 square feet on the roll, a median here is closer to a like-for-like figure than at most island complexes. Building and floor still move the price, as the sale list shows.

Every qualified sale since late 2023

Recorded Unit Building Price Per heated sq ft
November 30, 2023 E513 E $1,115,000 $942
March 31, 2025 142 1 $962,813 $813
June 6, 2025 184 1 $845,000 $714
November 4, 2025 D402 D $679,000 $573
December 29, 2025 C363 C $665,000 $562
February 11, 2026 C362 C $760,000 $642
March 23, 2026 C354 C $660,000 $557
May 29, 2026 122 1 $950,000 $802
July 29, 2026 264 2 $797,500 $674
August 31, 2026 191 1 $790,000 $667
September 14, 2026 C303 C $740,000 $625

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale records, qualified sales; price per square foot is the recorded price divided by the roll's 1,184 heated square feet.

Building 1 sets the top

The three highest prices of the last two years, $962,813, $950,000 and $845,000, were all in Building 1, the west-row building at the Gulf end. Building C, the road-end building of the same row, accounted for 4 of the 8 sales in the latest 12 months, at $660,000 to $760,000.

The 2024 deeds outside the count

Eight Loggerhead Cay deeds recorded in 2024, from $775,000 to $875,000 with an $860,000 midpoint, but the county did not mark any of them as qualified. The roll gives each a second sale code of 03 instead of the usual 01. We keep them out of every median above and show them here so you can see them: units 174, 181, 282, C324, D401, E543, 212 and D472. The county file does not say why they were set aside; units still under post-Ian repair at the time of sale is one possibility we could not confirm, so ask before you treat them as comparables.

Another deed outside the count

Unit 162 recorded at $880,000 on March 12, 2025 under transfer code 16, which the county does not count as a qualified sale. It is left out of the medians for the same reason.

Price per heated square foot

The 8 qualified sales of the latest 12 months ran from $557 to $802 per heated square foot, with a median of about $634. In the 24-month window the top was $813, set by unit 142 in March 2025.

Sales by year

Year Qualified sales Median
2015 12 $547,500
2016 9 $505,000
2017 12 $543,500
2018 16 $572,000
2019 8 $617,500
2020 13 $570,000
2021 15 $685,000
2022 0 none
2023 5 $750,000
2024 0 (8 deeds not marked qualified) none
2025 4 $762,000
2026 to September 14 6 $775,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale records, qualified sales grouped by recording year.

The storm years in the record

No qualified sale recorded in 2022, the year Ian struck, and none in 2024. The 5 qualified sales of 2023 ran from $715,000 to $1,115,000, and the high, unit E513 on November 30, 2023, is still the top qualified price in the county file.

Prices by decade

Decade Qualified sales Median Low High
1970s 37 $67,000 $38,900 $107,500
1980s 62 $178,950 $64,500 $306,000
1990s 79 $290,000 $203,000 $475,000
2000s 82 $600,000 $410,000 $922,500
2010s 84 $525,000 $350,000 $962,500
2020s, to September 2026 43 $685,000 $438,000 $1,115,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale records, qualified sales grouped by recording year.

How many units have sold

Of the 168 units, 159 show at least one qualified sale in the county file. The first was unit 264 at $43,400 in July 1974, and the 1974 median of $46,800 against the 2026 median of $775,000 is a rise of about 16.6 times.

A record that was corrected

The county sale index carried one deed twice, unit 101's July 2011 sale: $611,000 in the parcel file and $6,039,600 in a second file. We kept the $611,000 parcel-file figure, which matches the roll.

Loggerhead Cay buildings and floor plans

The county roll lists 168 units in five buildings, two from Phase I and three from Phase 2, plus a clubhouse on the common elements. The state condominium registry also counts 168 units, and Lee County's neighborhood layer counts six buildings, the five residential buildings and the clubhouse.

Building Row on the site Phase County year Units Unit numbers Median 2026 county value
1 West row, Gulf end I 1974 36 101 to 193 $924,643
2 West row, middle I 1974 32 201 to 283 $548,658
C West row, road end 2 1975 32 C301 to C383 $550,528
D East row, road end 2 1976 32 D401 to D483 $552,396
E East row, Gulf end 2 1975 36 E501 to E593 $579,131

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll LCPA2610, November 2026; row positions from the roll's building points on the FEMA panel aerial and our hero image.

One plan for every unit

Every unit is two bedrooms and two baths with 1,184 heated square feet on the roll. Listing pages show 1,184 and 1,235 square feet, and one broker page gives 1,235 living and 1,385 to 1,425 total square feet; those larger figures likely count the lanai, so measure before you rely on them.

The Gulf-end premium on the roll

Building 1 carries a median county value of $924,643, against about $550,000 in Buildings 2, C and D. Of the 30 units valued over $900,000, 22 are in Building 1 and 8 in Building E, the two buildings nearest the Gulf.

Four stories and elevators

The roll lists every building as four stories, and Realtor survey data and a rental listing report elevators. Only 27 unit numbers end in 4, so on our floor reading the top floor holds fewer units than the floors below it.

Build years

The roll dates units in Buildings 1 and 2 to 1974, Buildings C and E to 1975 and Building D to 1976. Nine units carry a 2004 or 2005 date in a second year field; the roll does not say what work that marks.

County values on the roll

The 2026 roll values the 168 units at about $105.8 million in total, from $548,658 to $1,021,016 per unit, with a $552,396 median. Exactly 100 of the 168 units sit at or under $560,000.

The Loggerhead Cay site between East Gulf Drive and the beach

The condominium rests on two common-element parcels, one per phase: 4.64 acres for Phase I and 5.76 acres for Phase 2 in the county's GIS, 10.4 acres together. That area likely runs into the beach, so treat it as the recorded parcel size rather than the lawn and buildings alone.

Two rows and a pool

On the aerial the west row holds Buildings 1, 2 and C, and the east row holds E and D, with the pool and lawn between them. The road end has parking and the courts; the Gulf end opens onto the dune and the sand.

On the beach

The Gulf-end buildings face the beach across a dune strip, so owners reach the sand without crossing a road. One broker page describes the beach access as deeded; we have not seen the deed.

Neighbors on East Gulf Drive

By address, Tortuga Beach Club (957 and 959 East Gulf Drive) and Shell Harbor Inn Resort (937) lie to the east, and Plantation Village of Sanibel (997 and 999) to the west. Sanibel Moorings, at 845 East Gulf Drive, is about 0.7 miles east.

Is Loggerhead Cay gated?

No. Lee County's neighborhood layer records the complex as not gated. A rental listing mentions owner decals or parking permits.

The location on the island

The roll's building points sit about 1.9 miles in a straight line west of the Sanibel Lighthouse, on the east end of the island. Some guides call the complex mid-island; the county coordinates do not support that.

Amenities at Loggerhead Cay

The amenities are association common elements; there is no golf course, no club membership and no marina. The list below comes from Chamber coverage, a property manager's post-storm updates and listing pages, and items that only a listing mentions are labeled that way.

The pool

The heated pool between the rows is described on listing pages as Olympic-size. It was resurfaced and fenced in July 2023 and reopened on December 1, 2023.

Courts

Chamber coverage of the 2024 reopening says the tennis and pickleball courts were being rebuilt with a five-layer cushion surface and designated pickleball courts, due in March 2024. Shuffleboard courts are also on site.

Clubhouse and grounds

The roll shows a 1975 two-story building of 2,400 square feet on the Phase 2 common element, which houses the clubhouse and office. Chamber coverage also lists a sitting area, grills and shell-washing stations.

Listed by rental pages

A rental listing advertises an on-site kayak launch and an e-bike charging station; confirm both with the association.

The Loggerhead Cay association

Loggerhead Cay Condo Assoc., Inc. governs the property, and one association covers both phases. The state condominium registry lists it as managing entity MA00011671, care of Alliant Property Management, LLC, 13831 Vector Ave, Fort Myers, and the condominium as file PR1S008142 with 168 units.

The declarations

The county legal descriptions cite the Phase I declaration at Official Records Book 964, Page 821 and the Phase 2 declaration at Book 1080, Page 1784. The common elements cite Book 1082, Page 239 and a 2008 amendment at Book 2008, Page 663. We have not read the declarations themselves.

The old address

The state registry still lists the condominium at 666 Beach Road, the address a July 1975 advertisement gave for "Loggerhead Cay Condominium Homes." The county roll uses 979 East Gulf Drive.

Corporate record

We did not read the association's Florida Division of Corporations record for this page, so its document number, status and registered agent are unconfirmed. Your closing agent or attorney can pull the Sunbiz record before closing.

The board

Chamber coverage named Phil Pilibosian as board president in February 2024. Current officers were not published in our sources.

What does it cost to own a Loggerhead Cay condo each year?

The main yearly costs of a Loggerhead Cay condo are the association fee, property tax and your own insurance, plus utilities and any rental program charges. Property tax can be worked out from public rates; the fee cannot, because the association does not publish its budget.

The association fee

Listing sites show condo fees of about $820 a month and $1,100 a month. Those are listing claims, not association figures, and they do not say what the fee covers. Ask for the current budget and the estoppel certificate before you rely on any number.

No CDD

The roll shows only the City of Sanibel taxing district and the Sanibel Fire District on every Loggerhead Cay parcel, with no community development district.

Property tax rate

Property tax on a Loggerhead Cay unit is the taxable value times the millage for Lee County taxing district 010, City of Sanibel, which totals 13.9007 mills for 2026 in the actual column of the Lee County Property Appraiser's printed millage book.

Levy in district 010, 2026 actual Mills
Lee County general revenue 3.7623
Public schools, local board and state law 2.2480 and 3.0230
City of Sanibel 2.5000
Sanibel Fire and Rescue District 1.3016
Sanibel Public Library District 0.4677
City of Sanibel recreation center voted debt 0.1000
South Florida Water Management District, three levies 0.2301
Hyacinth, mosquito and inland navigation districts 0.2680
Total 13.9007

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser, 2026 millage rates for Lee County, district 010, printed October 9, 2026; actual column. The sewer voted debt levy is 0.0000.

What the arithmetic gives

At 13.9007 mills a unit at the roll's median taxable value of $552,396 carries about $7,679 a year in ad valorem tax. A buyer whose value resets to the $750,000 median sale price would see about $10,426 a year, or about $1,390 for each $100,000 of taxable value. Treat both as planning figures: the Tax Collector's bill adds non-ad valorem charges and reflects your own exemptions.

Why your bill will differ from the seller's

A sale resets the assessed value to market value on the next January 1, so the seller's bill may be well below yours. For property that is not a homestead, Florida caps yearly growth in assessed value at 10 percent for non-school levies; a homestead is capped at 3 percent.

Homestead is rare here

Only 7 of the 168 units carry a homestead exemption on the roll, and 32 owners have a Florida mailing address. Most units are second homes or rentals for tax purposes.

How renting works at Loggerhead Cay

Short stays are allowed at Loggerhead Cay, and the city's zoning explains why. Most of Sanibel's residential districts require rentals of at least four consecutive weeks, but the Resort Housing District allows shorter stays, and city planning reports place Loggerhead Cay inside it.

The seven-night minimum

Rental listings and a local buyer guide describe a seven-night minimum stay here. That is a listing claim; confirm the current rule in the declaration and the association's rules before you count on weekly income.

The city license

Each rented unit needs a City of Sanibel rental dwelling license; rental listings show license numbers such as RDWL-003750 for unit 241. The license fee was not confirmed for this page.

Rental managers

The rental pages we read list Loggerhead Cay units one at a time, through a local property manager and vacation-rental sites, and we found no association-run rental program like the one at Sanibel Moorings. Ask how a unit you are weighing is rented today and what its booking record shows.

Tax on stays

Stays of six months or less carry Florida sales tax and the Lee County tourist development tax. Your rental manager usually collects them, but the owner is responsible for making sure they are paid.

The 2026 planning review

In May 2026 the Sanibel Planning Commission voted 6 to 1 to send Resort Housing District redevelopment options to the City Council. The staff report listed Loggerhead Cay as fully restored with 168 units, and showed a 116-unit figure for the complex beside its count; what the 116 measures is not explained in our sources. The Sanibel Plan lets existing resort condominiums in the district keep their density through redevelopment "provided short-term occupancy continues."

Pets at Loggerhead Cay

The pet rule is not settled in public sources. A Realtor survey and a Sanibel guide list owners at two pets under 25 pounds, and some rental units are marketed as pet friendly while others say no pets. Ask the association for its current rules before you buy.

Assistance animals

Under fair housing law an assistance animal is not a pet, so a pet limit does not stop a reasonable accommodation request. The association can explain how it handles one.

House rules seen on a rental page

One rental listing says smoking is not allowed anywhere on the grounds and that RVs, trailers and motorcycles may not park on site. These are listing claims; the association's rules control.

Is Loggerhead Cay in a flood zone?

Yes. Loggerhead Cay is on FEMA panel 12071C0533G, effective November 17, 2022, and on our reading of the printed panel the two Gulf-end buildings, 1 and E, fall in Zone VE with a 13 foot base flood elevation, while Buildings 2, C and D sit landward of that line. Lee County's own flood layer returns only the City of Sanibel community polygon inside the city, so the zone was read from the panel, not from a database. The county's panel layer also shows panel 12071C0541G touching the edge of the search area around the buildings; the per-building check in our research file places all five on 0533G.

Flood and storm fact Figure
FEMA panel 12071C0533G, effective November 17, 2022
Gulf-end buildings 1 and E Zone VE, base flood elevation 13 ft, on our panel reading
Buildings 2, C and D Landward of the VE line; nearest panel labels AE 11 and AE 10
FEMA community 120402, City of Sanibel
Ground elevation at the building points 7.3 to 7.4 ft at the Building 2 and Building 1 points; the service timed out before Buildings C, D and E
Lee County evacuation zone Zone A, surge zone 1
Coastal High Hazard Area Partly: Building D's point is inside, and the layer's edge runs within about 10 m of every building point
State storm surge zone Category 1, maximum height 12.1 ft, at all five building points

Sources: FEMA FIRM panel 12071C0533G as printed by Lee County; Lee County GIS layers FIRMPanels, FIRM, EvacuationZones, CoastalHighHazardArea and FDEM_Storm_Surge_Zones; USGS 3DEP elevation point service; all queried November 21, 2026.

What VE means for a buyer

Zone VE is a coastal high hazard zone with wave action, and both VE and AE are special flood hazard areas, so a lender will require flood cover on a mortgaged unit. The panel line was read by eye at the county's building points, so confirm each building's zone on its elevation certificate.

Ground-floor units

On our floor reading 47 units are on the ground floor. Those are the units Ian flooded, and the ones where an elevation certificate and the building's flood history matter most.

The 50 percent rule

When repairs or improvements in a flood zone cost 50 percent or more of a building's market value, the building must be brought up to current flood rules. Ask the City of Sanibel building department how that rule was applied to the Ian repairs here.

Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton at Loggerhead Cay

Hurricane Ian on September 28, 2022 flooded the ground floor. Chamber coverage reported that Ian "required gutting all first-floor units, the office, and nine second-floor units," and the roofs on all five buildings and the clubhouse were replaced. High-water marks reached 13 to 14 feet on Sanibel. Lee County's public damage inventory layer holds no entry inside our search area around the buildings, so the building-level record comes from the Chamber and the property manager.

The rebuild, step by step

A property manager's update log tracks the recovery through 2023: beach walkways finished, the pool resurfaced and first-floor windows and doors going in by July 14; a new sign on East Gulf Drive on July 21; the pool fence on July 28; bike racks back on August 10; power back to the first building, in the manager's own numbering, on October 23 and to the whole property on December 4.

Owners and guests return

Owners moved back on December 16, 2023 and rentals restarted on December 30, 2023. By early February 2024, 75 rental units were open, and the SanCap Chamber held a ribbon-cutting on February 5, 2024.

Helene and Milton in 2024

Helene's storm surge of about 5 feet caused flooding across Sanibel in September 2024, and the island was ordered evacuated before Milton made landfall on October 9, 2024 at Siesta Key. We found no Loggerhead Cay specific damage report for either storm; ask the association whether either one led to claims or repairs.

Where things stood in 2026

City planning staff listed all 168 Loggerhead Cay units as restored and occupied in May 2026.

The causeway

Ian broke the Sanibel Causeway in several places; temporary repairs reopened it to residents and island businesses on October 19, 2022, after crews worked around the clock for 15 days.

Florida condo law at Loggerhead Cay

Florida's post-2021 condominium laws require a milestone inspection for buildings of three or more habitable stories at 30 years, then every 10 years, and buildings that reached 30 before July 1, 2022 had a December 31, 2024 deadline. Loggerhead Cay's four-story buildings date from 1974 to 1976, so all five were past 30 before July 2022.

The reserve study

Unit-owner-controlled associations had to complete a structural integrity reserve study by December 31, 2025, and reserves for those items may not be waived in budgets adopted from January 1, 2025. Loggerhead Cay's study and its filing with the state were not public in our sources.

Sanibel's own rule

The City of Sanibel applies milestone inspections through Ordinance 24-006, and on March 19, 2026 the City Council voted 4 to 0 to mirror the 2025 state wording. The city publishes no list of buildings or compliance status, and we did not find Loggerhead Cay's report.

Insurance

The master policy carrier, the wind deductible and the flood policies were not found in public sources. Each owner insures the interior and contents with an HO-6 policy, and loss-assessment cover protects you if the master policy falls short. Read the master policy summary during your inspection period.

Assessments

We found no public record of a hurricane, reserve study or milestone special assessment at Loggerhead Cay. A rental listing mentions association work to repair sewer lines and reline pipes, with no year given. Ask the estoppel question directly.

Where is Loggerhead Cay on Sanibel?

Loggerhead Cay sits on the Gulf side of East Gulf Drive on the east end of Sanibel, between Plantation Village and Tortuga Beach Club. The drive estimates below are free-flow routing figures with no traffic or toll stop; in season, roughly February to April, real drives on Periwinkle Way and the causeway take longer.

Destination Distance Free-flow drive
Sanibel Lighthouse Beach Park about 2.2 mi about 6 min
The Sanibel School about 4.6 mi about 12 min
Sanibel Causeway toll plaza, Punta Rassa about 5.4 mi about 14 min
Bowman's Beach about 8.5 mi about 20 min
HealthPark Medical Center area, Fort Myers about 11.8 mi about 22 min
Downtown Fort Myers about 19.1 mi about 37 min
I-75 at Daniels Parkway about 20.7 mi about 35 min
Gulf Coast Town Center about 21.1 mi about 38 min
Southwest Florida International Airport about 22.8 mi about 41 min
Coconut Point about 23.7 mi about 42 min
Downtown Naples about 41.7 mi about 69 min

Source: OSRM public routing engine, one request on November 21, 2026 from the middle of the five building points; destination points placed by us, approximate. Not timed drives.

The causeway toll

The Sanibel Causeway is tolled inbound. A visitor guide lists $6 with a transponder; check the current fare with Lee County.

Shops and the island

Periwinkle Way, the island's main shopping street, runs parallel inland. For what everyday life on the island looks like, our sister site's guide to living on Sanibel Island covers it.

Captiva

Buyers who also want to look across Blind Pass can start with our Captiva Island homes for sale page.

Schools serving Loggerhead Cay addresses

Lee County assigns public schools through school choice zones, so the school tied to a Loggerhead Cay address depends on the district's zone map. For the 2026-27 school year the district's proximity-zone layers return elementary zone N, middle zone LL and high zone South 5 for all five buildings.

The island school

The Sanibel School, kindergarten through grade 8, is the island's only public school, about 12 minutes away by car, and high school is off the island. Its classes were displaced after Ian and again after Milton, so check its current status with the district.

Confirm the assignment

Which schools serve those zones by name was not confirmed for this page. Check the assignment for 979 East Gulf Drive by address with the School District of Lee County.

A short history of Loggerhead Cay

Loggerhead Cay opened in the fall of 1974, the year Sanibel became a city. The county dates Phase I's 68 units to that year, and the first deeds recorded in July 1974; the 6 qualified sales of 1974 ran from $38,900 to $51,900.

The 1975 hardship fight

When the new city paused building while it wrote its land use plan, Loggerhead Cay, Inc. asked the Planning Commission in April 1975 for a release to finish the project. Its attorney said 104 owners were carrying costs meant to be shared by "the projected 168 owners upon completion," and "sixty four units are in question with ten already sold." The commission voted unanimously against the request on April 28, 1975 and sent the case to the City Council.

Phase 2 is built anyway

The 64 contested units were built: the county dates Building E and Building C to 1975 and Building D to 1976, and the first Building C and D deeds recorded in 1976. The Council's ruling itself was not found in our sources.

Fifty years on

The complex marked its 50th anniversary in 2024 with a brick campaign to pay for new landscaping, announced around the Chamber ribbon-cutting that celebrated its reopening.

What should you check before you make an offer on a Loggerhead Cay condo?

A Loggerhead Cay offer turns on paperwork more than on the plan, since every unit has the same layout. These are the checks we run with buyers at 979 East Gulf Drive, roughly in the order a contract timeline allows them.

Place the unit

Match the unit number to its building, and ask which floor it is on. The Gulf-end buildings carry the highest values and the VE flood line.

Order the estoppel early

The estoppel certificate confirms the fee, any assessment and any balance owed. It is the only firm fee figure you will get here.

Get the milestone and reserve study status

Ask for the milestone inspection report and the structural integrity reserve study, and whether either calls for repairs or a funding plan.

Read the rental rules

If you plan to rent, confirm the minimum stay, any check-in day and any rental registration rules in the declaration and the association's rules.

Price the insurance

Get the master policy summary and quote your HO-6, loss-assessment and flood cover during the inspection period, using the building's elevation certificate.

Inspect the unit

Use an inspector with coastal condominium experience to look at the windows, sliders, lanai, air handler and the quality of the post-Ian repairs, above all on the ground floor.

Compare recorded sales

Price the unit against the county's qualified sales at 979 East Gulf Drive in the same building, then the rest of the complex.

Loggerhead Cay and other Sanibel condos buyers compare

Buyers who look at Loggerhead Cay often weigh it against other Gulf-front and east-end resort condominiums, which differ a great deal in unit count, building height and rental setup. The comparison below uses the yardstick of recorded qualified sales from our own Sanibel pages.

Community Units Recorded sales on our page How it differs from Loggerhead Cay
Loggerhead Cay, 979 East Gulf Drive 168 8 in 12 months, $750,000 median Four-story buildings, one plan, Gulf front, outside rental managers
Sanibel Moorings, 845 East Gulf Drive 122 11 in 24 months, $569,000 median Two-story buildings, mixed plans, bay-side docks, association-only rentals
Mariner Pointe, 760 Sextant Drive 100 5 since Ian, $425,000 median Bayfront, not on the Gulf, boat slips, five condominiums on one site
Gulfside Place, 1605 Middle Gulf Drive 84 8 from November 2024, $1,348,500 median Larger flats of 1,628 to 2,131 square feet, mid-island
Sanibel Siesta, 1246 Fulgur Street 61 3 in 12 months, $535,000 to $650,000 Smaller complex, also all two-bedroom flats, central Sanibel

Sources: Lee County Property Appraiser figures as published on each linked Domain Realty Group page, read November 21, 2026; each page states its own window.

Where Loggerhead Cay stands out, and where it does not

Loggerhead Cay gives you a full Gulf beach at a lower recorded price than the larger mid-island flats, weekly rentals under the city's resort zoning and one plan that makes pricing simple. Its limits are 1970s buildings with milestone and reserve study work to confirm, a VE zone at the Gulf end, an unpublished fee and a ground floor that flooded in Ian.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Loggerhead Cay specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, works Sanibel listings out of its Fort Myers office on College Parkway, the nearest of its three offices to the Sanibel Causeway. For this page we tracked 387 qualified Loggerhead Cay sales in the county file back to their units and buildings, and we will run the same check on any unit you are weighing.

★★★★★ "We worked with Marc Comisar to find a home in Southwest Florida area. Marc was very knowledgable of the real estate market and helped us narrow the search to specific developments and homes that would meet our needs and have long term value. Marc was very friendly and patient throughout the process. Would highly recommend Marc to anyone looking to buy a home in the Southwest Florida area."

Verified Zillow review. Walter Skawski, on buying a home with Marc Comisar.

Ask about a Loggerhead Cay unit

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816 with the building you prefer, the floor, your rental plans and your budget, and an agent will send matching listings, the recorded sales of comparable units and the association questions to ask. Or browse every current listing on your own.

Thinking of selling a Loggerhead Cay unit?

A Loggerhead Cay unit is priced by its building, its floor, its view and its finish after the rebuild, so pricing it against qualified sales at the same address beats pricing it against the island. Owners weighing a sale can read how our sister brand approaches selling a home on Sanibel or Captiva.

Frequently Asked Questions about Loggerhead Cay condos for sale

These answers come from the Lee County roll and sale records, the state condominium registry, Lee County map layers, the FEMA panel, City of Sanibel records and island news. An answer that rests on listing text or an unconfirmed reading says so.

What is Loggerhead Cay?

A 168-unit Gulf-front condominium at 979 East Gulf Drive, Sanibel, ZIP 33957, in the City of Sanibel, Lee County.

Where on Sanibel is Loggerhead Cay?

On the east end of the island, on the Gulf side of East Gulf Drive, about 1.9 miles in a straight line west of the Sanibel Lighthouse, between Plantation Village and Tortuga Beach Club.

When was Loggerhead Cay built?

Phase I opened in the fall of 1974; the county dates Buildings 1 and 2 to 1974, C and E to 1975 and D to 1976. The 1977 date on some portals is not supported by county records.

How many units are at Loggerhead Cay?

168, in five four-story buildings, plus a clubhouse. The county roll and the state registry both count 168 units.

How big are the units?

Every unit is two bedrooms and two baths with 1,184 heated square feet on the county roll.

What do Loggerhead Cay condos sell for?

The 8 qualified sales in the 12 months to October 21, 2026 ran from $660,000 to $950,000, with a $750,000 median. These are recorded deed prices, not asking prices.

What was the latest Loggerhead Cay sale?

Unit C303 recorded at $740,000 on September 14, 2026.

What is the top price ever recorded at Loggerhead Cay?

$1,115,000 for unit E513 on November 30, 2023.

Which building sells highest?

Building 1, the west-row building at the Gulf end, with recent sales of $790,000 to $962,813 and the highest county values.

What do Loggerhead Cay condos sell for per square foot?

The latest 12 months of qualified sales ran from $557 to $802 per heated square foot, with a median of about $634.

What are the HOA fees at Loggerhead Cay?

The association does not publish its budget. Listing sites show fees of about $820 to $1,100 a month, and there is no CDD; confirm the fee on the estoppel certificate.

Is there a special assessment?

We found no public record of one. Ask for the estoppel certificate and the board minutes.

Can you rent Loggerhead Cay weekly?

Yes, under the city's Resort Housing District, and rental listings advertise a seven-night minimum. Each rented unit needs a City of Sanibel rental dwelling license; confirm the current association rules.

Are pets allowed at Loggerhead Cay?

Rules vary by source: a Realtor survey and a Sanibel guide list two pets under 25 pounds for owners. Confirm with the association; assistance animals are handled as accommodation requests.

Is Loggerhead Cay on the beach?

Yes. The Gulf-end buildings face the beach across a dune strip.

What amenities are there?

A heated pool, tennis and pickleball courts, shuffleboard, a clubhouse, grills and shell-washing stations. There is no golf.

Is it gated?

No. The county's neighborhood layer records it as not gated.

What flood zone is Loggerhead Cay in?

On our reading of FEMA panel 12071C0533G, Buildings 1 and E are in Zone VE with a 13 foot base flood elevation, and Buildings 2, C and D sit landward of that line. Check each building's elevation certificate.

What evacuation zone is Loggerhead Cay in?

Lee County Evacuation Zone A, surge zone 1, and all five building points fall in the state's Category 1 storm surge zone.

How did Loggerhead Cay fare in Hurricane Ian?

Ian gutted all first-floor units, the office and nine second-floor units, and every roof was replaced. Owners returned on December 16, 2023, and by May 2026 all 168 units were reported restored.

Has Loggerhead Cay done its milestone inspection?

It is required: the four-story buildings were past 30 years before July 2022, so state law set a December 31, 2024 deadline. The association's reports are not public.

What are property taxes on a Loggerhead Cay condo?

At 13.9007 mills for 2026, about $7,679 a year on the median taxable value and about $10,426 on a $750,000 purchase, as estimates.

What school serves Loggerhead Cay?

The Sanibel School serves kindergarten through grade 8 on the island; confirm the assignment by address with the district.

How many buildings does Loggerhead Cay have?

Five residential buildings, numbered 1, 2, C, D and E on the county roll, plus a clubhouse on the common elements.

Which Loggerhead Cay units are on the ground floor?

On our reading of the unit numbers, the 47 units whose number ends in 1 are on the ground floor; confirm the floor of any unit with the listing agent or the plat.

Is there an elevator at Loggerhead Cay?

Realtor survey data and a rental listing report elevators in the four-story buildings; confirm on your tour.

How much land does Loggerhead Cay sit on?

The two common-element parcels total 10.4 acres in the county's GIS, 4.64 for Phase I and 5.76 for Phase 2, likely including beach.

What is the county value of a Loggerhead Cay unit?

The 2026 roll values units from $548,658 to $1,021,016, with a $552,396 median; Building 1 units carry the highest values.

Why do the 2024 Loggerhead Cay sales not count?

The county did not mark any of the eight 2024 deeds as qualified, so they stay out of the medians; they ran from $775,000 to $875,000.

How many Loggerhead Cay units are homesteaded?

Only 7 of the 168 units carry a homestead exemption on the 2026 roll.

How far is Loggerhead Cay from the airport?

About 22.8 miles and 41 minutes to Southwest Florida International Airport in free-flow traffic; season traffic adds time.

Who runs the association?

Loggerhead Cay Condo Assoc., Inc., managed by Alliant Property Management, LLC, according to the state registry.

Where do I see Loggerhead Cay condos for sale?

Use the listing links near the top of this page, call 239-441-2816 or contact us to set an alert.

About Domain Realty Group on Sanibel

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team working Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, including Sanibel and Captiva, from offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) lead the team, with over 45 years of combined direct experience.

Meet the team on our agents page, read our client reviews or learn more about our team. For this page we tracked every qualified Loggerhead Cay sale in the county file to its building and read the 1975 newspaper record of how the complex was finished.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816 info@domainrealtygroup.com

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Sanibel real estate, Sanibel Moorings condos for sale, Mariner Pointe condos for sale, Captiva Island homes for sale and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to a source below. No real estate portal is linked, by policy. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll (export of November 1, 2026) and sale records, qualified sales on the 168 Loggerhead Cay unit parcels in ZIP 33957, county sale index built November 18, 2026. Other sources were read November 21, 2026 unless another date is shown.

County, city and state records

Flood, storms and insurance

News, guides and history

Florida law and fair housing

Schools, places and roads