Opens in a new tab
Back to Fort Myers Beach

Fort Myers Beach · Florida · 33931

Gulf Island Manor Homes for Sale, Fort Myers Beach, FL

Gulf Island Manor homes for sale in a small single-family plat dating to about the 1940s, on Gulf Island Drive and Mandalay Road, mid-island on Estero Island in the Town of Fort Myers Beach. The county roll carries 59 residential parcels, 40 of them coded single-family and 19 vacant, plus an owners' beach lot and bay park. Recorded sales, lots, rebuilds after Hurricane Ian, flood zones, taxes and what to check before an offer. Updated November 2026.

Aerial view of Gulf Island Manor on Fort Myers Beach, with its Lee County parcels outlined from the Gulf-front lots on Estero Boulevard across Gulf Island Drive and Mandalay Road to the bay-front homes on Bayside Road

Gulf Island Manor homes for sale sit on two short streets, Gulf Island Drive and Mandalay Road, that run from Estero Boulevard back to the bay in the middle of Estero Island, in the Town of Fort Myers Beach. The subdivision is recorded in Lee County Plat Book 8, Page 68, as Blocks A to F. Most of it is interior lots on the bay side of the boulevard, with a row of large homes on the back bay along Bayside Road and four large Gulf-front parcels across Estero Boulevard.

The Lee County roll carries 61 parcels under the Gulf Island Manor legal: 40 coded single-family, 19 coded vacant and two tracts owned by Gulf Island Manor HOA, a bay park and a small beach lot. Lee County recorded 11 qualified sales here in the 60 months to October 21, 2026, from $575,000 to $1,500,000 at a $690,000 median, and none in the last 12 months of that file. This page covers those sales, the homes and lots, the shared beach and bay tracts, the rebuilding after Hurricane Ian, flood zones, taxes and rentals. It is one of the single-family neighborhoods we track for buyers browsing Fort Myers Beach homes for sale.

Updated November 2026. Data updated: November 2026.

Key takeaways for Gulf Island Manor buyers

  • A small recorded plat: 61 parcels in Plat Book 8, Page 68, on Gulf Island Drive, Mandalay Road, Bayside Road and Estero Boulevard, ZIP 33931.
  • Homes on the roll date from 1925 to 2024; 15 of the 37 homes with a building on the roll were built from 1925 to 1959. Heated area runs 729 to 3,554 square feet, with a median of 1,313.
  • 19 parcels are coded vacant on the 2026 roll, and five of them still show an in-ground pool, which points to homes removed after the 2022 storms. Four new homes from 2025 and 2026 are in the roll's new-construction fields.
  • Lee County recorded 11 qualified sales in the 60 months to October 21, 2026, from $575,000 for a lot to $1,500,000 for a 2018 home, at a $690,000 median.
  • Owners share two association tracts: a bay park on Bayside Road and a beach-access lot on Estero Boulevard. Listing records put the dues at $500 a year, unverified.
  • FEMA's layer maps the interior and bay lots in Zone AE with base flood elevations of 11 to 13 feet, and the Gulf-front lots in Zone VE at 14 feet or more.

Gulf Island Manor homes for sale right now

Listings in Gulf Island Manor are few: 59 residential parcels, and the county recorded 4 qualified sales in the 24 months to October 21, 2026, all in the first four months of 2025. MLS counts can differ from the county's; this page uses the qualified count Lee County records. Asking prices here depend first on what stands on the lot: a pre-1960 cottage, a home rebuilt or raised since the storms, a bay-front home with a seawall, or a cleared lot.

Listing records from 2026 show a 1957 home of 2,000 square feet on Gulf Island Drive asking $1,230,000, a 1951 home on Mandalay Road asking $939,000 and then $925,000, and two cleared lots asking $575,000 and $479,000. Those are asking prices from listing records, not sales. A listing record also shows a Mandalay Road lot closed at $430,000 on October 14, 2026, after the end of the county sale file; that sale is unverified until the county records it. To see what is on the market today, search current listings and filter for Fort Myers Beach, or ask us for a saved search on these two streets.

A street address is not membership

Bayside Road, Estero Boulevard and Hercules Drive run through several plats. Gulf View Plaza on Coconut Drive and Hercules Park on Hercules Drive are separate subdivisions next door. Check that the legal description reads Gulf Island Manor before you count on the shared beach lot or bay park.

Ready to tour Gulf Island Manor homes?

Name the street, say whether you want a finished home or a lot to build on, and we will match listings on Gulf Island Drive and Mandalay Road against the recorded sales. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do Gulf Island Manor homes sell for?

Gulf Island Manor homes and lots sold for a $690,000 median over the 60 months to October 21, 2026, the end of the county sale file, on 11 qualified sales from $575,000 to $1,500,000. There was no qualified sale in the last 12 months of the file. Only sales coded as qualified by Lee County are counted below.

Window to October 21, 2026 Qualified sales Median sold Low High
12 months 0 none none none
24 months 4 $802,500 $575,000 $1,500,000
36 months 5 $685,000 $575,000 $1,500,000
60 months 11 $690,000 $575,000 $1,500,000
10 years 24 $672,500 $383,000 $1,995,000

Data updated: November 2026. Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and sale files (sales through October 21, 2026), qualified sales over $1,000 on the 61 Gulf Island Manor parcels. The windows mix homes and lots, so read the sale list below with them.

Recorded sales since 2022

Month Street What the roll shows today Sale price Per sq ft
April 2025 Gulf Island Dr 2015 home, 1,262 sq ft, pool $920,000 $729
February 2025 Gulf Island Dr 2018 home, 2,050 sq ft, pool $1,500,000 $732
January 2025 Mandalay Rd vacant lot, 0.18 acre $575,000 lot
January 2025 Gulf Island Dr 1958 home, 1,104 sq ft, pool $685,000 $620
November 2023 Gulf Island Dr 1959 home, 1,076 sq ft $670,000 $623
July 2023 Mandalay Rd 1951 home, 1,190 sq ft $705,000 $592
May 2023 Gulf Island Dr vacant lot with a pool $640,000 lot
April 2023 Mandalay Rd vacant lot with a pool $690,000 lot
June 2022 Gulf Island Dr 1959 home, 1,076 sq ft $690,000 $641
April 2022 Gulf Island Dr 1940 home, 1,472 sq ft, pool $939,000 $638
March 2022 Mandalay Rd 1966 home, 1,080 sq ft $675,000 $625

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales and the 2026 parcel roll. "What the roll shows today" is the 2026 roll, not the condition at the sale; a lot that is vacant today may have held a damaged house when it sold. Per square foot uses the heated area on the 2026 roll.

The two newer homes, built in 2015 and 2018, sold for $920,000 and $1,500,000 in 2025, about $730 a square foot. The older cottages sold for $670,000 to $705,000 since the storm, and the lots for $575,000 to $690,000, so a buyer here is often weighing an older house against the price of a lot and a new build.

Sales the county did not code as qualified

Some deeds sit outside the qualified count: $770,000 for a Gulf Island Drive parcel in May 2022, $400,000 and $600,000 for the same Mandalay Road parcel in March and April 2022, and $600,000 for a Mandalay Road parcel in January 2023. A 2025 listing record for that last parcel said the house could not be renovated under Town rules and was offered for lot value; that statement is from a listing record and is unverified.

The waterfront and Gulf-front record

The highest qualified sale in the last 10 years is $1,995,000, for a Gulf-front parcel on Estero Boulevard in October 2018. A bay-front home on Bayside Road, built in 1993 with 3,554 square feet, sold for $1,500,000 in June 2019. Neither the four bay-front homes nor the four Gulf-front parcels have a qualified sale in the last 60 months of the file.

Sales by calendar year

Year Qualified sales Median Low High
2018 3 $481,000 $425,000 $1,995,000
2019 4 $567,500 $480,000 $1,500,000
2020 1 $550,000 $550,000 $550,000
2021 2 $699,500 $630,000 $769,000
2022 3 $690,000 $675,000 $939,000
2023 4 $680,000 $640,000 $705,000
2025 4 $802,500 $575,000 $1,500,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales. No qualified sale was recorded in 2024 or in 2026 through October 21.

What is Gulf Island Manor? A 1940s plat on Estero Island

Gulf Island Manor is a recorded single-family subdivision, not a condominium. The plat is in Lee County Plat Book 8, Page 68, in Section 29, Township 46 South, Range 24 East; one parcel on Mandalay Road cites Page 71 instead. The plat itself was not opened for this page, so its recording date and the name of the developer are unverified. A 2006 county document dates another plat in the same Plat Book 8 to 1946, and one listing aggregator says the community dates back to 1947.

Blocks and streets

Piece Blocks and streets What is there on the 2026 roll
Interior streets Blocks A and B on Mandalay Road, Blocks C and D on Gulf Island Drive, with corner lots on Estero Boulevard 22 parcels on each street, lots of 0.14 to 0.19 acre on most
Bay-front row Block E on Bayside Road and one lot on Hercules Drive 4 two-story homes of 3,067 to 3,554 square feet built 1991 to 2018, each with a seawall, and one vacant bay lot
Gulf-front row Block F on Estero Boulevard 4 vacant Gulf-front parcels of about half an acre to one acre
Association tracts Gulf Island Park tracts on Bayside Road and Estero Boulevard A 0.20 acre bay park and a 0.07 acre beach-access lot

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, 2026.

Gated or not

Gulf Island Manor is not gated. Both streets are open Town streets off Estero Boulevard, and a 2026 listing record describes the subdivision as non-gated.

Jurisdiction and zoning

Every parcel is inside the Town of Fort Myers Beach and the Fort Myers Beach Fire District. The roll codes the lots RS and RS-1, the Town's residential single-family districts. The Town issues building permits and applies its own flood rules.

The homes and lots

Gulf Island Manor is mostly one-story homes on lots of about a sixth of an acre. Of the 37 homes with a building on the 2026 roll, 31 are one story, one is one and a half stories and five are two stories. The roll counts 14 two-bedroom, 21 three-bedroom and 2 four-bedroom homes.

Age and size

Built Homes on the roll
1925 to 1959 15
1960 to 1979 5
1986 to 1998 10
2000 to 2024 7

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, 2026, 37 homes with a building on the roll.

Heated area runs from 729 square feet in a 1950 cottage on Mandalay Road to 3,554 square feet in a 1993 bay-front home, with a median of 1,313. The roll marks a pool on 19 of the 40 single-family parcels and a seawall on five parcels. It shows no private boat dock on any parcel.

New homes since the storms

Four new homes appear in the roll's new-construction fields: three on Gulf Island Drive dated 2025, of 1,477 to 1,588 square feet with three bedrooms each, and one on Bayside Road dated 2026, of 1,573 square feet on two stories. One more home on Mandalay Road carries a 2024 build year on the certified roll. New homes here have to meet the Town's elevation rule, so most are raised; how each one is built is unverified, so check the permits.

Lots to build on

The roll codes 19 parcels vacant. Nine are interior lots on Gulf Island Drive and Mandalay Road of 0.14 to 0.18 acre, with 2026 just values of $386,049 to $440,843. Others are corner lots on Estero Boulevard, one bay lot on Hercules Drive, the four Gulf-front parcels and one small sliver of land the roll lists with no street access. Interior lots recorded qualified sales of $575,000 to $690,000 from 2023 to 2025.

Roll values

The 2026 just value of the 40 single-family parcels runs from $402,112 to $2,911,572, with a median of $696,060. The four bay-front homes carry $1,908,667 to $2,911,572, and the four Gulf-front parcels $1,970,013 to $3,383,557. Treat these as tax figures from the appraiser, not market prices.

The shared beach lot and bay park

The roll names Gulf Island Manor HOA as owner of two tracts called Gulf Island Park on the plat, conveyed by a deed in Official Records Book 252, Page 868. Tract 1 is a 0.20 acre park on the bay at 3961 Bayside Road. Tract 2 is a 0.07 acre beach-access lot at 3910 Estero Boulevard, across the boulevard from the foot of the two streets.

What listings describe

2026 listing records describe the bay park with a large tiki hut, tables and chairs and a T-dock for fishing, and the beach lot with a Key West style gazebo, tables and chairs and room for golf carts and bikes. Another listing record mentions boat slips and a 40 foot dock at the park. An earlier listing said the beach gazebo was being built back after the storm. All of these are listing claims, unverified; ask the association what stands on each tract today and whether owners may keep a boat at the park.

The beach

The beach lot gives interior owners a short walk to the Gulf. A rental listing gives about 180 yards from a Gulf Island Drive house to the beach. The four Gulf-front parcels on Estero Boulevard front the beach directly.

The association and fees

The owners' group is Gulf Island Manor HOA on the county roll, with a Fort Myers Beach post office box; listing records call it GIMA. No association budget, covenant or annual report is posted publicly, so the dues, the rules and whether membership is required all come from listing records until you see the documents.

Dues

Listing records put the dues at $500 a year, said to cover management and a reserve fund. One listing record calls the dues voluntary, and another lists the HOA field as "No" while still showing $500. Whether membership and dues are mandatory under recorded covenants is unverified; ask for the documents and an estoppel letter before you sign.

No CDD

No community development district or master association sits above Gulf Island Manor. Parcels pay Town of Fort Myers Beach and Fort Myers Beach Fire District taxes. This is not a condominium, so the state condominium milestone and reserve study laws do not apply to these single-family homes.

Is Gulf Island Manor in a flood zone?

Yes, all of it. FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer maps the interior lots in Zone AE with a 12 foot base flood elevation at a Mandalay Road point, the bay-front homes in Zone AE at 11 feet, and the Gulf-front parcels in Zone VE, the coastal high-velocity zone, at 14 feet. Across the whole subdivision the layer returns AE areas of 11 to 13 feet and VE areas of 12 to 17 feet. The subdivision is on FIRM panel 12071C0558G, effective November 17, 2022. Ask for the elevation certificate of any home you are weighing.

Building height after the storms

The Town of Fort Myers Beach requires the lowest floor of a new or substantially damaged home to sit at least one foot above the base flood elevation, and in V zones the bottom of the lowest structural member. That means about 12 to 14 feet on the interior and bay lots and 15 feet or more on the Gulf lots; confirm the figure for the lot.

Coastal High Hazard Area and evacuation

Lee County maps Estero Island inside its Coastal High Hazard Area, and its evacuation layer puts Gulf Island Manor in evacuation zone A, which is ordered out first. Zones A and B were told to leave on October 7, 2024, ahead of Hurricane Milton.

The 50 percent rule

Most homes here were built before the first flood maps. The Town applies a 50 percent rule: once permitted work over a rolling five years adds up to half the structure's value, the home must be brought up to current flood rules. Ask for the permit history of an older home before you plan a renovation.

Insurance

Mortgage lenders require flood coverage in Zones AE and VE. Citizens now requires flood insurance on its homeowner policies in these zones, and does not write a home whose replacement cost is $700,000 or more. Fort Myers Beach policies written or renewed from April 1, 2026 carry a 25 percent NFIP discount under the Town's Community Rating System Class 5; confirm it on your quote.

How did Hurricane Ian affect Gulf Island Manor?

On September 28, 2022, Hurricane Ian pushed 10 to 15 feet of water above ground across Fort Myers Beach, according to the National Hurricane Center. The U.S. Geological Survey recorded a high-water mark of 12.4 feet (NAVD88) at Coconut Drive, about 200 meters east of the bay-front homes, and 13.8 feet on Connecticut Street, about half a kilometer northwest. No news report we found names Gulf Island Manor, but the county roll shows what changed.

What the record shows

The 2026 roll codes 19 parcels vacant, and five of them still carry an in-ground pool, at addresses where homes once stood. The aerial at the top of this page, taken four months after the storm, shows damaged and blue-tarped roofs across the island. Since then four new homes have entered the roll, three on Gulf Island Drive in 2025 and one on Bayside Road in 2026. Which homes the Town found substantially damaged was not checked for this page, so ask the Town about any address you are weighing.

Helene and Milton

Helene and Milton both sent surge over Estero Island in 2024; no public report ties specific damage in Gulf Island Manor to either one.

What to ask

Ask the seller for the repair or rebuild permits since 2022, the insurance claim history, any substantial damage letter from the Town and the elevation certificate.

Short-term rentals in Gulf Island Manor

Homes here can be rented short term under Town rules. Each short-term rental on the island must be registered with the Town of Fort Myers Beach every year; for 2027 the fee is $400 per unit, and filing runs November 15 to December 15, 2026. The Town's zoning sets minimum stays, so check the rule for the lot. At least one Gulf Island Drive home is marketed as a vacation rental. Any association rule on leasing is unverified, because the covenants are not posted online.

What does it cost to own a Gulf Island Manor home?

The yearly cost of a Gulf Island Manor home is property tax at the Town of Fort Myers Beach rate, flood and wind insurance, the association dues and, if you rent, Town registration, management and rental taxes. On an older home below the flood elevation, insurance can be the largest of these, so price it early.

Property tax

Parcels here sit in Lee County taxing district 032, the Town of Fort Myers Beach, with a 2026 applied rate of 13.3108 mills. On the $696,060 median just value of the single-family parcels, that is about $9,265 a year before non-ad valorem charges; on a $1,500,000 assessed value it would be about $19,966. Both are illustrations, not bills. 16 of the 61 parcels carry a homestead exemption, so a neighbor's bill can be far lower than yours will be after a sale.

Dues and insurance

Add the association dues ($500 a year on listing records, unverified) and flood and wind premiums, which depend on the home's elevation and age. Get quotes on the address before an offer.

Owners and homestead share

The 2026 roll shows 16 of the 61 Gulf Island Manor parcels with a homestead exemption, so most parcels here are second homes, rentals or lots rather than full-time residences. Owner mailing addresses: 28 of the 61 are in Florida and the rest are elsewhere, in other states or abroad.

Schools near Gulf Island Manor

Lee County's 2026 to 2027 proximity zones place Gulf Island Manor in Elementary Zone T, Middle Zone MM and High School South Zone 4. Zone T's school, Fort Myers Beach Elementary, closed after the 2024 storms, and students are bused to Heights Elementary in Fort Myers; in May 2026 the School Board voted to give the campus to the Town for a charter school. Middle Zone MM includes Cypress Lake Middle and Lexington Middle. The School District of Lee County makes the final assignment by street address.

Where is Gulf Island Manor?

Gulf Island Manor is mid-island on Estero Island, about 2.2 road miles southeast of Times Square and the pier site, between the Hercules Drive and Coconut Drive neighborhoods. The two streets run from Estero Boulevard to Bayside Road and the back bay.

Drive times

Destination Distance Time without traffic
Gulf beach, association beach lot about 180 yards on foot 2 to 4 minutes on foot
Times Square and the pier site about 2.2 mi about 7 min
Santini Marina Plaza and Publix about 3.3 mi about 10 min
Lovers Key State Park about 5.4 mi about 14 min
HealthPark Medical Center about 9.9 mi about 22 min
Bonita Beach Park about 10.0 mi about 23 min
Downtown Fort Myers about 16.9 mi about 34 min
Coconut Point about 17.8 mi about 36 min
Southwest Florida International Airport about 19.6 mi about 38 min
Downtown Naples about 25.5 mi about 50 min

Source: public routing engine without traffic, from the center of the subdivision on the county roll. Estero Boulevard is a two-lane island road, and season traffic from January to April adds time.

Rebuilding of the Fort Myers Beach pier was under way in September 2026, and Margaritaville Beach Resort opened near Times Square in December 2023.

Gulf Island Manor and nearby choices

Choice What sets it apart from Gulf Island Manor
Gulf View Plaza, Coconut Drive Next door to the southeast: about 34 residential parcels, a few on the Gulf and bay; no shared beach lot and bay park found
Hercules Park, Hercules Drive Next door on the same block: a separate small plat
Leilani Nearby: about 42 parcels in the same mid-island bay-side setting
Case's Subdivision To the northwest near the Mound House: Gulf-front lots and bay-side streets on an older island plat
Zimmers Addition to Shell Mound Park Canal homes on Donora and Shell Mound Boulevard
Other Fort Myers Beach neighborhoods Single-family streets and condominiums of every era along Estero Boulevard

What Gulf Island Manor offers a buyer, and what it does not

It offers a single-family lot on Estero Island without a condominium, a short walk to a shared beach lot, a shared bay park, and recorded prices of $575,000 to $1,500,000 since 2023. It does not offer a private boat dock on an interior lot, a gate, golf or low flood exposure.

What should you check before you make an offer in Gulf Island Manor?

Gulf Island Manor is easy to read on the roll, because the lots are similar in size, but the details that decide a deal are the home's age and elevation, its storm repair record, the flood rating and what the association actually requires. Here is the checklist we use with buyers on these streets.

For any home

  • The county record, to confirm the legal reads Gulf Island Manor and to see the year built, heated area and any pool or seawall.
  • Recorded sales on the two streets over 24 and 60 months and 10 years, from the sales tables on this page.
  • The seller's flood disclosure, the elevation certificate and flood and wind quotes on the address.

For an older home

  • The permit history since 2022 and any Town substantial damage letter.
  • How close past work comes to the Town's 50 percent rule before you plan a renovation.

For a lot

  • The base flood elevation for the lot, the Town's setback and height rules for RS or RS-1 zoning, and the cost of building raised.
  • Whether an old pool or slab remains on the lot and what removing it costs.

For the association

  • The covenants, whether dues are mandatory, and an estoppel letter.
  • Who may use the bay park dock and the beach lot, and any boat slip rules.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Gulf Island Manor specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows homes and lots in Gulf Island Manor, and our Bonita Springs and Fort Myers offices are a short drive from the island. We tracked every recorded sale on Gulf Island Drive, Mandalay Road and the Gulf Island Manor parcels on Bayside Road and Estero Boulevard against the county roll and the flood map, and we can pull that record for any address you are weighing.

★★★★★ "Marc has been a great help in securing a great price for our home during its build phase. Negotiated a much better deal from the builder."

Verified Google review. Michael Gatz, a new-construction buyer, on working with Marc Comisar of Domain Realty Group.

Talk to our team about a Gulf Island Manor home

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816, tell us whether you want a finished home or a lot, and your price range, and an agent will send matching listings, recent sales on the two streets and the flood, insurance and association questions for the address. Or browse current listings yourself, or step back to all Fort Myers Beach homes for sale.

Thinking of selling a home in Gulf Island Manor?

Buyers here compare a home by its age, its elevation and its repair record, so a home priced against recorded sales on the two streets sells faster than one priced against the roll value. For a number on your home, request a Fort Myers Beach home valuation from McGreevy and Comisar.

Frequently Asked Questions about Gulf Island Manor homes for sale

Where is Gulf Island Manor?

Mid-island on Estero Island, Fort Myers Beach 33931, on Gulf Island Drive and Mandalay Road between Estero Boulevard and Bayside Road, about 2.2 road miles southeast of Times Square.

Is Gulf Island Manor in the Town of Fort Myers Beach?

Yes. Every parcel is in the Town of Fort Myers Beach taxing district and the Fort Myers Beach Fire District.

How many homes are in Gulf Island Manor?

The 2026 roll carries 59 residential parcels: 40 coded single-family and 19 coded vacant, plus two association tracts.

Is Gulf Island Manor a condo?

No. It is a recorded single-family subdivision, Plat Book 8, Page 68.

When was Gulf Island Manor built?

The plat dates from about the 1940s, unverified. Homes on the roll date from 1925 to 2024, and four new homes were added in 2025 and 2026.

How big are the homes?

729 to 3,554 square feet of heated area on the roll, with a median of 1,313. Most are one story with two or three bedrooms.

What is the median price in Gulf Island Manor?

$690,000 across 11 qualified sales of homes and lots in the 60 months to October 21, 2026.

What is the most a home there has sold for?

$1,500,000, twice: a 2018 home on Gulf Island Drive in February 2025 and a bay-front home on Bayside Road in June 2019. A Gulf-front parcel sold for $1,995,000 in October 2018.

What do lots sell for?

Interior lots recorded qualified sales of $575,000 to $690,000 from 2023 to 2025.

What is the price per square foot?

The 2015 and 2018 homes sold at about $730 a square foot in 2025; older cottages sold at $592 to $641 a square foot from 2022 to 2025.

Does Gulf Island Manor have an HOA?

Yes. Gulf Island Manor HOA owns the bay park and beach lot. Listing records put dues at $500 a year, and one calls them voluntary; confirm in the documents.

Does Gulf Island Manor have beach access?

Yes. The association owns a beach-access lot at 3910 Estero Boulevard, across the road from the two streets.

Is there a dock or boat ramp?

Listing records describe a T-dock at the association's bay park, and one mentions boat slips. The roll shows no private boat dock on any parcel; ask the association about boat use.

Are the homes on the water?

Only some. Four bay-front homes and one bay lot sit on the back bay, and four Gulf-front parcels front the beach. The other lots are interior.

Is Gulf Island Manor gated?

No. A 2026 listing record describes it as non-gated.

Is there a CDD?

No community development district was found.

Is Gulf Island Manor in a flood zone?

Yes. Interior and bay lots are in Zone AE with base flood elevations of 11 to 13 feet, and the Gulf-front parcels are in Zone VE at 14 feet or more, on panel 12071C0558G.

What evacuation zone is it in?

Lee County evacuation zone A.

Was Gulf Island Manor damaged by Hurricane Ian?

Yes, like the rest of Estero Island. 19 parcels are vacant on the 2026 roll, five of them with old pools, and four new homes have been built since.

What is the 50 percent rule?

The Town requires a home to be brought up to current flood rules once permitted work over five years reaches half the structure's value.

Can I rent my Gulf Island Manor home short term?

Yes, with yearly Town registration, $400 per unit for 2027, and the Town's minimum stay rules.

What property taxes will I pay?

The 2026 Town of Fort Myers Beach district rate is 13.3108 mills, about $9,265 a year on the $696,060 median single-family roll value, before non-ad valorem charges and exemptions.

What schools serve Gulf Island Manor?

Lee County's 2026 to 2027 proximity plan lists Elementary Zone T, Middle Zone MM and High School South Zone 4.

How far is the beach?

A rental listing gives about 180 yards on foot from a Gulf Island Drive house to the beach, and the association's beach lot is across Estero Boulevard from the two streets.

How many owners have a homestead exemption?

16 of the 61 parcels on the 2026 roll.

What streets are in Gulf Island Manor?

Gulf Island Drive and Mandalay Road, plus Gulf Island Manor parcels on Bayside Road, Estero Boulevard and one on Hercules Drive.

Who issues building permits?

The Town of Fort Myers Beach.

What ZIP code is Gulf Island Manor?

ZIP 33931, Fort Myers Beach.

How far is the airport?

About 19.6 miles, about 38 minutes to Southwest Florida International Airport without traffic.

Where do I see Gulf Island Manor homes for sale?

Our team posts every active listing on our current listings search and sends new Gulf Island Manor listings as they come on the market. Reach us at 239-441-2816 or through the contact page to start one.

About Domain Realty Group around Fort Myers Beach

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team working Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, with offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. The team is led by Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671), who bring over 45 years of combined direct experience between them.

Reach any of our agents through our agents page, read our client reviews or see our team's story. We tracked every recorded sale in Gulf Island Manor on the county roll to build this page.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816 info@domainrealtygroup.com

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Fort Myers Beach homes for sale, Fort Myers homes for sale, Bonita Beach and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to one of the sources below. No real estate portal or other brokerage is linked, by policy; association dues, amenities, asking prices and rental claims come from listing records and are labeled unverified where they appear. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll and sale files (sales through October 21, 2026; newest qualified sale in the subdivision April 1, 2025). Flood, evacuation, school and drive figures come from public GIS layers and a public routing engine queried November 11 and 21, 2026.

Figures on this page

Town rules, flood and storms

Schools, places and news

County and state records

More county, town and state records