Opens in a new tab
Back to Sanibel

Sanibel · Florida · 33957

Sanctuary at Wulfert Homes for Sale in Sanibel, FL

Sanctuary at Wulfert homes for sale: 112 houses and villas and 77 condominium units around the private Sanctuary Golf Club course on Wulfert Road, at the bayside west end of Sanibel. Every qualified county sale since November 2024, the plats and condominiums, lot values, club membership terms, flood zone, storm record and the checks to run before you buy. Updated November 2026.

Aerial view of the Sanctuary at Wulfert on the west end of Sanibel, Florida: golf fairways and lakes wind north through mangrove forest, with homes along Wulfert Road and Baltusrol Court marked by small white dots, the clubhouse marked by a white ring, bay water to the north and east and the Blind Pass shore to the west

The Sanctuary at Wulfert is the private golf community on Wulfert Road at the bayside west end of Sanibel, ZIP 33957, in Lee County. The county roll carries 189 residences there: 112 single-family houses and villas and 77 condominium units in five small condominiums, plus 24 vacant homesites, all set along the fairways of The Sanctuary Golf Club. It is one of the island neighborhoods we follow on our Sanibel homes for sale guide.

Aerial view of the Sanctuary at Wulfert on the west end of Sanibel, Florida: golf fairways and lakes wind north through mangrove forest, with homes along Wulfert Road and Baltusrol Court marked by small white dots, the clubhouse marked by a white ring, bay water to the north and east and the Blind Pass shore to the west
The Sanctuary at Wulfert from above. Small white dots mark the 189 residential parcel points and the white ring the Sanctuary Golf Club clubhouse tract, from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll; no parcel outline is drawn. Aerial: USDA NAIP via USGS The National Map (public domain); capture date not confirmed.

Over the 24 months to November 21, 2026 the county recorded 11 qualified house sales here at a $2,300,000 median, 9 qualified condo sales at a $922,500 median and 3 homesite sales. The newest qualified sale in the county file is a homesite at 2438 Wulfert Road, recorded at $300,000 on October 5, 2026.

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group agents. Updated November 2026. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.

A note on the name. The MLS files this community as SANCTUARY AT WULFERT, the county plats call it Sanctuary at Wulfert Point, and most people simply say The Sanctuary. The Sanctuary Golf Club at 2801 Wulfert Road is a separate, member-owned private club that owns the course and clubhouse. Buying a house or condo here does not make you a member, and this page is about the homes. Other Florida communities share the word Sanctuary, in Bonita Bay, Babcock Ranch and elsewhere; none of them is this one.

Key takeaways for Sanctuary at Wulfert buyers

These points come from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale files, the club’s own site, island news reports and federal flood data. Each one is expanded below with its source, and anything we could not confirm is labelled that way.

  • The county roll counts 189 homes: 112 houses and villas on five recorded plats and 77 condo units in Sanctuary Golf Villages I, Heron at the Sanctuary I, II and III, and The Ibis at the Sanctuary.
  • 24 vacant homesites remain, with county just values on the current roll from $207,783 to $300,271.
  • House sales over the 24 months to November 2026 ran $850,000 to $3,150,000; condo sales ran $620,000 to $1,398,000.
  • Three newly built houses on Wulfert Road sold between $2,987,000 and $3,150,000 in 2025 and 2026.
  • Golf membership is separate from ownership and is applied for directly with the club.
  • FEMA sample points across the community fall in flood zone AE with base flood elevations of 7 to 8 feet.
  • The roll records a pool on 110 of the 112 house and villa parcels and codes 100 of them as golf course lots.
  • 86 of the 189 residences carry a homestead exemption, so a little over half are second homes or rentals.

Sanctuary at Wulfert homes for sale right now

With 189 residences and 8 to 18 qualified house and condo sales a year since 2022, the number of Sanctuary at Wulfert homes for sale at any moment is small, and houses, villas and condos rarely list in the same week. Watching the address ranges below is the most reliable way to catch one early.

Where each home type sits

Houses line Wulfert Road from the 2200 block north toward the clubhouse, plus Troon Court and Baltusrol Court. Detached villas sit in two clusters: Phase 2A on Wulfert Road near the clubhouse and Augusta Greens at the north end of Baltusrol Court. The condominiums sit in two groups: Sanctuary Golf Villages I at 2605 to 2675 Wulfert Road, and Heron and Ibis at 5657 to 5789 Baltusrol Court.

What a typical listing looks like

A house listing here is usually a pool home on a golf course lot. The roll flags a pool on 110 of the 112 house and villa parcels, a garage on 111, and records 100 of the 112 as sitting on the golf course. A condo listing is usually a two or three bedroom flat of 2,260 to 2,578 heated square feet in a low-rise building, or a 1,356 square foot two-bedroom at Ibis.

See current listings

To see what is on the market today, search current listings and filter for Sanibel, or ask us to set an alert on Wulfert Road and Baltusrol Court so a new listing reaches you the day it posts.

Ready to tour?

Tell us the home type, the section and whether club membership is part of the plan, and we will send every match with the recorded sales of comparable homes. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do homes in the Sanctuary at Wulfert sell for?

Houses at the Sanctuary at Wulfert recorded a $2,300,000 median over the 24 months to November 21, 2026, across 11 qualified sales from $850,000 to $3,150,000. Condos recorded a $922,500 median across 9 qualified sales from $620,000 to $1,398,000. The figures count only sales the Lee County Property Appraiser marks as qualified on the community’s residential parcels.

Window to November 21, 2026 House sales House median Condo sales Condo median Homesite sales Homesite median
12 months 6 $2,125,000 4 $800,000 2 $280,000
24 months 11 $2,300,000 9 $922,500 3 $300,000
60 months 33 $1,975,000 33 $1,015,000 14 $310,000

Data updated: November 2026. Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and sale files (local sales index built November 18, 2026), qualified sales on Sanctuary at Wulfert parcels in ZIP 33957; newest sale October 5, 2026. A house parcel sale dated before the roll’s build year is counted as a homesite sale.

Over 60 months, house sales ranged from $850,000 to $3,350,000 and condo sales from $620,000 to $1,450,000. The 12 month rows rest on a handful of closings, so read them as single data points rather than a trend.

Every qualified sale since November 2024

Recorded Address Section Type Heated sq ft Built Price Per sq ft
November 15, 2024 2255 Troon Court Wulfert Point Phase I House 5,750 1994 $2,150,000 $374
November 21, 2024 5657 Baltusrol Court 1B Heron at the Sanctuary Condo 2,348 1995 $922,500 $393
November 25, 2024 5675 Baltusrol Court 3B Heron at the Sanctuary II Condo 2,408 1996 $1,398,000 $581
February 12, 2025 5657 Baltusrol Court 3B Heron at the Sanctuary Condo 2,408 1995 $1,350,000 $561
March 11, 2025 2960 Wulfert Road Phase 3 House 7,181 1998 $2,625,000 $366
March 17, 2025 5657 Baltusrol Court 1A Heron at the Sanctuary Condo 2,348 1995 $900,000 $383
March 18, 2025 2933 Wulfert Road Phase 3 Homesite n/a n/a $445,000 n/a
March 20, 2025 5606 Baltusrol Court Phase 2B House 5,975 1996 $2,900,000 $485
May 2, 2025 2276 Wulfert Road Wulfert Point Phase I House 3,708 1993 $850,000 $229
May 16, 2025 2307 Wulfert Road Wulfert Point Phase I New house not yet on roll n/a $3,000,000 n/a
May 19, 2025 5657 Baltusrol Court 3A Heron at the Sanctuary Condo 2,408 1995 $1,000,000 $415
July 1, 2025 2364 Wulfert Road Wulfert Point Phase I House 3,334 1998 $1,548,000 $464
January 5, 2026 2319 Wulfert Road Wulfert Point Phase I House 3,622 2024 $2,987,000 $825
February 5, 2026 5639 Baltusrol Court Phase 2B House 3,618 2017 $2,300,000 $636
February 24, 2026 2453 Wulfert Road Wulfert Point Phase I Homesite n/a n/a $260,000 n/a
March 10, 2026 2969 Wulfert Road Phase 3 House 5,954 1997 $1,950,000 $328
March 16, 2026 2337 Wulfert Road Wulfert Point Phase I House 3,249 1993 $1,400,000 $431
April 21, 2026 2675 Wulfert Road 5 Sanctuary Golf Villages I Condo 2,578 1995 $1,050,000 $407
May 22, 2026 2297 Wulfert Road Wulfert Point Phase I House 4,400 2023 $3,150,000 $716
June 2, 2026 2313 Wulfert Road Wulfert Point Phase I House 2,787 1999 $1,335,000 $479
June 18, 2026 5681 Baltusrol Court 2B Heron at the Sanctuary III Condo 2,408 1998 $700,000 $291
July 1, 2026 2605 Wulfert Road 5 Sanctuary Golf Villages I Condo 2,260 1994 $900,000 $398
July 16, 2026 5775 Baltusrol Court 302 The Ibis at the Sanctuary Condo 1,356 1997 $620,000 $457
October 5, 2026 2438 Wulfert Road Wulfert Point Phase I Homesite n/a n/a $300,000 n/a

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale files, qualified sales; price per square foot is the recorded price divided by the roll’s heated area.

New construction sets the top

The three highest prices in that list are recently built houses on Wulfert Road: 2297 (built 2023) at $3,150,000, 2307 (a builder’s first sale, not yet on the roll) at $3,000,000 and 2319 (built 2024) at $2,987,000. Per heated square foot, 2319 and 2297 recorded $825 and $716, roughly double the $229 to $485 range of the 1990s houses that sold in the same period.

Older houses and condition

1990s houses span a wide band: 2276 Wulfert Road, built 1993, recorded at $850,000, while 2960 Wulfert Road, built 1998 with 7,181 heated square feet, recorded at $2,625,000. Our sources do not record the condition of any house at sale, so a spread like this should be read against an inspection, not assumed to be a bargain.

Condo prices by building

Over the 60 months to November 2026, qualified condo sales ran as follows: Sanctuary Golf Villages I, 15 sales at a $1,100,000 median; Heron at the Sanctuary, 8 sales at $961,250; Heron II, 3 sales at $1,250,000; Heron III, 3 sales at $875,000; and Ibis, 4 sales at $659,500. Ibis units are the smallest on the roll, which explains most of that gap.

Price movement by year

Year House sales House median Condo sales Condo median
2019 13 $1,525,000 5 $736,750
2020 10 $1,276,750 9 $683,000
2021 14 $1,674,598 11 $830,000
2022 7 $2,350,000 10 $947,500
2023 7 $2,500,000 11 $1,100,000
2024 7 $1,900,000 4 $1,086,250
2025 5 $2,625,000 3 $1,000,000
2026, to October 5 6 $2,125,000 4 $800,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale files, qualified sales grouped by recording year.

With five to fourteen house sales a year, one new-construction closing can move a yearly median by hundreds of thousands of dollars. Compare a specific home with the sales of similar age and size in the list above rather than with a single year’s median.

Sales the county left out

Transfers the Property Appraiser marks as unqualified, such as sales between related parties, estate transfers and some foreclosures, are not counted. Our county file shows at least two such transfers in the window, including one on Wulfert Road in April 2026; they are excluded from every figure on this page.

Sanctuary at Wulfert sections, plats and condominiums

The county records the community as five plats and five condominiums, filed between the early 1990s and 1999. Knowing which one a listing sits in tells you its lot size range, its build era and, for condos, which association governs it.

Section Street and numbers Home type Residences Vacant lots Years built (roll) Heated sq ft (roll)
Sanctuary at Wulfert Point Phase I Wulfert Road, Troon Court Single-family 59 13 1993 to 2024 2,614 to 9,191
Phase 2A villas Wulfert Road, 2689 to 2755 Detached villas 12 0 1995 to 2011 2,975 to 4,879
Phase 2B Baltusrol Court, 5603 to 5651 Single-family 11 5 1995 to 2024 3,506 to 7,513
Phase 3 Wulfert Road, 2829 to 2993 Single-family 20 5 1995 to 2023 3,529 to 7,335
Augusta Greens at The Sanctuary Baltusrol Court, 5687 to 5771 Villas 10 1 1999 to 2024 2,916 to 4,445
Sanctuary Golf Villages I Wulfert Road, 2605 to 2675 Condo 36 n/a 1994 to 1995 2,260 to 2,578
Heron at the Sanctuary Baltusrol Court, 5657 to 5663 Condo 12 n/a 1995 2,348 to 2,408
Heron at the Sanctuary II Baltusrol Court, 5669 to 5675 Condo 12 n/a 1996 2,348 to 2,408
Heron at the Sanctuary III 5681 Baltusrol Court Condo 5 n/a 1998 2,348 to 2,408
The Ibis at the Sanctuary Baltusrol Court, 5775 to 5789 Condo 12 n/a 1997 1,356
Total 189 24

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll LCPA2610, November 2026.

Phase I, the largest section

Phase I holds 59 houses and 13 open lots along Wulfert Road and Troon Court, with one parcel addressed on Dinkins Lake Road. Its lots run from 0.177 to 0.731 acres, median 0.378, and its houses are the oldest in the community, the first dating from 1993.

Phase 2B and Phase 3, the larger lots

Phase 2B on Baltusrol Court and Phase 3 at the north end of Wulfert Road carry the biggest lots in the community: Phase 3 runs 0.344 to 1.078 acres with a 0.42 acre median, and Phase 2B tops out at 0.85 acres. Heated area in Phase 3 houses has a median of 5,576 square feet.

The villa sections

The Phase 2A villas sit on lots of about 0.27 to 0.33 acres; Augusta Greens villas on 0.30 to 0.53 acres. Both carry three to five bedrooms on the roll. County just values for villas on the current roll run from $981,486 to $1,991,877.

The condominiums

Sanctuary Golf Villages I has 36 units in buildings of two and three stories. The three Heron condominiums together hold 29 units of 2,348 or 2,408 heated square feet. The Ibis has 12 two-bedroom units of 1,356 square feet in three-story buildings. Across the five, the roll records 47 units in three-story buildings and 29 in two-story buildings.

Unit count disagreements

Some broker pages give different counts: one lists 78 units at Sanctuary Golf Village, against 36 on the roll, and another counts 30 Heron units against 29. We use the county roll throughout. If a listing quotes a different figure, ask which building and declaration it refers to.

Parcels inside that are not homes

The club owns the 137.40 acre golf course parcel and a 5.866 acre clubhouse tract. The master association owns road, buffer and common tracts, including a pump station. The City of Sanibel owns a 6.665 acre tract at 2222 Wulfert Road that the roll’s legal description names as a wastewater treatment plant.

House and villa features on the roll

The 112 houses and villas at the Sanctuary at Wulfert share a profile: one or two stories on a golf lot, a private pool, an attached garage and three or more bedrooms. Here is what the Lee County Property Appraiser records for size, age, pools, golf frontage and value.

Size and bedrooms

Heated area runs from 2,614 to 9,191 square feet with a median of 3,883. Bedrooms run from three to seven. Of the 112, 61 are recorded at two stories.

Build era

Of the houses and villas with a recorded build year, 63 date from the 1990s, 25 from the 2000s, 16 from the 2010s and 7 from 2020 onward. One more, at 2307 Wulfert Road, sold new in May 2025 before it reached the roll.

Pools and garages

The roll shows a pool on 110 of the 112 house and villa parcels and a garage on 111.

Golf frontage

The roll codes 100 of the 112 house and villa parcels as sitting on the golf course. The other 12 carry no golf code. If a fairway view matters, check the parcel’s position on the course map during a tour.

County values

County just values on houses and villas run from $730,855 to $5,002,794 with a median of $1,474,862. Just value is the Property Appraiser’s estimate for tax purposes, not a price, and on this island it often trails recorded sales.

Condominium features on the roll

Condominium units make up 77 of the 189 residences at the Sanctuary at Wulfert, split across five separately declared condominiums on Wulfert Road and Baltusrol Court. Units carry two or three bedrooms, except at Ibis, where every unit is a two-bedroom, and each condominium has its own association and pool parcel.

Golf Villages I

Thirty-six units at 2605 to 2675 Wulfert Road, built 1994 and 1995, from 2,260 to 2,578 heated square feet. The roll lists a pool common element for the condominium at 2601 Wulfert Road.

Heron I, II and III

Twenty-nine units at 5657 to 5681 Baltusrol Court, built 1995, 1996 and 1998. Each of the three condominiums has its own common element parcel on the roll. Heron III shows five residential units on the roll; whether a sixth unit exists was not confirmed.

The Ibis

Twelve units in two buildings at 5775 to 5789 Baltusrol Court, built 1997, each 1,356 heated square feet with two bedrooms. Broker pages describe elevator service in the building.

County values for condos

County just values on the 77 units run from $433,434 to $890,027, with a median of $734,660.

Homesites and building new

Twenty-four lots inside the community are vacant on the roll: 13 in Phase I, 5 in Phase 2B, 5 in Phase 3 and 1 in Augusta Greens. Their county just values on the current roll run from $207,783 to $300,271, with a median of $257,371.

Recent lot sales

Three homesites recorded qualified sales from March 2025 to October 2026: 2933 Wulfert Road at $445,000, 2453 Wulfert Road at $260,000 and 2438 Wulfert Road at $300,000.

What new houses have sold for

The three new houses that sold in 2025 and 2026 recorded between $2,987,000 and $3,150,000. A buyer weighing a lot should price the land, the build, the flood elevation work and the wait together, against those resale figures.

Building rules

Any new house here is built in a FEMA AE zone under City of Sanibel building and flood rules, and under the master association’s architectural review. Ask the association for its design guidelines and review timeline before you buy a lot.

The Sanctuary Golf Club and how membership works

The Sanctuary Golf Club describes itself as a member-owned private club, and sources describe it as the only private club on Sanibel and Captiva. Owning a home here does not make you a member, and membership is not included with a purchase.

Separate from the house

Broker pages for the community, for Sanctuary Golf Village and for Ibis all say membership is separate from property ownership. A buyer who wants to join applies to the club, and the club sets its own availability, requirements and fees.

Fees

The club does not publish its fees online. An undated broker page listed an equity initiation of $150,000 with annual dues of $19,250 plus tax, and a social and sports category at $50,000 with $8,475 in dues. Those figures are not confirmed and may be out of date. Ask the club’s membership office for current figures before you count on any of them.

The course

The course is an 18-hole, par 72 Arthur Hills design with a course rating of 72.7 and a slope of 131, grassed in seashore paspalum, according to a course directory. In a 2010 review visit, Hills called it his “island masterpiece.” The club lists itself as a Certified Audubon Cooperative Sanctuary.

Recognition

The club lists Platinum Clubs of America recognition among the Top 50 Golf Clubs for 2025 to 2026 and Platinum Clubs of the World recognition for 2026 to 2027.

Clubhouse and fitness

The roll records the clubhouse tract with 29,192 heated and 62,291 total square feet in buildings dated 1994 and later. A 2016 construction notice described a new 6,000 square foot fitness facility with a sports pool and an interior refresh of the clubhouse. The club lists dining, wellness, courts and a golf shop.

Club history notes

The roll dates the course to 1992 and a broker history gives a groundbreaking of April 17, 1992. In March 2010 the club lowered its equity fee, according to a golf trade report. After Ian, the club’s charitable foundation gave $380,000 in grants to island organizations, including FISH of SanCap and The Sanibel School.

The master association and condo associations

A master association, recorded as the Sanctuary at Wulfert Point Community Association in the roll’s owner field, holds the roads, buffers and common tracts for every house, villa and condo. Each of the five condominiums has its own association on top of that, with its own budget, rules and manager.

Managers on record

The county roll lists care-of addresses that point to Island Management for the Heron and Golf Villages associations, Gulf Coast Property Management for Ibis, and Heritage Association Management or Island Management for master tracts. Ask the listing agent for the current manager and estoppel contact.

Dues

Neither the master nor the condo associations publish dues. Listing snippets quote master dues of roughly $900 to $1,200 a year for houses, which we could not confirm. Condo dues were not found. Get every figure from the estoppel certificate.

The roll truncates the master association’s name and also shows a variant spelling, Wulfret Pointe Community Assn. The exact legal name, status and registered agent were not confirmed; check them on the Florida Division of Corporations search before closing.

No CDD

We found no community development district for these parcels; they sit in the City of Sanibel taxing district.

Is the Sanctuary at Wulfert gated?

Sources disagree. One listing’s directions say to drive “into The Sanctuary (no gate),” while other marketing mentions gated entries. The internal roads are association tracts on the county roll, and the club is private. Confirm current entry arrangements with the association before a showing.

Is the Sanctuary at Wulfert in a flood zone?

Yes. FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer places eight sampled home points across the community, in Phase I, 2B, 3, Golf Villages, Heron, Ibis and Troon Court, in zone AE, the coastal floodplain, with a base flood elevation of 7 feet, and one Phase I point at 8 feet. The panel at the sampled central point is 12071C0506G, effective November 17, 2022.

Flood fact Figure Source
FEMA zone at sampled homes AE FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer
Base flood elevation 7 ft, one point 8 ft FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer
Map panel, central point 12071C0506G, effective November 17, 2022 FEMA FIRM panels
Panels at the north end of Wulfert Road Not checked

Source: FEMA point queries recorded in our research dossier, November 11, 2026.

What AE means for a loan

A mortgage on a house or condo in an AE zone comes with a flood insurance requirement. The premium turns on the building’s elevation, so the elevation certificate is the first document to request.

Ground-level 1990s designs

Many of the 1990s houses were built before current elevation standards. A newer house raised above the base flood elevation will usually price differently for flood cover than an older one at grade.

The substantial improvement rule

In a FEMA flood zone, repair or remodel work whose cost reaches half of a building’s market value can require the whole structure to meet current flood standards. Ask the City of Sanibel building department how that has applied to any house you are weighing.

Surge, not rain

After the 2024 storms, the City’s natural resources director said surge “overwashes the entire island” and that the stormwater system is built for rain rather than surge. Plan around surge exposure as the main flood risk here.

Hurricane Ian and the 2024 storms at the Sanctuary

Hurricane Ian made landfall on Cayo Costa, just north of Sanibel, on September 28, 2022. Island news reports say every structure on Sanibel took at least some damage and the causeway was cut in five places. House-by-house damage counts for the Sanctuary were not published.

The club after Ian

A PGA of America report summary described 4 to 5 feet of surge at the club, the loss of the golf shop, lower kitchen, cart barn and bag room, and a reopening in early January 2023. We read that only from a search summary, so treat it as unconfirmed detail.

Debby, Helene and Milton in 2024

The City reported surge on the island in all three 2024 storms. A February 2025 island report said the Sanctuary’s Bermuda grass areas were damaged while the paspalum mostly held, that the lake aeration system was being replaced and that native plantings were being restored.

Recovery by late 2025

A November 2025 report on the City’s golf course reviews found only “a few minor areas” needing work across Sanibel’s courses, such as turf loss and lake salinity.

Rebuilding on the roll

The roll shows new houses dated 2023 and 2024, and a third sold new in 2025. Whether they replaced storm-damaged houses is not public; City permit records would show it.

What to ask a seller

Ask for storm claims, repair invoices, permits and the elevation certificate for any house, and for condo board minutes since 2022, insurance claims and any open assessment.

Owning costs: taxes, insurance and condo rules

Carrying a Sanctuary at Wulfert home means county and city property taxes, insurance for wind and flood, association dues and, for members only, club dues. None of these is the same from one home to the next, so get the actual figures for the parcel you are weighing.

Property taxes

Bills depend on the assessed value, any homestead exemption and the millage set by Lee County, the City of Sanibel and other taxing bodies. Look up any parcel on the Lee County Property Appraiser site and the bill on the Lee County Tax Collector site.

The reset after a sale

Florida caps yearly increases in the assessed value of homestead property at 3 percent and most non-homestead property at 10 percent. A sale resets the assessment to market value, so a buyer’s first full bill can run far above the seller’s.

Homestead or second home

86 of the 189 residences carry a homestead exemption on the roll, about 46 percent. A buyer who makes the home a permanent Florida residence can apply; a second home or rental cannot.

Insurance

Wind and flood are priced separately on a barrier island. Get quotes during the inspection period, using the elevation certificate and any wind mitigation report.

Milestone inspections and reserve studies

Florida requires milestone structural inspections for condominium buildings of three or more habitable stories, starting by the end of the year the building turns 30, or 25 where the local agency requires it near salt water. The roll records the Heron, Ibis and some Golf Villages buildings at three stories, built 1994 to 1998, so they have reached or are reaching that age. The same building class must carry a structural integrity reserve study. The status of each Sanctuary condominium was not public; ask for the reports.

Houses and villas

Single-family houses and villas fall outside the condo inspection and reserve study rules.

Renting a Sanctuary at Wulfert home

Sanibel brokers summarize the City’s rules as a 28-day minimum rental for single-family homes, and the Golf Village and Ibis condominiums are listed with 28-day minimums. Weekly rentals do not fit. Get the written rule from the association and confirm the City’s rental registration requirements before you count on rental income.

Taxes on rentals

Stays of six months or less in Lee County carry tourist development tax and state sales tax. Ask a tax adviser how that applies.

Pets and assistance animals

Pet rules were not found for the master or condo associations. Assistance animals are not pets under fair housing law; ask each association for its accommodation process.

Age

No source we read describes any part of the Sanctuary at Wulfert as an age-restricted community. Confirm with the association.

Where is the Sanctuary at Wulfert on Sanibel?

The community sits north of Sanibel-Captiva Road on the bay side of the island’s west end, along Wulfert Road toward Wulfert Point. Roll points run from about 26.475 to 26.493 north and 82.161 to 82.173 west. The J.N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge surrounds much of it.

Destination Distance Free-flow drive
Bowman’s Beach about 2.5 mi about 9 min
HealthPark Medical Center area about 22.9 mi about 50 min
I-75 at Daniels Parkway about 27.9 mi about 56 min
Downtown Fort Myers about 28.4 mi about 60 min
Southwest Florida International Airport about 32.1 mi about 64 min
Downtown Naples about 51.0 mi about 93 min

Source: OSRM routing engine, free-flow estimates from the middle of the community, read November 11, 2026. Season and causeway traffic add time, often a lot of it from January to April.

The causeway

Every trip off the island crosses the Sanibel Causeway, about 3 miles with three bridges, and vehicles entering the island pay a toll.

The refuge next door

The Ding Darling refuge covers more than 6,400 acres, over 40 percent of it federal wilderness. Wildlife Drive is a 4-mile one-way road, $10 per vehicle and closed Fridays; the Visitor Center is free.

Beaches

Broker pages say the community has no deeded beach access. Bowman’s Beach, a public Gulf beach, is the closest at about 2.5 miles. For Gulf-front living, see our Colony Beach Estates and Nutmeg Village pages.

Captiva

Captiva is reached over the Blind Pass bridge to the west. See Captiva Island homes for sale.

Schools for Sanctuary at Wulfert addresses

Lee County assigns students through school choice zones. The island’s public school is The Sanibel School, a Lee County K to 8 school on Sanibel-Captiva Road; high school students attend mainland schools. Confirm the assignment for any address with the School District of Lee County.

A short history of the Sanctuary at Wulfert

The land at the west end of Sanibel was farmed early in the 1900s; the oldest deed in the county sale file for these parcels is dated September 1922. The golf course went in from 1992, the first houses followed in 1993, and the condominium buildings went up from 1994 to 1998.

Plats in order

Phase I was recorded at Plat Book 50, Pages 52 to 54; Phase 2A at Plat Book 50, Page 57, with later replats; Phase 2B at Plat Book 52, Pages 1 to 7; Phase 3 at Plat Book 55, Pages 30 to 33; and Augusta Greens at Plat Book 61, Page 6.

Condominium declarations

Sanctuary Golf Villages I at Official Records Book 2412, Page 1865; Heron at the Sanctuary at Book 2609, Page 648; Heron II at Book 2689, Page 1470; The Ibis at Book 2840, Page 3949; and Heron III at Book 3030, Page 2832.

The developer

A real estate blog names a developer and describes a land transfer to the refuge during permitting. We could not confirm either from deed records, so we leave them out until the Lee Clerk records can be checked.

What should you check before you make an offer?

A Sanctuary at Wulfert offer should rest on recorded sales for the right section and home type, the flood and storm record of the specific building, the association’s papers and, if you want to play, a separate conversation with the club. These are the steps we run with buyers here.

Match the parcel to its section

Find the plat or condominium on the roll, then compare it only with recorded sales from the same section and build era.

Get the elevation certificate

Ask for it on day one and price flood cover from it.

Inspect for storm history

Ask for permits, claims and repair invoices since 2022, and look at the house with an inspector who knows coastal construction.

Read the association papers

Get the master and condo budgets, reserves, rules, minutes and the estoppel certificate. For a condo, add the milestone inspection and reserve study.

Call the club separately

If membership matters, ask the club about categories, current fees and any wait before you sign the purchase contract.

Confirm the rental rule

Get the written minimum rental term from the association and check the City’s rule.

Sanctuary at Wulfert and other Sanibel options compared

Buyers drawn to the Sanctuary at Wulfert often weigh it against Sanibel’s other golf neighborhoods and against Gulf-side houses and condos with no club at all. The table below sticks to what our sources show for each, and the notes after it set out where the Sanctuary differs.

Community How it differs from the Sanctuary at Wulfert
The Dunes, Sanibel East-end golf neighborhood; club sold in October 2025; lower recorded prices in our research
Sanibel Island Golf Club area Semi-private course, bought by XUDE Hospitality in October 2025
Colony Beach Estates Gulf-side single-family neighborhood, no private club
Nutmeg Village Gulf-front condominium on West Gulf Drive
Bright Water West-end single-family neighborhood off West Gulf Drive

Sources: island news reports, our research dossiers and our own Sanibel pages, read November 2026.

Where the Sanctuary stands out, and where it does not

Its draws are a private club course inside a wildlife refuge setting, large golf lots with pools and a mix of houses, villas and condos. Its limits are a long drive to the mainland, no deeded beach access, an AE flood zone and club costs that sit on top of the house for anyone who wants to play.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Sanctuary at Wulfert specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows Sanibel homes from its Fort Myers office, the closest of our offices to the causeway. For this page we tracked every Sanctuary at Wulfert parcel on the county roll into its plat or condominium and matched each qualified sale to its section. We tracked 24 qualified sales since November 2024 for the table above, and we will run the same section-by-section check for any home you are weighing.

★★★★★ “In a very difficult buyers market, Marc really worked beyond our expectations to locate and view properties to help us find our place. I never imagined trying to buy a property remotely, but once we defined just what we were looking for, we were very comfortable having Marc narrow down properties. Ultimately, we put our house under contract prior to seeing it in person. His communication throughout the entire process was outstanding. His dedication to helping us was superb.”

Verified Zillow review. rick aszman, a buyer, on working with Marc Comisar of Domain Realty Group.

Talk to our team about a Sanctuary home

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816 with the home type and section you want, and an agent will send matching listings, the recorded sales of comparable homes and the association questions to ask. You can also search current listings at any time.

Thinking of selling?

A Sanctuary home is priced by its section, its golf frontage, its age and its elevation, so pricing it against recorded sales in the same section beats pricing it against the island. For a seller’s view, start with selling a home on Sanibel or Captiva with McGreevy and Comisar.

Frequently Asked Questions about Sanctuary at Wulfert homes for sale

These answers come from the Lee County roll and sale files, the club’s site, island news and federal flood data. Where we could not confirm a fact, the answer says so.

What is the Sanctuary at Wulfert?

A private golf community of 189 residences on Wulfert Road and Baltusrol Court at the west end of Sanibel, ZIP 33957, built around The Sanctuary Golf Club course.

How many homes are there?

The county roll counts 112 houses and villas, 77 condo units and 24 vacant homesites.

Do I have to join the golf club?

No. Membership is separate from ownership and not included in a purchase; buyers apply to the club directly.

How much is club membership?

The club does not publish fees. An undated broker figure of $150,000 for an equity initiation could not be confirmed; ask the club.

What do houses sell for?

Eleven qualified house sales in the 24 months to November 21, 2026 ran $850,000 to $3,150,000, with a $2,300,000 median.

What do condos sell for?

Nine qualified condo sales in the same 24 months ran $620,000 to $1,398,000, with a $922,500 median.

What was the highest recent sale?

2297 Wulfert Road, built 2023, at $3,150,000 on May 22, 2026.

Are there lots for sale?

The roll shows 24 vacant homesites; three sold from March 2025 to October 2026 at $260,000 to $445,000.

How big are the houses?

The roll gives 2,614 to 9,191 heated square feet, median 3,883, with three to seven bedrooms.

How big are the condos?

Golf Villages and Heron units run 2,260 to 2,578 heated square feet; Ibis units are 1,356.

When was it built?

The course dates to 1992, the first houses to 1993, the condominiums to 1994 through 1998, and new houses continue.

Who designed the course?

Arthur Hills. It is an 18-hole, par 72 course.

Is it gated?

Sources conflict; confirm entry arrangements with the association.

What flood zone is it in?

Sampled homes fall in FEMA zone AE with base flood elevations of 7 to 8 feet.

Did Hurricane Ian damage the Sanctuary?

Ian damaged every structure on Sanibel to some degree; house-level counts for the Sanctuary were not published.

Is there beach access?

Broker pages say there is no deeded beach access; Bowman’s Beach is about 2.5 miles away.

Can I rent my home?

Sources give a 28-day minimum; confirm with the association and the City.

Is there a CDD?

None was found.

What are the association dues?

They are not published; get them from the estoppel certificate.

Is it age restricted?

No source we read says so; confirm with the association.

What is the newest recorded sale?

A homesite at 2438 Wulfert Road, recorded at $300,000 on October 5, 2026.

Which condo is the smallest?

The Ibis at the Sanctuary, where all 12 units are two-bedroom, 1,356 square foot flats.

How many condo buildings are there?

Five condominiums: Sanctuary Golf Villages I, Heron at the Sanctuary I, II and III, and The Ibis at the Sanctuary.

Do most houses have pools?

Yes. The roll records a pool on 110 of the 112 house and villa parcels.

Are the houses on the golf course?

The roll codes 100 of the 112 house and villa parcels as golf course lots.

How many homes are full-time residences?

86 of the 189 residences carry a homestead exemption, about 46 percent.

What is a homesite worth?

Vacant lot values on the current roll run from $207,783 to $300,271.

Do condos need milestone inspections?

The three-story buildings fall under Florida’s milestone rule; ask each association for its report.

What school serves it?

The Sanibel School for grades K to 8; confirm with the district.

How far is the airport?

About 32 miles and an hour by free-flow estimate, longer in season.

Where do I see Sanctuary at Wulfert homes for sale?

Our current listings search shows active Sanibel homes. Call 239-441-2816 or contact us to set an alert.

About Domain Realty Group on Sanibel

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team working Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, including Sanibel and Captiva, from offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) lead the team, with over 45 years of combined direct experience.

Meet the team on our agents page, read our client reviews or learn more about our team.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816 info@domainrealtygroup.com

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Sanibel real estate, Captiva Island homes for sale, Colony Beach Estates homes for sale, Nutmeg Village condos for sale, Bright Water homes for sale and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to a source below. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser’s parcel roll (LCPA2610) and sale files, qualified sales on Sanctuary at Wulfert parcels in ZIP 33957, read from a local index built November 18, 2026. Web sources were read November 11, 2026 for our research dossier unless another date is shown.

County, city and state records

Club, community and news

Flood, storms and insurance

Florida law

Schools, places and roads