Opens in a new tab
Back to Sanibel

Sanibel · Florida · 33957

Sanibel Siesta Condos for Sale in Sanibel, FL

Sanibel Siesta condos for sale: two-bedroom, two-bath Gulf-front units at 1246 Fulgur Street in central Sanibel, with an association-run rental desk. Recorded county sales back to 1974, the roll's unit layout, dues, rental and pet rules, the post-Ian reopening and the questions to ask before you buy. Updated November 2026.

Aerial photo from January 16, 2023 of the Gulf side of central Sanibel, FL 33957, around 1246 Fulgur Street: long low-rise condominium buildings with flat roofs, two small pools, tennis courts, a pond, a road, sand dunes and the Gulf of Mexico beach

Sanibel Siesta is a Gulf-front condominium at 1246 Fulgur Street in central Sanibel, ZIP 33957, Lee County, and one of the island condominiums we track under Sanibel homes for sale. The Lee County roll lists 61 unit parcels, each a two-bedroom, two-bath flat built in 1975, while the chamber of commerce counts 62 units. Three qualified county sales were recorded in the 12 months to November 2026, at $535,000, $590,000 and $650,000, with the newest on May 13, 2026. Updated November 2026.

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.

This page is the Sanibel Siesta child of our Sanibel island page. It covers only the condominium recorded as Sanibel Siesta Condo, declared at Lee County Official Records Book 1050, Page 1083, which rents to guests under the name Sanibel Siesta on the Beach. The address is on Fulgur Street, a short side street that ends at the Gulf in the middle of the island; it is not on West Gulf Drive, and buildings there with similar names are different properties with their own records. Every county number below comes from the 61 Sanibel Siesta unit parcels and the one common-area parcel on the roll.

Key takeaways for Sanibel Siesta condo buyers

Here is the short version of what moves a Sanibel Siesta purchase, taken from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale files, the 2024 chamber reopening report, Sanibel real estate surveys, the county tourism listing and public sold records. Each point is expanded lower on the page with its source, and anything our research could not settle is marked to confirm.

  • Sanibel Siesta is one recorded condominium at 1246 Fulgur Street: 61 unit parcels on the county roll plus a common-area parcel, against 62 units in the chamber's count.
  • The roll lists every unit at 1,047 heated square feet, two bedrooms and two baths, built in 1975; listing pages quote larger total areas that include lanais.
  • Lee County recorded 3 qualified sales from February 26 to May 13, 2026: $650,000, $535,000 and $590,000, a $590,000 median.
  • The county file holds no qualified Sanibel Siesta sale in 2022, 2024 or 2025, and one in 2023, at $734,000.
  • Dues shown on 2025 and 2026 listings are about $1,300 a month, and one listing says the fee covers insurance, cable, water, sewer, trash and grounds.
  • Real estate surveys list a 3-day minimum rental, unusual for Sanibel, and nearly every unit sits in the association's own on-site rental program; one guide lists 7 days, so get the rule in writing.
  • Hurricane Ian flooded the ground-level units in 2022; the property reopened to new bookings on April 1, 2024, with 54 of 62 units open at the April 8, 2024 ribbon cutting.
  • The FEMA flood zone for the buildings was not confirmed by our research; all of Sanibel lies in Lee County evacuation Zone A.

Sanibel Siesta condos for sale right now

Sanibel Siesta condos for sale come up a few times a year at most, and in some recent years not at all. The county file shows three qualified closings in 2026 through May, after a gap of more than two years, so a buyer who wants a given building row or floor should be watching before the right unit lists rather than after.

Units on the roll

The Lee County roll carries 61 unit parcels and a common-area parcel, all described as Sanibel Siesta Condo under Book 1050, Page 1083. The unit addresses fall into eight number groups, from the 100s through the 800s.

Why the counts differ

The 2024 chamber report and Sanibel real estate surveys say 62 units, rental sites list 56 or 58, and one portal says 93. The roll has no parcel for a unit 108, which may explain part of the gap; ask the association for the official unit count from the declaration.

How often units sell

Across its whole recorded history the county file holds 139 qualified Sanibel Siesta sales since August 1974, a little under three a year. The pace since 2015 has been slower, with no more than four qualified sales in any one year.

Telling the right listing apart

Only listings at 1246 Fulgur Street belong to this condominium. Listings may use either Sanibel Siesta or Sanibel Siesta on the Beach, and the legal description on a deed reads Sanibel Siesta Condo followed by a letter code and the unit number.

Asking prices against recorded sales

Public records show unit 207 listed at $675,000 in August 2025 and recorded at $650,000 in February 2026, and unit 105 listed at $599,000 in November 2025 and recorded at $535,000 in March 2026. In November 2026 a portal showed unit 110 asking $749,000. Budget from the recorded figures.

See current listings

To see Sanibel Siesta units on the market today, search current listings and filter for Sanibel, or ask us to set a saved search on 1246 Fulgur Street that catches both names.

Ready to tour Sanibel Siesta?

Tell us the building row, the floor and how you plan to use the unit, and we will send every matching listing with the recorded county sales of comparable units. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do Sanibel Siesta condos sell for?

Recorded Sanibel Siesta prices since 2015 have run from $398,000 to $734,000, with one 2021 outlier at $1,375,000. The table counts only sales the Lee County Property Appraiser marks as qualified on the 61 unit parcels, through the newest sale in the county file on May 13, 2026. Because every unit has the same heated area on the roll, the spread reflects floor, view, condition and timing rather than size.

Window to May 13, 2026 Qualified sales Median Low High
12 months, since November 2025 3 $590,000 $535,000 $650,000
24 months, since November 2024 3 $590,000 $535,000 $650,000
60 months, since November 2021 4 $620,000 $535,000 $734,000
10 years, since November 2016 15 $590,000 $460,000 $1,375,000
20 years, since November 2006 34 $512,500 $285,000 $1,375,000
All recorded history, since August 1974 139 $265,000 $43,000 $1,375,000

Data updated: November 2026. Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and sale files, qualified improved sales on the Sanibel Siesta Condo unit parcels in ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026; newest Sanibel Siesta sale May 13, 2026.

The county tool's headline window is all recorded history, since no shorter window reached 10 qualified sales; the 12 and 24 month rows rest on only three closings.

Every qualified sale since 2018

Date recorded Unit Sale price Price per roll sq ft
August 6, 2018 306 $585,000 $559
November 27, 2018 701 $575,000 $549
May 1, 2019 601 $665,000 $635
May 31, 2019 109 $510,000 $487
January 28, 2020 804 $560,000 $535
March 6, 2020 601 $725,000 $692
March 3, 2021 302 $623,000 $595
July 23, 2021 801 $725,000 $692
October 26, 2021 506 $1,375,000 $1,313
September 29, 2023 403 $734,000 $701
February 26, 2026 207 $650,000 $621
March 2, 2026 105 $535,000 $511
May 13, 2026 306 $590,000 $564

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales and 2026 parcel roll. Price per square foot is our arithmetic on the roll's 1,047 heated square feet, not on the larger areas listings quote.

The three 2026 closings

Unit 207, a remodeled corner unit with impact glass on its listing, recorded at $650,000 on February 26, 2026. Unit 105, a second-floor unit with a garden and partial Gulf view on its listing, recorded at $535,000 on March 2, 2026. Unit 306 recorded at $590,000 on May 13, 2026.

The 2021 outlier

The highest qualified sale in the file is $1,375,000 on unit 506, recorded October 26, 2021, more than double the next highest recent sale. The county marks it qualified, but the file does not say why it cleared so far above the rest; do not price a unit from it without asking what that sale included.

The pre-Ian peak

Leaving out the 2021 outlier, the strongest recent prices were $725,000 in March 2020 and July 2021, and $734,000 in September 2023, a year after Ian. The 2026 closings came in below those figures.

Years with no recorded sale

The county file shows no qualified Sanibel Siesta sale in 2022, 2024 or 2025. The file records closings only, not reasons, so read that gap beside the storm history further down rather than as a verdict on demand.

Price per square foot

Because the roll gives every unit 1,047 heated square feet, price per foot tracks price directly: the 2026 sales ran from $511 to $621 per roll square foot, and the 2018 to 2023 sales, the outlier aside, from $487 to $701.

Prices by decade

Decade Qualified sales Median Low High
1970s 32 $62,250 $43,000 $121,100
1980s 26 $163,700 $123,000 $200,000
1990s 24 $270,000 $220,000 $520,000
2000s 25 $452,500 $320,000 $875,000
2010s 23 $460,000 $285,000 $665,000
2020s, to May 13, 2026 9 $650,000 $535,000 $1,375,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales, our grouping by decade of the recording date.

The first sales in the 1970s

The county file holds 17 sales it reads as first sales from the developer, recorded from August 1974 to December 1976 at $43,000 to $67,000. The earliest, in August 1974, was unit 603 at $61,000.

Units that changed hands twice

Several units appear twice in the recent file, which gives a rough read on how one unit's value moved. Unit 105 recorded $398,000 in April 2015 and $535,000 in March 2026. Unit 306 recorded $585,000 in August 2018 and $590,000 in May 2026. Unit 601 recorded $665,000 in May 2019 and $725,000 in March 2020. Unit 701 recorded $494,000 in March 2015 and $575,000 in November 2018. Condition changes between sales are not in the county file, so treat these pairs as markers, not as an index.

The 2006 high and the 2010 low

Before 2021 the highest qualified sale was $875,000 on unit 608 in February 2006. Four years later the low point came in November 2010, when unit 104 recorded at $285,000, and 2011 sales ran from $299,000 to $515,000.

Portal figures

A portal reported in November 2026 three sales in the past year, an average sale near $591,667 and 113 average days to sell. Those are portal estimates, not county records, so this page relies on the county figures above.

Sanibel Siesta floor plans, buildings and unit numbers

Every Sanibel Siesta unit is a two-bedroom, two-bath condominium with a full kitchen and a screened lanai, set in low-rise buildings that run back from the beach toward Fulgur Street. What separates one unit from another is its building, its floor, its view and how far the interior has been updated since Ian, not its plan.

Attribute County roll Listings and surveys
Bedrooms and baths 2 and 2, every unit 2 and 2
Heated area 1,047 sq ft, every unit About 995 to 1,400 sq ft total, 1,100 to 1,300 living
Year built 1975 1975
Unit parcels 61 plus a common area 56 to 62 units cited

Sources: Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 parcel data file; Sanibel real estate surveys and listing records read November 13, 2026.

Roll area against listed area

The roll's 1,047 square feet is heated area. Listings quote other measures: one unit 112 record gives 1,047 under air and 1,322 total, and unit 110 is shown at 1,298 under air and 1,498 total. Ask which measure a listing uses before you compare price per foot.

The unit number groups

Number group Units on the roll Parcels
100s 101 to 107, 109 to 112 11
200s 201 to 212 12
300s 301 to 308 8
400s 401 to 408 8
500s 501 to 506 6
600s 601 to 608 8
700s 701 to 704 4
800s 801 to 804 4

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll. Reading the first digit as a building is our inference from the groups; the association's site plan is the authority.

Each legal description carries a letter before its sequence number, such as L1, M18, U2 or P20. Listings place P20, which is unit 112, on the top floor as a corner unit, and M-22, unit 105, on the second floor. The codes appear to mark the level, but confirm the floor of any unit on a visit.

Elevators

Listings note an elevator serving at least some buildings, and the 2024 chamber report said the elevators were under repair after Ian. Ask which buildings have one and whether all are back in service.

Storage and lanais

Unit listings mention owner storage on the ground floor and, on some units, two lanais. One review site mentions attached garages, which no other source repeats; treat that as to confirm.

Interiors

Interiors range from original layouts to full remodels. The 2026 sale of unit 207 was described as a remodeled corner unit with impact glass; ask each seller what was replaced after Ian and what the association handled.

The Sanibel Siesta site on Fulgur Street

Sanibel Siesta sits where Fulgur Street meets the Gulf beach, in the middle stretch of the island's Gulf side that the county tourism bureau calls central Sanibel. The site is a single parcel of shared grounds with the unit buildings set around a pool deck and courts, and a path leads out to the sand.

Getting there

Fulgur Street runs toward the beach from the Middle Gulf Drive area. The exact street routing was not confirmed by our research, so follow the address on a map before a showing.

The beach

The property has its own deeded access to the Gulf beach, according to real estate surveys and the tourism listing. The aerial at the top of this page shows the dune line and the beach seaward of the buildings.

The golf course nearby

Sanibel Island Golf Club, at Beachview, is under a 10-minute walk according to a travel review, and the Dunes Golf and Tennis Club is about 5 minutes by car. Neither is part of the condominium.

Is Sanibel Siesta gated?

No source our research read describes a gate. Treat gate status as to confirm on a visit.

The coordinates

Public records place 1246 Fulgur Street at about 26.4348 north, 82.0461 west. The hero aerial is framed on that point.

Amenities at Sanibel Siesta

Sanibel Siesta runs more like a small beach resort than a quiet owner building, with a front desk and shared facilities aimed at both owners and rental guests. There is no golf, no club and no membership to buy; the amenities come with the condominium.

The pool

The heated outdoor pool was rebuilt after Ian, and the 2024 chamber report called it essentially new.

Tennis and shuffleboard

The grounds include tennis and shuffleboard, according to real estate surveys and the tourism listing.

Grills and laundry

There are two gas grill areas and laundry facilities on site.

Bikes and Wi-Fi

Bike rentals and free Wi-Fi are listed among the guest amenities.

The front desk

An on-site office and front desk handle check-ins and the rental program. Ian destroyed the original office, and the 2024 chamber report said it was being replaced.

Resort fee for guests

The county tourism listing shows a $50 resort fee for rental guests. That is a guest charge, not an owner fee.

Claims to confirm

One travel review mentions a garden, a pond and a swim-up bar. No other source repeats the bar, so treat it as to confirm on a visit.

The Sanibel Siesta association and its rental operation

Sanibel Siesta is a single condominium with one association, and it does something most Sanibel condominiums do not: the association itself runs the rental desk, under the Sanibel Siesta on the Beach name. That operation shapes the budget, the rules and the day-to-day feel of the property.

The association

The chamber named the association as the Sanibel Siesta Condominium Corporation in April 2024, when it reported Brooke Keneford as vice president. The entry on the state corporate register, its document number and its registered agent were not confirmed by our research, so they are to confirm through the title company.

The declaration

The declaration is recorded at Lee County Official Records Book 1050, Page 1083, and the common-area parcel is described in the same instrument. The recording date was not pulled.

The rental desk

The on-site desk takes reservations at (239) 472-4117, and the tourism listing shows a Florida lodging license in the condominium class, CND4600048. The state license search did not confirm that number in our research.

How many units rent

About 60 of the 62 units were in the on-site rental program in 2024, according to the chamber. Owners who join share the property's front desk and booking system; the program's commission and terms were not published.

Recognition

The tourism listing cites a AAA Two Diamond rating and a Lee County visitor bureau "Superior Small Lodging" designation. Those are lodging ratings for guests, not ratings of the real estate.

Ties to the island

The property's beach camera is used on the chamber's website, and a December 2025 Sanibel Sea School flyer advertised a beach walk starting from Sanibel Siesta.

No master association or CDD

Our research found no master association and no community development district over Sanibel Siesta. The association's dues are the one fixed charge besides property tax and the owner's own insurance.

What does it cost to own a Sanibel Siesta condo each year?

The fixed costs of a Sanibel Siesta unit are the association dues, property tax and the owner's unit policy, plus licensing and tax filings for a unit that rents. Every figure below is a dated public record, not a quote, so check the current budget and an estoppel letter before you write an offer.

Cost item Figure on record Source and date
Association dues, unit 207 $1,300 a month 2025 to 2026 listing record
Association dues, unit 112 $1,300 a month 2025 listing record
Portal range $1,100 to $1,400 a month Portal pages, 2026
Dues for 12 months at $1,300 $15,600 Our arithmetic
Master association or CDD None found County records and listings
Application fee Required, amount not shown Portal page
Capital contribution or transfer fee Not found; to confirm None

Data updated: November 2026. Sources: listing records for units 207 and 112 read November 13, 2026; portal fee ranges. Confirm each figure with the association.

What the dues cover

The unit 112 listing says the dues include association management, cable TV, insurance, irrigation water, legal and accounting, grounds maintenance, pest control, sewer, trash and water.

A year of dues

At $1,300 a month the dues alone come to $15,600 a year, before property tax, the unit policy and any rental costs.

Special assessments

No public source shows a special assessment for the Ian repairs to the office, elevators, ground-floor units or pool. Ask for the last three years of assessments and whether any is open or planned.

Rental program costs

The share an owner pays the rental program, and what it covers, was not published. Ask the front desk for the owner agreement before you buy if you plan to rent.

Property taxes on a Sanibel Siesta unit

Sanibel Siesta tax bills vary widely from unit to unit because they follow each owner's assessed value and exemptions, not the unit itself, and the millage comes from the City of Sanibel, Lee County, the school board and the other authorities that tax the island. A buyer's first full bill is figured on the new assessment after a sale.

Two bills on record

Listing records show $6,367 on unit 105 for 2025 and $1,092 on unit 112 for 2024. The second figure is low enough to suggest an exemption or a post-Ian value reduction; it is not a guide to your bill.

The reset at a sale

Florida's assessment caps limit how fast a homestead's assessed value can rise, and the limit ends when the unit sells. Plan on a bill based on your purchase price.

Homestead and rental use

An owner who makes a unit a permanent home can apply for homestead with the Lee County Property Appraiser. A unit in the on-site rental program raises separate questions; ask the appraiser's office before you file.

Checking a bill

Look up the current bill for any unit on the Lee County Tax Collector site before you make an offer.

Rental rules, pets and occupancy at Sanibel Siesta

Rental terms are the main reason many buyers look at Sanibel Siesta, and they are also where the sources disagree most. The rules come from the declaration, the association and the City of Sanibel's rental licensing; our research did not read the governing documents, so confirm each point in writing.

The 3-day minimum

Two Sanibel real estate surveys and a 2025 listing give a 3-day minimum stay. One local rental guide lists Sanibel Siesta at 7 days. Ask the association which applies to the unit you want.

Why it stands out on Sanibel

Sanibel's base rule outside the resort housing district is a four-week minimum, and many island condominiums use 7 days. A shorter minimum at Sanibel Siesta likely reflects its zoning or a long-standing license, which the City of Sanibel can confirm.

City licensing and enforcement

A rented unit needs a City of Sanibel rental license. In January 2026 the city was reviewing about 360 possibly non-compliant short-term rental addresses with scanning software, out of 1,823 short-term rental units on the island.

Tourist tax

Lee County's tourist development tax applies to transient guest stays. Ask the front desk whether the on-site program collects and files it for units in the program, and how an owner renting outside the program would handle it.

Pets

Real estate surveys and a pet-friendly condo guide say owners may keep pets on a leash with no stated limit, while rental guests generally may not bring them. A few individual unit ads have said otherwise, so get the current pet rule in writing.

Assistance animals

A pet rule does not end the question for an assistance animal. Federal fair housing law and Florida's statute on emotional support animals require the association to weigh a reasonable accommodation request for one.

Age

No source our research read describes an age restriction at Sanibel Siesta. Confirm with the association and the declaration.

Is Sanibel Siesta in a flood zone?

Almost certainly, though the exact FEMA zone for these buildings was not confirmed by our research. All of Sanibel is mapped in special flood hazard zones, AE inland and VE along much of the Gulf front, and Sanibel Siesta's buildings stand just behind the Gulf dune. Look up each building on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center before you buy.

Question What our research found Where to confirm
FEMA zone for the buildings Not confirmed; likely AE, VE or both FEMA Flood Map Service Center
Base flood elevation Not confirmed FEMA map and an elevation certificate
Elevation certificate None found Association or City of Sanibel
Lee County evacuation zone Zone A, all of Sanibel Lee County Emergency Management

Data updated: November 2026. Sources: Sanibel-wide flood and evacuation records; FEMA Map Service Center for a reader's own lookup. No FEMA zone is stated for this property.

Why the zone matters for a lender

If a building sits in a special flood hazard area, a federally backed lender will require flood coverage, normally through the association's master flood policy, with the owner carrying a unit policy.

VE and AE

A VE zone adds wave action to the flood risk and carries stricter building rules than AE. A Gulf-front site can straddle the line, so check the footprint of the building the unit is in.

Evacuation Zone A

Lee County orders Zone A out first. The county ordered Sanibel evacuated on September 27, 2022, the day before Ian made landfall. An evacuation zone is a separate map from a FEMA flood zone.

The 50 percent rule

Under FEMA's floodplain rules as the City of Sanibel applies them, repairs or improvements that reach 50 percent of a building's market value can require the building to meet current flood elevation standards. Ask the city how that rule was applied to the Sanibel Siesta buildings after Ian.

Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton at Sanibel Siesta

Hurricane Ian hit Sanibel on September 28, 2022, and the Sanibel Siesta record from that storm comes from the chamber of commerce and the island newspaper's coverage of its 2024 reopening. Helene and Milton flooded parts of the island again in 2024, but no report specific to Sanibel Siesta from either storm was found. The points below say only what those sources say.

What Ian did

Flooding damaged the ground-level units most. The office was demolished and was being rebuilt in 2024, the elevators needed repair, the landscaping was lost and replanted, and the pool was redone.

The big blue chair

Floodwater carried away the property's landmark big blue chair, which was later found and brought back, according to the chamber's report.

The reopening

Guests with existing reservations returned from January 2024, new bookings opened April 1, 2024, and the chamber held a ribbon cutting on April 8, 2024, with 54 of 62 units open and eight ground-level units still closed.

After the reopening

A June 2024 reader comment on a Florida travel site said some units were fully renovated and others still in progress. That site's October 2026 update lists Sanibel Siesta on the Beach Inn among island lodgings back in operation, and 2025 guest reviews scored the property about 9.2 to 10 out of 10.

Helene and Milton in 2024

Helene's surge in September 2024 and Milton's in October 2024 flooded parts of Sanibel, according to the Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation. No Sanibel Siesta damage report from either storm was found; ask the association.

What a buyer should ask

Ask which units were rebuilt, which buildings had flood repairs, whether any substantial-damage determination was made, and how the repairs were paid for.

Florida condo law and insurance at Sanibel Siesta

Florida's condominium safety laws passed after 2022 changed inspections, reserves and the papers a buyer receives, and they bear directly on a 1975 building near the Gulf. Whether each applies to Sanibel Siesta turns on how many habitable stories the buildings have, which our research could not settle from public records.

Milestone inspections

Under the 2025 change in HB 913, milestone inspections apply to condominium buildings of three habitable stories or more once they reach the age trigger. Sanibel Siesta's buildings date from 1975 and are described as three or four floors, so they likely qualify; ask for the inspection report and its date.

Sanibel's ordinance

The City of Sanibel updated its local milestone language to match the state wording, according to the island newspaper.

Reserve studies

The same law set December 31, 2025 as the deadline for structural integrity reserve studies on covered buildings, with a delay allowed for associations that just completed a milestone inspection. Sanibel Siesta's study status was not public; ask for it.

The master policy

Insurance is included in the dues, according to the unit 112 listing. The carrier, the wind deductible and the flood coverage were not published, and a large deductible can fall back on owners after a storm.

The unit policy

An owner carries a unit policy for the interior, contents and liability. Quote it once you know what the master policy and the declaration assign to the owner.

Disclosure papers

Ask for the Florida Realtors milestone and reserve study disclosure, the current budget, the reserve schedule and the estoppel certificate. Read them in your review period.

Where is Sanibel Siesta on Sanibel?

Sanibel Siesta is on the Gulf side of central Sanibel, at the beach end of Fulgur Street. The times below are the estimates a travel review and a portal published for this address; they assume normal traffic and do not allow for the causeway in season, which can stretch any trip off the island.

Destination Distance or time Source
Gulf beach On site Surveys and tourism listing
Sanibel Island Golf Club Under a 10-minute walk Travel review
Dunes Golf and Tennis Club About 5 minutes Travel review
Sanibel Historical Village and Museum About 5 minutes by car Travel review
Sanibel Lighthouse and the shell museum About 10 minutes Travel review
J.N. "Ding" Darling refuge and Turner Beach About 20 minutes Travel review
Page Field, Fort Myers About 15 miles Portal
Southwest Florida International Airport About 19 miles, about 40 minutes Portal and travel review
Punta Gorda Airport About 34 miles Portal

Sources: a travel review and a portal page read November 13, 2026. Our research did not run its own drive-time check for this address.

The causeway

The Sanibel Causeway is the only road on and off the island, and it charges a toll. Ian washed out sections of it in September 2022, and it was rebuilt.

Hospital care

Sanibel has no hospital. The nearest hospitals are on the mainland in Fort Myers.

Shops and dining

Periwinkle Way is the island's main shopping and dining street. There is no restaurant at Sanibel Siesta itself.

Captiva

Captiva is reached by driving west past the end of Sanibel; see our Captiva Island homes for sale page for that island.

Schools serving Sanibel Siesta addresses

Lee County assigns public schools through a choice system with zones, so confirm the assignment for 1246 Fulgur Street with the School District of Lee County before relying on any portal. The notes below come from the district, a portal and Sanibel records, and none of them replaces the district's own address lookup.

The Sanibel School

The Sanibel School is the island's public school, serving kindergarten through eighth grade.

High school

There is no high school on Sanibel; students attend on the mainland. A portal lists the address in Elementary Zone N, Middle Zone L and High South Zone 5; confirm with the district.

Checking the assignment

Use the district's school zone tools with the street address, since zone lines and choices change by school year.

A short history of Sanibel Siesta

Sanibel Siesta's story starts before the condominium. The chamber of commerce says the site was a 1960s motel with cottages and became a condominium in 1974, the year the City of Sanibel incorporated, and the county roll gives 1975 as the year built for every unit.

Motel to condominium

The 1974 conversion and the 1975 year built suggest the current buildings replaced or added to the motel, though our research did not confirm which. The declaration would settle it.

The first sales

The county file records its first Sanibel Siesta sales in August 1974 and lists 17 sales it treats as first sales through December 1976, at $43,000 to $67,000.

The developer

No public source our research reached names the developer or converter. A clerk search of Book 1050, Page 1083 would name the declarant.

Prices over five decades

The decade medians in the county file rose from $62,250 in the 1970s to $650,000 in the 2020s so far, across 139 qualified sales.

After Ian

After Ian in 2022 the association rebuilt the pool and office, repaired the elevators and replanted the grounds, and reopened to new bookings in April 2024.

What should you check before you make an offer on a Sanibel Siesta condo?

A Sanibel Siesta purchase turns on the unit's floor and condition after Ian, the association's finances and insurance, the rental terms, and the flood picture of a 1975 building behind the Gulf dune. This list follows from the county record and the gaps this page could not close.

Confirm the unit count and building

Ask for the site plan and confirm which building and floor the unit sits on, and how the association counts its units.

Inspect the unit

Cover the air conditioning, water heater, windows, sliders and lanai, and ask what was rebuilt after Ian and by whom.

Read the budget and reserves

Ask for the current budget, the reserve schedule and the reserve balances, and confirm what the dues include.

Ask about assessments

Ask whether any special assessment was levied for Ian repairs and whether any is open or planned.

Get the insurance details

Ask for the master wind and flood certificates and deductibles, then quote a unit policy before you write the offer.

Confirm the rental terms

Get the minimum stay in writing, check the City of Sanibel license for the unit, and read the owner agreement for the on-site rental program.

Check the flood zone by building

Look up the FEMA zone for the unit's building and ask whether an elevation certificate is on file.

Get the milestone and reserve study status

Ask for the milestone inspection report and the structural integrity reserve study, or the association's written position on why one does not apply.

Compare recorded sales

Compare the asking price with recorded Sanibel Siesta sales of similar floor and condition, not with the island average.

Sanibel Siesta and other Sanibel condos buyers compare

Buyers who look at Sanibel Siesta often weigh it against other Gulf-front condominiums in the middle of the island and other buildings with weekly or shorter rentals. The comparison sticks to what each source shows, and the strengths and weak points close the section.

Community How it compares with Sanibel Siesta
Sandpiper Beach A smaller Gulf-front neighbor in the mid-island stretch, with two-story walk-up buildings
Sanddollar A Gulf-front condominium on Middle Gulf Drive
Gulfside Place Another Gulf-front building on Middle Gulf Drive
Signal Inn 19 two-story beach houses on Olde Middle Gulf Drive, with a weekly minimum and plans from one to three bedrooms
Sanibel Arms Listed by a rental guide with a 7-day minimum
Pelicans Roost and Sanibel Beach Club Named by a travel review as similarly priced rental choices

Sources: Sanibel real estate surveys, a rental rules guide, a travel review and our own Sanibel pages, read November 2026.

Sandpiper Beach

Our Sandpiper Beach condos for sale page covers a much smaller Gulf-front condominium in the same middle stretch of the island, useful if you want a quieter building with fewer units.

Sanddollar and Gulfside Place

Our pages for Sanddollar condos for sale and Gulfside Place condos for sale cover two other Gulf-front buildings on Middle Gulf Drive, for comparing a different building form on a nearby stretch of beach.

Signal Inn

Signal Inn is smaller and offers more plan sizes; Sanibel Siesta offers one plan and a shorter minimum stay.

Where Sanibel Siesta stands out, and where it does not

Sanibel Siesta's draws are its short minimum stay, an association-run rental desk, a Gulf-front setting and recorded prices below many Gulf-front buildings. Its limits are 1975 construction, a single two-bedroom plan, a busy resort operation with a front desk, and roughly $15,600 a year in dues.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Sanibel Siesta specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows island condominiums from its Fort Myers office, the one closest to the Sanibel Causeway. For this page we tracked all 139 qualified Sanibel Siesta sales in the county file and matched each to its unit number, and we will run the same check for any unit you are weighing.

★★★★★ "Marc was key in three real estate transactions for my wife and I in the past ten years! He worked tirelessly for us in all three deals! We highly recommended Marc to anyone wanting a true professional."

Verified Zillow review. stephenjgraham, on buying and selling a condo in Bonita Springs with Marc Comisar.

Talk to our team about a Sanibel Siesta unit

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816 with the building, the floor and how you plan to use the unit, and an agent will send matching listings, the recorded county sales of comparable units and the association questions to ask. You can also search current listings at any time.

Thinking of selling a Sanibel Siesta unit?

A Sanibel Siesta unit is priced by its floor, its view, its finish after Ian and its rental record, so pricing it against recorded sales at the same address beats pricing it against the island. For a seller's view, start with selling a home on Sanibel or Captiva with McGreevy and Comisar.

Frequently Asked Questions about Sanibel Siesta condos for sale

These answers come from the Lee County roll and sale files, the chamber and island news reports, Sanibel real estate surveys, the tourism listing and public sold records. Where our research could not confirm a fact, the answer says so plainly.

What is Sanibel Siesta?

A Gulf-front condominium of two-bedroom, two-bath units at 1246 Fulgur Street, Sanibel, ZIP 33957, Lee County, recorded as Sanibel Siesta Condo.

Is Sanibel Siesta on West Gulf Drive?

No. It is on Fulgur Street in central Sanibel; complexes on West Gulf Drive are separate properties.

What is Sanibel Siesta on the Beach?

That is the name the association's rental operation uses for guest stays at the same property.

How many units are there?

The county roll lists 61 unit parcels plus a common area, and the chamber counts 62 units. Ask the association for the declared figure.

How big are the units?

The roll records 1,047 heated square feet for every unit; listings quote about 995 to 1,400 square feet in total, including lanais.

How many bedrooms do the units have?

Every unit is two bedrooms and two baths.

When was Sanibel Siesta built?

The roll gives 1975. The chamber says the site was a 1960s motel that became a condominium in 1974.

Who built Sanibel Siesta?

No public source our research found names the developer or converter; the declaration at Book 1050, Page 1083 would.

Are there elevators?

Listings say at least some buildings have elevators, which were under repair after Ian in 2024. Confirm for the building you want.

What do Sanibel Siesta condos sell for?

Lee County recorded 3 qualified sales in the 12 months to November 2026, at $535,000, $590,000 and $650,000, a $590,000 median.

What was the most recent sale?

$590,000 for unit 306, recorded May 13, 2026.

What is the highest recorded sale?

$1,375,000 for unit 506 in October 2021, far above every other sale in the file. The next highest recent sale was $734,000 in September 2023.

How many units sell each year?

Since 2015 the county file shows no more than four qualified sales in a year, and none in 2022, 2024 or 2025.

What is the price per square foot?

The 2026 sales ran $511 to $621 per square foot of the roll's heated area.

What are the monthly dues?

Listings in 2025 and 2026 show about $1,300 a month; portals show $1,100 to $1,400. Confirm the current figure with the association.

What do the dues include?

One listing lists management, cable TV, insurance, irrigation water, legal and accounting, grounds, pest control, sewer, trash and water.

Are there special assessments?

None was published. Ask the association about Ian repair assessments and any open or planned assessment.

Is there a master association or CDD?

Our research found neither.

What is the minimum rental?

Most sources give 3 days; one guide lists 7 days. Confirm the current rule in writing.

Does the association run the rentals?

Yes. The association's front desk runs an on-site rental program under the Sanibel Siesta on the Beach name, and about 60 of 62 units were in it in 2024.

Do I need a rental license?

Yes. A rented unit needs a City of Sanibel rental license, and Lee County's tourist tax applies to short stays.

Are pets allowed?

Surveys say owners may keep leashed pets and rental guests generally may not. An assistance animal is a separate accommodation request under fair housing law.

Is Sanibel Siesta age restricted?

No source our research read describes an age restriction; confirm with the association.

Is Sanibel Siesta on the beach?

Yes. The property has its own deeded access to the Gulf beach.

What amenities are there?

A heated pool, tennis, shuffleboard, two grill areas, laundry, bike rentals, Wi-Fi and an on-site front desk.

Is there golf?

Not on site. Sanibel Island Golf Club is under a 10-minute walk, according to a travel review.

Is Sanibel Siesta gated?

No source our research read mentions a gate; confirm on a visit.

What flood zone is Sanibel Siesta in?

Our research did not confirm the FEMA zone. Sanibel is mapped in AE and VE zones, so check each building on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center.

What evacuation zone is it in?

Lee County evacuation Zone A, like all of Sanibel.

Did Hurricane Ian damage Sanibel Siesta?

Yes. Flooding hit the ground-level units hardest, the office was demolished, the elevators needed repair and the pool was rebuilt.

When did it reopen after Ian?

New bookings opened April 1, 2024, and the chamber's ribbon cutting on April 8, 2024 counted 54 of 62 units open.

What about Helene and Milton?

Both storms flooded parts of Sanibel in 2024. No Sanibel Siesta damage report from either was found; ask the association.

Does Sanibel Siesta need a milestone inspection?

Probably, since the 1975 buildings are described as three or four floors. Ask the association for the report or its written position.

What are property taxes on a unit?

Listing records show $6,367 on one unit for 2025 and $1,092 on another for 2024, depending on exemptions and assessed value. Expect a reset at your purchase.

How far is the airport?

Southwest Florida International Airport is about 19 miles, roughly 40 minutes, according to a portal and a travel review.

What school serves Sanibel Siesta?

The Sanibel School serves kindergarten through eighth grade; confirm the assignment with the district.

Where do I see Sanibel Siesta condos for sale?

Our current listings search shows active Sanibel units, and we send new ones as they list. Call 239-441-2816 or contact us to start a saved search.

About Domain Realty Group on Sanibel

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team working Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, including Sanibel and Captiva, from offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) lead the team, with over 45 years of combined direct experience.

Meet the team on our agents page, read our client reviews or learn more about our team. We tracked every qualified Sanibel Siesta sale in the county file back to 1974, unit by unit, to build this page.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Sanibel real estate, Captiva Island homes for sale, Sandpiper Beach condos for sale, Sanddollar condos for sale, Gulfside Place condos for sale and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to a source below. No real estate portal is linked, by policy; facts credited to "listing records", "sold records" or "portal pages" come from public broker and portal records read November 13, 2026 and are labelled as such. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll and sale files, qualified sales on the Sanibel Siesta Condo unit parcels in ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026. Web sources were read November 13 to November 21, 2026 unless another date is shown.

County, clerk and state records

Sanibel Siesta reports, guides and records

Flood, storms and insurance

Florida condominium law and fair housing

Schools, places and roads