Opens in a new tab
Back to Fort Myers Beach

Fort Myers Beach · Florida · 33931

Case's Subdivision Homes for Sale, Fort Myers Beach, FL

Case's Subdivision homes for sale on the first plat recorded on Estero Island, in the Town of Fort Myers Beach: Gulf-front lots on Estero Boulevard and four bay-side streets around the Mound House, with 1970s cottages, duplexes, large new elevated homes and lots to build on. Recorded sales, lot prices, flood zones, Hurricane Ian history and what to check before an offer. Updated November 2026.

Aerial view of Case's Subdivision in Fort Myers Beach, with its Lee County parcels outlined from the Gulf beach across Estero Boulevard to the bay-side streets

Case's Subdivision homes for sale are spread along the middle of Estero Island in the Town of Fort Myers Beach, on Gulf-front lots on the even-numbered side of Estero Boulevard and on four short bay-side streets: Connecticut Street, Anchorage Street, Andre Mar Drive and Bay Mar Drive. Listing feeds shorten the name to "Cases." It is the island's first recorded plat, Lee County Plat Book 1, Pages 58 and 59, laid out in 1911 by H.C. Case. Today it is a legal label, not a marketed community: 152 parcels on the county roll, with no association, gate or entrance sign.

Lee County recorded 4 qualified home sales here in the 12 months to October 21, 2026, from $699,000 to $6,900,000, at a $777,051 median, plus 4 qualified vacant lot sales. This page covers those sales, the lots, the flood zones, Hurricane Ian, taxes and what to check before an offer, for buyers comparing Fort Myers Beach homes for sale.

Updated November 2026. Data updated: November 2026.

Key takeaways for Case's Subdivision buyers

  • 152 Lee County parcels carry a Case's legal: 64 single-family, 31 small multifamily (mostly duplexes), 45 vacant residential and 12 other uses, among them the Mound House museum and a church.
  • Two very different markets share the name: 39 Gulf-side parcels on Estero Boulevard, where the homes are large and mostly built since 2014, and bay-side streets of 1960s and 1970s cottages and duplexes.
  • 4 qualified home sales in the 12 months to October 21, 2026, at a $777,051 median; 24 home sales over 60 months at a $905,000 median.
  • 45 parcels are vacant residential land on the October 2026 roll, so lot sales are as common here as home sales.
  • FEMA puts all 39 Gulf-side parcels in Zone VE at a 14 foot base flood elevation; most bay-side parcels test Zone AE at 11 to 13 feet.
  • No homeowners association, CDD, gate or clubhouse was found.

Case's Subdivision homes for sale right now

Few homes in Case's Subdivision are listed at any one time, and many listings here are lots. The county file holds 9 qualified transfers in the last 12 months across 152 parcels: 4 homes, 4 vacant lots and one vacant institutional tract. Price depends mostly on which side of Estero Boulevard a parcel sits.

Price band, last 60 months Qualified home sales
Under $1,000,000 13
$1,000,000 to $2,999,999 8
$3,000,000 or more 3

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales of improved parcels with a Case's Subdivision legal, October 22, 2021 to October 21, 2026.

To see what is on the market today, search current listings and filter for Fort Myers Beach, or ask us for a saved search on these streets. Some feeds file nearby parcels on other plats under "Cases," so check the legal description on every address.

Ready to tour homes in Case's Subdivision?

Tell us whether you want a cottage, a duplex, a Gulf-front house or a lot, and we will send every matching listing with the recorded sales around it. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do homes in Case's Subdivision sell for?

Homes here sold at a $777,051 median in the 12 months to October 21, 2026, the end of the county sale file. The newest qualified home sale was February 21, 2026, and the newest qualified sale of any kind, a lot, was April 7, 2026. The table counts only sales of improved parcels that Lee County marks as qualified.

Window to October 21, 2026 Qualified home sales Median sold Low High Median per sq ft
12 months 4 $777,051 $699,000 $6,900,000 $741
24 months 9 $779,101 $699,000 $6,900,000 $713
60 months 24 $905,000 $675,000 $6,900,000 $710

Data updated: November 2026. Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and sale files (sales through October 21, 2026), qualified sales over $1,000. Price per square foot is the sale price divided by the roll's heated area.

Home sales since Hurricane Ian

Month Street Built Heated sq ft Sale price
April 2023 Connecticut Street 1975 1,800 $1,100,000
May 2023 Anchorage Street 1985 1,536 $1,735,000
July 2023 Bay Mar Drive 1972 1,008 $725,000
August 2023 Estero Boulevard, Gulf side 2014 4,205 $6,750,000
September 2023 Anchorage Street, duplex 1979 4,652 $1,825,000
November 2024 Andre Mar Drive 1969 1,088 $768,000
March 2025 Connecticut Street 1985 1,930 $820,000
May 2025 Connecticut Street 1967 1,461 $1,200,000
May 2025 Anchorage Street 2021 2,725 $2,350,000
August 2025 Connecticut Street 1967 1,316 $699,000
November 2025 Bay Mar Drive 1972 1,008 $775,000
November 2025 Bay Mar Drive 1973 1,236 $699,000
December 2025 Estero Boulevard, Gulf side 2017 3,955 $6,900,000
February 2026 Andre Mar Drive 1972 1,092 $779,101

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales and parcel roll. House numbers are left off.

The top sale in the county file is $6,900,000 for a 2017 Gulf-front home in December 2025. On the bay-side streets, original cottages of about 1,000 to 1,500 square feet have traded between $699,000 and $1,200,000 since the storm. The same Bay Mar Drive cottage sold for $725,000 in July 2023 and $775,000 in November 2025.

Lot sales since Hurricane Ian

Vacant land is a large share of this market. Gulf-front lots on Estero Boulevard recorded qualified sales of $2,900,000 to $3,100,000 from 2023 to January 2026, and a commercially coded Gulf-front parcel sold for $4,650,000 in February 2024. Bay-side lots on Anchorage Street, Andre Mar Drive and Bay Mar Drive sold for $425,000 to $925,000, with the four most recent, from July 2025 to April 2026, between $425,000 and $550,000.

Sales by calendar year

Year Qualified home sales Median Low High
2018 8 $1,295,000 $353,000 $4,750,000
2019 7 $600,000 $426,000 $4,550,000
2020 14 $613,000 $400,000 $3,625,000
2021 14 $805,000 $475,000 $2,500,000
2022 6 $1,145,000 $675,000 $4,625,000
2023 5 $1,735,000 $725,000 $6,750,000
2024 1 $768,000 $768,000 $768,000
2025 7 $820,000 $699,000 $6,900,000
2026, partial 1 $779,101 $779,101 $779,101

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales of improved parcels. Medians swing with the mix of Gulf-front and bay-side sales in a year.

Qualified sales in the county file go back to 1972. The yearly median depends on how many Gulf-front homes closed that year, so compare a bay-side cottage only with bay-side sales.

What is Case's Subdivision? The first plat on Estero Island

The Estero Island Historic Society writes that H.C. Case platted the first subdivision on the island in 1911, on part of the Robert Gilbert homestead, starting at Connecticut Street and running about three quarters of a mile both north and south. The Town credits William Case with the first subdivision and the island's cottage rental business; whether the two are the same man is unresolved. The plat is recorded at Lee County Plat Book 1, Page 58, for the bay-side and numbered lots, and Page 59, for Gulf lots 1 to 26. A separate "Cases Sub of Blk 50" is recorded at Plat Book 4, Page 22.

Why the name is "Cases" in listings

County legal descriptions write the name several ways: CASES SUBD, CASE'S SUBD, CASE SUBD and CASE S/D. Listing feeds use "Cases" or "Case Subdivision." No one markets it as a neighborhood, so the name works as a location tag on a listing rather than a brand.

The pieces inside the plat

The big numbered lots were later divided by deed and by unrecorded resubdivisions, so the streets carry their own names in the legals.

Piece Streets Parcels
Gulf lots and Estero Boulevard frontage Estero Boulevard, about 2943 to 3880, plus 4254 to 4300 46
Anchorage Estates, in Lot 53 Anchorage Street 29
Andre-Mar, in Lot 52 Andre Mar Drive 28
Bay Mar, in Lot 55 Bay Mar Drive 27
Lot 51, Cocos Park and Lot 46 Connecticut Street 20
Edge parcels Bay Road and Saint Peters Drive 2

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, October 2026 extract.

Jurisdiction

All 152 parcels are in the Town of Fort Myers Beach taxing district and the Fort Myers Beach Fire District, with a Fort Myers Beach site address. Zoning is mostly RS-1 (66 parcels) and the Town's TFC-2 code (59), with RC, RS, IN, CB and other codes on the rest.

The Mound House

The Town-owned Mound House at 451 Connecticut Street stands on plat Lot 46, on a Calusa shell mound. The house is listed on the National Register of Historic Places, and the roll dates the building to 1906, the oldest in the plat. The Town says the Case family first placed a house on the mound in 1906. Its parcel is the one roll point here that FEMA maps in Zone X, on the high ground of the mound.

The homes and lots

Case's Subdivision holds 95 homes on the roll: 64 single-family and 31 small multifamily parcels, most of them duplexes. Heated area runs from 840 to 9,268 square feet, with a median of about 1,726. The stock splits sharply by side of the road.

Bay-side streets

The 80 homes on the side streets have a median of about 1,493 square feet and a median build year of 1974. Most are one-story concrete-block cottages and duplexes built at ground level. Anchorage Street is mostly duplexes; Andre Mar Drive and Bay Mar Drive are mostly single-family cottages.

Gulf-front homes

The 14 homes on the Gulf side of Estero Boulevard, 11 single-family and 3 multi-unit, have a median of about 5,664 square feet, and most were built from 2014 on. They include big multi-unit rental homes built in 2014 and 2021, from 6,774 to 9,268 square feet with 8 to 10 bedrooms.

Age of the buildings

Decade built Buildings
Before 1950 2
1950s 3
1960s 13
1970s 39
1980s 14
1990s 7
2000s 2
2010s 6
2020s 5

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, October 2026 extract (91 dated buildings).

65 of the dated buildings went up before 1984, and 11 were built in 2014 or later. The newest on the roll is a 2024 home on Anchorage Street.

Vacant land

The roll codes 45 parcels as vacant residential: 22 on the Gulf side of Estero Boulevard, 21 on the bay-side streets and 2 on the bay side of Estero Boulevard. Several sold as homes before Hurricane Ian, which points to houses removed since; check the permit history on any lot. The median Gulf-side parcel is about 0.282 acres and the median bay-side parcel about 0.187 acres.

Roll values

The 2026 roll just value of the 95 homes has a median of $753,890, from $284,117 to $6,189,938. Gulf-side homes have a median of $3,769,111 and bay-side street homes $708,822. Vacant residential parcels run $305,628 to $2,598,955.

Is Case's Subdivision in a flood zone?

Yes. FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer, tested at each of the 152 roll points, puts 104 in Zone AE and 47 in Zone VE, with one in Zone X at the Mound House. All 39 Gulf-side Estero Boulevard parcels test Zone VE with a base flood elevation of 14 feet, as do 8 parcels on the bay side of the boulevard. Elsewhere on the bay side, 77 points test AE at 11 feet, 22 at 12 feet and 5 at 13 feet. Every point sits on FIRM panel 12071C0558G, effective November 17, 2022. The elevation certificate and the FEMA address lookup decide the rating for any one house.

Coastal High Hazard Area and evacuation

151 of the 152 parcels are inside Lee County's Coastal High Hazard Area; the Mound House parcel is the exception. The whole plat is in Lee County evacuation zone A, storm surge zone 1, the first zone ordered to leave.

The 50 percent rule

The Town requires full flood compliance, in practice elevating or rebuilding, when improvements or repairs reach 50 percent of a building's value, counting permits from the past five years. With 65 buildings dating from before 1984, this rule shapes nearly every bay-side resale.

Flood insurance

Fort Myers Beach regained a Community Rating System Class 5 rating, worth a 25 percent NFIP discount for most policies issued or renewed on or after April 1, 2026, per WGCU. A ground-level cottage in AE and a Gulf-front home in VE price very differently, so get quotes by address.

How did Hurricane Ian affect Case's Subdivision?

Hurricane Ian struck on September 28, 2022, with a surge over the island reported at up to about 18 feet, and the Army Corps listed more than 1,000 Fort Myers Beach homes and apartments as substantially damaged. No street-level damage list for this plat was published.

What the record shows

Today 45 parcels are vacant residential land, and several of them sold as homes before the storm, among them Gulf-front and Andre Mar Drive parcels. New elevated homes went up afterward, including the 2024 home on Anchorage Street. The Mound House survived on its mound, though flooding closed its underground exhibit.

What to ask

Ask the seller for the repair and permit history since 2022, any substantial damage determination, the insurance claim outcome and the elevation certificate.

What does it cost to own a home in Case's Subdivision?

The yearly cost here is property tax at the Town rate, homeowners and flood insurance, and rental registration and taxes if you rent. No association fee was found, so the main swing between two parcels is insurance, which depends on the flood zone, the elevation and the age of the building.

Property tax

The 2026 total millage for the Town of Fort Myers Beach district is 13.3108 mills. At the $777,051 12-month median, that is about $10,343 a year before non-ad valorem charges, if the assessed value equaled the price; it is an illustration, not a bill. 32 of the 95 homes carry a homestead exemption on the 2026 roll.

No HOA or CDD

No homeowners association appears in the county legals, and the plat has no CDD. A 2026 listing on Andre Mar Drive reported no HOA. Some duplexes or shared drives may have private agreements, so read the deed and title commitment.

Short-term rentals

Every short-term rental in the Town must register each year with the Town. Minimum stays depend on zoning, and which rule applies to a given parcel here is unverified; confirm with the Town before an offer that depends on rental income.

Owners and homestead share

The 2026 roll shows 32 of the 95 homes with a homestead exemption, so most homes here are second homes, rentals or investment property on the tax roll. Owner mailing addresses across all 152 parcels: 93 in Florida, 57 in other states and 2 outside the United States.

Schools near Case's Subdivision

Fort Myers Beach Elementary, on Oak Street, is the island's public school, about 0.77 miles from the middle of the plat in a straight line. Lee County's 2026 to 2027 proximity zones place the plat in Elementary Zone T, Middle Zone MM and High School South Zone 4. Lexington Middle is about 3.84 miles away and Cypress Lake High about 6.91 miles. Confirm assignment by address with the School District of Lee County.

Where is Case's Subdivision?

The plat sits mid-island, south of Times Square and the pier, with the Mound House at the bay end of Connecticut Street. Estero Boulevard, the island's only through road, splits it into the Gulf-front lots and the bay-side streets, and the Town's numbered beach accesses sit a short walk away.

Distances

Place Straight-line distance
Estero Island Beach Access 22, Estero Boulevard 0.21 mi
Estero Island Beach Access 21, Hercules Drive 0.30 mi
Newton Beach Park 0.57 mi
Fort Myers Beach Elementary, Oak Street 0.77 mi
Bay Oaks Recreation Center 0.93 mi
Lee Health HealthPark Hospital emergency room 4.52 mi
Coconut Point, Estero 7.86 mi
Southwest Florida International Airport terminal 12.48 mi

Source: Lee County GIS park, hospital and school layers, measured from the middle of the Case's roll points. Road distances are longer.

Drive times

A public routing engine, without traffic, puts the Times Square and pier area about 6 minutes away, HealthPark Medical Center about 14 minutes, downtown Fort Myers about 34 minutes and Southwest Florida International Airport about 37 minutes. Season traffic is slower.

Case's Subdivision and nearby choices

Choice How it differs
Lynn's Highland Park and Hyde Park Neighboring mid-island plats with the same no-association mix; some listings file them under Cases
Shell Mound Park A bay-side plat near the Mound House
El Sol A canal subdivision farther south with seawalls and docks, which most Case's parcels lack
Gulf-front condominiums on Estero Boulevard Association buildings with milestone and reserve rules that fee-simple lots avoid

What the plat offers, and what it does not

It offers fee-simple Gulf-front lots, walkable bay-side streets a few blocks from the beach and no association fee. It does not offer amenities, a gate, canal frontage on most parcels or low flood exposure.

What should you check before you make an offer in Case's Subdivision?

A parcel in Case's Subdivision is easy to find on a map, but what decides a deal is the side of Estero Boulevard, the building's elevation, its permit history and the insurance quotes. These are the documents and questions we work through with a buyer here.

For any parcel

  • The county record, to confirm the legal reads Case's Subdivision, plus the build year and heated area.
  • Recorded sales on the same side of Estero Boulevard, from the tables above.
  • The flood disclosure, the elevation certificate and flood and wind quotes by address.

For a home or a lot

  • Permits from the past five years and how close the house is to the 50 percent limit.
  • For a lot, the zoning, setbacks and the base flood elevation you would build to.
  • For a duplex, any shared wall, drive or party agreement.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Case's Subdivision specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows homes and lots in Case's Subdivision, and our Fort Myers office on College Parkway is the closest of our offices to Estero Island. We tracked every recorded sale on this plat against the county roll and the flood map to build this page.

★★★★★ "Lindsey consistently prioritized our customer experience. She was attentive, responsive, and made sure we felt well taken care of."

Verified Google review. T N, a buyer, on working with Lindsey Moffat-Ridge.

Talk to our team about a home in Case's Subdivision

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816, tell us the street and whether you want a home or a lot, and an agent will send matching listings, recent sales nearby and the flood and permit questions for the address. You can also search current listings any time, or start from all Fort Myers Beach homes for sale.

Thinking of selling in Case's Subdivision?

Buyers here price a parcel by its side of Estero Boulevard, its elevation and its condition, so a price set against recorded sales of similar parcels works better than the plat median. To see what yours is worth, start with a Fort Myers Beach home valuation from McGreevy and Comisar.

Frequently Asked Questions about Case's Subdivision homes for sale

Where is Case's Subdivision in Fort Myers Beach?

Mid Estero Island, on Gulf-front Estero Boulevard lots and on Connecticut Street, Anchorage Street, Andre Mar Drive and Bay Mar Drive on the bay side.

Is "Cases" the same as Case's Subdivision?

Yes. Listing feeds shorten the recorded plat name, Case's Subdivision, to "Cases."

When was it platted?

The Estero Island Historic Society dates the plat to 1911. It is recorded at Lee County Plat Book 1, Pages 58 and 59.

How many parcels are in Case's Subdivision?

152 on the county roll: 64 single-family, 31 small multifamily, 45 vacant residential and 12 other uses.

What is the median home price?

$777,051 on 4 qualified home sales in the 12 months to October 21, 2026, and $905,000 on 24 sales over 60 months.

What is the most a home there has sold for?

$6,900,000, a 2017 Gulf-front home, in December 2025.

What do lots sell for?

Recent bay-side lots sold for $425,000 to $550,000, and Gulf-front lots for $2,900,000 to $3,100,000 since 2023.

What is the price per square foot?

About $741 at the median over the last 12 months and $710 over 60 months.

Is it in the Town of Fort Myers Beach?

Yes. All 152 parcels are in the Town of Fort Myers Beach taxing district.

Does Case's Subdivision have an HOA?

None was found in the county legals.

Is there a CDD?

No.

Is it gated?

No. There is no gate, clubhouse or pool.

What flood zone is it in?

Gulf-side parcels test Zone VE at 14 feet; most bay-side parcels test Zone AE at 11 to 13 feet, on panel 12071C0558G.

What evacuation zone is it in?

Lee County evacuation zone A, storm surge zone 1.

Was it damaged by Hurricane Ian?

Ian's surge crossed the whole island. 45 parcels are vacant land today, and several of them were homes before the storm.

What is the 50 percent rule?

The Town requires a building to meet current flood rules when repairs or improvements reach 50 percent of its value, counting five years of permits.

Are the homes on the water?

The Gulf-front lots are on the beach. The roll codes 39 parcels Gulf, 7 bay and 7 canal; most bay-side street parcels have no water frontage coded.

How old are the homes?

65 of the 91 dated buildings predate 1984; 11 were built in 2014 or later.

How big are the homes?

From 840 to 9,268 square feet of heated area, with a median of about 1,726.

Are there duplexes?

Yes. 31 parcels are coded small multifamily, mostly duplexes on Anchorage Street.

What property taxes will I pay?

The 2026 Town district rate is 13.3108 mills, about $10,343 a year on a $777,051 assessed value, before non-ad valorem charges and exemptions.

What is the Mound House?

A Town-owned museum on a Calusa shell mound at 451 Connecticut Street, on plat Lot 46, listed on the National Register.

What schools serve the plat?

Fort Myers Beach Elementary is the island's public school, about 0.77 miles away. Confirm assignment with the School District of Lee County.

How far is the beach?

The Gulf-front lots are on it. From the middle of the plat, Beach Access 22 is about 0.21 miles in a straight line.

How many owners have a homestead exemption?

32 of the 95 homes on the 2026 roll.

What ZIP code is it?

ZIP 33931, Fort Myers Beach.

Is there new construction in Case's Subdivision?

Yes, one home at a time. 11 buildings date from 2014 or later, the newest a 2024 home on Anchorage Street, and 45 parcels are vacant land.

Is the Mound House in Case's Subdivision?

Yes. It sits on plat Lot 46 at 451 Connecticut Street, and its parcel is the only one in the plat that FEMA maps in Zone X.

Do any homes have docks or seawalls?

A few. The roll codes a seawall on 13 parcels and a boat dock on 4.

Where do I see Case's Subdivision homes for sale?

Our team posts every active listing on our current listings search and sends new listings filed under Cases as they come on the market. Call 239-441-2816 or contact us to set up a search.

About Domain Realty Group around Fort Myers Beach

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team working Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, with offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. The team is led by Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671), who bring over 45 years of combined direct experience between them.

Reach any of our agents through our agents page, read our client reviews or see our team's story. We tracked every qualified sale on the Case's plat in the county roll to build this page.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816 info@domainrealtygroup.com

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Fort Myers Beach homes for sale, Fort Myers homes for sale, Bonita Beach and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to one of the sources below. No real estate portal or other brokerage is linked, by policy. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll and sale files (sales through October 21, 2026). Flood, evacuation, school and distance figures come from public GIS layers queried November 20, 2026. Web sources were read November 11 to 20, 2026.

Figures on this page

History and the Town of Fort Myers Beach

Flood, storms and evacuation

Schools, laws and records

More records and reporting