Sanibel · Florida · 33957
Bright Water Homes for Sale in Sanibel, FL
Bright Water homes for sale: 33 single-family homesites on Saint Kilda Road, Barra Circle and Tiree Circle, inland of West Gulf Drive on Sanibel's west end, with private lakes and a deeded beach path. Recorded county sales, the yearly association fee, the flood zone and the checks to make before you buy. Updated November 2026.

Bright Water is a small, ungated subdivision of 33 single-family homesites on the inland side of West Gulf Drive, on the west end of the City of Sanibel, ZIP 33957, Lee County. Its three streets, Saint Kilda Road, Barra Circle and Tiree Circle, loop around private freshwater lakes, and listings describe a deeded beach path across West Gulf Drive. Lee County has recorded 47 qualified home sales here since September 1987, at a $705,000 median; the seven since Hurricane Ian have a $800,000 median. Updated November 2026.
By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.
This page is one neighborhood inside our Sanibel homes for sale section and covers only the plat called Bright Water, recorded in Lee County Plat Book 28, pages 57 and 58, with a stated area of 27.31 acres. A naming point before anything else: Bright Water on Sanibel is a different place from Brightwater in Fort Myers and from Brightwater in Cape Coral. Nothing on this page comes from those mainland communities, and when you search listings, filter for Sanibel and ZIP 33957 so a Fort Myers home does not slip into your results.
Key takeaways for Bright Water home buyers
These are the points that matter most when you shop Bright Water homes for sale on Sanibel. Each one comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale file, Lee County and FEMA map layers, City of Sanibel pages or public broker listing pages, and each is covered further down with its source and date.
- Bright Water is one recorded plat, "BRIGHT WATER," Plat Book 28, pages 57 and 58, a 27.31-acre subdivision of part of Section 27, Township 46 South, Range 22 East, inside the City of Sanibel.
- Brokers count 33 homesites. The November 2026 county roll lists 32 numbered lot parcels, 26 with a home and 6 vacant, plus lettered common tracts and an easement parcel; Lot 26 has no parcel of its own on the roll.
- Every improved parcel is a detached single-family home. Heated area runs 1,300 to 3,025 square feet, median about 1,836, and 22 of the 26 homes have three bedrooms.
- Homes on the roll date from 1973 to 2024, and a further house on Lot 7, 3324 Saint Kilda Road, was listed in 2026 as new construction.
- Lee County recorded 47 qualified improved sales from September 1987 through June 26, 2026, median $705,000, from $183,200 to $1,350,000. The seven since October 2022 ran $670,000 to $1,350,000, median $800,000.
- Listings show an association fee of about $100 a year, described as covering beach rights and access. There is no gate, clubhouse, community pool or golf.
- FEMA's map puts the four Bright Water addresses tested in Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 9 feet, and Lee County places the subdivision in evacuation Zone A.
- Single-family homes on Sanibel may be rented only for stays of 28 days or more, with a city rental license.
Bright Water homes for sale right now
Bright Water homes for sale are scarce at any moment, because the whole plat holds only 26 finished houses and a handful of lots, and owners tend to hold for years. In November 2026 broker pages showed asks of about $979,000 to $3,250,000, from a remodeled 1982 house on Barra Circle to a new concrete home on Saint Kilda Road.
How many homes there are to buy
The county roll counts 26 improved single-family parcels and 6 vacant lots among the 32 numbered lots it lists, all in ZIP 33957. In a typical recent year the county has recorded between one and three qualified home sales here, so a buyer who wants this street plan usually sets a saved search and moves quickly when a match appears.
What was on the market in fall 2026
Broker pages read in November 2026 showed 3359 Barra Circle, a 1982 home remodeled and raised, with 3 bedrooms, 3 baths, 1,828 square feet, a pool and a metal roof on 0.309 acre, reduced to $979,000 after a June 2026 listing. They also showed 3312 Saint Kilda Road at $1,395,000, added October 9, 2026, with 4 bedrooms and 3 baths, and the new build at 3324 Saint Kilda Road at $3,250,000.
Listing prices against recorded prices
Asking prices on broker pages and county recorded prices are two different measures, so we keep them apart on this page. A 2025 ask of $1,195,000 on 3366 Barra Circle, for example, ended as a $740,388 county-recorded sale on June 26, 2026.
See current listings
To see what is on the market today, search current listings and filter for Sanibel, or ask us to set a saved search for Saint Kilda Road, Barra Circle and Tiree Circle. Some listings spell the name as one word, Brightwater, so we watch both spellings and screen out mainland addresses.
Ready to tour Bright Water homes?
Tell us whether you want a finished house or a lot, how much of the lake you want behind you and how soon you plan to buy, and we will send every matching listing with the recorded sales of similar homes on the plat. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.
What do Bright Water homes sell for?
Bright Water home prices on the county record have climbed in steps over four decades, from a $183,200 first sale in 1987 to a $1,350,000 resale in December 2023. The figures below count only improved sales the Lee County Property Appraiser marks as qualified on this plat, through the newest improved sale in the county index, June 26, 2026.
| Window | Qualified improved sales | Median | Low | High |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| September 1987 to June 26, 2026 (all history) | 47 | $705,000 | $183,200 | $1,350,000 |
| Resales in the same window | 42 | $707,500 | $263,500 | $1,350,000 |
| First sales flagged by the index as builder-direct | 5 | $301,000 | $183,200 | $1,150,000 |
| January 2021 to June 26, 2026 | 10 | $925,000 | $670,000 | $1,350,000 |
| October 2022 to June 26, 2026 (after Ian) | 7 | $800,000 | $670,000 | $1,350,000 |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale file, DOR-qualified improved sales on the BRIGHT WATER plat (all 34 matching parcels read "BRIGHT WATER PB 28 PG 58"), index built November 18, 2026.
Every recorded improved sale since 2021
| Date | Address | Year built and county heated sq ft | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| April 30, 2021 | 3330 Saint Kilda Rd | 1998, 1,924 | $840,000 |
| November 10, 2021 | 3357 Saint Kilda Rd | 1999, 2,155 | $1,200,000 |
| March 18, 2022 | 402 Tiree Cir | now coded vacant | $1,150,000 |
| February 15, 2023 | 3354 Saint Kilda Rd | 1979, 2,151 | $760,000 |
| December 22, 2023 | 3320 Saint Kilda Rd | 1998, 2,289 | $1,350,000 |
| July 30, 2024 | 3343 Saint Kilda Rd | 1997, 1,698 | $1,010,000 |
| August 29, 2025 | 3314 Saint Kilda Rd | 1985, 1,798 | $800,000 |
| October 17, 2025 | 3362 Barra Cir | 2002, 1,589 | $670,000 |
| May 20, 2026 | 3351 Barra Cir | 2004, 2,539 | $1,250,000 |
| June 26, 2026 | 3366 Barra Cir | 1988, 1,500 | $740,388 |
Source: Lee County sale file joined to the Lee County parcel roll for year built and heated area.
The top recorded price
The highest qualified sale on the plat is $1,350,000 for 3320 Saint Kilda Road on December 22, 2023, a 1998 home of 2,289 heated square feet with four bedrooms on the roll. The same lot shows how values have moved: it sold vacant for $92,800 in 1997, then with its house for $892,500 in 2002, $1,000,000 in 2018 and $1,350,000 in 2023.
The newest recorded sale
The newest improved sale in the county index is 3366 Barra Circle, a 1988 home of 1,500 heated square feet, recorded at $740,388 on June 26, 2026. A 2,539-square-foot 2004 home at 3351 Barra Circle closed at $1,250,000 a month earlier.
Price per heated square foot
Dividing the recorded price by county heated area, recent sales ran about $422 a square foot (3362 Barra Circle, 2025), $445 (3314 Saint Kilda Road, 2025), $492 (3351 Barra Circle, 2026) and $494 (3366 Barra Circle, 2026). The 2023 and 2024 sales at 3320 and 3343 Saint Kilda Road worked out to about $590 and $595. Listing pages often quote total area under roof, which makes their per-foot figure look lower.
A sale the county did not count
The county file also shows 3312 Saint Kilda Road at $680,000 on March 20, 2024, coded unqualified, so it is left out of every median above. Unqualified sales can be family transfers, partial interests or distressed deals; the reason for this one is to confirm from the deed.
What vacant lots have sold for
Bright Water lots have recorded prices since 1973. The county file shows $19,500 to $30,000 in 1981 and 1982, $87,000 to $128,500 from 1991 to 1998, $225,000 to $370,000 from 2007 to 2014, $430,000 for two lots in April 2021 and $575,000 to $640,000 for three lots from January to March 2022. Lot 1, 3304 Saint Kilda Road, sold vacant for $550,000 on August 13, 2026, after asks of $739,000 and $599,000; it had sold for $590,000 in March 2022.
Bright Water homes: types, sizes and lots
Bright Water homes are all detached single-family houses on their own lots, with no condominiums, townhomes or duplexes anywhere on the plat. They were built one at a time by individual owners over five decades, so styles, sizes and elevations differ from house to house. Every figure below comes from the county parcel roll extract dated November 2, 2026, unless a listing is named.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Property type | Detached single-family, 26 of 26 improved parcels |
| Numbered lot parcels on the roll | 32: 26 improved, 6 vacant |
| Heated area | 1,300 to 3,025 sq ft; median about 1,836 |
| Bedrooms | 3 bedrooms 22; 4 bedrooms 2; 2 bedrooms 2 |
| Year built | 1973 to 2024 |
| Lot sizes seen in listings | 0.289 to 0.387 acre |
| Plat area | 27.31 acres |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, November 2, 2026; Lee County GIS plat layer; listing pages for lot sizes.
The three streets
Saint Kilda Road holds 16 lots, Lots 1 to 7 and 16 to 24, with addresses from 3304 to 3362: 13 homes built 1979 to 2016 and 3 vacant lots on the roll. Barra Circle holds 8 lots, Lot 25 and Lots 27 to 33, at 3350 to 3366: 8 homes built 1982 to 2024. Tiree Circle holds Lots 8 to 15, 401 to 413: 5 homes built 1973 to 2013 and 3 vacant lots.
Bedrooms and baths
Twenty-two of the 26 houses have three bedrooms on the roll. Two have four bedrooms, 3312 and 3320 Saint Kilda Road, and two have two bedrooms, 3316 Saint Kilda Road and 3362 Barra Circle. Bath counts vary by house and are to confirm on each listing.
The largest homes
The three largest houses by county heated area are 3334 Saint Kilda Road (2016, 3,025 square feet), 413 Tiree Circle (2013, 2,925 square feet) and 3361 Saint Kilda Road (1999, 2,601 square feet). The house going up at 3324 Saint Kilda Road is listed at 4,486 square feet under air, larger than any home now on the roll.
When the houses were built
By decade, the roll dates 2 homes to the 1970s (1973 and 1979), 9 to the 1980s, 6 to the 1990s, 3 to 2000 through 2004, 5 to 2013 through 2017 and 1 to 2024. The 1973 and 1979 houses predate Sanibel's 1979 entry into the National Flood Insurance Program, which matters for flood rating.
Construction features in listings
Listing pages describe raised island construction, metal roofs, screened pools and lanais, roll-down shutters and whole-house generators on several Bright Water homes. Two newer houses are described as insulated concrete form construction. Which features a given home has is to confirm on its listing and in the inspection.
Lot sizes
Lot areas quoted on listing pages include 0.289 acre (3314 Saint Kilda Road), 0.309 acre (3359 Barra Circle), 0.33 acre (3304 Saint Kilda Road), 0.34 acre and 0.387 acre (3351 Barra Circle). Check the county record for the exact lot area of any address.
The vacant lots
The roll codes Lots 1, 2, 7, 12, 14 and 15 as vacant. Lot 1 sold in August 2026, Lot 7 is the 2026 build at 3324 Saint Kilda Road, and Lot 12, 402 Tiree Circle, sold with a house in March 2022 for $1,150,000 and is coded vacant now. The reason for that change, which may be removal of the house after Hurricane Ian, is to confirm with the City of Sanibel permit records.
The lakes, the beach path and the common land
Bright Water's shared land is simple compared with a club community: lakes behind many of the lots and a path to the Gulf across the road. Both are described mainly in listing pages, and the plat drawing is the record to read for exactly who owns each piece and who may use it.
The private lakes
Listing pages describe private freshwater lakes behind many Bright Water homes. One Barra Circle listing has the lake wrapping its whole back yard, 3314 Saint Kilda Road advertises lake views, one Saint Kilda lot quotes about 142 feet of lake frontage, and 3324 Saint Kilda Road is listed as lakefront. The January 2023 aerial at the top of this page shows a winding lake running behind the loop streets.
The deeded beach path
Several listings say Bright Water owners hold deeded beach access across West Gulf Drive, a short walk from the homes; one 2025 listing placed its house four lots from the path. One broker community page contradicts itself, showing "Deeded Beach Access: No" in a table and "Deeded Beach" among amenities. Confirm the easement on the plat and in your own deed before you rely on it.
The common tracts on the roll
The roll carries lettered tracts, Lots A through N, addressed on West Gulf Drive with a county use code of 70, and Parcels O through R, an easement parcel coded 09, less a part described in Official Records Book 1783, Page 4508. Whether the lettered tracts are the lakes and whether the easement parcel is the beach path is to confirm on the plat.
Not gated and not a club community
A broker community page describes Bright Water as "not a gated or amenity-centered development." There is no clubhouse, community pool, tennis court or golf course on the plat, and the streets are open to the public road.
No boat access
The lakes are freshwater and enclosed. No Bright Water lot has canal or dock access to the Gulf or the bay, so a boat owner would keep the boat at a marina elsewhere on the island.
What does it cost to own a Bright Water home each year?
Bright Water ownership costs are mostly property tax, insurance and, when you leave the island, the causeway toll, because the association charge is small. The figures below are from listing pages, county records and Lee County; confirm each one for the address you buy.
| Cost | Figure | Source and note |
|---|---|---|
| Association fee | About $100 a year | Listing pages; described as covering beach rights and access |
| Same fee on one portal | $8 a month | Listing portal |
| Property tax on recent listings | $5,856 to $18,582 a year | 2024 and 2025 bills quoted in listings |
| Sanibel Causeway toll | $6 with a transponder, $9 without | Inbound only |
| LeeWay unlimited annual pass | $400 | Lee County tolls |
| Community development district | None found | To confirm on the tax bill |
The association fee
Several listing pages show an association fee of $100 a year, which they describe as covering beach rights and access; one portal shows $8 a month, about the same. One broker flags the figure as third-party data that may be inaccurate. The association's legal name and whether membership is mandatory were not found in public records read for this page, so ask the seller for the governing documents.
The estoppel letter
Florida law lets a homeowners' association charge up to $250 for an estoppel certificate, with more for an expedited or delinquent account. The certificate states the current fee, any balance and any special assessment, so order it early in the contract.
Property tax on recent listings
Tax bills quoted on listing pages ran $5,856 for 3314 Saint Kilda Road (2024), $9,057 for 3351 Barra Circle (2024), $9,214 for 3359 Barra Circle (2025) and $18,582 for the 2024 concrete home listed as 3354 Barra Circle (2025). A seller's bill reflects that owner's exemptions and caps; yours will be based on your purchase.
What resets when a home sells
Florida's Save Our Homes cap limits yearly increases in a homestead's assessed value, and the cap resets at sale. Non-homestead property has its own 10 percent cap that also resets. Budget from your price and the current millage on the Lee County Tax Collector's site, not from the seller's bill.
The causeway toll
Leaving Sanibel by car means crossing the Sanibel Causeway, tolled inbound only: $6 with a transponder or $9 without, and Lee County sells a $400 LeeWay unlimited annual pass. Owners who drive to the mainland often price the pass into their budget.
No CDD found
No community development district or other special district was found for Bright Water. Check the non-ad valorem lines on the Lee County Tax Collector's bill for the address to be sure.
Rules for renting, pets and building at Bright Water
Bright Water homes fall under City of Sanibel rules for rentals, building and flood protection, and under whatever recorded restrictions apply to the plat. The points below are the ones buyers ask about most; read the recorded documents and the city code for the full text.
Rental minimum
Single-family homes on Sanibel may be rented only for stays of at least 28 days, so weekly vacation rentals are not allowed. Confirm the rule for the address with the City of Sanibel before you buy for income.
The city rental license
Owners who rent need a City of Sanibel dwelling rental license. The city's registration form, dated February 26, 2020, lists $300 a year for a limited license for rentals of 28 days or more, and owners also need a business tax receipt. The current fee is to confirm with the city.
Pets and assistance animals
Listing portals describe Bright Water as "Dogs and Cats OK" for owners and tenants; the recorded restrictions are the source to confirm any limit. An assistance animal for a person with a disability is a reasonable accommodation under federal and Florida fair housing law, not a pet, and a pet limit does not bar it.
Signs
One listing notes "no sign on property per HOA," so for-sale signs may be restricted. Ask for the written rule.
Height and raising a home
Sanibel caps building height at 45 feet measured from NAVD datum, and a June 2026 city ordinance lets existing homes be raised up to 10 feet regardless of the height and angle-of-light limits. Any work on a lot goes through the City of Sanibel building department.
The 50 percent rule
When repairs or improvements cost 50 percent or more of a structure's market value, a home that does not meet current flood rules must be brought into compliance, which usually means raising it above base flood elevation. Ask the city whether a home has had substantial damage or improvement on record.
Is Bright Water in a flood zone?
Bright Water homes sit in a FEMA special flood hazard area: the federal map returns Zone AE, coastal floodplain, with a base flood elevation of 9 feet at the four addresses tested, so a lender will require flood insurance. Lee County also places the subdivision in evacuation Zone A, the first ordered to leave in a storm.
| Item | Bright Water |
|---|---|
| FEMA flood zone at four addresses | AE, base flood elevation 9 ft |
| South edge near West Gulf Drive | BFE about 10 ft, to confirm per lot |
| FIRM panel | 12071C0536G, effective November 17, 2022 |
| Sanibel NFIP entry | 1979 |
| Sanibel CRS class | Class 5, 25% flood premium discount |
| Lee County evacuation zone | Zone A, storm surge zone 1 |
Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, read November 11, 2026; City of Sanibel flood information; Lee County evacuation zone layer.
The flood elevation across the plat
FEMA's layer returned base flood elevation 9 feet at 3320 Saint Kilda Road, 3304 Saint Kilda Road, 409 Tiree Circle and 3358 Barra Circle. A north to south line of test points rose from 8 feet at the north edge of the plat to 10 feet at its south edge, then to 11 feet and to Zone VE at 14 feet toward the Gulf. Lots nearest West Gulf Drive may carry the higher figure.
Checking a single lot
The City of Sanibel runs a flood lookup portal that shows the zone and any elevation certificate on file for an address, and the building department can answer questions at 239-472-4555. Ask the seller for an elevation certificate as well.
Older homes and flood rating
Homes built before Sanibel joined the flood program in 1979 are called pre-FIRM. Bright Water has two on the roll, from 1973 and 1979, and their flood premiums may be rated differently from those of raised homes built to current code.
Hurricane Ian in 2022
Hurricane Ian struck on September 28, 2022. We found no Bright Water damage count in public sources. A local history of West Gulf Drive describes surge crossing the road from the Gulf, flooding ground-level space and filling pools with sand, with older one-story homes hit hardest and raised homes keeping their upper floors. Ask each seller what work was done and with what permits.
Signs of rebuilding on the record
The roll and listings show work after Ian: 402 Tiree Circle went from a 2022 home sale to a vacant parcel, a lot bought in February 2022 has a 2024 house on the roll, and listings mention new drywall at 3314 Saint Kilda Road and a 2023 roof at 3351 Barra Circle. What happened at each address is to confirm with the city.
Helene and Milton in 2024
Helene and Milton brought surge to parts of Sanibel again in 2024. We found no Bright Water-specific record for either storm; ask the seller and check city permits.
Insurance and construction for a Bright Water home
Bright Water homes are fee-simple single-family houses, not condominiums, so the owner insures the whole structure and the flood risk is priced address by address. Flood elevation, roof and opening protection are what insurers ask about first on the west end of Sanibel.
Not a condominium
Florida's milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study rules apply to condominium and cooperative buildings of three or more habitable stories. They do not apply to Bright Water houses.
Flood insurance
Zone AE means a federally backed mortgage requires flood insurance. Sanibel's Class 5 standing in the Community Rating System gives a 25 percent discount on National Flood Insurance Program premiums, and a home raised well above base flood elevation, like the concrete homes of 2024 and 2026, should price better than an older ground-level house. Get a quote before you make an offer.
Wind protection
Listings stress metal roofs, roll-down shutters, impact features and generators. A wind mitigation inspection records roof shape, roof-to-wall connections and opening protection and can lower the wind portion of a Florida homeowner's premium.
Building on a vacant lot
New homes must sit above the flood elevation that applies to the lot, plus any freeboard the city requires. A 2026 local estimate put new construction on the island at about $450 to $650 or more a square foot; the 3324 Saint Kilda Road ask works out to about $724 a square foot under air at $3,250,000.
Where is Bright Water on Sanibel?
Bright Water lies on Sanibel's west end, between about 26.4274 and 26.4300 degrees north, on the north side of West Gulf Drive behind the row of Gulf-front condominiums that line that road. The Lake Murex and Little Lake Murex subdivisions sit next to it, and the island's shared-use path runs along West Gulf Drive.
| Destination | Time from Bright Water | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Deeded beach path across West Gulf Drive | A short walk | Listing pages |
| Blind Pass Beach | About 5 minutes | Broker community page |
| Bowman's Beach | About 10 minutes | Broker community page |
| Captiva Island | About 10 minutes | Broker community page |
| J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge | About 15 minutes | Broker community page |
| Shops on Periwinkle Way | About 20 minutes | Broker community page |
| Island end of the Sanibel Causeway | About 30 minutes | Broker community page; longer in season |
Neighbors on the map
Lee County's subdivision layer shows Lake Murex (53.39 acres) and Little Lake Murex (50.99 acres) beside Bright Water, with smaller plats such as Cardinal Ridge, Poinciana Circle and Palm Lake nearby. Gulf-front condominium buildings in the same map window include Sayana of Sanibel, Tantara, Somerset at the Reef, Tamarind at the Reef, Seascape of Sanibel, Wedgewood of Sanibel and Breakers West.
Beaches
Beyond the deeded path, Blind Pass Beach at the island's north tip is about five minutes away and Bowman's Beach about ten, per a broker community page.
Captiva
Captiva is about ten minutes north by car, per a broker community page. For homes there, see our Captiva Island homes for sale page.
Shops and services
A broker community page lists Bailey's shopping center, The Village Shops, the Sanibel post office and Island Pharmacy among the nearest services. The broker page puts the shops on Periwinkle Way about 20 minutes away by car.
Getting off the island
Downtown Fort Myers, Interstate 75 and Southwest Florida International Airport are all across the causeway, and from the west end we estimate roughly 45 to 60 minutes depending on season and traffic; that range is to confirm with your own drive. HealthPark Medical Center, part of Lee Health, is the nearest full hospital, also on the mainland.
Nature nearby
The J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge is about 15 minutes away. The Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation manages preserve land on the island, including land behind some Lake Murex lots.
Schools for Bright Water addresses
Bright Water addresses are served by The Sanibel School, a public school that teaches kindergarten through eighth grade. High school students attend school on the mainland in Fort Myers. Lee County uses school choice zones, so confirm the assignment for any address with the School District of Lee County.
The Sanibel School
The Sanibel School is at 3840 Sanibel Captiva Road, phone 239-472-1617. It describes itself as an A-rated school, a National Blue Ribbon School and a PBIS Model School, and it says students do not need to live on the island to enroll.
High school
The zoned high school for Bright Water addresses was not confirmed for this page. Use the district's address lookup to check.
Private schools
Private schools on the mainland include Canterbury School in Fort Myers, which runs from pre-kindergarten through grade 12; other private options are to confirm by drive time from the island.
A short history of Bright Water
Bright Water is one of Sanibel's older platted neighborhoods: the plat was on record by early 1973, before the city incorporated in 1974, and its lots sold one at a time to owners who built over the next fifty years. The record below comes from the county sale file and roll.
The plat
The plat is recorded in Lee County Plat Book 28, pages 57 and 58, as a subdivision of part of Section 27. The exact recording date and the developer named in the dedication were not found in public sources; both are on the plat itself at the Lee County Clerk.
The first lot sales
The oldest deeds in the county file are vacant lot sales in February 1973: Lot 2 for $5,200 and Lot 21 for $6,900. Lot prices then rose to about $20,000 to $30,000 by 1981 and 1982 and $48,500 to $55,000 by 1986.
Building through the decades
Owners built houses lot by lot rather than through one tract builder. The first improved sale in the county index is 3350 Barra Circle at $183,200 in September 1987, and building continued through the 1980s and 1990s.
The 2013 to 2017 wave
Five homes went up on lots bought vacant between 2010 and 2014: 413 Tiree Circle (2013), 3358 Saint Kilda Road (2014), 3351 Saint Kilda Road (2015), 3334 Saint Kilda Road (2016) and 3355 Barra Circle (2017).
After Ian
3363 Barra Circle, Lot 30, was bought vacant for $575,000 in February 2022 and now carries a 2024 house on the roll. 3324 Saint Kilda Road, Lot 7, bought vacant for $430,000 in April 2021, was listed in May 2026 as new construction at $3,400,000, reduced to $3,250,000 on July 31, 2026.
The street names
Saint Kilda, Barra and Tiree are all names of islands in Scotland's Hebrides. Whether the developer chose them for that reason is not documented.
What should you check before you make an offer on a Bright Water home?
Bright Water houses differ widely in age, height and construction, so the checks that matter most are the flood elevation, the storm history of the specific house and the recorded rights to the lake and the beach path. These steps come straight from the records summarized above.
Get the elevation certificate
Ask the seller for an elevation certificate and look the address up on the city's flood portal. The gap between the lowest floor and the base flood elevation drives both insurance cost and future repair rules.
Ask for the storm and permit history
Ask what happened to the house in Ian, Helene and Milton, what was repaired and under which permits, and whether the city ever made a substantial damage finding.
Read the plat and your deed
Confirm on Plat Book 28, pages 57 and 58, and in the deed that the lot carries rights to the beach path and the lake tracts.
Find the association documents
Ask for the recorded restrictions, the association's legal name and an estoppel letter showing the current fee.
Price the insurance first
Get flood and wind quotes, with the elevation certificate and roof age stated, before your inspection period ends.
Compare like with like
Compare a house against recorded Bright Water sales of similar age, height and size rather than against an island-wide median, and keep county recorded prices and listing asks separate.
Order a full inspection
Have the roof, the structure below the living floor, the air conditioning, the pool and any generator inspected and priced, with particular attention to older ground-level houses.
Bright Water and other Sanibel neighborhoods buyers compare
Bright Water buyers usually compare it with other west end and mid-island single-family neighborhoods that offer a lake or a beach path without Gulf-front prices. The notes below stick to what public records and research show, and our Sanibel real estate section links the wider island.
| Neighborhood | How it compares with Bright Water |
|---|---|
| Lake Murex and Little Lake Murex | Next door on the west end, also lake lots off West Gulf Drive; larger, with 115 single-family parcels on the roll; 2025 and 2026 sales of about $579,000 to $1.1 million |
| Gulf Pines | West end neighborhood with deeded beach access; one 2026 closed sale of $844,000 |
| Sanibel Bayous | West end wooded neighborhood from the 1970s with no lakes or beach path; closed $645,000 to $1.5 million from May 2025 to February 2026 |
| Beachview Country Club Estates | Mid-island, Gulf side, on a golf course; 238 lots, median $1,222,500 from October 2025 to September 2026 |
| Gulf-front homes on West Gulf Drive | Same road, direct beachfront, about $1.5 million to more than $8 million, with Zone VE exposure |
Source: Lee County roll and sale file and DRG research on each neighborhood, November 2026.
Other single-family pages on Sanibel
For single-family homes elsewhere on the island, our Gulf Ridge homes for sale page covers another Sanibel subdivision of detached houses, and our Southwinds Estates page covers single-family homes on the East End.
Choosing a condo on the Gulf instead
Buyers who want to be on the sand rather than a walk from it often weigh a Gulf-front condominium. Our Gulfside Place page covers one such building on Middle Gulf Drive.
What Bright Water offers and what it does not
Bright Water offers detached houses on lake lots, a recorded beach path across the road, a very small association fee and a quiet west end setting. It does not offer a gate, a clubhouse, golf, boat access or weekly rentals.
Talk to a Domain Realty Group Bright Water specialist
Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows Bright Water and other Sanibel homes, and our Fort Myers office on College Parkway is the closest of our three offices to the causeway. We tracked every qualified Bright Water sale in the county file and matched each one to the roll by year built and heated area to build this page.
★★★★★ "Wonderful buying experience with Marc. Will definitely reach out to him in our next adventure. He helped us tremendously in buying our first home and has helped our family with other homes as well. Highly recommend him as he is very well versed in the business."
Verified Zillow review. mengx1984, on buying a single-family home in Fort Myers with Marc Comisar.
Talk to our team about a Bright Water home
Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816, tell us whether you want a house or a lot, a lake view or a pool and the budget you have in mind, and an agent will send matching listings, the recorded sales on the plat and the questions to put to the seller. You can also search current listings any time.
Thinking of selling a Bright Water home?
Buyers here weigh elevation, storm repairs, the lake view and the beach path, so a Bright Water house priced against recorded sales of similar homes on the plat tends to sell faster than one priced against an island average. Start with a free home valuation from our team, and for a seller's plan for the island, see McGreevy and Comisar's guide to selling a home on Sanibel and Captiva.
Frequently Asked Questions about Bright Water homes for sale
These are the questions buyers ask most about Bright Water homes for sale on Sanibel, answered from the Lee County roll and sale file, FEMA and Lee County map layers, City of Sanibel pages and public listing pages. Where a fact was not confirmed for this page, the answer says so in plain words.
Where is Bright Water?
On the west end of Sanibel, ZIP 33957, on the inland side of West Gulf Drive, beside the Lake Murex neighborhoods. Its streets are Saint Kilda Road, Barra Circle and Tiree Circle.
Is Bright Water on Sanibel the same as Brightwater in Fort Myers?
No. Bright Water on Sanibel is a different place from Brightwater in Fort Myers, and from Brightwater in Cape Coral. This page covers only the Sanibel plat in Plat Book 28, pages 57 and 58; filter any listing search for Sanibel and 33957.
Is it spelled Bright Water or Brightwater?
The recorded plat and the county roll say BRIGHT WATER, two words. Some listings spell it as one word.
How many homes are in Bright Water?
Brokers count 33 homesites. The county roll lists 32 numbered lot parcels, 26 with homes and 6 vacant.
What kind of homes are in Bright Water?
Detached single-family houses only; there are no condominiums or townhomes on the plat.
How big are Bright Water homes?
County heated area runs 1,300 to 3,025 square feet, median about 1,836. The 2026 new build is listed at 4,486 square feet under air.
How many bedrooms do Bright Water homes have?
Twenty-two of the 26 homes have three bedrooms, two have four and two have two.
When were Bright Water homes built?
From 1973 to 2024 on the roll, with one more house listed as 2026 new construction.
Who built Bright Water?
The developer was not found in public sources; the dedication on the plat names it. Lots sold to individual owners who built their own homes.
What do Bright Water homes sell for?
Lee County recorded 47 qualified home sales from 1987 to June 2026 at a $705,000 median. The seven since October 2022 ran $670,000 to $1,350,000, median $800,000.
What was the most recent Bright Water sale?
The newest improved sale in the county index is 3366 Barra Circle, $740,388, on June 26, 2026. A vacant lot, 3304 Saint Kilda Road, sold for $550,000 on August 13, 2026.
What is the highest Bright Water sale on record?
$1,350,000 for 3320 Saint Kilda Road on December 22, 2023.
What were asking prices in November 2026?
Broker pages showed asks of about $979,000 to $3,250,000.
Are there lots for sale in Bright Water?
The roll shows six vacant lots. Lots recorded $430,000 to $640,000 in 2021 and 2022, and Lot 1 sold for $550,000 in August 2026.
Is there new construction in Bright Water?
One house, 3324 Saint Kilda Road, was listed in May 2026 as new insulated concrete form construction at $3,400,000, later $3,250,000. Its builder was not named.
Does Bright Water have beach access?
Listings say owners hold a deeded beach path across West Gulf Drive. One broker page contradicts itself, so confirm it on the plat and in your deed.
Is Bright Water on the water?
Many lots back onto private freshwater lakes. The Gulf is across West Gulf Drive, reached by the beach path.
Can I keep a boat at Bright Water?
No lot has canal or dock access to the Gulf or the bay; the lakes are enclosed.
Is Bright Water gated?
No. It is an open, ungated subdivision.
Does Bright Water have a clubhouse or pool?
No. There is no clubhouse, community pool, tennis or golf.
What are the HOA fees in Bright Water?
Listings show about $100 a year, described as covering beach rights and access. Confirm the current figure on an estoppel letter.
Is there a CDD in Bright Water?
None was found; check the non-ad valorem lines on the tax bill for the address.
What are property taxes on a Bright Water home?
Recent listings quoted bills of $5,856 to $18,582 a year. Your bill will be based on your purchase price and exemptions.
Can you rent out a Bright Water home?
Yes, for stays of 28 days or more, with a City of Sanibel rental license and a business tax receipt.
Are weekly rentals allowed?
No. Sanibel single-family homes have a 28-day minimum rental period.
Does Bright Water allow pets?
Listing portals say dogs and cats are allowed; confirm any limit in the recorded restrictions. Assistance animals are a reasonable accommodation, not a pet.
Is Bright Water a 55+ community?
No age restriction was found in public sources for Bright Water. Confirm with the association documents.
What flood zone is Bright Water in?
FEMA Zone AE, base flood elevation 9 feet at four tested addresses, rising toward 10 feet near West Gulf Drive, on panel 12071C0536G.
Is flood insurance required in Bright Water?
Yes, a lender will require it in Zone AE. Sanibel's Class 5 rating gives a 25 percent discount on flood program premiums.
What evacuation zone is Bright Water in?
Lee County evacuation Zone A.
Was Bright Water damaged in Hurricane Ian?
We found no Bright Water damage count in public sources. Ask each seller about repairs and permits, and check the city's records.
How far is Bright Water from the beach?
The deeded path is a short walk; Blind Pass Beach is about 5 minutes and Bowman's Beach about 10.
How far is Bright Water from Captiva?
About 10 minutes, per a broker community page.
What school serves Bright Water?
The Sanibel School, K-8, at 3840 Sanibel Captiva Road. High school is on the mainland; confirm the assignment with the district.
Where do I see Bright Water homes for sale?
Our team posts active Bright Water listings on our current listings search and sends new ones as they come up. Call 239-441-2816 or contact us to set up a search.
About Domain Realty Group on Sanibel
Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team working Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, and we show homes on Sanibel and Captiva from our Fort Myers office, the closest of our offices to the causeway. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. The team is led by Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671), who bring over 45 years of combined direct experience between them.
Reach any of our agents through our agents page, read our client reviews or learn more about our team. We tracked the Bright Water plat parcel by parcel, lot sales included, to build this page.
Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816 info@domainrealtygroup.com
Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:
- Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
- Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
- Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919
Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.
Where to go next: Sanibel homes for sale, Captiva Island homes for sale, Gulf Ridge homes for sale, Southwinds Estates homes and current listings.
Sources
Each figure on this page traces to one of the sources below. By policy we link no real estate portal; facts credited to "listings" or "broker pages" say so. County sale figures come from the Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and sale file for the BRIGHT WATER plat, Plat Book 28, index built November 18, 2026. Web pages were read November 11 to November 21, 2026 unless another date is given.
Lee County records and maps
- Lee County Property Appraiser, parcel roll and sale history (Bright Water parcels)
- Lee County Property Appraiser, downloadable sale data files
- Lee County Property Appraiser, downloadable tax roll data
- Lee County Property Appraiser, homestead and other exemptions
- Lee County GIS, Subdivisions and Condominiums map layer (BRIGHT WATER, PB 28 PGS 57 and 58, 27.31 acres)
- Lee County GIS, Land Records map service (neighboring plats around West Gulf Drive)
- Lee County Emergency Management, evacuation zone layer (Zone A at Tiree Circle)
- Lee County, know your evacuation zone
- Lee County Clerk of Court, Official Records search (Plat Book 28, pages 57 and 58; OR Book 1783, Page 4508)
- Lee County Tax Collector, property tax bills and non-ad valorem charges
- Florida Department of Revenue, property tax data portal (roll files)
- Lee County, LeeWay toll program and Sanibel Causeway toll rates
- Lee County, toll costs for the Sanibel Causeway and other bridges
- U.S. Census Bureau Geocoder (Saint Kilda Road, Tiree Circle and Barra Circle points)
City of Sanibel
- City of Sanibel, official site
- City of Sanibel, Flood Information page (NFIP since 1979, CRS Class 5)
- City of Sanibel, flood zone and elevation certificate lookup portal
- City of Sanibel, Building Department
- City of Sanibel, Permitting Information
- City of Sanibel, Code of Ordinances on Municode (rental and building rules, Chapter 126)
- City of Sanibel, Dwelling Rental License and Registration form, dated February 26, 2020 (copy hosted by a local guide)
- City of Sanibel, Hurricane Re-Entry Passes
Flood, storms and insurance
- FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, flood hazard zones (Zone AE, BFE 9 ft at four Bright Water addresses)
- FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, FIRM panel index (12071C0536G, effective November 17, 2022)
- FEMA Flood Map Service Center, address lookup
- FEMA, National Flood Insurance Program overview
- FEMA, Community Rating System discounts
- FEMA, substantial improvement and substantial damage desk reference
- FEMA, elevation certificate guidance
- National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Report on Hurricane Ian (2022)
- National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Report on Hurricane Helene (2024)
- National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Report on Hurricane Milton (2024)
- Lifestyle and Luxury Living, history of West Gulf Drive on Sanibel from the 1880s to 2026
- Lifestyle and Luxury Living, 2026 new construction costs on Sanibel
- Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, flood coverage requirement
- My Safe Florida Home, wind mitigation program
- Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
Florida law, taxes and fair housing
- Florida Statutes, Chapter 720 on homeowners' associations
- Florida Statutes section 720.30851, the estoppel certificate fee
- Florida Statutes section 720.401, the HOA disclosure summary given to buyers
- Florida Statutes section 553.899, the condominium milestone inspection law
- Florida Statutes section 718.112, condominium bylaws and reserve study rules
- Florida Statutes section 193.155, the Save Our Homes cap
- Florida Statutes section 193.1555, the cap on non-homestead residential property
- Florida Statutes section 196.031, the homestead exemption
- Florida Statutes section 760.23, discrimination in the sale or rental of housing
- Florida Statutes section 760.27, emotional support animals in housing
- U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, assistance animal guidance
- Florida Division of Corporations, entity search (association name to confirm)
Schools
- The Sanibel School, School District of Lee County
- School District of Lee County
- School District of Lee County, school site locator by address
- Canterbury School, Fort Myers
Places and services
- U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge
- Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation
- Lee Health, HealthPark Medical Center
- Southwest Florida International Airport
- Lee County Parks and Recreation, beach parks including Bowman's Beach
- Sanibel and Captiva Islands Chamber of Commerce
- Microsoft Planetary Computer, USDA NAIP aerial collection (hero image: USDA NAIP, January 16, 2023, public domain)
Listing and broker pages (read for this page, not linked by policy)
- Broker community page, Pfeifer Realty Group, "About Bright Water" (33 homesites, not gated, drive times, active asks; read November 2026)
- Broker listing page, 3359 Barra Circle (listed June 1, 2026; remodeled and raised 1982 home, 0.309 acre, 2025 taxes)
- Broker listing page, 3351 Barra Circle (listed November 12, 2025; association fee $100 a year, 2024 taxes, 2023 roof)
- Broker listing page, 3314 Saint Kilda Road (listed February 7, 2025; raised home, lake views, 2024 taxes)
- Broker article, understanding the FEMA 50 percent rule on Sanibel (updated January 26, 2026)
- Broker article, rental rules on Sanibel Island (28-day minimum for single-family homes; updated October 28, 2026)
- Broker subdivision page, Homes by Marco, Bright Water, Sanibel (asks, sizes, average tax)
- Listing records for 3304 Saint Kilda Road (vacant lot asks of $739,000 and $599,000, 0.33 acre)
- Listing records for the 2024 concrete home listed as 3354 Barra Circle (asks of $1,824,000 and $1,774,000, 0.34 acre, 2025 taxes)
- Listing records for 3324 Saint Kilda Road new construction (listed May 29, 2026; $3,400,000 then $3,250,000; 4,486 sq ft under air)
- Listing records for 3366 Barra Circle (2025 ask of $1,195,000; deeded beach access across West Gulf Drive)
- Subdivision listing summaries for Bright Water (pets, association fee, sign rule)
239-441-2816Search homes