Opens in a new tab
Back to Sanibel

Sanibel · Florida · 33957

Colonnades Condos for Sale in Sanibel, FL

Colonnades condos for sale: 36 one-bedroom, one-bath flats in two small 1968 and 1969 condominiums on East Gulf Drive near the Sanibel Lighthouse, rented through the on-site Colony Inn program. Recorded county sales since Hurricane Ian, the fee and what it covers, the rental rules on file, flood and condo-law checks. Updated November 2026.

Aerial photo from January 16, 2023 of the Colonnades condominium site on East Gulf Drive in Sanibel, FL 33957: two long low-rise buildings with pale roofs and a small building between them beside a curving road, with houses and sandy, sparsely treed ground around the edges

The Colonnades is a 36-unit condominium on East Gulf Drive on the East End of Sanibel, ZIP 33957, in the City of Sanibel and Lee County, and part of the island inventory we follow for our Sanibel homes for sale coverage. It is really two small condominiums, The Colonnades Condominium at 409 East Gulf Drive (20 units, 1968) and Colonnade Condominium No. 2 at 429 East Gulf Drive (16 units, 1969), run as one rental resort called The Colony Inn. Every unit is a one-bedroom, one-bath flat of 511 heated square feet on the county roll. Lee County recorded 4 qualified Colonnades sales from November 2025 to the newest one on March 13, 2026, from $225,000 to $278,000. Updated November 2026.

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.

This page covers only the 36 Colonnades units and their two shared common-element parcels at 419 and 431 East Gulf Drive. It sits under our Sanibel real estate page for the whole island. The single-family plat next door on Bella Vista Way is a different community with its own owners and records; see Colony Beach Estates homes for sale for that street, because none of its house sales are counted here and none of the Colonnades sales are counted there.

Key takeaways for Colonnades condo buyers

The short list below holds the facts that most often shape a Colonnades purchase. Each comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale files, the state condominium extract, the Colony Inn's own site, City of Sanibel code, Florida statutes or dated listing records, and each is explained further down with its source.

  • The Colonnades holds 36 condominium units in two recorded condominiums under one association: 20 units at 409 East Gulf Drive and 16 at 429 East Gulf Drive.
  • Every unit on the county roll is one bedroom and one bath with 511 heated square feet; listings quote 540 to 675 square feet because they measure differently.
  • The units are rented to visitors through an on-site program that trades as The Colony Inn at 419 East Gulf Drive.
  • Guides and recent listings give a one-day rental minimum, which is uncommon on Sanibel; a City of Sanibel rental license is still required.
  • Lee County recorded 11 qualified sales from April 2023 to March 2026, from $175,000 to $299,900, and 4 in the most recent 12 months on file, from $225,000 to $278,000.
  • Listings from 2024 and 2025 showed the complex under construction after Hurricane Ian, and a December 2025 listing said the pool was nearing completion.
  • Listings from 2024 and 2025 quote an association fee of $2,700 per quarter that includes building insurance, cable, internet, water and trash.
  • The buildings are two stories with no elevator, which likely places them outside Florida's milestone inspection and reserve study mandates.
  • None of the 36 units carries a homestead exemption on the current roll.

Colonnades condos for sale right now

Colonnades condos for sale appear a few times a year, because the complex has only 36 units and most owners keep them in the rental program for years at a stretch. The county file shows 7 qualified sales in the 24 months from November 2024 through the newest recorded sale on March 13, 2026, and 4 in the latest 12 months.

Thirty-eight parcels on the roll

The Lee County Property Appraiser lists 38 Colonnades parcels: 36 residential unit parcels and two common-element parcels that hold the pool land. The 20 units of the first condominium use 409 East Gulf Drive, and the 16 units of the second use 429 East Gulf Drive.

Rental and listing sites name the units C-01 and onward, while the county roll numbers them 1 to 20 and 1 to 16. A listing for "Unit 51" carried the legal description Colonnade Condominium No. 2, Unit 11, so read the legal description in any listing rather than the rental number.

Matching a listing to a county record

Our research suggests that Colonnade No. 2 unit numbers map to rental numbers C-41 to C-56, and that the first condominium uses C-01 to C-20. That is an inference from two records, so confirm the legal unit number on the deed and the parcel record before you compare prices.

Asking prices and recorded prices

A seller's asking price is a hope; a recorded sale is a fact. Every sale price on this page comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's qualified sale files, which trail a closing by weeks, so weigh any asking price against the recorded sales below.

Searching for a Colonnades listing

To see what is on the market today, search current listings for Sanibel or ask us to watch East Gulf Drive for you. Listings use "Colonnades," "Colonnade" and "Colony Inn" in their titles, and some list the street as Gulf Drive, so we search every form.

Ready to tour a Colonnades unit?

Tell us your budget, whether you want a ground-floor or upper unit, and how you plan to use it, and we will send every matching listing with the recorded sales of comparable units. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do Colonnades condos sell for?

Since Hurricane Ian, Lee County recorded qualified Colonnades sales from $175,000 to $299,900, and the latest four, from November 2025 to March 2026, ran from $225,000 to $278,000. Every unit shares one floor plan, so condition, floor level and renovation status explain most of the gap between prices.

Window to the March 13, 2026 sale Qualified sales Median Low High
12 months, since November 2025 4 $263,500 $225,000 $278,000
24 months, since November 2024 7 $227,500 $210,000 $278,000
60 months, since November 2021 12 $263,500 $175,000 $455,000
Since January 2016 20 $240,000 $175,000 $455,000
All recorded history, since December 1968 90 $157,500 $12,000 $455,000

Data updated: November 2026. Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and sale files, qualified improved sales on the 36 Colonnades unit parcels, index built November 18, 2026; newest Colonnades sale March 13, 2026.

All of these sales are resales. None is a first sale from a developer, because the units were first sold in 1968 and 1969.

Every recorded sale since Hurricane Ian

These are all eleven qualified sales the county recorded from April 2023 to March 2026. Each unit is 511 heated square feet with one bedroom and one bath on the roll, so the table shows the building and the price.

Date recorded Condominium Sale price Price per county sq ft
April 21, 2023 No. 2 (429 E Gulf Dr) $299,900 about $587
April 24, 2023 Colonnades I (409 E Gulf Dr) $175,000 about $342
September 29, 2023 Colonnades I $274,000 about $536
November 6, 2023 Colonnades I $274,000 about $536
April 8, 2025 No. 2 $212,000 about $415
May 12, 2025 Colonnades I $227,500 about $445
May 27, 2025 No. 2 $210,000 about $411
November 14, 2025 No. 2 $225,000 about $440
December 3, 2025 Colonnades I $262,000 about $513
February 17, 2026 No. 2 $265,000 about $519
March 13, 2026 Colonnades I $278,000 about $544

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sale files and parcel roll, index built November 18, 2026. Price per square foot is our arithmetic on the county's 511 heated square feet.

The eleven sales since April 2023 have a median of $262,000. No qualified sale recorded between November 2023 and April 2025, the stretch when listings described the complex as under construction.

Price per square foot two ways

On the county's 511 heated square feet, the sales from April 2025 to March 2026 work out to about $411 to $544 per square foot. On the 600 square feet most listings quote, the same sales come to about $350 to $463, so always check which area a price per square foot uses.

The 2022 peak

The highest qualified Colonnades price on the county file is $455,000, recorded on July 1, 2022 for a unit in the first condominium, less than three months before Hurricane Ian. No sale since has come close, which shows how far the storm reset prices here.

White-box sales in 2025

A unit in Colonnade No. 2 recorded at $212,000 in April 2025 after a listing that offered it as a white box with construction ongoing. A unit in the first condominium recorded at $227,500 in May 2025 after a listing that said construction continued. Buyers in that period paid for unfinished interiors.

Finished units in late 2025 and 2026

The December 2025 sale at $262,000 followed a listing for an updated ground-floor unit, and the March 2026 sale at $278,000 followed a listing that described impact-resistant windows and doors. Those two sales are the highest since 2023 other than the $299,900 sale in April 2023.

Colonnades I against Colonnade No. 2

In the 60 months to the newest sale, the seven qualified sales in the first condominium had a median of $274,000 and the five in No. 2 a median of $225,000. Both buildings share the same plan on the roll, so the gap reflects the mix of finished and unfinished units sold, not a size difference.

Value on the county roll

The 2026 roll carries most units in the first condominium at a just value of $179,094, units 10 and 15 at $188,276 and units 13 and 18 at $197,621. Every unit in No. 2 carries $179,744. Land value is $0 on every unit, which is normal for a condominium on the roll.

The Colonnades floor plan and unit sizes

Every Colonnades unit shares one basic plan: a one-bedroom, one-bath flat in a two-story walk-up building. The county roll, the condominium documents and the listings each give a different area for that plan, and the gap is a matter of measurement, so the table below shows each figure with its source.

Measure Area Source
County heated area, every unit 511 sq ft Lee County Property Appraiser roll
Condominium documents, one unit 540 sq ft Listing remarks quoting the documents
Listing living area, several units 600 sq ft Listing records
Total area including porch, one unit 675 sq ft Listing records

Sources: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, November 2026; public listing records read November 18, 2026.

The 511 square foot county figure

The Property Appraiser records 511 heated square feet for all 36 units, with one bedroom, one bath and two stories on each record. Use that figure when you compare a Colonnades unit with other condominiums, because the county measures them all the same way.

The 540 and 600 square foot figures

A listing quoting the condominium documents gave 540 square feet, and most listings give 600 square feet of living area. Those figures likely count space the county leaves out of heated area, such as a porch or a measured wall line.

The 675 square foot upper unit

One listing for an upper unit in Colonnade No. 2 gave 675 square feet in total, including its porch. Ask for the measurement basis on any unit you tour, because the porch is part of how a unit lives but not of its heated area.

Bedroom and sleeping layout

Rental listings show units sleeping up to four guests, with two double beds in the bedroom of some units. The plan has one bath. Furnishings vary by owner, so confirm what conveys with the unit.

Stairs and no elevator

The buildings are two stories with no elevator, according to the roll and listings. Upper units are reached by stairs, so consider that if anyone who will use the unit needs single-level access.

Screened lanais and porches

Some units have a screened lanai or porch, according to listing records. Ask which units have one and whether it counts in the area a listing quotes.

Finish after the rebuild

The Colony Inn now describes all 36 units as completely renovated. Each unit is owned separately, so finishes vary. Ask the seller for the permits and dates for the interior work and check them with the City of Sanibel.

Two condominiums, one association

The Colonnades name covers two separate condominiums created by two declarations a year apart, and Florida's condominium division lists one association that manages both. Knowing which condominium a unit belongs to matters, because each declaration sets its own unit shares and rules and its own common-element parcel.

The Colonnades Condominium

The first condominium has 20 units at 409 East Gulf Drive, built in 1968 according to the roll. Its declaration is recorded at Lee County Official Records Book 464, Page 376, and the state extract lists it as Colonnades I Condo, The, project PR1S018276.

Colonnade Condominium No. 2

The second condominium has 16 units at 429 East Gulf Drive, built in 1969 according to the roll. Its declaration is recorded at Official Records Book 553, Page 740, and the state extract lists it as Colonnades II Condo, The, project PR1S019372.

The shared pool parcels

Two common-element parcels hold the pool land: 419 East Gulf Drive, about 0.98 acres, carried on the roll as a pool common element for both condominiums, and 431 East Gulf Drive, about 0.77 acres, carried as a pool common element of No. 2. Together they map at about 1.75 acres.

The association record

The state extract lists one managing entity for both condominiums, spelled there as Colannades Condo Assn of Sanibel Inc, with a mailing address of 419 East Gulf Drive. The state corporate record could not be read for this page, so confirm the exact legal name, officers and registered agent yourself.

Management

The Colony Inn site shows a "managed by" credit for Gulf Coast Association Management, a firm based in Bradenton that lists Sanibel among its service areas and offers both condominium management and resort-style management. Whether it manages the association, the rental program or both is not stated, so ask.

The developer

No public source we read names the original developer. The two declarations at the Lee County Clerk would name the declarant, if the history matters to you.

Documents to request

Ask for both declarations, the bylaws, the rules, the current budget, the reserve schedule, two years of minutes, the master insurance policy, any engineering reports and a written list of special assessments. Ask which condominium your unit sits in and which declaration governs it.

The Colony Inn rental program

The Colony Inn is the name the on-site rental operation uses for the Colonnades units, and it is the main reason most buyers look here. Its site describes 36 individually owned, completely renovated one-bedroom condominiums with a heated freshwater pool and a private path to the beach, run from an office at 419 East Gulf Drive.

The Colony Inn and the Colony Resort

Older travel listings show 419 East Gulf Drive as the Colony Resort, and the Colony Inn site says the inn began as a small group of island cottages and has been part of island hospitality since the 1960s. The name changed; the address did not.

What the city code says

Sanibel Code section 126-152(e)(4) refers to "the on-site rental management program of the Colony Resort or the Collonades Condominium" by name. It ties the short-term rental status of several nearby resort housing units to that program, which shows the city has long treated the Colonnades as a rental operation.

Nearby houses tied to the program

That code section lists seven nearby resort housing units, at 432 and 424 East Gulf Drive, 440 Glory Circle and 350 East Gulf Drive, that may keep renting only through the Colony Resort or Colonnades program and only while their tenants may use the Colonnades pool. Those houses are not Colonnades units.

The one-day minimum

Guides and recent listings give a one-day rental minimum at the Colonnades, with nightly, weekly and monthly stays through the on-site program. An island rental guide updated in October 2026 notes that most Sanibel condominiums require seven days or more, which makes a nightly minimum rare on the island.

The city's four-week rule elsewhere

Outside the Resort Housing District, Sanibel's code generally sets a four-consecutive-week minimum for dwelling unit rentals, according to copies of the code. Confirm with the City of Sanibel Planning Department which district and basis apply to the Colonnades parcels before you plan a nightly rental schedule.

Rental license

Every rented unit needs a City of Sanibel dwelling rental license under Code section 126-1078, and the license number must appear in advertising, according to a copy of the city form revised in February 2020. Confirm current license types and fees with the city.

Tourist tax

Lee County collects a 5 percent tourist development tax on stays of six months or less, on top of Florida sales tax. Ask the rental office which taxes it collects and files on behalf of owners.

Program terms to confirm

The rental commission, owner-use rules and whether owners must use the on-site program are not public. Ask the association and the rental office for the program agreement in writing before you sign a contract, and ask for the unit's rental statements, not a summary.

Booking-site scores

Guest-review scores for the Colony Inn on booking sites run about 8.5 to 8.7 out of 10, according to search summaries read in November 2026. Those scores describe guest stays, not the condition of any unit for sale.

Amenities at the Colonnades

The Colonnades keeps a short, simple list of shared amenities built around one pool court and a path to the Gulf. Some items come from older guides and some from 2025 and 2026 listings and the operator, so treat the list as a starting point and confirm each item with the association.

The heated pool

The Colony Inn site lists a heated freshwater pool on the 419 East Gulf Drive common element. A December 2025 listing said the pool was nearing completion after the post-storm work. Colonnade No. 2 also has a pool common element at 431 East Gulf Drive; ask whether one or two pools operate today.

The path to the beach

The operator describes the beach as just steps down a private path from the inn, and guest reviews describe a walk of two to five minutes down a path and boardwalk. One guide lists deeded beach access. The buildings do not appear to front the Gulf themselves, so confirm the access route on a parcel map.

Grills, shuffleboard and laundry

Guides and the operator list barbecue grills, shuffleboard and coin laundry on the grounds. These sit on common land, so their upkeep comes out of the shared budget.

Bikes on site

The Colony Inn lists bike rentals on site. Sanibel's shared-use path network reaches restaurants, preserves and shops from the East End.

Parking

A 2025 listing describes one assigned space per unit plus common and guest parking, and some unit legal descriptions on the roll include a numbered parking space. Ask which space goes with the unit you want.

What is not on site

There is no tennis, elevator, golf, marina or club membership at the Colonnades, according to guides and listings. Buyers who want those will look at the larger Gulf-front complexes along East Gulf Drive.

What does it cost to own a Colonnades condo each year?

Yearly costs at the Colonnades come from the association fee, property taxes, an HO-6 policy for the unit interior and contents, the city rental license if you rent, rental program costs and any special assessment. The association does not publish its budget, so the figures below come from dated listings and should be confirmed.

The quarterly fee

Listings from 2024 to 2025 for unit 1 and from December 2025 for unit 17 both quote an association fee of $2,700 per quarter, about $900 a month. Ask for the current budget and the fee for the specific unit.

What the fee is said to cover

Those listings say the fee covers building insurance, cable television, internet, water, sewer, trash, irrigation water, laundry, grounds, legal and accounting, a manager, exterior pest control, recreation facilities and pool service. Check that list against the association's budget.

An older estimate

An undated guide estimated fees at about $1.56 per square foot per month. That figure is older than the listings and was read only in a search summary, so rely on the current budget instead.

Special assessments

No public record of a special assessment for the post-Ian rebuild was found for this page. The cost of the rebuild and how it was funded are not public, so ask for a written statement of any assessment levied since 2022 and any still being collected.

The estoppel certificate

Before closing, the association issues an estoppel certificate stating what the seller owes, under Florida Statutes 718.116. It is the document that shows any balance a buyer could inherit, so read it line by line.

Transfer fees and capital contributions

No transfer fee or capital contribution was found in public sources. Ask the association, and read the declaration and bylaws for any charge due at sale.

No master association or CDD

No master association and no community development district was found for the Colonnades. Confirm on the tax bill, where any district assessment would show as its own line.

Rental program costs

The rental commission and any housekeeping or booking charges are not published. Ask the rental office for its fee schedule, because those charges come out of every booking.

Property taxes on a Colonnades unit

Colonnades property taxes are set from the Lee County Property Appraiser's assessed value and the millage of the City of Sanibel, Lee County, the school board and island districts, and the Lee County Tax Collector sends the bill. None of the 36 units carries a homestead exemption on the current roll, so taxable value equals just value on each one.

Taxes shown in listings

Listings show annual taxes of about $350 to $365 for tax years 2024 and 2025 on several units. That is far below what the current just values of about $179,000 would produce for a non-homestead unit, which suggests reduced post-storm assessments on those rolls. That is an inference; check the bill.

Expect the bill to change

A buyer's tax is figured on the assessment after the sale and after any storm reductions end, not on the seller's last bill. Look up the unit on the Lee County Tax Collector's site and the Property Appraiser's record before you budget.

Homestead and Save Our Homes

A Florida resident who makes a unit a permanent home can apply for the homestead exemption under Florida Statutes 196.031, and the Save Our Homes cap in 193.155 then limits yearly increases in assessed value. A unit used as a rental does not qualify.

Taxes on rental stays

Rental stays carry their own taxes, separate from property tax: the Lee County tourist development tax and Florida sales tax on stays of six months or less. Ask a tax adviser how rental income and expenses will be reported.

Pets, occupancy and age rules at the Colonnades

Because the Colonnades runs as a small inn, its pet and occupancy rules differ for owners and for rental guests. The facts below come from listings, guides and rental pages; read the current rules and both declarations, and confirm each rule with the association in writing.

Pets for owners

A December 2025 listing says owners may keep one pet under 35 pounds, and guides say pets are allowed subject to association rules. Ask for the written pet rules, including size, number and breed limits.

Pets for rental guests

Colony Inn unit listings on travel sites say "No Pets" for rental guests. If you plan to rent through the program, expect guest pets to be refused unless the rules change.

Assistance animals

A pet limit does not apply the same way to an assistance animal. Federal fair housing law and Florida Statutes 760.27 require housing providers to consider requests for assistance animals, so an owner or renter who needs one should make that request to the association.

Occupancy

Rental listings show units sleeping up to four guests. Occupancy limits come from the rules, the building code and the city rental license, so ask the association for the limit that applies.

Age rules

No public source describes the Colonnades as a 55 or older community, and no age rule was found in the guides we read. Ask the association to confirm in writing.

Is the Colonnades in a flood zone?

The Colonnades sits near the Gulf on Sanibel's East End, and the exact FEMA flood zone and base flood elevation for its two buildings were not confirmed for this page. A 1968 or 1969 building also predates Sanibel's first FEMA flood maps, so the flood questions below deserve answers before you write an offer.

Sanibel's mapped zones

The City of Sanibel's flood information page lists the island's mapped zones as AE, AO, VE and X. Nearby East End Gulf-side condominiums map as VE on the beach side and AE inland, according to research on a neighbouring complex, so do not assume one zone for the whole site.

Finding the zone for a unit

The city sends owners to its Forerunner flood portal, which shows the zone and any elevation certificate on file by address. Search 409 or 429 East Gulf Drive there and on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center.

Older buildings and the base flood elevation

Both buildings were built about a decade before Sanibel's first FEMA flood maps in 1979, so their ground-floor units are likely below today's base flood elevation. That is an inference until you see an elevation certificate; ask the association for one.

The 50 percent rule

Sanibel enforces FEMA's substantial improvement rule: if work on a building costs 50 percent or more of its market value, the building must meet current flood rules. The city measures value from the Property Appraiser's market value or a private appraisal. Ask how the post-Ian repairs were measured against that line.

Flood insurance discount

Sanibel holds a Community Rating System Class 5 rating, worth a 25 percent discount on flood insurance premiums, according to the city. A financed purchase in a special flood hazard area needs flood coverage on the building, usually through the association's master policy.

Evacuation Zone A

All of Sanibel is in Lee County Evacuation Zone A, the first zone ordered out when a storm threatens. Lee County ordered Zone A to evacuate on September 27, 2022, the day before Ian came ashore.

Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton at the Colonnades

Hurricane Ian struck Sanibel on September 28, 2022, and Helene and Milton brought more flooding in 2024. No news report names the Colonnades, so the record below comes from county sales, dated listings and the operator's site, and the rest is a question for the association.

What hit the East End

The Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation's high-water-mark review found that parts of Sanibel saw possibly up to 10 feet of water above ground during Ian. At the island's eastern tip, Ian stripped trees and destroyed the two historic lighthouse keepers' cottages; the lighthouse itself stood.

The listing timeline

From July 2024 to May 2025 a listing for unit 1 showed the complex under construction. From October 2024 to April 2025 a unit in No. 2 was offered as a white box with construction ongoing. In December 2025 a listing showed impact-resistant windows and doors and a pool nearing completion.

The operator's description in 2026

The Colony Inn site now describes all 36 units as completely renovated. Our reading of the record is that ground-floor interiors were gutted and rebuilt and that the amenities were restored into late 2025 or early 2026; that is an inference, so ask for the dates.

Helene and Milton

The conservation foundation reported that Helene's approximately 5-foot storm surge caused flooding across the island in September 2024, and that Milton's flooding, overwash and wind in October 2024 topped Helene's but not Ian's. No report names the Colonnades for either storm.

The neighbourhood around it

The Lighthouse Beach Park bayside lot reopened on June 30, 2023. The Sanibel fishing pier at Lighthouse Beach Park was still closed in August 2026, pending temporary repairs and a planned replacement. No damaging storm was reported for Sanibel in 2025 or 2026 in the sources we read.

What to ask about the rebuild

Ask the association for the scope of storm repairs to each building, the permit numbers and final dates on file with the City of Sanibel, the insurance claims, and how the work was paid for. Get any answer about assessments in writing.

Florida condo law and insurance at the Colonnades

Florida rewrote parts of its condominium law after 2021, and several of the new rules depend on building height. The Colonnades buildings are two stories on the county roll, so the useful question for a buyer is which rules apply and which documents prove it.

Structural integrity reserve studies

Florida Statutes 718.112 requires a structural integrity reserve study only for condominium buildings three habitable stories or higher. The Colonnades buildings are two stories on the roll and in listings, so they likely fall outside that rule. Ask for the association's written position.

Milestone inspections

Florida's milestone structural inspection applies to condominium buildings of three or more habitable stories at 30 years of age, according to the state condominium division. In March 2026 the Sanibel City Council voted 4 to 0 to mirror the state's three-habitable-story language in its own rule.

Reserves still matter

Even an association outside the study rule must keep a budget, and chapter 718's ordinary reserve rules still apply. Ask for the reserve schedule and how much is set aside for roofs, painting, stairs and the pool.

The master insurance policy

Listings say the association fee includes building insurance. The carrier, wind and flood limits and deductibles are not public. Ask for the master policy and how a deductible would be shared among owners after a storm, and price your own HO-6 policy early.

Disclosure before a resale

Florida Statutes 718.503 lists what a seller must give a resale buyer, including the declaration, bylaws, rules, budget and latest financial report, and gives the buyer a short window to review them and cancel.

Renovation permits

Interior work, from a new kitchen to new windows, usually needs a City of Sanibel permit and association approval. Ask the association for its alteration rules, and check the city's permit records for the unit.

Where is the Colonnades on Sanibel?

The Colonnades sits on the Gulf side of East Gulf Drive on Sanibel's East End, between Periwinkle Way and the beach and a short drive from the lighthouse. The free-flow times below come from one public routing request from the first condominium's parcel point; they exclude causeway toll lines and winter traffic.

Destination Distance Time, free-flow
Lighthouse Beach Park 0.9 mi 3 min
The Sanibel School 5.4 mi 12 min
Sanibel Causeway toll plaza, mainland side 5.8 mi 14 min
HealthPark Medical Center 13.0 mi 25 min
Downtown Fort Myers 19.6 mi 38 min
I-75 Exit 131, Daniels Parkway 19.7 mi 34 min
Gulf Coast Town Center 21.4 mi 38 min
Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) 23.1 mi 41 min
Coconut Point, Estero 24.3 mi 42 min
Downtown Naples, Fifth Avenue South 42.0 mi 70 min

Source: OSRM public routing engine, one table request from 26.44806 N, 82.02402 W, November 18, 2026. In-season times can be much longer.

On and off the island

Every trip to the mainland uses the single Sanibel Causeway, which carries a toll collected by Lee County. From the East End, Periwinkle Way runs west through the island's shops and restaurants.

Lighthouse Beach Park

Lighthouse Beach Park is about 0.9 miles from the Colonnades by road, roughly three minutes in light traffic. One unit listing gave about a 15-minute walk to the lighthouse.

The houses next door

The single-family homes of Colony Beach Estates sit on Bella Vista Way beside the Colonnades, and other East End streets hold more houses: Bayshore Village homes for sale cover a raised-home neighbourhood near the Gulf, and Ferry Landing homes for sale cover a bayside street near the lighthouse.

Condominiums along East Gulf Drive

Sanibel Moorings, Sanibel Arms West, Sanibel Surfside and Loggerhead Cay are other condominiums along East Gulf Drive and Donax Street. Each is a separate association with larger units and its own rental rules.

Shops and landmarks

Booking sites name Tuttle's Sea Horse Shell Shop as the closest landmark, and guests mention walking to the Lighthouse Cafe, now at 1020 Periwinkle Way. Groceries and most dining sit along Periwinkle Way.

Health care

There is no hospital on Sanibel. HealthPark Medical Center, run by Lee Health, is about 25 minutes away in free-flow traffic.

Captiva to the northwest

Captiva Island lies at the far end of Sanibel past Blind Pass, about as far from the Colonnades as you can drive on the islands. If you are weighing both islands, see our Captiva Island homes for sale.

Schools serving Colonnades addresses

The Colonnades is in the School District of Lee County, which assigns students by address and a choice process. Sanibel has one public school on the island, and high school students travel to the mainland. Few Colonnades owners use the schools, since every unit is non-homestead, but confirm any assignment with the district.

The Sanibel School

The Sanibel School at 3840 Sanibel Captiva Road serves kindergarten through grade 8. It is about 5.4 miles and 12 minutes from the Colonnades in free-flow traffic.

High school

Island students attend high school on the mainland. The formal zone needs confirming with the district's address lookup.

Private schools

Canterbury School and Fort Myers Christian School are private schools in Fort Myers. Check admission and transport from an island address.

School grades

The Florida Department of Education publishes school grades every year. Look up any school you are weighing on its site.

A short history of the Colonnades

The Colonnades is one of the older condominiums on Sanibel, recorded before the City of Sanibel was incorporated in 1974 and before the 1976 Sanibel Plan. Its county sale file begins with the first unit sales in December 1968 and runs through the storms of 2022 and 2024 to the newest sale in 2026.

The Colony Beach Resort cottages

A broker community page says the Colonnades were once part of the Colony Beach Resort, which held several beach-front duplex cottages, and that many cottages were moved to other island sites to make room for Colony Beach Estates. The Colony Inn site says the inn began as a small group of island cottages.

1968 and the first condominium

The first declaration was recorded at Official Records Book 464, Page 376. The county file shows the first qualified unit sales in December 1968 at $12,000 each.

1969 and Colonnade No. 2

The second declaration followed at Official Records Book 553, Page 740. The first No. 2 sales recorded in December 1969 at $16,100 to $16,600.

Prices in the 1970s and 1980s

The county recorded two qualified sales in the 1970s, at $26,000 in 1975 and $27,500 in 1976. Eleven sales from 1981 to 1989 ran from $75,000 to $97,500, at an $85,000 median.

Prices in the 1990s

Seventeen qualified sales recorded from 1990 to 1998, from $79,000 to $112,500, at a $90,000 median.

Prices from 2000 to 2009

Fourteen qualified sales recorded from 2000 to 2009, from $140,000 to $300,000, at a $215,000 median. The $300,000 sale in January 2006 was the high point of that decade.

Prices from 2010 to 2019

Twenty-three qualified sales recorded from 2010 to 2019, from $106,700 in October 2012 to $245,000 in June 2019, at a $180,000 median.

Prices since 2020

Fifteen qualified sales recorded from February 2020 to March 2026, from $175,000 to $455,000, at a $262,000 median. That count includes three 2020 sales from $235,000 to $283,000, the July 2022 peak and the eleven sales since Ian.

What should you check before an offer on a Colonnades condo?

A Colonnades offer goes more smoothly when the buyer gathers the right papers before the inspection period ends. The checklist below follows the questions this page could not answer from public records; put each one to the seller, the association, the rental office or the City of Sanibel in writing.

Confirm the unit and the condominium

Match the rental number to the legal unit number and the condominium, I or No. 2, on the deed and the parcel record. The declaration that governs your unit depends on it.

Get the budget, reserves and minutes

Ask for the current budget, the reserve schedule, two years of minutes and the latest financial statement. Those show what the $2,700 quarterly fee pays for and what the board plans to spend.

Ask about the rebuild and assessments

Ask for the permits and final dates for the post-Ian work, the cost and how it was funded, and a written list of any special assessment levied since 2022.

Read the rental agreement

Get the rental program agreement, the commission, the owner-use rules and two years of statements for the unit. Then check the unit's City of Sanibel rental license.

Check the flood file

Get the flood zone, the elevation certificate for the building and the association's master flood policy, and price your own coverage before the inspection period ends.

Order an inspection

Hire a licensed inspector for the unit, and ask the association for any engineering or roof reports on the buildings, stairs and walkways.

Colonnades and other condos buyers compare

Buyers who look at the Colonnades often compare it with other small-unit or rental-friendly condominiums on Sanibel. The comparison below uses public research on each complex; unit counts and sizes come from the county roll or the complex's own records, and the point is the honest difference, not a ranking.

Complex Units Unit type and size Rental minimum on file
Colonnades 36 1 bed, 1 bath, 511 county sq ft 1 day
Signal Inn 19 527 to 2,400 county sq ft 7 days in most sources
Sanibel Surfside 38 958 to 1,425 sq ft 7 days
Sanibel Arms West about 104 2 bed, about 967 to 1,040 sq ft 3 days on one broker page
Loggerhead Cay 168 2 bed Weekly
Spanish Cay 40 1 bed plans of 810 to 950 sq ft 7 to 14 days

Sources: Lee County Property Appraiser roll and our research dossiers on each complex, read November 18 to November 21, 2026.

Signal Inn's small flats

Signal Inn condos in mid-island Sanibel include six one-bedroom flats of 527 square feet on the roll, close to the Colonnades size, but they sit on the Gulf beach and most sources give a 7-day rental minimum.

Sanibel Surfside and Sanibel Arms West

Both are East End Gulf-front complexes with larger two-bedroom units and elevators or Gulf frontage the Colonnades lacks, and both carry longer rental minimums.

Loggerhead Cay

Loggerhead Cay at 979 East Gulf Drive holds 168 two-bedroom Gulf-front units with tennis and pickleball, a larger complex with a weekly rental model.

Spanish Cay

Spanish Cay on Middle Gulf Drive has 40 units including one-bedroom plans of 810 to 950 square feet. It is the nearest size peer in our research but has no nightly rentals.

Resort hotels and inns

The Sanibel Inn, Island Inn and Tarpon Tale also offer nightly stays, but as hotel rooms or inn rooms, not individually deeded condominiums an owner can buy.

What the Colonnades offers and what it does not

The Colonnades offers the lowest recorded price point we have found for deeded Sanibel condominium ownership, a one-day rental minimum on file and an East End location with a path to the beach. It does not offer more than one bedroom, an elevator, its own Gulf frontage or buildings raised to current flood rules.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Colonnades specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows Colonnades units and other Sanibel condominiums, and our Fort Myers office on College Parkway is our closest office to the causeway. We tracked all 90 recorded Colonnades sales since 1968 against the county roll, and we can pull that record for any unit you are weighing.

★★★★★ "Excellent! Marc was there every step of the way for us. He is exceptional in all aspects of real estate. I would highly recommend him. In 2009 Marc helped us purchase a home in Bella Terra in Estero Florida. Also, in 2020 Marc oversaw the purchase of our 2nd home in Fort Myers. You cannot find a more knowledgeable or helpful person in the real estate business."

Verified Zillow review. pdcaron7, on buying homes in Estero and Fort Myers with Marc Comisar.

Talk to our team about a Colonnades unit

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816 with your budget and rental plans, and an agent will send matching Colonnades listings, the recorded sales behind them and the association questions for that unit. You can also search current listings at any time.

Thinking of selling a Colonnades unit?

Colonnades buyers compare a unit against recent recorded sales, its finish after the rebuild and its rental history, so a seller who prices a white-box unit like a finished one can sit on the market. To plan a sale, start with selling a home on Sanibel or Captiva with McGreevy and Comisar.

Frequently Asked Questions about Colonnades condos for sale

These are the questions buyers ask most often about Colonnades condos for sale, answered from the Lee County roll and sale files, the state condominium extract, the Colony Inn's site, City of Sanibel code and dated listing records. When a fact could not be confirmed for this page, the answer says so plainly.

What is the Colonnades on Sanibel?

The Colonnades is a 36-unit condominium on East Gulf Drive on Sanibel's East End, made up of The Colonnades Condominium at 409 East Gulf Drive and Colonnade Condominium No. 2 at 429 East Gulf Drive. Its one-bedroom units are rented to visitors as The Colony Inn.

Is the Colonnades the same as the Colony Inn?

In practice, yes. The Colony Inn is the on-site rental operation for the Colonnades units, and travel sites list units as Colonnades Condominium C-numbers. Sanibel's code names it as the Colony Resort or the Collonades Condominium program.

Where is the Colonnades?

The Colonnades is at 409 to 431 East Gulf Drive on the East End of Sanibel, near the lighthouse. Lighthouse Beach Park is about 0.9 miles away by road.

What ZIP code is the Colonnades in?

The Colonnades is in ZIP code 33957, the ZIP for all of Sanibel, inside the City of Sanibel in Lee County.

How many units does the Colonnades have?

There are 36 units: 20 in The Colonnades Condominium and 16 in Colonnade Condominium No. 2, plus two common-element parcels for the pool land.

When was the Colonnades built?

The county roll dates the first condominium to 1968 and No. 2 to 1969. The first unit sales recorded in December 1968.

Who built the Colonnades?

No public source we read names the developer. The declarations at Official Records Book 464, Page 376 and Book 553, Page 740 would name the declarant.

How big are Colonnades units?

The county roll lists every unit at 511 heated square feet. Listings quote 540 square feet from the condominium documents, 600 square feet of living area, and 675 square feet in total for one upper unit with its porch.

How many bedrooms do Colonnades units have?

Every Colonnades unit has one bedroom and one bath on the county roll. Rental listings show units sleeping up to four guests.

Does the Colonnades have an elevator?

No. The buildings are two stories with no elevator, according to the roll and listings, so upper units are reached by stairs.

Is the Colonnades on the beach?

The beach is a short walk down a private path and boardwalk, according to the operator and guest reviews, and one guide lists deeded beach access. The buildings do not appear to front the Gulf themselves.

Is there a pool at the Colonnades?

Yes. The Colony Inn lists a heated freshwater pool, and a December 2025 listing said it was nearing completion after storm work. Ask whether both pool parcels have a working pool.

What do Colonnades condos sell for?

Lee County recorded 4 qualified sales from November 2025 to March 2026, from $225,000 to $278,000, at a $263,500 median. The eleven sales since April 2023 ran from $175,000 to $299,900.

What was the most recent Colonnades sale?

The newest qualified sale on the county file is $278,000 for a unit in the first condominium on March 13, 2026.

What is the highest recorded Colonnades sale?

The highest qualified sale on the county file is $455,000, recorded on July 1, 2022, before Hurricane Ian.

How often do Colonnades units sell?

The county recorded 12 qualified sales in the 60 months from November 2021, 7 of them in the 24 months from November 2024.

What are the Colonnades association fees?

Listings from 2024 and 2025 quote $2,700 per quarter, about $900 a month. Ask the association for the current budget.

What does the Colonnades fee cover?

Listings say it covers building insurance, cable, internet, water, sewer, trash, irrigation, laundry, grounds, management, legal and accounting, exterior pest control and pool service.

Are there special assessments at the Colonnades?

No public record of a special assessment was found for this page. Ask for a written list of assessments levied since 2022 and any still being collected.

Is there a CDD at the Colonnades?

No community development district or master association was found. Check the tax bill to confirm.

Can I rent my Colonnades unit nightly?

Guides and recent listings give a one-day minimum through the on-site program. Confirm the rule in the current documents and with the City of Sanibel, and hold a city rental license.

Do I need a rental license?

Yes. Every rented unit needs a City of Sanibel dwelling rental license under Code section 126-1078, and the license number must appear in advertising.

Do rental stays carry tourist tax?

Yes. Lee County's 5 percent tourist development tax and Florida sales tax apply to stays of six months or less.

Are pets allowed at the Colonnades?

A December 2025 listing says owners may keep one pet under 35 pounds, while Colony Inn unit listings say no pets for rental guests. Assistance animal requests follow fair housing law, not the pet limits.

Is the Colonnades a 55 or older community?

No public source describes it as a 55 or older community. Ask the association to confirm in writing.

Is the Colonnades in a flood zone?

The exact zone was not confirmed for this page. Sanibel's zones are AE, AO, VE and X, so check the city's Forerunner portal and the FEMA map for 409 and 429 East Gulf Drive.

Was the Colonnades damaged by Hurricane Ian?

No news report names the complex, but listings from 2024 and 2025 showed it under construction, with units sold as white boxes. The operator now describes all 36 units as completely renovated.

Does the Colonnades need a milestone inspection?

Probably not. Florida's milestone inspection and reserve study rules apply to buildings of three or more habitable stories, and the Colonnades buildings are two stories. Ask the board for written confirmation.

What are property taxes on a Colonnades unit?

Listings showed about $350 to $365 a year for 2024 and 2025, likely reflecting post-storm reductions. The 2026 just values run from $179,094 to $197,621, so expect a buyer's bill to differ.

Do any Colonnades owners have a homestead exemption?

None of the 36 units carries a homestead exemption on the current roll.

What schools serve the Colonnades?

The Sanibel School serves kindergarten through grade 8 on the island, about 12 minutes away. High school students attend on the mainland; confirm the zone with the district.

How far is the Colonnades from the airport?

Southwest Florida International Airport is about 23.1 miles and 41 minutes away in free-flow traffic. Causeway and season traffic add time.

Is the Colonnades part of Colony Beach Estates?

No. Colony Beach Estates is a separate plat of single-family homes on Bella Vista Way next door, with its own owners and sales.

Where do I see Colonnades condos for sale?

Our team posts active Colonnades listings on our current listings search and sends new ones as they come up. Call 239-441-2816 or contact us to set up a search.

About Domain Realty Group on Sanibel

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team serving Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, Sanibel and Captiva included, and our Fort Myers office sits closest to the Sanibel Causeway. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) lead the team and bring over 45 years of combined direct experience.

Meet the agents who would show you a unit on our agents page, read our client reviews or learn more about our team. We tracked every qualified Colonnades sale since the first one in 1968, building by building, before we wrote this page.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Sanibel real estate, Captiva Island homes for sale, Fort Myers homes for sale and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to one of the sources below. No real estate portal or other brokerage is linked, by policy; facts attributed to "listings", "listing records", "guides" or "a broker community page" come from public listing and broker records read November 18, 2026 and are labelled as such. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll and sale files, qualified sales on the 36 Colonnades unit parcels, index built November 18, 2026. Web sources were read November 18 to November 21, 2026 unless another date is shown.

County records

The inn, management and state records

City of Sanibel

Local news and travel coverage

Storms and the coast

Flood maps and insurance

Florida condominium law, taxes and fair housing

Schools

Places, roads and services