Opens in a new tab
Back to Sanibel

Sanibel · Florida · 33957

Bayshore Village Homes for Sale in Sanibel, FL

Bayshore Village homes for sale: 32 single-family homes on Oliva Street, Pyrula Avenue and Junonia Street on the East End of Sanibel, most built from 1979 to 1987 and raised on pilings. Recorded county sales, the plat and its two common tracts, the flood and evacuation zones, the rental rule and the questions to ask before you buy. Updated November 2026.

Aerial photo from January 16, 2023 of the East End of Sanibel Island around Bayshore Village: a grid of single-family homes among trees on parallel streets, with golf fairways and ponds at left and a waterway across the top

Bayshore Village is a recorded subdivision of 32 single-family homes on Oliva Street, Pyrula Avenue and Junonia Street, with one lot on Donax Street, on the East End of Sanibel Island in the City of Sanibel, ZIP 33957, Lee County, and part of our Sanibel homes for sale coverage. It is not a condominium. Most of the homes went up from 1979 to 1987 and sit raised above garages or storage, and the Lee County Property Appraiser recorded 9 qualified sales here from November 2021 through October 8, 2026, from $575,000 to $2,015,000, at a $1,000,000 median. Updated November 2026.

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.

This page covers only the 32 lots of the Bayshore Village plat, Lee County Plat Book 30, Page 143. Several shell-named streets nearby (Donax, Nerita and Cardium among them) carry older East End homes that are outside the plat, and some property sites mix their sales into Bayshore Village results. Every county figure here comes from the 32 parcels whose legal description begins "Bayshore Village," so a home on a neighboring street is not counted even when a listing calls it part of the neighborhood.

Key takeaways for Bayshore Village home buyers

These are the points that matter most when you shop Bayshore Village homes for sale. Each comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and sale file, federal flood and elevation services, Lee County map layers, the City of Sanibel's rental rules as published, or public listing records, and each is covered further down with its source and date.

  • Bayshore Village is 32 detached single-family homes in three blocks (A, B and C) plus Lot 17, recorded in Plat Book 30, Page 143, with two common tracts held by the lot owners.
  • The county roll dates 25 of the 32 homes to 1979 through 1987, two to 1991 and 1994 and five to 2001 through 2015. Heated area runs 1,116 to 3,488 square feet, median 1,609.
  • Twenty homes have 3 bedrooms and 9 have 2. Twenty-four have 2 baths.
  • Lee County recorded 9 qualified sales from November 2021 through October 8, 2026, at a $1,000,000 median, from $575,000 to $2,015,000. The three sales since October 2025 ran $575,000 to $1,150,000.
  • No mandatory homeowners' association dues appear on any listing record read for this page, and no Bayshore Village association filing was found. Each lot carries an undivided interest in the two common tracts.
  • Federal flood map points at three Bayshore Village addresses return Zone AE with a 10-foot base flood elevation, and Lee County places the neighborhood in evacuation Zone A.
  • The City of Sanibel sets a minimum rental period of four consecutive weeks for single-family homes, with a city rental license.
  • Listings describe homes as one to two blocks from the Gulf beach, and every trip off the island crosses the Sanibel Causeway.

Bayshore Village homes for sale right now

Bayshore Village homes for sale are scarce because the plat holds only 32 houses and owners tend to keep them: the county file shows just 9 qualified sales in five years. In November 2026 public listing records showed several homes on the market at once, which is unusual for this street grid, so a buyer has more choice now than in most recent years.

How many homes there are to buy

The Lee County roll counts 32 improved single-family parcels whose legal description starts "Bayshore Village," all in ZIP 33957: 5 in Block A, 16 in Block B, 10 in Block C and Lot 17, which carries no block letter. Two more parcels are the common tracts, coded by the county as common elements, not homes. One Sanibel brokerage page also counts 32 homes. An aggregator summary of the 2025 state tax roll counts 41 homes and 3 vacant lots, but that total appears to sweep in neighboring streets, and the county parcel list for the plat itself shows 32.

What was listed in November 2026

Public listing records read November 13, 2026 showed 1318 Junonia Street asking $824,900 after a cut from $950,000, 645 Oliva Street asking $1,400,000, 640 Oliva Street asking $849,000 after an earlier $999,000 ask, and 1345 Junonia Street pending at an $800,000 ask. These are asking prices reported by listing sites, not recorded sales, and any of them may have changed since.

Where Bayshore Village homes are listed

Bayshore Village homes appear in the multiple listing service under the development name BAYSHORE VILLAGE. Some sites file nearby Pyrula Avenue and Oliva Street homes under the same name even when the lot is outside the plat, so check the legal description on the listing for "Bayshore Village" and Plat Book 30, Page 143 before you treat a home as part of it.

See current listings

To see what is on the market today, search current listings and filter for Sanibel, or ask us for a saved search limited to Oliva Street, Pyrula Avenue and Junonia Street. We check each new listing's legal description against the plat before we send it.

Ready to tour Bayshore Village homes?

Tell us the bedroom count, whether you want room for a pool and how soon you plan to come down, and we will send every matching Bayshore Village listing with the recorded sales of similar homes on the same street. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do Bayshore Village homes sell for?

Bayshore Village sale prices peaked in 2021 and 2022, when the two highest recorded sales closed at $2,015,000 and $1,425,000, and have run lower since: the three sales recorded from October 2025 to October 2026 were $575,000, $800,000 and $1,150,000. These figures count only sales the Lee County Property Appraiser marks as qualified on the 32 plat lots, through the newest sale in the county file, October 8, 2026.

Window Qualified sales Median Low High
November 2021 to October 8, 2026 (60 months) 9 $1,000,000 $575,000 $2,015,000
November 2023 to October 8, 2026 (36 months) 4 $825,000 $575,000 $1,150,000
November 2016 to October 8, 2026 (10 years) 16 $862,500 $565,000 $2,015,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale index, DOR-qualified improved sales on the Bayshore Village plat, index built November 18, 2026.

Every recorded sale since November 2021

Date Address County heated sq ft, beds and baths Price
November 15, 2021 682 Pyrula Ave (built 2002) 3,488, 4 and 4 $2,015,000
March 17, 2022 645 Oliva St (built 1983) 1,827, 3 and 3 $1,301,000
May 31, 2022 750 Oliva St (built 1987) 1,816, 2 and 2 $1,425,000
May 5, 2023 1334 Junonia St (built 1980) 1,356, 3 and 2 $1,000,000
September 21, 2023 1345 Junonia St (built 1985) 1,375, 2 and 2 $1,000,000
February 23, 2024 734 Oliva St (built 1982) 1,468, 2 and 2 $850,000
October 31, 2025 734 Pyrula Ave (built 1979) 2,170, 3 and 2 $1,150,000
November 5, 2025 653 Oliva St (built 1984) 1,650, 3 and 2 $575,000
October 8, 2026 702 Pyrula Ave (built 1979 on the roll) 1,552, 3 and 2 $800,000

Source: Lee County sale index joined to the Lee County parcel roll for year built, heated area, bedrooms and baths.

Sales by calendar year

By calendar year, Lee County recorded 4 qualified Bayshore Village sales in 2021 at an $840,000 median, 2 in 2022 ($1,301,000 and $1,425,000), 2 in 2023 (both $1,000,000), 1 in 2024 ($850,000), 2 in 2025 ($1,150,000 and $575,000) and 1 so far in 2026 ($800,000).

Price per heated square foot

The 2022 and 2023 sales ran about $712 to $785 per county heated square foot. The three sales since October 2025 ran about $348 to $530. The larger 2002 home at 682 Pyrula sold for about $578 per heated foot in 2021. Listing sites often quote a bigger area than the county's heated figure, so a listing's price per foot can look lower than the county number.

The highest recorded sale

The highest qualified sale in the 60-month window is $2,015,000 for 682 Pyrula Avenue on November 15, 2021, a 4-bedroom, 4-bath home of 3,488 heated square feet built in 2002, the largest house on the plat by county heated area.

Settling the 734 Pyrula price

Listing sites reported two different closing prices for 734 Pyrula Avenue in October 2025, $1,150,000 and $1,229,000. The county sale file records $1,150,000 on October 31, 2025, so that is the figure used here. The same home sold for $1,135,500 in April 2019.

Asking prices against closed prices

Listing records show recent sales closing well under their first asks. 702 Pyrula Avenue was listed in January 2025 at $1,559,000 and recorded at $800,000 in October 2026; 653 Oliva Street was listed in June 2025 at $750,000 and recorded at $575,000 in November 2025. Price a home from recorded sales of similar size and condition, not from the asking prices around it.

The longer view

The ten-year window holds 16 qualified sales at an $862,500 median. Recorded prices before Hurricane Ian included $622,000 for 702 Oliva Street in 2016, $660,000 and $725,000 in 2018 and $649,000 and $1,135,500 in 2019.

The island figure

Momentum Research put the 12-month median sale price for all of Sanibel at $910,000 as of September 25, 2026, up 2.0% year over year, with homes closing at 87.7% of original asking price. That figure covers every Sanibel property type, so it is context, not a Bayshore Village benchmark.

Bayshore Village home types, sizes and lots

Bayshore Village homes are detached single-family houses on large lots, nearly all raised on pilings or stilts with parking, storage or a garage below the living floor, and most of them were built in a short burst from 1979 to 1987. Every figure in the table comes from the Lee County parcel roll for the 32 plat lots, with lot sizes from listing records.

Item Value
Property type Single-family, 32 of 32
Year built 1979 to 2015; 25 homes from 1979 to 1987
Heated area 1,116 to 3,488 sq ft; median 1,609
Bedrooms 2 bed 9, 3 bed 20, 4 bed 2, 5 bed 1
Baths 1 bath 1, 2 baths 24, 3 baths 5, 4 baths 2
Streets Oliva St 16, Pyrula Ave 10, Junonia St 5, Donax St 1
Lot size (listing records) About 0.36 to 0.514 acre on the five lots checked

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, index built November 18, 2026; lot sizes from public listing records read November 13, 2026.

Raised construction

Listings for Bayshore Village homes describe stilt or piling construction with the main living area one level up and a garage, carport or storage enclosure below. That design matters for flood insurance and for any renovation, covered further down.

Year built

The county roll dates five homes to 1979, three to 1980, eight to 1981, four to 1982, two to 1983 and one each to 1984, 1985 and 1987. Later homes include 1991 (660 Oliva), 1994 (750 Pyrula), 2001 (639 Donax), 2002 (682 Pyrula), 2003 (705 Oliva), 2004 (726 Pyrula) and 2015 (1326 Junonia).

Heated area against listed area

The county heated figure and a listing's square footage often differ. The roll shows 1,827 heated square feet at 645 Oliva Street, where a listing quotes 2,016, and 1,248 at 1318 Junonia Street, where a listing quotes 1,468. Compare homes on the county figure, then ask the seller what was enclosed or added.

Bedrooms and baths

Twenty homes have 3 bedrooms, 9 have 2, two have 4 and one, 726 Pyrula Avenue, has 5. Twenty-four homes have 2 baths, 5 have 3, two have 4 and one has a single bath.

The largest and smallest homes

The largest homes by county heated area are 682 Pyrula Avenue (3,488 square feet), 710 Oliva Street (2,627), 1326 Junonia Street (2,598), 726 Pyrula Avenue (2,459) and 750 Pyrula Avenue (2,408). The smallest is 742 Oliva Street at 1,116 square feet.

Lots and room for a pool

Lots are large for Sanibel: listing records show 0.36 acre at 702 Pyrula, 0.38 at 734 Pyrula, 0.386 at 653 Oliva, 0.475 at 1318 Junonia and 0.514 on the corner at 645 Oliva. Several listings mention room to add a pool; any pool, addition or new structure needs City of Sanibel approval.

A year-built check worth making

The county roll dates 702 Pyrula Avenue to 1979, while a 2025 listing for the same address said 1993. A difference like that can mean a major rebuild or simply a listing error. Ask for permits and the elevation certificate so you know which parts of the house meet which code.

The plat, the blocks and the common tracts

Bayshore Village is a platted single-family subdivision in Section 30, Township 46 South, Range 23 East, recorded in Lee County Plat Book 30, Page 143. The plat created three lettered blocks of house lots, one unlettered lot and two common tracts, and every lot's legal description carries a share in those tracts.

Blocks A, B and C

Block A holds five lots: 1318, 1326, 1334 and 1342 Junonia Street and 750 Pyrula Avenue. Block B holds 16 lots on Pyrula Avenue and Oliva Street, and Block C holds 10 lots on Oliva Street plus 639 Donax Street. Lot 17, 1345 Junonia Street, carries no block letter in its legal description.

Tract A and Tract B

The county roll lists two common-element parcels on the plat: Tract A of Blocks B and C, carried as Bayshore Village common elements, and Tract B, addressed on Oliva Street. Neither has a building. What each tract is used for, and whether either one is the path behind the "beach rights" that listings mention, is to confirm on the recorded plat drawing.

The undivided interest

Most lot descriptions end "plus undivided interest." One spells it out: 734 Oliva Street carries an undivided 1/32 interest in Tract A of Block B and an undivided 1/32 interest in Tract B of Block C. With 32 lots, that reads as each lot owning an equal share of both tracts. Ask the title company to confirm how the tracts are held and who maintains them.

Beach rights on listings

Several listings name "Beach Rights" and "Beach Access" as association amenities, and one adds "Trails." A brokerage page instead marks deeded beach access as "No." The legal nature of any beach right is not settled in the public sources read for this page, so treat it as a question for the title search, not a feature.

No association found

No Bayshore Village homeowners' association appears in the public sources checked, and an automated search of the state corporation records was blocked, so the absence of an association is to confirm. Listing records show "Assoc. Fees Include: None" and "Management Type: None."

The streets

The plat's streets carry shell names. A 2018 Times of the Islands article on Sanibel street names says Pyrula, Cardium, Nerita and Donax are the genus names of fig, cockle, sea snail and clam shells and places Junonia Street in the same neighborhood. Oliva, the olive shell, is not covered by that article.

Beach access and what is nearby

Bayshore Village sits on the East End of Sanibel between Periwinkle Way and the Gulf, and listings place its homes one to two blocks from the beach. The figures below are straight-line distances from the census-geocoded point at 734 Pyrula Avenue, not driving distances, plus a brokerage's own drive estimates.

Destination Straight-line distance
Gulfside City Park beach About 1.5 mi
Lighthouse Beach Park About 2.2 mi
Sanibel Causeway toll plaza at Punta Rassa About 4.1 mi
HealthPark Medical Center About 5.9 mi
Coconut Point About 15.0 mi
Gulf Coast Town Center About 16.5 mi
Downtown Fort Myers About 17.6 mi
I-75 at Daniels Parkway About 17.7 mi
Southwest Florida International Airport About 19.3 mi
Downtown Naples About 25.9 mi

Source: distances computed from the US Census geocoder point for 734 Pyrula Ave; landmark points approximate.

The walk to the beach

Listings describe 645 Oliva Street as one block from the beach and 1318 Junonia Street as about two blocks, and say 653 Oliva Street is a short walk to two beach accesses.

Public beach parks

Gulfside City Park, about 1.5 miles away in a straight line, and Lighthouse Beach Park at the island's eastern tip, about 2.2 miles, are the nearest public parks with parking. The Southwinds Estates neighborhood sits right beside Gulfside City Park, farther west along the same Gulf shore.

Bike paths

The Donax Street bike path and Sanibel's shared-use path network run close to the plat, so many errands on the East End can be made by bicycle.

Golf nearby

No golf course belongs to Bayshore Village. One listing says a neighborhood course is "right around the corner," and a brokerage page names the Sanibel golf club as nearby. Sanibel's courses completed their hurricane recovery by November 2025, and Sanibel Island Golf Club changed owners in September 2025.

Periwinkle Way and the refuge

A Sanibel brokerage estimates about 3 minutes to the causeway, about 5 minutes to the Periwinkle Way shops and beaches, about 10 minutes to the J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge and about 20 minutes to Captiva. Season traffic on Periwinkle Way can add a good deal to those times.

Off the island

Every trip to Fort Myers, the airport or I-75 crosses the Sanibel Causeway. Drive times are estimates and depend on the season and causeway traffic: roughly 20 to 25 minutes to HealthPark Medical Center and 35 to 45 minutes to the airport, to I-75 at Daniels Parkway and to downtown Fort Myers.

What does it cost to own a Bayshore Village home each year?

Bayshore Village owners carry property tax, homeowner's and flood insurance and the causeway toll, and no mandatory association dues appear on any listing record read for this page. The figures below are what public records and listings show; confirm each one for the address you buy, because taxes and insurance vary home by home.

Charge What the records show Notes
Association dues None shown on listing records "Assoc. Fees Include: None"; one record shows "Other" with no amount
CDD None found Confirm on the Lee County tax bill
Property tax, recent bills $8,195 to $14,543 a year (2024 and 2025) Listing records tied to county tax data
Causeway toll $6 with SunPass, $9 toll-by-plate Charged westbound, onto Sanibel only
Flood insurance Varies with first-floor height Zone AE, 10-foot base flood elevation
Transfer or capital fee None published Confirm with the title company

Source: public listing records read November 13, 2026; Lee County toll standard; FEMA flood map layer.

No mandatory dues on record

Listing records for 653 Oliva Street, 1318 Junonia Street and 702 Pyrula Avenue show "Assoc. Fees Include: None" and "Management Type: None," a record for 645 Oliva Street shows "None," and a brokerage page says there is no HOA. A record for 734 Pyrula Avenue shows "Other" with no amount. Ask the seller whether owners share any voluntary cost for the common tracts.

No CDD found

No community development district appears for Bayshore Village in the sources read, and none is known on Sanibel. Confirm on the Lee County Tax Collector's bill for the address, which lists any non-ad valorem charge.

The causeway toll

The Sanibel Causeway toll is $6 with a SunPass or an interoperable transponder and $9 by plate, charged only on the westbound trip onto the island. Lee County commissioners adopted all-electronic tolling for the county's bridges.

Flood insurance budget

A lender requires flood insurance on a mortgaged home in Zone AE. The premium depends heavily on how far the lowest floor sits above the 10-foot base flood elevation and on what is enclosed below it, so get the elevation certificate and a quote early.

Estoppel and closing items

With no association on record, there may be no estoppel letter to order. Your title company will still search for liens, any recorded restrictions on the plat and any unpaid city charges.

Property taxes on a Bayshore Village home

Bayshore Village homes are taxed by Lee County, the City of Sanibel, the school district and other island taxing districts, and a buyer's bill depends on the purchase price and homestead status, not on the seller's bill. Recent bills on listing records show how widely the figures vary across the 32 homes.

Recent bills on record

Listing records tied to county tax data show $14,543 for 734 Pyrula Avenue (2024), $14,075 for 645 Oliva Street (2024), $13,031 for 702 Pyrula Avenue (2025), $8,195 for 1318 Junonia Street (2025, on a $598,509 assessed value) and $8,705 for 653 Oliva Street (2023).

Why the bills differ

A long-held homestead carries a capped assessed value, while a home bought recently or held as a second home is assessed nearer market value. That is why two similar Bayshore Village homes can carry very different bills.

What resets at a sale

Florida's Save Our Homes cap limits yearly increases on a homestead's assessed value, and the cap resets when a home sells. A buyer's first full tax bill is usually based on a value close to the purchase price, so budget from the price, not from the seller's bill.

Homestead exemption

If the home will be your permanent residence, file for the homestead exemption with the Lee County Property Appraiser by the state deadline. It lowers taxable value and starts the Save Our Homes cap.

Check the millage

The combined millage for a Sanibel address is shown on the Lee County Tax Collector's bill. We did not pull the current rate for this page, so look it up for the exact parcel before you estimate.

Rules for rentals, pets and use in Bayshore Village

Bayshore Village rental limits come from the City of Sanibel's code, not from an association, because no Bayshore Village association or recorded rule set was found in public sources. The points below cover what buyers ask about most; confirm each one with the City of Sanibel and the title search before you rely on it.

The 28-day rental minimum

Sanibel city code limits single-family home rentals to no less than four consecutive weeks under Chapter 126, Article VII, as summarized by a Sanibel real estate guide citing the code. Nightly and weekly rentals are not allowed for these homes. Confirm the current rule with the City of Sanibel.

The city rental license

A rented Sanibel dwelling needs a city dwelling rental license under Section 126-1078 and a business tax receipt. Apply before the first tenant arrives.

Recorded restrictions

We found no recorded declaration of restrictions for Bayshore Village in the public sources read. A plat can still carry notes or restrictions, so ask your title company for every recorded document that touches the lot.

Pets and assistance animals

No Bayshore Village pet rule was found, and one aggregator tags the neighborhood "Dogs and Cats OK." Assistance animals for a person with a disability are a reasonable accommodation under federal and Florida fair housing law, not a pet, and a pet limit does not bar them.

Age

No recorded age restriction was found for Bayshore Village. One aggregator lists it as 55 and over, which no other source supports and which appears to be a data error; confirm with the title search before relying on either.

Building and remodeling

Additions, pools, fences and exterior changes on Sanibel go through the City of Sanibel's planning and building review. Ask the city about setbacks and lot coverage before you plan any change to a Bayshore Village lot.

Is Bayshore Village in a flood zone?

Yes. FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer returns Zone AE, the 1 percent annual chance flood area, with a 10-foot base flood elevation at the three Bayshore Village addresses queried, and Lee County places the neighborhood in evacuation Zone A. Ground level is only about 3 to 4 feet, so the height of each home's living floor is the key flood fact.

Item Bayshore Village
FEMA flood zone AE, base flood elevation 10 ft (coastal floodplain)
FIRM panel 12071C0533G, effective November 17, 2022
Ground elevation About 3.4 to 4.2 ft (NAVD88) at three addresses
Evacuation zone Lee County Zone A (storm surge zone 1)

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, USGS elevation point service and Lee County evacuation-zone layer, queried November 13, 2026.

What the screen covers

The flood points were taken at 734 Pyrula Avenue, 645 Oliva Street and 1318 Junonia Street, and all three returned Zone AE with a 10-foot base flood elevation. A screen is not a determination: confirm each address on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center and with the elevation certificate.

Ground elevation

The USGS 3DEP elevation service gives ground heights of about 3.4 to 4.2 feet at those three addresses. To meet a 10-foot base flood elevation, a living floor has to sit well above the ground, which is why these homes are raised.

Evacuation Zone A

Lee County's evacuation-zone layer places 734 Pyrula Avenue in Zone A, storm surge zone 1. Zone A is the first area ordered out and can be ordered to leave before storm effects arrive, and every Sanibel resident leaves by the causeway.

Hurricane Ian in 2022

Hurricane Ian made landfall on September 28, 2022. Every structure on Sanibel had some damage, storm surge of 9 to 13 feet was reported in parts of the island, and the causeway was cut and later repaired. Damage to individual Bayshore Village homes is to confirm with each seller and the permit record.

Helene and Milton in 2024

Hurricane Helene in September 2024 brought nearly 3 feet of surge to Sanibel, and Hurricane Milton in October 2024 brought surge over 5 feet in some areas of the island. We found no Bayshore Village-specific damage report from either storm.

Seller statements

Some Bayshore Village listings state that the raised living area was not reached in recent storms, and one lists a 2022 metal roof and impact openings. These are seller statements; ask for the inspection report, the insurance claim history and the permits behind them.

Elevation certificates

An elevation certificate shows the height of the lowest floor and of the equipment below it against the base flood elevation. Ask the seller for it, or ask the City of Sanibel's floodplain office whether one is on file.

Insurance and construction for a Bayshore Village home

Bayshore Village homes are fee-simple single-family houses, not condominiums, so the owner insures the whole house, and flood coverage is a separate policy from homeowner's coverage. On older raised homes, insurers and lenders look first at the elevation certificate, the roof and the window and door protection.

Not a condominium

Florida's milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study rules apply to condominium and cooperative buildings of three or more habitable stories. They do not apply to Bayshore Village homes.

The 50 percent rule

Under FEMA's floodplain rules, a home in a flood zone that is substantially improved or substantially damaged, generally work or damage costing 50 percent or more of the structure's market value, must be brought up to current flood elevation standards. For a home built in 1979 to 1984, ask the City of Sanibel whether post-Ian repairs counted toward that limit.

Community Rating System

Sanibel's Community Rating System standing was not downgraded in FEMA's April 2024 review, so flood policyholders kept their discount. FEMA's scale runs from Class 1, a 45 percent discount, to Class 10, no discount; Sanibel's current class is to confirm.

Roof and openings

A Florida homeowner's policy prices the roof's age and type and the protection on windows and doors. Ask for the roof permit date and any impact window or shutter records.

Wind mitigation report

A wind mitigation inspection records roof shape, roof-to-wall connections and opening protection, and can lower the wind part of the premium. Order one with your home inspection.

What sits below the living floor

The ground level under a raised home in Zone AE is generally limited to parking, access and storage. Ask what is enclosed below, whether it has flood vents and whether any finished space was added there, because that affects both insurance and permits.

Schools serving Bayshore Village addresses

Bayshore Village addresses are served by The Sanibel School, a public K to 8 school on the island run by the School District of Lee County, and listing records show the Lee choice zones below. Lee County uses zones with choice, so a zone does not guarantee a seat; confirm the exact address with the district's school locator.

The Sanibel School

The Sanibel School reopened to students on February 8, 2023 after Hurricane Ian, was closed again after Hurricane Milton in October 2024, and began its 2025 to 2026 year on August 11, 2025.

Zones on listing records

Listings for 734 Pyrula Avenue and 645 Oliva Street show Elementary Zone N, Middle Zone L and High School South Zone 5. Zone boundaries change; check the 2026 to 2027 zones for the address.

High school

High school students attend school off the island in Fort Myers. Confirm the assignment with the district's student assignment tool for the address.

A short history of Bayshore Village and the East End

Bayshore Village is a small, late-1970s plat on the East End of Sanibel, the part of the island where homesteading began, and most of its homes were built within a few years of the plat. The public record shows the first recorded sales on the plat in 1979 and steady resales ever since.

The plat and the first homes

The county roll dates the oldest Bayshore Village homes, 747 Oliva Street, 644, 702, 734 and 742 Pyrula Avenue, to 1979, and the county sale file's earliest records on the plat are from 1979 and 1980. The recording date of Plat Book 30, Page 143 and the name of the developer were not found in public sources and are to confirm at the Lee County Clerk.

The shell-named streets

According to Times of the Islands, the Bailey family platted the Donax-area streets in the 1920s between their Periwinkle Way homestead and the Gulf but did not build them out during the Depression. Whether Bayshore Village is a later replat of part of that land is to confirm.

Building through the 1980s

Twenty-five of the 32 homes were built from 1979 to 1987, and no production builder for the plat was named in the public sources read. Later homes went up in 1991, 1994 and from 2001 to 2004, and the newest on the roll, 1326 Junonia Street, dates to 2015.

After the storms

Several homes show renovation after 2021 on listing records, including new metal roofs and impact openings. Resales continued after Ian, with qualified sales recorded in 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026.

What should you check before you make an offer on a Bayshore Village home?

Bayshore Village homes are similar in age and type, so the differences that move value are the elevation of the living floor, the roof and openings, what is enclosed below and the condition after the 2022 and 2024 storms. These checks come straight from the records on this page and keep guesswork out of an offer.

Get the elevation certificate

Ask for the elevation certificate first. It drives the flood premium and tells you how the living floor compares with the 10-foot base flood elevation.

Order a full inspection

A home built around 1980 may carry original pilings, wiring or plumbing next to newer work. Have the structure, roof, electrical, plumbing, air conditioning and the area below the house inspected and priced.

Pull the permit history

Ask the City of Sanibel for the permit history so you know which repairs after Ian, Helene and Milton were permitted and how the city counted them against the 50 percent rule.

Get insurance quotes

Get flood and homeowner's quotes, with a wind mitigation report, before your inspection period ends.

Run the title search on the tracts

Ask the title company to explain the undivided interest in Tract A and Tract B, any plat notes and any recorded easement behind the beach access listings describe.

Check the tax bill

Look up the address on the Lee County Tax Collector's site for the current millage and any non-ad valorem charge, then estimate your own bill from the price.

Confirm the rental rules

If you plan to rent, confirm the four-week minimum and the license steps with the City of Sanibel before you count on rental income.

Bayshore Village and other Sanibel neighborhoods buyers compare

Bayshore Village buyers often compare other single-family neighborhoods on Sanibel with raised homes and short walks to the Gulf. The comparison below sticks to what the records show, and our Sanibel homes for sale page and our Captiva Island homes for sale page cover the wider field.

Neighborhood How it compares with Bayshore Village
Southwinds Estates Small mid-island Gulf-side street beside Gulfside City Park; homes from 1971 to 2009 on the county roll
Herons Landing West End neighborhood of 32 single-family homes, 8 townhomes and 2 lots, deed-restricted, built 1989 to 2017
Gulf Ridge West End neighborhood of 55 parcels on much larger lots, with an association, pools, courts and Gulf-front lots
Sanibel Bayous West End older raised homes on large lots, with a pool, tennis and a small association fee; 139 sites
Donax-area streets Same shell-named East End grid and beach walk, but outside the plat and without its common tracts

Source: Lee County roll and our Sanibel neighborhood pages; Sanibel Bayous from public records summarized in our island research.

Southwinds Estates

Southwinds Estates is another small Gulf-side neighborhood of older single-family homes, farther west beside Gulfside City Park. Compare its recorded sales and lot sizes with Bayshore Village's directly.

Herons Landing

Herons Landing on the West End has the same count of detached homes, 32, but newer construction and recorded deed restrictions, which Bayshore Village does not appear to have.

Gulf Ridge

Gulf Ridge is a West End neighborhood of much larger lots with association amenities and some Gulf frontage, at higher recorded prices.

What Bayshore Village offers and what it does not

Bayshore Village offers raised single-family homes on lots of about a third to half an acre, a short walk to the Gulf beach, no association dues on record and a share in two common tracts. It does not offer a gate, a clubhouse, a community pool, golf or boat docks.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Bayshore Village specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows Sanibel and Captiva homes, including the older raised houses of the East End. We tracked every qualified Bayshore Village sale of the past five years and matched each one to the county roll by year built, heated area and bedroom count to build this page.

★★★★★ "The sale of our home was not without challenges. Jesse and his team worked extremely hard to get us to the closing table and our home sold!!! Would recommend Domain and the great team to anyone!!!"

Verified Zillow review. user63385, on selling a single-family home in Fort Myers with Jesse McGreevy.

Talk to our team about a Bayshore Village home

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816, tell us the bedroom count, the street you prefer and the budget you have in mind, and an agent will send matching listings, recent recorded sales on Oliva, Pyrula and Junonia and the flood and title questions for the home. You can also search current listings any time.

Thinking of selling a Bayshore Village home?

Bayshore Village buyers weigh the living-floor elevation, the roof and the storm record as much as the bedroom count, so a home priced against recorded plat sales of similar age and size sells faster than one priced against an island-wide median. Start with a free home valuation from our team, and for the selling side, see McGreevy and Comisar's guide to selling a home on Sanibel and Captiva.

Frequently Asked Questions about Bayshore Village homes for sale

These are the questions buyers ask most about Bayshore Village homes for sale, answered from the Lee County roll and sale file, federal flood and elevation services, Lee County map layers, the City of Sanibel's rules as published and public listing records. Where a fact was not confirmed for this page, the answer says so in plain words.

What is Bayshore Village on Sanibel?

A recorded subdivision of 32 single-family homes on Oliva Street, Pyrula Avenue and Junonia Street, with one lot on Donax Street, on the East End of Sanibel, FL 33957.

Is Bayshore Village a condominium?

No. It is a platted single-family subdivision, Lee County Plat Book 30, Page 143, and each owner holds the house and lot.

How many homes are in Bayshore Village?

Thirty-two, per the Lee County parcel roll for the plat, plus two common tracts. One aggregator's count of 41 homes appears to include neighboring streets.

What streets are in Bayshore Village?

Oliva Street (16 homes), Pyrula Avenue (10), Junonia Street (5) and Donax Street (1).

What ZIP code is Bayshore Village in?

All 32 parcels are in ZIP 33957, City of Sanibel, Lee County.

When were Bayshore Village homes built?

The county roll dates 25 homes to 1979 through 1987 and the rest to 1991 through 2015.

How big are Bayshore Village homes?

County heated area runs 1,116 to 3,488 square feet, median 1,609.

How many bedrooms do Bayshore Village homes have?

Twenty have 3 bedrooms, 9 have 2, two have 4 and one has 5.

How big are the lots?

Listing records show about 0.36 to 0.514 acre on the five lots checked.

Are the homes raised?

Listings describe nearly all of them as raised on pilings or stilts, with parking or storage below.

What do Bayshore Village homes sell for?

The 60-month median to October 8, 2026 is $1,000,000 across 9 qualified sales, from $575,000 to $2,015,000.

What was the most recent recorded sale?

702 Pyrula Avenue, $800,000, on October 8, 2026.

What is the highest recorded sale?

$2,015,000 for 682 Pyrula Avenue on November 15, 2021.

What is the price per square foot?

The three sales since October 2025 ran about $348 to $530 per county heated square foot.

How many homes sell each year?

One to four a year since 2021 in the county file, 9 in five years.

Does Bayshore Village have an HOA?

No association appears on listing records or in the public sources read; that is to confirm on the title search.

Are there HOA fees in Bayshore Village?

Listing records show "Assoc. Fees Include: None." Ask whether owners share any voluntary cost for the common tracts.

Is there a CDD?

None was found; confirm on the Lee County tax bill.

What are the property taxes?

Recent bills on listing records run $8,195 to $14,543 a year, depending on homestead status and assessed value.

Does Bayshore Village have beach access?

Listings describe homes one to two blocks from the beach and name beach rights, while one brokerage page says deeded access is "No." Confirm on the title search.

What are Tract A and Tract B?

Two common-element parcels on the plat in which each lot holds an undivided interest, 1/32 each on one lot's description.

Is Bayshore Village gated?

No. A listing describes it as non-gated.

Is there a pool or clubhouse?

No. The plat has no clubhouse, community pool, tennis or golf.

Can I rent my Bayshore Village home?

Yes, for no less than four consecutive weeks under Sanibel city code, with a city rental license and a business tax receipt.

Are pets allowed?

No Bayshore Village pet rule was found. Assistance animals are a reasonable accommodation, not a pet.

Is Bayshore Village a 55+ community?

No recorded age restriction was found; one aggregator's 55+ tag appears to be an error. Confirm on the title search.

Is Bayshore Village in a flood zone?

Yes, Zone AE with a 10-foot base flood elevation at the three addresses queried, on panel 12071C0533G.

Is flood insurance required?

A lender requires it on a mortgaged home in Zone AE.

What evacuation zone is Bayshore Village in?

Lee County evacuation Zone A, storm surge zone 1.

How did Hurricane Ian affect Bayshore Village?

Every Sanibel structure had some Ian damage. Damage to each Bayshore Village home is to confirm with the seller and the permit record.

What schools serve Bayshore Village?

The Sanibel School (K to 8) on the island; listings show Elementary Zone N, Middle Zone L and High School South Zone 5.

How far is Bayshore Village from the airport?

About 19.3 miles in a straight line to Southwest Florida International Airport, roughly 35 to 45 minutes by road across the causeway.

How much is the causeway toll?

$6 with SunPass and $9 by plate, westbound onto the island only.

Where do I see Bayshore Village homes for sale?

Our team posts active listings on our current listings search and sends new ones as they come on the market. Call 239-441-2816 or contact us to set up a search.

About Domain Realty Group on Sanibel

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team working Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, including Sanibel and Captiva, from offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers, the closest of them across the causeway from the island. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. The team is led by Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671), who bring over 45 years of combined direct experience between them.

Reach any of our agents through our agents page, read our client reviews or learn more about our team. We tracked the recorded sales on all 32 Bayshore Village lots, home by home, to build this page.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Sanibel homes for sale, Southwinds Estates homes for sale, Herons Landing homes for sale, Captiva Island homes for sale and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to one of the sources below. No real estate portal is linked, by policy; facts attributed to "listings" or "broker pages" are labelled as such. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll and sale files, qualified sales on the 32 Bayshore Village plat lots, index built November 18, 2026. Web sources were read November 13 to November 21, 2026 unless another date is shown.

County records and plat

City of Sanibel

Listings and broker pages (read, not linked by policy)

  • Broker page, Pfeifer Realty Group, About Bayshore Village (32 homes, no HOA, drive estimates, deeded beach access; read November 13, 2026)
  • Broker page, Homes by Marco, Bayshore Village subdivision (year built and size ranges, taxes; read November 13, 2026)
  • Aggregator page, Neighborhoods.com, Bayshore Village (median sale price and size range; read November 13, 2026)
  • Aggregator page, Momentum, Bayshore Village (2025 state roll summary; read November 13, 2026)
  • Aggregator page, Subdivisions.com, Bayshore Village single-family homes (pet and age tags; search snippet, November 13, 2026)
  • Public listing records for 653 Oliva St, 1318 Junonia St and 702 Pyrula Ave (sale history, fees, taxes, lot sizes; read November 13, 2026)
  • Public listing records for 734 Pyrula Ave, 645 Oliva St and 653 Oliva St (legal descriptions, school zones, beach rights, taxes; read November 13, 2026)
  • Public listing records for 640 Oliva St, 1345 Junonia St, 734 Oliva St and 829 Pyrula Ave (asks and look-alike addresses; read November 13, 2026)
  • Momentum Research, Sanibel home values (updated September 25, 2026)

Flood, storms and insurance

Florida law and fair housing

Schools

Places, roads and services