Opens in a new tab
Back to Sanibel

Sanibel · Florida · 33957

Sanibel Moorings Condos for Sale in Sanibel, FL

Sanibel Moorings condos for sale: 122 one, two and three bedroom resort units and two townhouses at 845 East Gulf Drive, with a Gulf beach on one side of the road and boat docks on a canal on the other. Recorded county sales, the fee and the hurricane assessment, the association-only rental program, flood zone and the checks to run before you buy. Updated November 2026.

Aerial view of Sanibel Moorings at 845 East Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957: two-story condominium buildings and a pool between East Gulf Drive and the Gulf beach, more buildings and tennis courts along a canal across the road, each building point marked with a white ring

Sanibel Moorings is a 122-unit resort condominium at 845 East Gulf Drive, Sanibel, ZIP 33957, in Lee County, on the east end of the island. East Gulf Drive splits the property in two: one parcel runs from the road to the Gulf beach, and the other faces a Shell Harbor canal where the association keeps its boat docks. It is one of the island condominiums we follow on our Sanibel homes for sale guide.

Aerial view of Sanibel Moorings at 845 East Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957: two-story condominium buildings and a pool between East Gulf Drive and the Gulf beach, more buildings and tennis courts along a canal across the road, each building point marked with a white ring
Sanibel Moorings from above. White rings mark the 16 building points and the white dot the common-element point from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll; no parcel outline is drawn. Aerial: USDA NAIP via USGS The National Map (public domain); capture date not confirmed.

The county recorded 11 qualified Sanibel Moorings sales in the 24 months to November 2026, from $262,500 to $800,000, with a $569,000 median. The newest two, units 611 and 811, both recorded at $569,000 on September 18, 2026. This page lays out those sales and the long record behind them, the unit plans, the fee and the hurricane assessment that sits on top of it, the rental program every leasing owner must use, the flood and storm record and the checks to run before an offer.

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group agents. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.

Key takeaways for Sanibel Moorings condo buyers

These points come from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale files, the association’s own posted documents (fees, FAQ, insurance summary and the audit for the year ended September 30, 2025), island news reports and FEMA flood maps. Each one is expanded below, and anything our research could not settle is marked as unconfirmed.

  • Sanibel Moorings has 122 units in 16 two-story buildings: 16 one-bedroom units, 92 two-bedroom flats, 12 three-bedroom flats and 2 canal-front townhouses.
  • Qualified county sales over the last 24 months ran from $262,500 to $800,000, with a median of $569,000 on 11 sales.
  • For the 2025 to 2026 budget year every unit pays $1,386.47 a month, plus an $850 a month hurricane special assessment, for $2,236.47 in total.
  • The assessment repays a $7 million bank loan taken after Hurricane Ian; $5,943,277 was still owed on September 30, 2025, and the loan matures August 2, 2032.
  • Units may be leased only through the association’s own rental program, which runs the property as a resort with a front desk.
  • Bay-side docks take boats up to 25 feet, and the Gulf beach is on the other half of the property.
  • FEMA maps the building sites in zone AE with an 11 foot base flood elevation, and the beach side in VE at 13 feet.
  • Every building is two stories on the county roll, so Florida’s milestone inspection and reserve study rules for three-story buildings do not appear to apply; confirm with the association.

Sanibel Moorings condos for sale right now

Units at Sanibel Moorings come up a handful at a time: the county recorded 5 qualified sales in 2025 and 6 so far in 2026. Listing portals were not used for this page, so for what is on the market today, search current listings and filter for Sanibel, or ask us to watch 845 East Gulf Drive for you.

What a listing at this address means

Every unit shares the street number 845, and the unit number follows it. A listing for 845 East Gulf Drive unit 1541, for example, is in Building 15 on the county’s numbering, which helps you place it on the aerial before you tour.

Reading the unit number

The county numbers units by building, then stack, then a last digit that our research reads as the floor: Building 1 holds units 111, 112, 121, 122, 131, 132, 141 and 142, and the pattern runs to Building 16, units 1611 to 1642. That floor reading is not confirmed against the condominium plat, so ask the listing agent which level a unit sits on.

Comparing asks with recorded prices

Price a Sanibel Moorings unit against what the county actually recorded at 845 East Gulf Drive, not against asking prices nearby. Since 2025 the qualified record has run from $262,500 for a one-bedroom unit to $800,000 for a two-bedroom and a three-bedroom unit.

Ready to tour Sanibel Moorings?

Tell us the plan you want, whether the unit will go into the rental program and whether you keep a boat, and we will send each match with the recorded sales of comparable units. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do Sanibel Moorings condos sell for?

Recorded Sanibel Moorings prices in the 24 months to November 2026 ran from $262,500 to $800,000, with a $569,000 median on 11 qualified sales. The table counts only sales the Lee County Property Appraiser marks as qualified on the 122 unit parcels, through the newest sale in the county file, September 18, 2026.

Window to November 21, 2026 Qualified sales Median Low High
12 months, since November 2025 6 $609,500 $470,000 $700,000
24 months, since November 2024 11 $569,000 $262,500 $800,000
36 months, since November 2023 12 $609,500 $262,500 $810,000
60 months, since November 2021 13 $650,000 $262,500 $810,000
10 years, since November 2016 39 $562,000 $262,500 $1,250,000
20 years, since November 2006 78 $486,250 $260,000 $1,250,000
All qualified sales since September 1972 250 $263,750 $28,800 $1,250,000

Data updated: November 2026. Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and sale files, qualified improved sales on the Sanibel Moorings unit parcels in ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026; newest Sanibel Moorings sale September 18, 2026. Deeds under $10,000 are left out.

The windows mix one-bedroom, two-bedroom and three-bedroom units, so a median moves with whichever plans happened to sell. The plan table further down is the better guide to a single unit.

Every qualified sale since 2023

Recorded Unit Bedrooms Heated sq ft Price Per heated sq ft
April 13, 2023 222 2 983 $662,500 $674
January 26, 2024 612 2 981 $810,000 $826
April 30, 2025 1112 2 983 $800,000 $814
July 14, 2025 912 1 612 $262,500 $429
September 5, 2025 531 3 981 $400,000 $408
September 17, 2025 1541 3 983 $800,000 $814
October 2, 2025 822 2 983 $505,000 $514
February 10, 2026 111 2 983 $700,000 $712
February 20, 2026 331 2 975 $650,000 $667
June 10, 2026 232 2 983 $470,000 $478
July 24, 2026 121 2 983 $700,000 $712
September 18, 2026 611 2 981 $569,000 $580
September 18, 2026 811 2 983 $569,000 $579

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale files, qualified sales; price per square foot is the recorded price divided by the roll’s heated area.

The two September 2026 records

Units 611 and 811 both recorded at $569,000 on September 18, 2026. Two identical prices on the same day can mean one deed covering two units rather than two separate sales. We have not read the deed, so treat the pair with care when you use it as a comparable.

A wide spread on similar plans

Two-bedroom units of 983 heated square feet recorded anywhere from $470,000 to $800,000 between 2025 and 2026. Condition explains much of that: after Ian the association restored units to a base level, and owners paid for their own upgrades, so finishes differ from one door to the next.

One unit, two prices in nine months

Unit 111 changed hands for $365,100 in May 2025 in a transfer the county did not treat as qualified, then recorded a qualified sale at $700,000 in February 2026. The county file does not say what changed in between; ask about work done on any unit with a short resale history.

Other recent transfers outside the qualified count

The county also recorded unit 721 at $1,125,000 in May 2024, unit 1411 at $524,000 in September 2024 and unit 1342 at $840,000 in December 2024 without marking them qualified. Unqualified deeds can be estate, related-party or package transfers, so we keep them out of every median above.

Price per heated square foot

Across the 11 qualified sales of 2025 and 2026, recorded prices ran from $408 to $814 per heated square foot, with a $580 median. The county lists most units at 975 to 983 heated square feet, which keeps the measure useful for comparing two-bedroom flats.

Sales by year

Year Qualified sales Median
2016 6 $435,750
2017 4 $482,500
2018 7 $510,000
2019 3 $560,000
2020 5 $575,000
2021 7 $529,000
2022 0 none
2023 1 $662,500
2024 1 $810,000
2025 5 $505,000
2026 to September 6 $609,500

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale files, qualified sales grouped by recording year.

The Ian gap

The county file holds no qualified sale in 2022 and one each in 2023 and 2024, the years the resort was closed and under repair. Sales picked back up in 2025 once units were open again.

The pre-Ian high

Units 512 and 112 each recorded at $1,150,000 in September 2021, and unit 522, a three-bedroom flat, recorded the highest qualified price in the county file, $1,250,000, in September 2020. No qualified sale since the storm has reached $1,000,000.

Prices by decade

Decade Qualified sales Median Low High
1970s 38 $48,000 $28,800 $100,000
1980s 46 $157,500 $92,500 $265,000
1990s 54 $240,750 $180,000 $365,000
2000s 39 $455,000 $280,000 $970,000
2010s 48 $431,000 $260,000 $965,000
2020s, to September 2026 25 $575,000 $262,500 $1,250,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale files, qualified sales grouped by recording year.

How many units have sold

Of the 122 units, 110 show at least one qualified sale in the county file, and the first recorded qualified sale was unit 521 at $43,200 in September 1972.

Sales by plan since 2011

Plan, qualified sales since 2011 Sales Median Low High
One bedroom, 612 sq ft 12 $382,000 $260,000 $525,000
Two bedroom flats 52 $500,000 $325,000 $1,150,000
Three bedroom flats 6 $767,500 $400,000 $1,250,000
Building 12 townhouses 1 $965,000 $965,000 $965,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale files and parcel roll, qualified sales from 2011 to September 18, 2026.

Sanibel Moorings floor plans and buildings

The county roll lists 16 residential buildings: fifteen of 8 units and one of 2, Building 12, which holds the two canal-front townhouses. Every suite has a living room, a dining area, a full kitchen and a screened lanai, according to the association’s accommodation pages.

Plan Units on the roll Heated sq ft on the roll 2026 county value
One bedroom, one bath 16 612 $304,395 to $393,617
Two bedroom, two bath flat 92 975 to 983 $392,723 to $743,030, plus one unit at $103,996
Three bedroom, two bath flat 12 981 to 983 $518,430 to $741,079
Building 12 townhouses 2 1,886 and 2,187 $1,019,390 and $1,054,413

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll LCPA2610, November 2026.

Where the plans sit

Buildings 1, 2, 9 and 14 mix four one-bedroom units with four two-bedroom units. Buildings 3, 4, 8, 10, 11 and 13 hold two-bedroom units only, Buildings 5, 7 and 15 carry the three-bedroom units, and Buildings 6 and 16 are all two-bedroom.

The three-bedroom size question

The roll gives the three-bedroom flats the same 981 to 983 heated square feet as the two-bedroom flats, while a Realtor survey guide puts the three-bedroom plans at 1,300 to 1,500 square feet. Those two figures cannot both describe the same rooms, so check the condominium plat or an appraisal sketch before you pay a three-bedroom premium.

The townhouses

Building 12 holds the property’s two townhouses on the canal: unit 1211 with three bedrooms, two and a half baths and 1,886 heated square feet, and unit 1221 with two bedrooms, two and a half baths and 2,187 heated square feet. They carry the highest county values here, above $1,000,000 each.

Two stories, no elevator reported

The roll lists the flats as two-story buildings, and a Realtor survey guide says there is no elevator. One portal lists an elevator; ask on the tour if stairs matter to you.

Build years

The roll shows 1973 for 66 unit parcels and 1974 for 56, and the resort’s own marketing gives 1974 as the opening year.

Interiors after Ian

The association rebuilt units to a base standard after Hurricane Ian under its own construction contract, and owners could hire the same contractor for upgrades at their own cost. Rental-program units must meet the association’s Unit Standards Manual and are inspected at least once a year, so a unit in the program has a set floor for its finishes.

County values on the roll

The 2026 roll values the 122 units at about $57.2 million in total, with a $396,461 median per unit. One two-bedroom unit, 541, is listed at $103,996, far below its neighbors; ask what lies behind that figure if that unit comes up.

The Sanibel Moorings site on both sides of East Gulf Drive

The declaration describes two parcels: a Gulf-side parcel running about 543 to 563 feet from East Gulf Drive to the water, and a bay-side parcel made up of Lots 112 to 116, Block 3, First Addition to Shell Harbor, on a canal. On the county’s roll points, Buildings 12 to 16 stand on the canal side and Buildings 1 to 11 on the Gulf side, with the common-element point and a pool on the Gulf side.

Size of the grounds

The Chamber and the resort describe a six-acre complex, a 2010 article spoke of nearly seven acres of gardens, and the county’s GIS puts the common-element parcel at 9.81 acres. Those measure different things; none of them is the upland area alone.

The beach

The Gulf-side buildings sit behind a dune strip that opens onto the beach, so owners walk to the sand without crossing a road.

The canal and docks

The bay-side docks reach the back bay and the Gulf, and the association says they take boats up to 25 feet. Guest slips with water and electric cost $20 a day. Boat trailers may not be parked anywhere on the grounds.

Neighbors

Loggerhead Cay, a 168-unit Gulf-front condominium at 979 East Gulf Drive, is next door to the east. The Shell Harbor canal neighborhood lies behind the bay-side parcel.

Is Sanibel Moorings gated?

No gate turns up in any source we read. Parking is by permit and monitored, according to the association’s letter to Realtors.

The coordinates

The common-element point on the Lee County roll sits at about 26.4407 north, 82.0354 west, and the unit parcels carry Lee strap numbers beginning 294623T1004.

Amenities at Sanibel Moorings

The amenities at Sanibel Moorings are association common elements spread across both parcels, and the association’s FAQ says owners pay no separate rent or land-use fee for them. There is no golf course and no club membership, and the list below comes from the association’s pages and its insurance schedule.

Pools

The insurance schedule lists a main pool, a north pool and a wading pool. Tourism and Realtor pages describe the two main pools as heated.

Tennis

Tennis courts are insured common elements, and the aerial shows courts on the canal side beside Building 12. Whether any court is lined for pickleball was not confirmed.

Boating and the water

Beyond the docks, the association lists kayaks and canoes, fishing from the beach and the docks, and a weekly beach walk.

Grounds and shared rooms

A boardwalk, a guest center, a north cabana with laundry, a fitness room, grills and Wi-Fi across the property round out the list.

The botanical garden

The grounds were designated a botanical garden by the American Public Gardens Association in January 2010, with butterfly, hummingbird and moon gardens and a hibiscus collection, and weekly tours cost $5. Hurricane Ian badly damaged the garden; a local writer reported in April 2023 that it no longer existed as it was. Its current state and any tour schedule are not published.

Paths

The resort says guests have direct access to more than 20 miles of paved shared-use paths, which reach Lighthouse Beach and Periwinkle Way without a car.

The association and how the resort is run

Sanibel Moorings Condominium Association, Inc., a Florida not-for-profit incorporated November 3, 1971 under charter number 722002, governs the property. The association itself operates the resort: its letter to Realtors describes “a Condominium Association that operates as a resort hotel,” with a welcome center front desk and a general manager.

The declaration

The original declaration was recorded January 21, 1972 at Official Records Book 772, Page 452, with condominium plats in Condominium Plat Book 2, Pages 129 and 175. The amended and restated declaration lists 11 later amendments, and The Mariner Group, Inc. is named as the entity that submitted the land to condominium.

Votes and shares

Each unit carries a 1/122 share of the common expenses and one vote, and every unit pays the same assessment whatever its size.

The board

The 2026 to 2027 officers sheet lists Charlie Lais as president, Mark Lorenger as vice president, Bill Hallberg as secretary and Nadine Miller as treasurer, with three more directors. The election and annual meeting were set for November 7, 2026; results were not public when this page was written.

Corporate record

An automated search of the Florida Division of Corporations returned an error during research, so the association’s current status and registered agent were not read for this page. Check them on Sunbiz before closing.

Owners not in the rental program

Owners who keep their unit out of the program may hire the association’s outside cleaning company, and the association asks them not to use the property as a mailing address.

What does it cost to own a Sanibel Moorings condo each year?

The big carrying costs at Sanibel Moorings are the monthly association fee, the hurricane special assessment and property taxes, before your own unit insurance. On the association’s 2025 to 2026 fee sheet those first two come to $2,236.47 a month, or $26,837.64 a year.

Monthly charge, 2025 to 2026 Amount
Condominium fee $698.98
Common property insurance $550.88
Reserve fee $136.61
Total condominium fee $1,386.47
Hurricane special assessment $850.00
Total paid to the association $2,236.47

Source: Sanibel Moorings Condominium Association, Fees to Owners and FAQ, 2025 to 2026. Confirm every figure on the estoppel certificate.

Insurance inside the fee

The insurance line alone is $550.88 a month, about 39.7 percent of the regular fee, or $6,610.56 a year per unit.

The hurricane assessment

In the year ended September 30, 2024 the board approved a $9,992,659 special assessment to repay the Hurricane Ian loan, billed at $850 a month per unit over 98 months from September 30, 2024. Counting forward, the 98th payment falls in October 2032; ask the association for the final installment date.

The loan behind it

The association borrowed $7,000,000 at 8.25 percent, maturing August 2, 2032, with monthly payments of $95,393. At September 30, 2025, $5,943,277 was still owed, which works out to about $48,715 per unit.

Who pays the rest at a sale

The association’s February 2024 notice tells buyers and sellers to settle in the contract who pays the installments still to come, and says surplus insurance proceeds go only to owners of record on the distribution date. Write that into the offer.

Rental program charges

Units in the program pay a cleaning charge per departure of $105 for a one-bedroom, $115 for a two-bedroom, $125 for a three-bedroom and $135 for a townhouse, plus linen charges of $5 to $15 per occupied day, an annual deep cleaning of $260 to $410 and an expense-recovery share deducted monthly. The expense-recovery formula is not published.

What the association does not charge

The published documents show no capital contribution, transfer fee, master association or community development district. Confirm each on the estoppel certificate and the tax bill.

Association finances

The audit for the year ended September 30, 2025 shows total revenue of $4,657,203, including $1,523,204 of rental income against a $1,980,916 budget, and replacement funds of $2,260,245. Owners voted to waive the statutory reserve funding requirement of $171,305 for that year, and the reserve schedule rests on a 2008 board study rather than an outside reserve study.

Property taxes on a Sanibel Moorings unit

Property tax on a Sanibel Moorings unit is the taxable value times the millage for Lee County taxing district 010, City of Sanibel, which totals 14.0021 mills for 2026. That rate is the sum of the county, school, city, water management, fire, library and other levies in the Lee County Property Appraiser’s 2026 millage book.

Levy in district 010, 2026 Mills
Lee County general revenue 3.7623
Public schools, local board and state law 2.2480 and 3.0230
City of Sanibel 2.5000
Sanibel Fire and Rescue District 1.3915
Sanibel Public Library District 0.4677
Water management, mosquito, hyacinth, navigation and city voted debt the balance
Total 14.0021

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser, 2026 millage rates, district 010.

What the arithmetic gives

At 14.0021 mills, a unit with the roll’s median taxable value of $396,461 carries an estimated $5,551 a year in ad valorem tax. A buyer whose taxable value resets to a $569,000 purchase price would see about $7,967 a year. These are estimates before non-ad valorem charges, not bills.

Why a new owner pays more

A sale resets the assessed value to market value on the next January 1. The seller’s bill can sit well below yours, so budget from your own price.

Homestead is rare here

Only 2 of the 122 unit parcels carry a homestead exemption on the roll, and 103 owners have a mailing address outside Florida. A unit in the rental program is a second home or an investment for tax purposes.

The yearly cap

For non-homestead property, Florida caps growth in assessed value at 10 percent a year for non-school levies; a homestead is capped at 3 percent. Look up any unit on the Lee County Property Appraiser site and the bill on the Lee County Tax Collector site.

One year of carrying cost

Taxes at about $7,967 plus $26,837.64 in association charges come to roughly $34,805 a year on a $569,000 unit, before your own insurance, utilities not covered by the association and any rental program charges.

How renting works at Sanibel Moorings

At Sanibel Moorings, renting is done by the association or not at all. The declaration says no unit may be leased except through the Association Rental Program, which takes bookings, sets rates and minimum stays and runs housekeeping, and the FAQ repeats the rule. Owners who want to list on their own or through an outside agency should look elsewhere.

The rental program agreement

The sample agreement asks program owners to keep the unit available at least 51 percent of each calendar year, to accept the association’s minimum stays, to keep the unit to the Unit Standards Manual and to carry at least $500,000 of liability cover per occurrence naming the association as an additional insured.

Minimum stays

The declaration sets a two-day minimum lease, and the association sets the working minimum inside that rule. Realtor guides report minimums from 4 days to 7 days by season; confirm the current policy with the association.

Why short stays are allowed

Sanibel limits rentals under four weeks to its Resort Housing District, and Sanibel Moorings sits in that district. In January 2026 the city counted 1,823 short-term rental units on the island and about 360 addresses possibly out of compliance with its rental rules.

Where the rental money goes

Rental income flows through the association’s books: the audit shows $1,523,204 of rental revenue for the year ended September 30, 2025. The declaration makes rental-program surplus a common surplus that is not paid out to owners, and the owner revenue split is not published, so ask for the current agreement and a unit’s statements.

Guest rules

Guest stays are smoke-free with a $500 fine for smoking in a unit, check-in by 4:30 pm and check-out at 11 am, one parking space per unit and $25 passes for extra cars, up to two.

Tax on stays

Rentals of six months or less carry Florida sales tax and the Lee County tourist development tax; ask the association how the program collects and remits them.

The 2026 planning review

In May 2026 the Sanibel Planning Commission reviewed redevelopment in the Resort Housing District. City staff listed Sanibel Moorings at 122 units, restored and occupied, and 70.95 units over its development intensity allowance before Ian, and the commission voted 6 to 1 to send the resort matter to City Council. No rule change for the property had been adopted in our sources.

Pets at Sanibel Moorings

Owners may keep small, noiseless household pets under the declaration; renters and guests need board approval. Guests booking through the resort may bring up to two approved pets at $30 per pet per night, and several breeds are not accepted.

Assistance animals

An assistance animal is not a pet under fair housing law, and a pet rule does not bar a request for a reasonable accommodation. Ask the association for its process.

Quiet hours and floors

Quiet hours run from 10 pm to 8 am, and units above the ground floor need carpet or an approved floor covering, which matters if you plan to change the flooring.

Is Sanibel Moorings in a flood zone?

Yes. FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer places the sampled building sites at Sanibel Moorings in zone AE with an 11 foot base flood elevation, and points toward the beach in zone VE with a 13 foot base flood elevation. The map panel is 12071C0533G, effective November 17, 2022.

Flood fact Figure
FEMA zone at the building sites AE, base flood elevation 11 ft
Toward the beach VE, base flood elevation 13 ft
Map panel 12071C0533G, effective November 17, 2022
Evacuation zone Lee County Zone A, the island zone
Building elevation certificates Not found; ask the association

Sources: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer as recorded in our research file; Lee County Emergency Management.

What AE and VE mean for a buyer

Both are special flood hazard areas, so a lender will require flood cover on a mortgaged unit. The association’s flood policies sit inside the fee; your own contents cover and any lender requirement are on top.

The 50 percent rule

When repair or improvement work in a flood zone costs 50 percent or more of a building’s market value, the building must be brought up to current flood rules. Ask the City of Sanibel building department how that rule was applied in the Ian rebuild here.

Ground-floor units

The flats are two stories, so roughly half of the stacked units sit on the ground floor. Ask for any elevation certificate and for the flood history of the specific building before you choose a level.

Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton at Sanibel Moorings

Hurricane Ian on September 28, 2022 closed the resort. Lee County had ordered evacuation Zones A and B, including Sanibel and Captiva, the day before. The association rebuilt under its own construction contract, reopened units from mid-December 2023, more than 14 months after the storm, and the SanCap Chamber held a ribbon-cutting on January 9, 2024.

The rebuild

A February 19, 2024 association notice said the premises “remains a construction site,” that units and common elements were being restored to a base level of like quality, and that owners could contract with the association’s builder for upgrades. More than half of the 122 units were bookable by January 12, 2024.

How the rebuild was paid for

The recovery leaned on a $7 million bank loan and the $9,992,659 special assessment that repays it. The audit restated prior-year hurricane costs by $5,887,823 and showed a hurricane fund balance of negative $6,662,989 at September 30, 2025, which tells you costs ran well past insurance recoveries.

Helene and Milton in 2024

We found no public report specific to Sanibel Moorings for Helene in September 2024 or Milton in October 2024, and the audit books no separate 2024 storm fund. Lee County again ordered the barrier islands evacuated for Milton. Ask the association whether either storm led to claims or repairs.

Where things stood in 2026

City planning staff counted the property as restored and occupied with 122 units in May 2026.

What to ask

Ask which buildings were gutted, what the repair scope was, the total cost against insurance recoveries and whether any further assessment is planned. Building-level damage detail was not published.

Florida condo law and insurance at Sanibel Moorings

Florida’s post-2021 condominium laws added milestone inspections and structural integrity reserve studies for buildings of three habitable stories or more. Every Sanibel Moorings building is two stories on the county roll, so neither appears to be required, and no milestone or study document is posted on the association’s owners’ page. Get that confirmed in writing.

Reserves at a two-story association

Because the study rules reach only three-story buildings, owners here may still vote to waive or reduce ordinary reserves, and they did so for the year ended September 30, 2025. Read the reserve schedule with that in mind.

The master insurance program

The association’s broker summary for the 2025 annual meeting puts the total premium at $746,364.48, about $6,118 per unit a year. It layers Citizens wind cover limited to $1 million per building with a 3 percent hurricane deductible, Lloyd’s wind cover on Building 5 and the ancillary buildings, an excess wind layer of $3,568,000 with a $1,000,000 per-occurrence deductible, an all-other-perils policy with a $25,000 deductible and Wright National flood policies with per-building limits of $500,000 to $2,000,000.

Why the limits matter

Building values on the schedule run from about $0.68 million to $1.58 million each, against $1 million of primary wind cover per building and one shared excess layer. The insured values come from a January 4, 2023 appraisal totalling $23,380,119, and ordinance or law and business income are excluded on the wind layers. A gap between cover and value is the kind of thing a big storm turns into an assessment, so ask about the current renewal.

Your own policy

Owners carry an HO-6 policy for the interior and contents and should ask about loss-assessment cover. Program owners must add the $500,000 liability policy named above.

Lending on a resort condominium

A condominium run as a resort, with a front desk and an association rental program, can fall outside some lenders’ standard condo guidelines. Ask your lender early whether it lends at Sanibel Moorings, and expect questions about the special assessment, the reserves and the master policy.

Litigation

The association’s FAQ says it is not party to any litigation over $100,000.

Where is Sanibel Moorings on Sanibel?

Sanibel Moorings sits on the east end of the island, on East Gulf Drive between Loggerhead Cay and the lighthouse end. The drive estimates below are free-flow routing figures with no traffic or causeway delay; in season, from January to April, real drives run longer.

Destination Distance Free-flow drive
Lighthouse Beach Park about 1.7 mi about 5 min
Sanibel Causeway toll plaza about 5.7 mi about 13 min
HealthPark Medical Center, Fort Myers about 16.4 mi about 31 min
Downtown Fort Myers about 19.0 mi about 36 min
I-75 at Daniels Parkway about 20.6 mi about 35 min
Southwest Florida International Airport about 22.7 mi about 40 min
Downtown Naples about 41.6 mi about 70 min

Source: OSRM public routing engine estimates from the property, recorded in our research file; not timed drives.

The causeway toll

The Sanibel Causeway charges inbound only. Public guides list $6 with a transponder and $9 by toll-by-plate; check the current fare with Lee County.

Shops and the refuge

Periwinkle Way carries most of the island’s shops and restaurants, with Bailey’s General Store about 6 minutes away, and the J.N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge visitor center is about 14 minutes.

Captiva

For homes on the next island north, see Captiva Island homes for sale.

Schools serving Sanibel Moorings addresses

Lee County assigns public schools through school choice zones, so the school tied to a Sanibel Moorings address depends on the district’s zone map rather than distance. The island’s public school is The Sanibel School, which serves kindergarten through grade 8 at 3840 Sanibel-Captiva Road, about 7 minutes from the property; high school is off the island.

Checking the assignment

One directory places The Sanibel School in choice zone N. Confirm the zone and the school for 845 East Gulf Drive by address with the School District of Lee County.

A short history of Sanibel Moorings

Sanibel Moorings dates from the early 1970s, when the island’s east-end Gulf front was filling with low-rise condominiums. The association was incorporated in November 1971, the declaration was recorded in January 1972, and the buildings went up in 1973 and 1974.

The developer

The restated declaration names The Mariner Group, Inc. Reporting on a Fort Myers company of that name, founded in 1972 and best known for South Seas Plantation on Captiva, does not settle whether it is the same entity, because the association predates that founding date; treat the link as unconfirmed.

The garden years

Under chief gardener Anita Marshall the grounds became Sanibel’s first designated botanical garden in 2010, a draw that lasted until Ian.

Five decades of prices

The qualified medians climbed from $48,000 in the 1970s to $575,000 so far in the 2020s.

What should you check before you make an offer on a Sanibel Moorings condo?

A Sanibel Moorings offer has more moving parts than most island condos because of the hurricane assessment, the association-only rental program and the layered master insurance. These are the checks we run with buyers at 845 East Gulf Drive, roughly in the order a contract timeline allows them.

Confirm the plan and size

Match the unit number to its building, plan and heated area on the roll, and settle the three-bedroom size question from the plat.

Order the estoppel early

The estoppel certificate confirms the fee, the remaining assessment installments and any balance owed. Agree in the contract who pays the installments still to come.

Read the program agreement

If you plan to rent, read the current rental program agreement, the expense-recovery terms and a year of owner statements for the unit.

Get the insurance picture

Ask for the current master policy summary and price your HO-6, loss-assessment and any flood cover during the inspection period.

Ask about the reserves and study status

Get the reserve schedule and a written statement on milestone inspection and reserve study status for the two-story buildings.

Inspect the unit

Hire an inspector who knows coastal construction, windows, the lanai, the air conditioning and post-Ian repair work.

Check financing first

Confirm your lender will lend on a resort-operated condominium before you spend on inspections.

Compare recorded sales

Price the unit against the county’s recorded sales at 845 East Gulf Drive for the same plan.

Sanibel Moorings and other Sanibel condos buyers compare

Buyers who look at Sanibel Moorings often weigh it against other resort condominiums on the east and middle Gulf front, where unit counts, building heights and rental setups differ a great deal. The differences below come from city planning reports, our research files and our own Sanibel pages.

Community How it differs from Sanibel Moorings
Loggerhead Cay, 979 East Gulf Drive Next door with 168 units, all two-bedroom, taller buildings, no bay-side docks, rentals through outside agencies
Sundial Beach Resort Much larger, with 407 units restored, and a different rental setup
Mariner Pointe 100 units facing the bay and canals rather than the Gulf
Sanibel Arms West 104-unit resort condominium on Middle Gulf Drive
Sanibel Siesta Mid-island Gulf-front condominium with its own rental desk
Signal Inn Gulf-front condos on Olde Middle Gulf Drive

Sources: Santiva Chronicle report on the May 2026 Planning Commission review and our own Sanibel pages, read November 2026.

More Sanibel condo pages

Our pages for Sandpiper Beach condos for sale and Nutmeg Village condos for sale cover two smaller Gulf-front buildings with different rental rules, useful as a contrast to an association-run resort.

Where Sanibel Moorings stands out, and where it does not

Sanibel Moorings pairs a Gulf beach with boat docks on one property, something few Gulf-front complexes on the island can offer. It has low-rise buildings, an association that handles bookings and cleaning, and recorded prices that mostly sat between $470,000 and $810,000 since 2024. Its limits are the $850 a month assessment to about 2032, association-only leasing, no reported elevator and insurance limits that sit below some building values.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Sanibel Moorings specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows island condominiums from its Fort Myers office, the closest of our offices to the Sanibel Causeway. For this page we tracked 250 qualified Sanibel Moorings sales in the county file back to their units and plans, and we will run the same check on any unit you are weighing.

Talk to our team about a Sanibel Moorings unit

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816 with the plan, the rental plan and your budget, and an agent will send matching listings, the recorded sales of comparable units and the association questions to ask. You can also search current listings at any time.

Thinking of selling a Sanibel Moorings unit?

A Sanibel Moorings unit is priced by its plan, its building, its finish after the rebuild and its rental record, so pricing it against sales at the same address beats pricing it against the island. For a seller’s view, start with selling a home on Sanibel or Captiva with McGreevy and Comisar.

Frequently Asked Questions about Sanibel Moorings condos for sale

These answers come from the Lee County roll and sale files, the association’s posted documents, island news reports and FEMA flood maps. Where our research could not confirm a fact, the answer says so.

What is Sanibel Moorings?

A 122-unit resort condominium at 845 East Gulf Drive, Sanibel, ZIP 33957, in Lee County, run by its own association as a resort with a front desk.

Where is Sanibel Moorings?

On the east end of Sanibel, on both sides of East Gulf Drive, next to Loggerhead Cay and about 5 minutes from Lighthouse Beach Park.

How many units are there?

122: 16 one-bedroom units, 92 two-bedroom flats, 12 three-bedroom flats and 2 townhouses.

How big are the units?

The roll lists 612 heated square feet for one-bedroom units, 975 to 983 for the flats and 1,886 and 2,187 for the townhouses.

When was it built?

1973 and 1974 on the county roll.

How many stories are the buildings?

Two, with no elevator reported by a Realtor survey guide.

What do Sanibel Moorings condos sell for?

The 11 qualified sales in the 24 months to November 2026 ran from $262,500 to $800,000, with a $569,000 median.

What was the most recent sale?

Units 611 and 811 each recorded at $569,000 on September 18, 2026.

What is the highest recorded sale?

$1,250,000 for unit 522 in September 2020.

What is the price per square foot?

The 2025 and 2026 qualified sales ran from $408 to $814 per heated square foot, median $580.

What is the monthly fee?

$1,386.47 a month for 2025 to 2026, covering the condo fee, common property insurance and reserves.

Is there a special assessment?

Yes, $850 a month per unit to repay the Hurricane Ian loan, billed over 98 months from September 2024.

What is the total monthly outlay to the association?

$2,236.47 a month, or $26,837.64 a year, before rental program charges.

Can I rent my unit on my own?

No. Every lease must go through the Association Rental Program.

What is the minimum stay?

The declaration sets two days; the association sets the working minimum, which guides report at 4 to 7 days. Confirm with the association.

Do I have to put my unit in the rental program?

No, but owners who rent must use it, and program owners keep the unit available at least 51 percent of each year.

Are there boat docks?

Yes. Bay-side docks take boats up to 25 feet; the slip count and how slips are assigned were not published.

Are pets allowed?

Owners may keep small, quiet household pets; renters and guests need approval. Assistance animals are handled as accommodation requests.

Is Sanibel Moorings on the beach?

Yes. The Gulf-side parcel runs to the beach.

What amenities are there?

Two main pools and a wading pool, tennis, docks, kayaks and canoes, a boardwalk, a fitness room, grills, laundry and a guest center.

Is there golf?

No.

Is it gated?

No gate was found in any source; parking is by permit.

What flood zone is it in?

FEMA zone AE with an 11 foot base flood elevation at the buildings and VE at 13 feet toward the beach, on panel 12071C0533G.

What evacuation zone is it in?

Lee County Zone A.

Did Hurricane Ian damage Sanibel Moorings?

Yes. The resort closed, was rebuilt under an association contract and reopened from mid-December 2023.

Does it need a milestone inspection?

The buildings are two stories, so Florida’s three-story rule does not appear to apply; confirm in writing.

What are property taxes on a unit?

At 14.0021 mills, about $5,551 a year on the median taxable value and about $7,967 on a $569,000 purchase, as estimates.

What school serves Sanibel Moorings?

The Sanibel School for kindergarten through grade 8; confirm the assignment by address with the district.

Who runs the association?

Sanibel Moorings Condominium Association, Inc., which operates the resort with a general manager.

Where do I see Sanibel Moorings condos for sale?

Our current listings search shows active Sanibel units. Call 239-441-2816 or contact us to set an alert.

★★★★★ “Marc is extremely knowledgeable, professional and a true pleasure to work with. He kept us informed throughout the process and went over and beyond our expectations to ensure an extremely smooth process.”

Verified Google review. Lori Crosby, a buyer, on working with Marc Comisar of Domain Realty Group.

About Domain Realty Group on Sanibel

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team working Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, including Sanibel and Captiva, from offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) lead the team, with over 45 years of combined direct experience.

Meet the team on our agents page, read our client reviews or learn more about our team. For this page we tracked every qualified Sanibel Moorings sale in the county file and read the association’s own fee sheet, audit and insurance summary beside it.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816 info@domainrealtygroup.com

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Sanibel real estate, Captiva Island homes for sale, Sanibel Siesta condos for sale, Signal Inn condos for sale, Nutmeg Village condos for sale and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to a source below. No real estate portal is linked, by policy. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser’s parcel roll and sale files, qualified sales on the Sanibel Moorings unit parcels in ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026. Association documents and news were read November 11, 2026 unless another date is shown.

County, clerk and state records

Sanibel Moorings association documents

News, guides and history

Flood, storms and insurance

Florida law and fair housing

Schools, places and roads