Opens in a new tab
Back to Sanibel

Sanibel · Florida · 33957

Nutmeg Village Condos for Sale in Sanibel, FL

Nutmeg Village condos for sale: 45 two-bedroom, two-bath Gulf-front units at 2777 West Gulf Drive on Sanibel. Every qualified county sale since 1976, the two recorded phases, the quarterly fee, the monthly rental rule, pets, flood zone and the questions to ask before you buy. Updated November 2026.

Aerial photo from January 16, 2023 of the Gulf side of West Gulf Drive on Sanibel, FL 33957, around 2777 West Gulf Drive: three flat-roofed low-rise condominium buildings set in a U shape around a pool, a tennis court, nearby buildings and houses, the road, sandy open lots, the beach and the Gulf of Mexico

Nutmeg Village is a Gulf-front condominium of 45 two-bedroom, two-bath units at 2777 West Gulf Drive, Sanibel, ZIP 33957, in Lee County, and one of the island buildings we follow under Sanibel homes for sale. The two most recent qualified county sales were $1,100,000 for unit 314 on February 4, 2026 and $925,000 for unit 109 on August 3, 2026. Updated November 2026.

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.

This page covers only the condominium the Lee County roll records as Nutmeg Village, declared in two phases at Official Records Book 1126, Page 351 and Book 1148, Page 2166. Its 45 unit parcels share one street number on the beach side of West Gulf Drive, with two common-area parcels at 2775 and 2779 West Gulf Drive. A cleared lot next door at 2761 West Gulf Drive, once The Sandbar restaurant, sometimes shows up under the same name in listing searches; it is land, not a condo unit, and it is left out of every county figure below.

Key takeaways for Nutmeg Village condo buyers

Here is what shapes a Nutmeg Village purchase, drawn from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale files, Sanibel real estate surveys, public listing records and federal flood and elevation data. Each point is expanded further down with its source, and any fact our research could not settle is marked to confirm with the association.

  • Nutmeg Village holds 45 recorded condo units in two phases: 18 in Phase 1 and 27 in Phase 2, all on the Gulf side of West Gulf Drive.
  • Every unit on the roll has two bedrooms and two baths; 33 units carry 1,276 heated square feet and 12 end units carry 1,366.
  • Lee County recorded 97 qualified sales since March 1976, with a $504,000 median across that whole span.
  • The two qualified sales in the 12 months to November 2026 were $925,000 and $1,100,000.
  • The county file shows no qualified Nutmeg Village sale in 2022, 2023 or 2024.
  • 2026 listing records show a condo fee of $2,740 a quarter, about $913 a month, covering insurance, cable, water, sewer and trash among other items.
  • Rentals are monthly, not weekly: sources give a 28 to 30 day minimum.
  • FEMA maps the site in flood zone AE, with a base flood elevation of 10 feet at the address point; ground there sits about 5.3 feet above sea level.

Nutmeg Village condos for sale right now

In November 2026, listing records showed two Nutmeg Village units for sale: unit 104 at $889,000 and unit 309 at $1,100,000. With 45 units in total and a handful of recorded sales in a typical year, the number on the market at any one time is small, so it pays to watch the building rather than wait for a search to surface it.

Units on the roll

The Lee County roll lists 45 residential unit parcels at 2777 West Gulf Drive and two common-area parcels. Phase 1 holds units 100 to 105, 200 to 205 and 300 to 305. Phase 2 holds units 106 to 114, 206 to 214 and 306 to 314. The first digit is the floor, so each floor carries 15 units.

How often units come up

Across 2018 to 2021 the county recorded 11 qualified sales, then none for three calendar years, then one in 2025 and two by August 2026. In years with any qualified sale since 1977 the count ran from one to six, and the busiest of them was 2018, with six.

Telling the right listing apart

Search results for the name can mix in the land parcel at 2761 West Gulf Drive. That lot was offered in September 2025 at $1,500,000 for restaurant, retail or multi-family use, according to its listing record. It sits outside the condominium's recorded parcels, so set it aside when you compare unit prices.

Asking prices against recorded sales

Listing records show unit 109 asking $1,175,000 in January 2026, cut twice to $950,000 by May. The county then recorded that unit's sale at $925,000 on August 3, 2026. Gaps like that are common on Sanibel after 2022, so build your offer from recorded figures.

See current listings

To see Nutmeg Village units on the market today, search current listings and filter for Sanibel, or ask us to set an alert on 2777 West Gulf Drive so a new unit reaches you the day it lists.

Ready to tour Nutmeg Village?

Tell us the floor, the plan size and how you plan to use the unit, and we will send every match along with the recorded county sales of comparable units. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do Nutmeg Village condos sell for?

Recorded Nutmeg Village prices over the last ten years have run from $610,000 to $1,400,000, with a median of $837,500 across 16 qualified sales. The figures below count only sales the Lee County Property Appraiser marks as qualified on the 45 unit parcels, through the newest sale in the county file, on August 3, 2026.

Window to August 3, 2026 Qualified sales Median Low High
12 months, since November 2025 2 $1,012,500 $925,000 $1,100,000
24 months, since November 2024 3 $925,000 $900,000 $1,100,000
60 months, since November 2021 4 $912,500 $740,000 $1,100,000
10 years, since November 2016 16 $837,500 $610,000 $1,400,000
20 years, since November 2006 39 $745,000 $503,000 $1,400,000
All recorded history, since March 1976 97 $504,000 $83,000 $1,400,000

Data updated: November 2026. Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and sale files, qualified improved sales on the Nutmeg Village unit parcels in ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026; newest Nutmeg Village sale August 3, 2026.

The county tool reports all recorded history as its headline window, because no shorter window reaches 10 qualified sales. The 12 and 24 month rows rest on two and three closings, so read them as single data points rather than a trend.

Every qualified sale since 2018

Recorded Unit Heated sq ft Price Price per sq ft
January 4, 2018 205 1,276 $745,000 $584
January 12, 2018 211 1,276 $630,000 $494
February 26, 2018 201 1,366 $965,000 $706
May 18, 2018 313 1,366 $950,000 $695
July 24, 2018 208 1,276 $672,300 $527
July 25, 2018 205 1,276 $705,000 $553
March 1, 2019 103 1,276 $775,000 $607
January 28, 2020 202 1,276 $610,000 $478
July 29, 2021 313 1,366 $1,295,000 $948
October 27, 2021 109 1,276 $1,400,000 $1,097
December 30, 2021 104 1,276 $740,000 $580
June 17, 2025 211 1,276 $900,000 $705
February 4, 2026 314 1,366 $1,100,000 $805
August 3, 2026 109 1,276 $925,000 $725

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale files, qualified sales; price per square foot is the recorded price divided by the roll's heated area.

The two 2026 closings

Unit 314, a 1,366 square foot third-floor end unit, recorded at $1,100,000 on February 4, 2026. Unit 109, a 1,276 square foot first-floor unit, recorded at $925,000 on August 3, 2026. Per heated foot, those work out to $805 and $725.

The 2021 peak

Two 2021 sales stand out: unit 313 at $1,295,000 in July and unit 109 at $1,400,000 in October, the highest qualified Nutmeg Village price in the county file. Unit 109 later recorded at $925,000, about 34 percent less, which shows how far the post-2022 market moved for this building.

Three years without a recorded sale

The county file holds no qualified Nutmeg Village sale in 2022, 2023 or 2024. A gap like that does not prove nothing changed hands; sales between related parties, estate transfers and other unqualified deeds are left out of the qualified count. Listing records report a June 2022 closing for unit 211. The county file does not carry that one as a qualified sale.

Price per square foot

Across the 2025 and 2026 closings, recorded prices ran from about $705 to $805 per heated square foot. From 2018 to 2020 the same measure ran from $478 to $706. A portal figure of $697 per square foot circulated in November 2026; treat it as a portal estimate.

Prices by decade

Decade Qualified sales Median Low High
1970s 13 $95,000 $83,000 $210,000
1980s 11 $247,000 $160,000 $275,000
1990s 23 $335,000 $243,100 $500,000
2000s 15 $650,000 $504,000 $1,065,900
2010s 28 $722,500 $503,000 $1,150,000
2020s, to August 2026 7 $925,000 $610,000 $1,400,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale files, qualified sales grouped by recording year.

The first sales in 1976 and 1977

The earliest qualified sales in the county file date from March 1976 to May 1977. Nine units recorded first sales in that span at prices from $83,000 to $100,000, among them units 300, 201, 303, 114 and 208.

Units that changed hands more than once

Unit 211 recorded at $503,000 in March 2012, $630,000 in January 2018 and $900,000 in June 2025. Unit 314 recorded at $1,150,000 in May 2012 and $1,100,000 in February 2026. Unit 205 sold twice in 2018, at $745,000 in January and $705,000 in July.

Sales by floor and plan size

Since 2011 we tracked 35 qualified sales at Nutmeg Village. Floor made less difference than plan size over that span. The table splits those sales both ways.

Group, qualified sales since 2011 Sales Median Low High
First floor, 100s 12 $762,500 $580,000 $1,400,000
Second floor, 200s 13 $705,000 $503,000 $965,000
Third floor, 300s 10 $765,000 $521,000 $1,295,000
1,276 sq ft units 25 $672,300 $503,000 $1,400,000
1,366 sq ft end units 10 $957,500 $830,000 $1,295,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale files and parcel roll, qualified sales from 2011 to August 3, 2026.

How many units have sold

Of the 45 units, 39 show at least one qualified sale in the county file since 1976. Phase 1 units account for 45 of the 97 qualified sales and Phase 2 units for 52. Units 103, 201, 202, 205 and 304 have each recorded four.

End units against standard units

The 1,366 square foot end units have carried the higher figures: units 313 and 314 account for three of the five qualified sales at or above $1,000,000 since 2012. Standard 1,276 square foot units have mostly recorded between $600,000 and $925,000 since 2018, with unit 109's 2021 sale the outlier.

Nutmeg Village floor plans, phases and unit numbers

Nutmeg Village is a set of three-story, elevator-served buildings of two-bedroom, two-bath flats, with Gulf-facing lanais on most units. The roll gives two heated sizes, and listing records describe split-bedroom layouts with enclosed or screened lanais, covered parking and storage. Here is how the plans and unit numbers fit together.

Item Phase 1 Phase 2
Recorded at OR Book 1126, Page 351 OR Book 1148, Page 2166
Units 18 27
Unit numbers 100 to 105, 200 to 205, 300 to 305 106 to 114, 206 to 214, 306 to 314
1,366 sq ft units 100, 101, 200, 201, 300, 301 113, 114, 213, 214, 313, 314
1,276 sq ft units 12 21
Common-area parcel 2775 West Gulf Drive 2779 West Gulf Drive

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, November 2026.

Roll area against listed area

Listing records quote 1,275 to 1,350 square feet under air and 1,375 to 1,574 square feet in total for these units. The roll's heated figure leaves out lanais and storage, which is why the listed total runs higher. Compare units on the roll figure.

The larger end units

Units numbered 00, 01, 13 and 14 on each floor carry 1,366 heated square feet on the roll, 90 more than the others. They sit at the ends of the unit runs, which listing remarks tie to extra windows; confirm the layout on a tour.

The unit number pattern

The first digit gives the floor: 100s on the first floor, 200s on the second and 300s on the third. Phase 1 numbers end 00 to 05 and Phase 2 numbers end 06 to 14 on every floor.

The year built on the roll

The roll shows 1976 for 30 units, 2005 for 14 units and 2006 for one. The roll's year can reflect an effective year after major work on a unit rather than the original build, and our sources do not explain the later dates. Guides give 1975 or 1976 for the original construction.

Elevators and parking

Listing records describe elevator service and covered parking, with one assigned space per unit and carport space for some. Ask the association which elevator serves the unit you are weighing and how parking is assigned.

Views by position

Every unit sits on the Gulf-front site, but the outlook differs by floor and by where the unit sits in the three buildings, and a first-floor unit sits at the level of the pool deck and grounds. Walk the lanai at the unit you are weighing before you write an offer.

Lanais and interiors

Most units open to a Gulf-facing lanai, enclosed or screened. A 2022 listing noted a condo rule requiring carpet in place of wood floors; ask for the current flooring and sound rules before planning a remodel.

The Nutmeg Village site on West Gulf Drive

Nutmeg Village sits on the beach side of West Gulf Drive in the western half of Sanibel, between the Rabbit Road and Tarpon Bay Road areas. The aerial at the top of this page shows its three buildings set around a pool, with a tennis court toward the road and the beach on the Gulf side.

The beach

The buildings face the Gulf directly, and listing records describe deeded beach access from the property. Owners walk from the pool deck to the sand without crossing a road.

Getting there

All drives on and off the island cross the Sanibel Causeway from Fort Myers. From the causeway, the route runs west along Periwinkle Way and Tarpon Bay Road or along Gulf Drive to the property. The shared-use path along West Gulf Drive passes in front.

Straight-line distances

Measured as straight lines from the census point for the address, Nutmeg Village is about 0.5 miles from the Tarpon Bay Road beach access, about 5 miles from Bowman's Beach, about 4.9 miles from Lighthouse Beach Park and about 6.7 miles from the causeway toll plaza. Driving distances run longer.

Off-island trips

By the same straight-line measure, HealthPark Medical Center is about 7.8 miles away, downtown Fort Myers about 20 miles, Southwest Florida International Airport about 22 miles and downtown Naples about 26.6 miles. Season and causeway traffic swing drive times widely.

Is Nutmeg Village gated?

No. Listing records describe a non-gated property on a public road, and the shared-use path runs along its frontage.

The coordinates

The US Census geocoder places 2777 West Gulf Drive at about 26.4240 north, 82.0877 west. The Lee County parcel numbers begin 35-46-22-T1 for Phase 1 and 34-46-22-T2 for Phase 2.

Amenities at Nutmeg Village

Nutmeg Village keeps a short list of shared features on a compact Gulf-front site, according to Sanibel real estate surveys and listing records. There is no golf, no clubhouse membership and no marina, and the quarterly fee covers the shared facilities below.

The pool and spa

A Gulf-view pool and spa sit between the buildings, with a lounging deck. Whether the pool is heated is not stated in our sources; ask the association.

Tennis, pickleball and shuffleboard

Listing records name a tennis court, pickleball and shuffleboard. The aerial shows one court between the buildings and the road.

Gazebo and grill

A gazebo, a courtyard and an outdoor grill area round out the shared spaces.

Storage

Listing records describe storage for owners; ask how much comes with the unit you are weighing and whether bikes, beach gear and kayaks have a set place.

The path out front

The shared-use path along West Gulf Drive gives owners a bike route toward Rabbit Road, Tarpon Bay Road and the rest of the island's path network without loading a car.

What the property does not have

No golf, no gate, no clubhouse, no on-site restaurant and no boat dock appear in any source we read.

The Nutmeg Village association and its records

A condominium association governs Nutmeg Village under its two recorded declarations, collecting the quarterly fee, holding the master insurance policy and setting the rental and pet rules. The facts below come from the county roll and public listing records; anything about the association's records that we could not read is marked to confirm.

The declarations

Phase 1 was declared at Lee County Official Records Book 1126, Page 351 and Phase 2 at Book 1148, Page 2166. The common-area descriptions on the roll also cite Book 2131, Page 1130 and Condominium Plat Book 4, Pages 240 and 252. Recording dates and the text of those documents were not read for this page.

The association's exact legal name, status and registered agent were not confirmed for this page. Check them on the Florida Division of Corporations search before closing.

Management

Listing records do not agree on a manager: five different phone numbers appear across 2021 to 2026 listings. Ask the listing agent for the current manager's name and the estoppel contact.

No master association or CDD

Our research found no master association, community development district, capital contribution or transfer fee tied to Nutmeg Village. Confirm on the estoppel certificate.

What does it cost to own a Nutmeg Village condo each year?

The main carrying costs at Nutmeg Village are the quarterly condo fee, property taxes and the owner's own unit insurance. Listing records from 2026 show the fee at $2,740 a quarter, about $913 a month or $10,960 a year, and say it bundles most utilities and the master insurance policy.

Cost item Figure Source
Condo fee, 2026 $2,740 a quarter 2026 listing records
Condo fee, October 2021 $1,950 a quarter 2021 listing record
Special assessment None reported in January 2026 2026 listing record
Master association or CDD None found Listing records

Sources: public listing records read November 2026. Confirm every figure on the estoppel certificate.

What the fee covers

Listing records say the fee includes association management, cable TV, master insurance, irrigation water, legal and accounting, grounds, pest control, recreation facilities, the reserve fund, sewer, trash and water.

How the fee has moved

At $1,950 a quarter in October 2021 and $2,740 a quarter in 2026, the fee rose about 40 percent in five years. Insurance and reserve costs have pushed fees up at many Florida condominiums since 2022; ask for the current budget to see where this one goes.

Special assessments

A January 2026 listing reported no assessment and strong reserves. That is a seller's statement; the estoppel certificate and the board minutes are where to confirm it.

Unit insurance

Owners carry their own HO-6 policy for the interior and contents, and a lender may require flood cover. The master policy's carrier and its wind and flood terms were not found in our sources.

Property taxes on a Nutmeg Village unit

Property taxes on a Nutmeg Village unit depend on the assessed value, the homestead status and the millage set by Lee County and the City of Sanibel. Listing records give recent bills, and the Lee County Tax Collector holds the official figure for any unit.

Recent bills

Listing records show 2024 property taxes of $1,697 for units 104 and 211 and $1,768 for unit 109, and $2,639 for unit 309 for 2023. Each owner's bill reflects that owner's assessment history.

The reset at a sale

Florida caps yearly assessment increases for homestead and non-homestead property, and a sale resets the assessment to market value. A new owner's bill can run well above the seller's.

Homestead and second homes

A full-time Florida resident who makes the unit a primary home may claim the homestead exemption. A unit used as a second home or rented by the month does not qualify.

Checking a bill

Look up the parcel on the Lee County Property Appraiser site for the assessed value and on the Lee County Tax Collector site for the bill.

Rental rules and pets at Nutmeg Village

Nutmeg Village allows monthly rentals but not weekly ones, according to Sanibel real estate surveys and listing records, and pet rules are written for owners rather than tenants. Because these rules come from secondary sources, get the current declaration, bylaws and rules from the association before you write an offer.

The monthly minimum

One guide gives a 28-day minimum rental and a 2026 listing gives a 30-day minimum lease. An October 2021 listing said two 30-day rentals a year were allowed. Weekly vacation rental is not allowed under any version we read.

City of Sanibel rules

The City of Sanibel also regulates short-term rentals by zoning. Confirm both the association's rule and the city's rule before counting on rental income.

Planning around a monthly minimum

A 28 to 30 day minimum shapes how a unit earns, because stays shorter than a month do not fit the rule at all. If rental income matters to your numbers, ask the listing agent for the unit's actual rental history and calendar, and price the purchase on what the unit has rented for rather than on weekly rates seen at resort properties nearby.

Tourist development tax

Rentals of six months or less in Lee County carry tourist development tax and state sales tax. Ask a tax adviser how that applies to a monthly rental.

Pets

A Sanibel brokerage list shows owner pets under 30 pounds, and a 2026 listing says one pet. Tenants may not bring pets, and older guides say owners only. Ask the association for the written pet rule.

Assistance animals

Assistance animals are not pets under fair housing law, and a pet rule does not bar a reasonable accommodation request for an assistance animal. Ask the association for its accommodation process.

Age

No source we read describes Nutmeg Village as an age-restricted community. Confirm with the association.

Is Nutmeg Village in a flood zone?

Yes. FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer places the Nutmeg Village address point in zone AE, with a base flood elevation of 10 feet, and a point about 90 meters closer to the Gulf in AE with an 11 foot base flood elevation. The map panel is 12071C0537G, effective November 17, 2022.

Flood fact Figure Source
FEMA zone at the address point AE, base flood elevation 10 ft FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer
Closer to the Gulf AE, base flood elevation 11 ft FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer
Map panel 12071C0537G, effective November 17, 2022 FEMA FIRM panels
Ground elevation at the point About 5.3 ft (NAVD88) USGS 3DEP
Evacuation zone Lee County Zone A Lee County evacuation zones

Sources: FEMA, USGS and Lee County data queried November 13, 2026.

Why the zone matters

A lender requires flood insurance on a mortgaged unit in an AE zone, and the master policy's flood cover shapes what an owner needs on top. Ask the association for the building's flood policy.

Flood cost for a buyer

The flood cost on a Nutmeg Village unit has two layers: the association's building policy, paid through the fee, and any contents or unit policy the owner chooses or a lender requires. Get quotes during the inspection period, not after it.

Ground-floor units

Ground at the address point sits about 5.3 feet above sea level and the base flood elevation is 10 feet. Whether a ground-floor unit's floor sits above or below that line is a question for the building's elevation certificate.

VE near the beach

Beachfront strips on Sanibel can map VE, a coastal high hazard zone with stricter building rules. Check the zone for each building on the FEMA map before you buy.

The 50 percent rule

In a FEMA flood zone, work whose cost reaches 50 percent of a building's market value triggers the substantial improvement rule, which can require bringing the structure up to current flood standards. Ask the City of Sanibel building department how that has applied to this property.

Evacuation Zone A

All of Sanibel sits in Lee County evacuation Zone A, the first zone ordered out ahead of a storm surge threat.

Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton near Nutmeg Village

Hurricane Ian struck Sanibel on September 28, 2022, cutting the causeway and flooding large parts of the island, and Helene and Milton brought more flooding in 2024. West Gulf Drive took heavy damage. No source we read reports building-specific damage, repair or reopening at Nutmeg Village, so ask the association directly.

The neighbor that did not return

The Sandbar restaurant at 2761 West Gulf Drive is listed among Sanibel restaurants lost after Ian. Its cleared lot was offered for sale from September 2025.

Statements in listings

Some listing remarks describe storm-related features or conditions of individual units, such as impact glass or hurricane-rated windows. Treat those as seller statements and confirm them in the inspection and the association's records.

Helene and Milton

Helene in September 2024 and Milton in October 2024 pushed surge across parts of the island again. Ask whether either storm caused claims or repairs at the property.

What a buyer should ask

Ask for the board minutes since 2022, any insurance claims, the scope of repairs, how they were paid for and whether any assessment remains open.

Florida condo law and insurance at Nutmeg Village

Florida condominium law changed after 2021, adding milestone inspections and structural integrity reserve studies for buildings of three stories or more. Nutmeg Village is three stories and about 50 years old, so both apply. Their status for this property was not public in any source we read.

Milestone inspections

Florida requires milestone inspections for condominium buildings of three stories or more at 25 years of age when they are within three miles of the coast, and on a set cycle after that. Ask for the report and any repairs it called for.

Sanibel's local ordinance

The City of Sanibel updated its milestone inspection ordinance on March 19, 2026 to match the 2025 state change, according to the Santiva Chronicle.

Reserve studies

A structural integrity reserve study is required for buildings of three stories or more. Ask whether the association has completed one and how its reserves compare with the study.

The master policy

Listing records say insurance is part of the fee. Ask for the declarations page to see the carrier, the wind deductible and the flood cover.

Lending on an older condominium

Lenders review the association as well as the buyer on a condo loan. Expect questions about the reserves, the master insurance, any open litigation, the share of units used as rentals and the milestone inspection. A building that cannot answer them cleanly can push a buyer toward a portfolio lender or a cash purchase, so ask your lender for its condo questionnaire early and send it to the manager the day the contract is signed.

Disclosure papers

A Florida condo buyer is entitled to the declaration, bylaws, rules, budget and frequently asked questions sheet, along with recent inspection reports, before the contract becomes binding. Read them with the estoppel certificate.

Where is Nutmeg Village on Sanibel?

Nutmeg Village sits on the Gulf side of West Gulf Drive in the western half of Sanibel, near the Rabbit Road and Tarpon Bay Road areas, the Sanibel Recreation Center and the Shalimar Resort. The island's main shops sit on Periwinkle Way to the east, and Captiva lies past Blind Pass to the north and west.

The causeway

All trips off the island use the Sanibel Causeway, which carries a toll for vehicles entering the island.

Hospital care

The closest full hospital is HealthPark Medical Center in Fort Myers, across the causeway.

Shops and dining

Periwinkle Way holds most of the island's shops, grocery and restaurants, east of the property. Rabbit Road Center and the Sanibel Recreation Center sit closer, near the Rabbit Road end of West Gulf Drive.

Wildlife refuge

The J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge covers much of the island's bay side and is reached by the island's bike paths.

Captiva

For homes on the next island, see Captiva Island homes for sale, reached over the Blind Pass bridge.

Schools serving Nutmeg Village addresses

Lee County uses school choice zones, and listing records show Nutmeg Village in Elementary Zone N, Middle Zone L and High South Zone 5. The island's public school is The Sanibel School, serving kindergarten through eighth grade; high school students attend off the island.

The Sanibel School

The Sanibel School serves grades K through 8 on the island. Ask the district about its current status after the 2022 and 2024 storms.

High school

High school assignment falls under the South Zone 5 choice zone on the mainland.

Checking the assignment

Confirm the assignment for 2777 West Gulf Drive with the School District of Lee County's school zone tool.

A short history of Nutmeg Village

Nutmeg Village dates from the mid-1970s, when Sanibel's Gulf-front strip along Gulf Drive was filling with low-rise condominiums. Island newspaper items from 1974 and 1975 describe the project before it opened, the two phases were declared in the county's Official Records, and the county file records the first unit sales in March 1976.

The 1974 announcement

A December 1974 Sanibel Islander item described a 45-unit project on Gulf-front land then owned by Rochester Realty. The scanned page could not be read in full, so treat the detail as to confirm.

The developer

A January 1975 Sanibel Islander item reported Spectrum Development Corporation opening a furnished model for the condominium. The general contractor and architect were not found.

The Gulf Drive condo years

Nutmeg Village went up in the same wave of mid-1970s building that lined much of Gulf Drive with low-rise condominiums. Our sources do not record the architect, the general contractor or the original asking prices; the Sanibel Historical Museum and Village keeps the island's wider building history.

The name

Sanibel brokerage pages say the name refers to the nutmeg, a small sea snail whose shell turns up on Sanibel beaches, not the spice.

Five decades of prices

The decade medians climbed from $95,000 in the 1970s to $925,000 so far in the 2020s.

What should you check before you make an offer on a Nutmeg Village condo?

A Nutmeg Village offer should rest on the unit's recorded size and sales, the association's money and paperwork, the flood and insurance picture, and the written rental and pet rules. These are the steps we take with buyers at this address, in roughly the order a contract timeline allows.

Confirm the unit and phase

Match the unit number to its phase and roll size: 1,276 or 1,366 heated square feet.

Inspect the unit

Hire an inspector who knows coastal concrete, windows, the lanai and the air conditioning.

Read the budget and reserves

Ask for the current budget, the reserve schedule and the most recent reserve study.

Ask about assessments

Get the estoppel certificate and ask the board about any planned work.

Get the insurance details

Request the master policy declarations and price your HO-6 and any flood policy early.

Confirm the rental rule

Get the written minimum rental term and any limit on rentals a year from the association, and check the City of Sanibel's rule.

Check the flood zone by building

Look up the building on the FEMA map and ask for an elevation certificate.

Get the milestone and reserve study status

Ask for the milestone inspection report and the structural integrity reserve study.

Compare recorded sales

Price the unit against the county's recorded sales at 2777 West Gulf Drive, by floor and plan size.

Nutmeg Village and other Sanibel condos buyers compare

Buyers who look at Nutmeg Village often weigh it against other Gulf-front condominiums along Gulf Drive. The comparison below sticks to what each source shows. A listing site's comparable table named several West Gulf and Middle Gulf Drive complexes with similar two-bedroom plans, and our own pages cover several more.

Community How it compares with Nutmeg Village
Signal Inn Gulf-front condos on Olde Middle Gulf Drive, east of Nutmeg Village
Sandpiper Beach Gulf-front condos on Olde Middle Gulf Drive
Sanibel Siesta Gulf-front condos in the middle of the island
Sunward of Sanibel West Gulf Drive; two-bedroom plans of about 1,584 sq ft per a listing site
Island Beach Club West Gulf Drive; two-bedroom plans of about 1,440 sq ft per a listing site
Sundial of Sanibel Larger resort complex on Middle Gulf Drive

Sources: a listing site's comparable sales table and our own Sanibel pages, read November 2026.

Signal Inn and Sandpiper Beach

Our pages for Signal Inn condos for sale and Sandpiper Beach condos for sale cover two Gulf-front properties a few miles east, useful for comparing a different building form and rental rule on the same shoreline.

Sanibel Siesta

Our Sanibel Siesta condos for sale page covers a larger mid-island Gulf-front condominium with an association-run rental desk, a contrast to Nutmeg Village's monthly-only rule.

Single-family homes nearby

For houses on the west end off West Gulf Drive, see our Bright Water homes for sale page.

Where Nutmeg Village stands out, and where it does not

Nutmeg Village's draws are a direct Gulf-front site, a small 45-unit count, elevator buildings and recorded prices that have mostly sat under about $1,100,000 since 2022. Its limits are 1970s construction, a single two-bedroom plan type, a monthly-only rental rule and a fee of about $10,960 a year.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Nutmeg Village specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows island condominiums from its Fort Myers office, the closest of our offices to the Sanibel Causeway. For this page we matched all 97 qualified Nutmeg Village sales in the county file to their unit numbers, and we will run the same check for any unit you are weighing.

★★★★★ "Jesse helped us to buy a condo in Naples in 2009. After few dozens showings we finally found what we were looking for. Jesse was extremely patient. He even helped us finding the best solution with financing! We were working on finding a right home for us for over a year and Jesse was helpful every step of a road. No matter how often or how late i called he always had an answer for me. This year when i had to rent my property out Jesse was the one who recommended me the right realtor. He is a first person for me to contact with every real estate question i might have. I will definitely recommend Jesse to everyone and no doubt he will be the one who i will contact when it will be time for me to sell. Six stars out of five!"

Verified Zillow review. user717113, on buying a condo in Naples with Jesse McGreevy.

We tracked every qualified sale at 2777 West Gulf Drive for this page, so when a unit lists we can show you what its own floor and plan size have recorded before you make an offer.

Talk to our team about a Nutmeg Village unit

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816 with the floor, the plan size and how you plan to use the unit, and an agent will send matching listings, the recorded county sales of comparable units and the association questions to ask. You can also search current listings at any time.

Thinking of selling a Nutmeg Village unit?

A Nutmeg Village unit is priced by its floor, its plan size, its finish and its view down the beach, so pricing it against recorded sales at the same address beats pricing it against the island. For a seller's view, start with selling a home on Sanibel or Captiva with McGreevy and Comisar.

Frequently Asked Questions about Nutmeg Village condos for sale

These answers come from the Lee County roll and sale files, Sanibel real estate surveys, public listing records, island newspaper archives and federal flood and elevation data. Where our research could not confirm a fact, the answer says so plainly and points to who can.

What is Nutmeg Village?

A Gulf-front condominium of 45 two-bedroom, two-bath units at 2777 West Gulf Drive, Sanibel, ZIP 33957, in Lee County.

Where is Nutmeg Village?

On the beach side of West Gulf Drive in the western half of Sanibel, near the Rabbit Road and Tarpon Bay Road areas.

How many units are there?

The Lee County roll lists 45 unit parcels: 18 in Phase 1 and 27 in Phase 2.

How big are the units?

The roll lists 33 units at 1,276 heated square feet and 12 end units at 1,366. Listing totals with lanais run up to about 1,574 square feet.

How many bedrooms do the units have?

Every unit on the roll has two bedrooms and two baths.

When was Nutmeg Village built?

Guides give 1975 or 1976, and the county's first recorded sales date from March 1976.

Who built Nutmeg Village?

A January 1975 island newspaper item names Spectrum Development Corporation; confirm in the declaration.

How many stories are the buildings?

Three, with elevator service per listing records.

What do Nutmeg Village condos sell for?

The 16 qualified sales in the ten years to August 2026 ran from $610,000 to $1,400,000, with an $837,500 median.

What was the most recent sale?

Unit 109 recorded at $925,000 on August 3, 2026.

What is the highest recorded sale?

$1,400,000 for unit 109 on October 27, 2021.

How many units sell each year?

One to six qualified sales in the years that had any since 1977, with none in 2022, 2023 or 2024.

What is the price per square foot?

The 2025 and 2026 qualified sales ran about $705 to $805 per heated square foot.

What is the condo fee?

2026 listing records show $2,740 a quarter, about $913 a month.

What does the fee include?

Management, cable TV, master insurance, water, sewer, trash, irrigation, grounds, pest control, recreation, legal and accounting, and reserves, per listing records.

Are there special assessments?

A January 2026 listing reported none; confirm on the estoppel certificate.

Is there a master association or CDD?

None was found; confirm on the estoppel certificate.

Can I rent my unit weekly?

No. Sources give a 28 to 30 day minimum rental.

How many times a year can I rent?

One 2021 listing said two 30-day rentals a year; ask the association for the current limit.

Are pets allowed?

Owners may keep one pet under 30 pounds per brokerage and listing records; tenants may not. Assistance animals are handled as accommodation requests.

Is Nutmeg Village age restricted?

No source we read says so; confirm with the association.

Is Nutmeg Village on the beach?

Yes. The buildings face the Gulf with deeded beach access.

What amenities are there?

A pool and spa, tennis, pickleball, shuffleboard, a gazebo, a grill area, storage and covered parking.

Is there golf?

No.

Is Nutmeg Village gated?

No.

What flood zone is Nutmeg Village in?

FEMA zone AE, with a base flood elevation of 10 to 11 feet, on panel 12071C0537G.

What evacuation zone is it in?

Lee County Zone A.

Did Hurricane Ian damage Nutmeg Village?

No building-specific report was found; ask the association for its records since 2022.

Does Nutmeg Village need a milestone inspection?

Yes, as a three-story coastal building over 25 years old; ask for the report.

What are property taxes on a unit?

Listing records show 2024 bills of $1,697 to $1,768 on three units, which reset after a sale.

What school serves Nutmeg Village?

The Sanibel School for grades K to 8; confirm with the district.

What is the land next door?

The former Sandbar restaurant lot at 2761 West Gulf Drive, offered for sale from September 2025.

Where do I see Nutmeg Village condos for sale?

Our current listings search shows active Sanibel units. Call 239-441-2816 or contact us to set an alert.

About Domain Realty Group on Sanibel

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team working Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, including Sanibel and Captiva, from offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) lead the team, with over 45 years of combined direct experience.

Meet the team on our agents page, read our client reviews or learn more about our team. We matched every qualified Nutmeg Village sale in the county file back to 1976 to its unit to build this page.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Sanibel real estate, Captiva Island homes for sale, Signal Inn condos for sale, Sandpiper Beach condos for sale, Sanibel Siesta condos for sale and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to a source below. No real estate portal is linked, by policy; facts credited to "listing records" or "portal" figures come from public broker and portal records read November 13, 2026 and are labelled as such. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll and sale files, qualified sales on the Nutmeg Village unit parcels in ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026. Web sources were read November 13 to November 21, 2026 unless another date is shown.

County, clerk and state records

Nutmeg Village guides, listing records and news

Flood, storms and insurance

Florida condominium law and fair housing

Schools, places and roads