Opens in a new tab
Back to Sanibel

Sanibel · Florida · 33957

Colony Beach Estates Homes for Sale in Sanibel, FL

Colony Beach Estates homes for sale: 18 two-story single-family pool homes on Bella Vista Way, set between East Gulf Drive and the Gulf on Sanibel's East End. Recorded county sales, the two land tiers, the common beach tract, flood zones, fees and the questions to ask before you buy. Updated November 2026.

Aerial photo from January 16, 2023 of Colony Beach Estates in Sanibel, FL 33957: a tight cluster of two-story single-family homes with pools on two short curving streets, open dune land and beach to the south, and other homes and roads around the edges

Colony Beach Estates is an 18-home single-family subdivision on the East End of Sanibel homes for sale, ZIP 33957, Lee County, with every house on two short private streets, Bella Vista Way East (401 to 435) and Bella Vista Way West (439 to 445), between East Gulf Drive and the Gulf of Mexico. All 18 lots hold two-story homes built from 1988 to 1990, and a 4.50-acre common tract owned by the homeowners association lies on the Gulf side of the lots. Lee County records 11 qualified home sales since 2013, from $1,350,000 to $2,700,000, at a $2,000,000 median, with the newest on May 15, 2024. Updated November 2026.

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.

This page covers only the 18 recorded lots and the common Tract B of Colony Beach Estates. It sits under our Sanibel real estate page, which covers the whole island. One point to settle first: the Colonnades, also known as the Colony Inn, at 409 to 431 East Gulf Drive, is a separate condominium with its own owners, its own sales and its own rules. It shares the "Colony" name through the old resort that once stood along this shore, but it is not part of Colony Beach Estates and none of its sales are counted on this page.

Key takeaways for Colony Beach Estates home buyers

Colony Beach Estates buyers tend to start with the same short list: how close each house is to the sand, what the homes have recorded for since 2013, what the flood map says and what the dues cover. Each point below draws on the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale files, the FEMA flood layer, City of Sanibel rules or listing remarks, and each is explained further down with its date.

  • Colony Beach Estates has 18 single-family homes in two recorded plats: Phase 1, Plat Book 40, Page 41 (Lots 1 to 3 on Bella Vista Way West) and Phase II, Plat Book 42, Page 17 (Lots 4 to 18 on Bella Vista Way East, plus Tract B).
  • Every lot is improved. There are no vacant lots and no condominium units in the subdivision.
  • Tract B, a 4.50-acre common tract owned by the homeowners association, lies on the Gulf side of the lots at 400 Bella Vista Way East.
  • All 18 homes are two-story houses from 1988 to 1990 with 2,949 to 3,340 heated square feet, a garage on every lot and a private pool on 17 of 18.
  • The appraiser splits the lots into a Gulf tier (14 lots) and an interior tier (Lots 8, 9, 11 and 15), and the split shows up clearly in sale prices.
  • Lee County records 11 qualified home sales since 2013, $1,350,000 to $2,700,000, median $2,000,000. The newest is $2,000,000 for 417 Bella Vista Way East on May 15, 2024.
  • On the FEMA flood layer, 11 lot centers and Tract B fall in Zone VE with a 13-foot base flood elevation, and 7 lot centers fall in Zone AE at 12 feet.
  • Listing remarks describe the community as gated with deeded beach access across the common land; neither is confirmed by a city or county record, so check the association documents.

Colony Beach Estates homes for sale right now

Colony Beach Estates homes for sale are rare because the subdivision has only 18 houses and no lots left to build on. Lee County's file shows no qualified home sale since May 15, 2024, so a buyer who wants this street usually keeps a saved search running and is ready to move when a house with the right lot tier and condition comes up.

How many homes there are to buy

The 2026 parcel roll lists 19 parcels under the Colony Beach Estates legal descriptions: 18 home lots and the association's Tract B at 400 Bella Vista Way East. All 19 sit in the City of Sanibel tax district and ZIP 33957.

The spelling quirk on the roll

Lot 16, 407 Bella Vista Way East, is keyed on the county roll as "CONLONY BEACH ESTS," with an extra letter. A plain "Colony Beach" search returns only 17 homes and misses that lot's sales. Every count on this page includes it.

Not the Colonnades or the Colony Inn

The Colonnades / Colony Inn condominium at 409 to 431 East Gulf Drive sits on the same block and carries a similar name, but it is a 36-unit condominium recorded on its own. Its prices, rental program and association are unrelated to the homes on Bella Vista Way, so a condo sale there should never be compared with a house sale here.

Not the Colony Beach and Tennis Resort

The Colony Beach and Tennis Resort on Longboat Key, near Sarasota, is a different property in a different county. Searches for "Colony Beach" often mix the two.

See current listings

To see what is on the market today, search current listings and filter for Sanibel, or ask us to set a saved search on Bella Vista Way East and West that flags each address's lot tier and flood zone.

Ready to tour Colony Beach Estates homes?

Tell us whether you want a Gulf-tier lot or one of the four interior lots, how much updating you are willing to do and when you want to close, and we will send each matching Colony Beach Estates listing with the recorded sales on the street. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do Colony Beach Estates homes sell for?

Colony Beach Estates prices on the county record sit in the low-to-mid seven figures, with a wide gap between Gulf-tier and interior lots. All figures in this section are Lee County Property Appraiser and Florida Department of Revenue qualified improved sales on the 19 Colony Beach Estates parcels, index built November 18, 2026, newest sale May 15, 2024.

Window Qualified sales Median Low High
2013 to May 15, 2024 11 $2,000,000 $1,350,000 $2,700,000
All recorded history, October 1988 to May 15, 2024 28 $1,550,000 $725,000 $2,725,000
Resales only, all history 24 $1,725,000 $725,000 $2,725,000
First sales of new homes (builder-direct estimate) 4 $935,000 $865,000 $1,010,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale index, qualified improved sales on the Colony Beach Estates plats (including the roll record spelled "Conlony"), ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026. The Colonnades condominium is excluded.

Every qualified sale since 2013

Date Address and lot Land tier and county heated sq ft Price
March 2013 Lot not matched in our file to confirm $1,500,000
July 2013 407 Bella Vista Way E, Lot 16 Gulf, 3,041 $2,600,000
January 15, 2014 431 Bella Vista Way E, Lot 5 Gulf, 3,240 $2,400,000
June 10, 2015 428 Bella Vista Way E, Lot 9 Interior, 3,240 $1,600,000
March 20, 2017 407 Bella Vista Way E, Lot 16 Gulf, 3,041 $2,700,000
June 29, 2017 408 Bella Vista Way E, Lot 15 Interior, 3,340 $1,350,000
May 30, 2018 411 Bella Vista Way E, Lot 14 Gulf, 3,240 $1,950,000
August 24, 2018 413 Bella Vista Way E, Lot 13 Gulf, 3,240 $2,400,000
April 9, 2019 401 Bella Vista Way E, Lot 18 Gulf, 3,240 $2,500,000
February 16, 2021 418 Bella Vista Way E, Lot 11 Interior, 3,340 $1,700,000
May 15, 2024 417 Bella Vista Way E, Lot 12 Gulf, 3,340 $2,000,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale files joined to the 2026 parcel roll for land tier and heated area. Rows before about 2013 in the state file carry month precision only.

Gulf tier against interior lots

Split by the appraiser's land tiers, the seven Gulf-tier sales since 2013 ran $1,950,000 to $2,700,000 with a median of $2,400,000. The three interior-lot sales in the same years, Lots 9, 11 and 15, ran $1,350,000 to $1,700,000 with a median of $1,600,000. That gap of roughly $800,000 at the median is the single biggest driver of price on this street.

Price per heated square foot

The ten matched sales since 2013 worked out to about $404 to $888 per county heated square foot. The high end is 407 Bella Vista Way East at $2,700,000 on 3,041 heated square feet in March 2017; the low end is 408 Bella Vista Way East at $1,350,000 on 3,340 square feet in June 2017. The May 2024 sale came to about $599 per heated square foot.

The record qualified sale

The highest qualified price in the county file is $2,725,000 for 401 Bella Vista Way East (Lot 18) on May 26, 2006. Prices from 2003 to 2006 ran $2,350,000 to $2,725,000 on the record, and the market has not recorded a higher qualified figure since.

A deed that is not a comparable

The largest recorded deed amount on the street is $4,800,000 for 435 Bella Vista Way East (Lot 4) on February 22, 2022. The county did not qualify that transfer as an arm's-length sale, so we leave it out of every count above and do not treat it as a market price. Why it was not qualified is to confirm.

Deeds since the last qualified sale

Through the November 2026 index there is no qualified home sale after May 15, 2024. Deeds recorded in 2025 on Lot 17 (April, July and December) and Lot 11 (December) carried $0 to $100 of consideration, which is typical of trust or estate transfers. Whether any of them was an arm's-length sale the county had not yet coded is to confirm.

The builder-era prices

The first recorded sale on the plat was Lot 2 as vacant land at $875,000 in February 1988. Qualified builder-era home sales then ran $865,000 (Lot 5, October 1988), $1,010,000 (Lot 6, October 1988), $875,000 (Lot 17, November 1988) and $995,000 (Lot 16, January 1989). The lowest qualified sale in the file is $725,000 for Lot 9 in February 1994.

Value on the county roll

The 2026 roll sets just values of $1,933,980 to $2,238,062 on most Gulf-tier homes and $843,322 to $1,077,224 on the four interior-tier homes. Each Gulf-tier lot carries a 2026 land value of $1,340,817, down from $1,447,092 on the 2025 roll, while the interior lots carry land values of $257,254 to $344,759. Just value is the county's tax estimate, not a sale price.

Two vacant parcels on the same street

Two vacant parcels at 385 and 395 Bella Vista Way East, about 0.41 acre each, sold as land in February 2024 for $1,215,000 and $1,275,000. They share the street name but sit in Section 21 outside both Colony Beach Estates plats, so they are not counted here. Whether they share the gate or the association is to confirm.

Colony Beach Estates home types, sizes and lots

Colony Beach Estates homes are detached two-story single-family houses on small cluster lots, all built in one short burst from 1988 to 1990 and close in size and plan. The figures below come from the Lee County parcel roll for 2026, covering all 18 improved lots, and none of them comes from a listing.

Item Value
Property type Single-family, 18 improved lots, no vacant lots, no condos
Year built 1988 (12 homes), 1989 (2 homes), 1990 (4 homes)
Effective year built, 2026 roll 1994 to 2004
Heated area 2,949 to 3,340 sq ft
Total area under roof 5,340 to 6,445 sq ft
Bedrooms 3 bed 10 homes, 4 bed 7 homes, 2 bed 1 home
Baths 3 to 4
Private pool 17 homes (none recorded at 417 Bella Vista Way E)
Garage All 18 homes
Lot size 0.083 to 0.209 GIS acre
Common land Tract B, 4.50 GIS acres, owned by the association

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and Florida DOR tax roll, 2026.

Two-story homes from one building burst

Twelve homes carry a 1988 year built, two carry 1989 (Lots 12 and 13) and four carry 1990 (Lots 8, 9, 11 and 15). No home has been demolished and replaced: every original year built on the roll is still 1988 to 1990.

Near-identical floor areas

Ten homes show exactly 3,240 heated square feet and five show 3,340 on the roll; the other three are 2,949 (439 Bella Vista Way West), 3,041 (407 Bella Vista Way East) and 3,049 (435 Bella Vista Way East). That pattern points to one builder working from a small set of plans, though the builder's name is to confirm.

Heated area against total area

Total area under roof runs 5,340 to 6,445 square feet, roughly double the heated area on most homes. That fits living space above ground-level garage and storage areas. Whether each house sits on pilings, stem walls or a slab is not shown in the bulk roll file and is to confirm from the field card and an elevation certificate.

Bedrooms and baths

The roll counts ten three-bedroom homes, seven four-bedroom homes and one two-bedroom home (435 Bella Vista Way East), each with three or four baths. Interior plans may have changed in later remodels, so the listing and the county card can differ.

Private pools and garages

Seventeen homes carry a private pool on the roll; 417 Bella Vista Way East does not. All 18 carry a garage. The subdivision has no shared pool, so each pool is the owner's to maintain unless the association documents say otherwise.

Small cluster lots

Lots run from 0.083 to 0.209 GIS acre, and the 18 lots together total about 2.28 acres. Add Tract B's 4.50 acres and the subdivision covers about 6.8 acres, or roughly 2.7 homes per gross acre. The open land is shared rather than split into yards.

Renovations shown by effective year

The 2026 roll gives effective years built of 1994 to 2004, well after the original 1988 to 1990 dates. That is the appraiser's signal that most homes have been substantially updated at least once.

Phase 1 and Phase II at a glance

Part Lots and addresses Homes Year built Heated size
Phase 1, PB 40 PG 41 Lots 1 to 3, 439 to 445 Bella Vista Way W 3 1988 2,949 to 3,240 sq ft
Phase II, PB 42 PG 17 Lots 4 to 18, 401 to 435 Bella Vista Way E 15 1988 to 1990 3,041 to 3,340 sq ft
Tract B, Phase II 400 Bella Vista Way E none roll created 1995 n/a

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, 2026.

The Gulf tier, the interior lots and Tract B

Colony Beach Estates lots are not all equal, and the county's own land values say so plainly. The appraiser puts 14 lots in a Gulf land tier and four in an interior tier, and the shared Tract B sits between the homes and the beach. Reading which tier a house is in is the first step in comparing prices.

The 14 Gulf-tier lots

Lots 1 to 7, 10, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17 and 18 carry neighborhood code 6118400 and a 2026 land value of $1,340,817 each. These are the lots with the most direct outlook across the common land toward the Gulf, though a view from any one house is to confirm in person.

The four interior lots

Lots 8, 9, 11 and 15, at 430, 428, 418 and 408 Bella Vista Way East, carry neighborhood code 6118000 and 2026 land values of $257,254 to $344,759. They are the lowest-priced homes on the street on both the roll and the sale record, and all four were built in 1990.

Tract B, the common element

Tract B at 400 Bella Vista Way East is 4.50 GIS acres and is owned by "COLONY BEACH ESTS HOMEOWNERS," in care of Island Mgmt Group, PO Box 100, Sanibel. Its parcel point lies seaward of the homes, so it is the land owners cross to reach the beach. What the tract holds on the ground, from dune to paths to open space, is to confirm from the recorded plat.

The deeded beach access

Listing remarks describe deeded beach access across the association's land. No city or county record read for this page confirms the access path or its terms, so ask the association for the recorded easement or plat note before closing.

The gate

Listing remarks call Colony Beach Estates gated and describe it as one of only a few gated communities on Sanibel. No city or county record found confirms the gate, its type or how entry works, so confirm it with the association.

The two private streets

Bella Vista Way East and Bella Vista Way West are short private ways that serve only the Colony Beach Estates homes and Tract B, entered from East Gulf Drive. Road maintenance is listed as an association cost in listing remarks.

The plats, the association and the City's view

Colony Beach Estates is a small recorded subdivision with a homeowners association that owns the common tract rather than a condominium that owns the buildings. Knowing how the two plats, the association and the City's planning view fit together helps a buyer read a title report and an estoppel certificate.

Plat Book 40, Page 41

Phase 1 created Lots 1 to 3 on Bella Vista Way West. The roll gives those lot parcels a 1988 creation year. The plat's recording date and its developer of record are to confirm from the plat image at the Lee County Clerk.

Plat Book 42, Page 17

Phase II created Lots 4 to 18 on Bella Vista Way East and Tract B. The lot parcels show a 1989 creation year on the roll, and Tract B shows 1995, probably the year the common parcel was split out on the roll; that reason is to confirm.

Section, township and range

The subdivision lies in Section 20, Township 46 South, Range 23 East. Its parcel points run about 26.4467 to 26.4479 north latitude and 82.0235 to 82.0251 west longitude.

The roll names the Tract B owner as "COLONY BEACH ESTS HOMEOWNERS." The full legal name, its Florida corporate document number, status and officers are to confirm on the state's Division of Corporations search, which did not respond to our automated request.

The management company

The roll mails Tract B in care of Island Mgmt Group. A directory profile lists Island Management Group at 711 Tarpon Bay Road, Sanibel, as a manager of island associations of 2 to 99 units. The manager is the usual source for an estoppel certificate.

The City's cluster example

At hearings on September 8, 2025, City of Sanibel staff described a cluster development of duplex and/or single-family homes and named Victoria Way, Colony Beach Estates and Ferry Landing as examples. That is the City using the layout as a planning model, not a statement about any one home.

Kinzie Island next door

Kinzie Island S/D, a 22-home subdivision recorded in the same plat book run (Plat Book 40, Pages 43 to 44), adjoins Colony Beach Estates to the east. It has its own lots, larger homes and its own sale record, so it is compared separately below.

Where is Colony Beach Estates?

Colony Beach Estates is on the Gulf side of East Gulf Drive on Sanibel's East End, east of the junction of Periwinkle Way and East Gulf Drive, with the Colonnades condominium to the west and Kinzie Island to the east. Drive times below come from one routing request from the Lot 15 parcel point and are free-flow times.

Destination Road distance Free-flow drive
Lighthouse Beach Park 0.8 mi 3 min
HealthPark Medical Center, Fort Myers 9.0 mi 18 min
Bell Tower area, US 41 and Daniels Pkwy 16.5 mi 30 min
Downtown Fort Myers, River District 19.6 mi 38 min
I-75 Exit 131, Daniels Pkwy 20.6 mi 36 min
Gulf Coast Town Center 21.7 mi 39 min
Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) 23.1 mi 41 min
Coconut Point, Estero 24.2 mi 41 min
Downtown Naples, Fifth Avenue South 42.0 mi 70 min

Source: OSRM public routing engine, one request from 26.44788 N, 82.02380 W, November 18, 2026. Times include no toll plaza, causeway backup or seasonal traffic.

Getting there from the causeway

Coming off the Sanibel Causeway, the usual route is left on Periwinkle Way, right on East Gulf Drive and then into Bella Vista Way. In season, add time for the toll plaza and Summerlin Road traffic; the free-flow figures above do not.

The causeway and toll

The island is reached only by the three-mile Sanibel Causeway. The toll is charged inbound only: $6 with a transponder or $9 by mail, and a LeeWay unlimited pass costs $400 a year.

Lighthouse Beach Park

Lighthouse Beach Park and the Sanibel Lighthouse are about 0.8 road mile east, roughly three minutes by car. The park has a Gulf beach, a bay beach and a fishing pier, which is being replaced.

Groceries and dining

The Periwinkle Way corridor holds the island's groceries, shops and restaurants. Bailey's General Store at Periwinkle Way and Tarpon Bay Road was rebuilding after Hurricane Ian, with an interim store open since August 2025.

Hospital and mainland trips

There is no hospital on the island. HealthPark Medical Center is about 9.0 miles and 18 minutes away in free-flow traffic, and the airport is about 23.1 miles.

Captiva and the rest of the island

Captiva sits at the far west end beyond Blind Pass. Buyers comparing both islands can read our Captiva Island homes for sale page; for more Sanibel houses on the bay side of the same end of the island, see our Ferry Landing homes for sale page.

The beach, the path and what is close by

Colony Beach Estates is a short walk or ride from the island's east tip, and the community's own beach lies beyond Tract B. This section covers what owners have nearby and what the community itself does not include, using county, city and news sources dated below.

The Gulf beach beyond Tract B

The common tract lies on the Gulf side of the lots, and the beach lies beyond it. Fourteen lots sit in the Gulf land tier. The exact route of the owners' path across the tract is to confirm with the association.

The shared-use path

The island's shared-use path runs along East Gulf Drive toward Lighthouse Beach Park. Lee County's March 2026 beach and shoreline report showed Phase 1 resurfacing done and Phase 2 set for summer 2026; the finish date is to confirm.

The fishing pier project

Lee County's beach program lists a Lighthouse Beach Park fishing pier project of $2,148,209 for fiscal 2026, paid from tourist tax. Parking-lot regrading for Ian recovery ran in June 2026, with park access kept open.

Beach renourishment at the lighthouse

From 2024 into early 2025, about 105,000 tons of sand went onto the bayside beach at Lighthouse Beach Park, with about 29,000 dune plants set in afterward, according to local news coverage.

Golf

There is no golf in Colony Beach Estates and no bundled membership. Island golf is at The Dunes, Sanctuary Golf Club and Sanibel Island Golf Club, each with its own terms.

What is not here

No clubhouse, tennis court, pickleball court, dock or marina appears on the roll or in any primary record for Colony Beach Estates. Listing remarks mention a gazebo on the common land; that is to confirm with the association.

What does it cost to own a Colony Beach Estates home?

Colony Beach Estates ownership costs come from four places: association dues, City of Sanibel and county property taxes, flood and wind insurance, and the causeway toll. The association does not publish its budget, so the dues figures below are from listing remarks and are labelled that way.

Cost What we found Source type
Association dues About $2,000 to $2,500 per quarter Listing remarks, to confirm
CDD None County roll
City operating millage, FY2026-27 (proposed) 2.5000 mills plus 0.1000 voted debt Local news, City hearings
Fire district millage (tentative) 1.3915 mills Local news
Library millage (tentative) 0.4677 mills Local news
Causeway toll $6 transponder, $9 by mail, inbound only Island research file
Flood insurance Required by lenders in Zones VE and AE FEMA, City of Sanibel

The dues and what they cover

Listing remarks put the association fee at about $2,000 to $2,500 a quarter. They say it covers common-area mowing and landscaping, care of the private pools, a gazebo, road maintenance, street lights, irrigation water, pest control, common-area insurance and reserves. Only the association's estoppel certificate gives the current figure.

No CDD

The parcels pay City of Sanibel, Sanibel Fire District and county levies, with no community development district on the roll.

Property tax on a purchase

Florida resets the assessed value to market value after a sale, so a buyer's first bill can run well above the seller's. Final FY2026-27 millage rates for the City, fire district and library were adopted in September 2026 and are to confirm against the Tax Collector's bill.

Homestead and the Save Our Homes cap

Eight of the 18 homes carry a homestead exemption on the 2026 roll. A buyer who makes a home a primary residence can apply for the homestead exemption of up to $50,000, and Save Our Homes then caps yearly assessed-value growth at 3 percent or CPI, whichever is lower.

Estoppel and disclosure

Florida's homeowners' association law, Chapter 720, lets a buyer request an estoppel certificate with dues, assessments and any amounts owed, and requires a disclosure summary before sale. Ask for both early.

Transfer or capital fees

No transfer fee or capital contribution was found in public sources. Ask the association or manager whether one applies at closing.

Water and utilities

Island Water Association, a non-profit member-owned utility, supplies drinking water and has said updated rates take effect January 1, 2027, with irrigation barred from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. LCEC supplies electricity. Central sewer on the island is the City-owned Donax facility; service on Bella Vista Way itself is to confirm.

Rules for renting, pets and changes at Colony Beach Estates

Colony Beach Estates owners answer to two sets of rules: the City of Sanibel's land development code and the association's recorded documents. Where this page could not read a rule, it says so, and the association's declaration is the document to ask for before an offer.

Rentals and the four-week minimum

The City of Sanibel code allows a dwelling outside the Resort Housing District to be rented for no less than four consecutive weeks. Whether these lots sit inside or outside that district, and any stricter association limit, are to confirm with the City and the association.

Rental licensing

Sanibel requires owners who rent a dwelling to hold a City rental registration. Confirm the current form and fee with the City before you count on rental income.

Pets and assistance animals

No pet rule for Colony Beach Estates was found in public sources; confirm with the association's declaration and rules. Assistance animals are not pets under fair housing law, and a pet limit does not bar a reasonable accommodation request.

Changes, permits and the City

Exterior work, pools, fences and additions on Sanibel need City permits, and the association may require its own approval first. Permit history for each address is in the City's EnerGov portal for existing permits and CityView for new ones.

Height limits

The City caps building height at 45 feet NAVD and no more than three stories above base flood elevation. A June 2026 ordinance lets existing homes be raised up to 10 feet regardless of the height and angle-of-light limits; check its final terms with the City.

Is Colony Beach Estates in a flood zone?

Yes. Every Colony Beach Estates lot center sits in a FEMA special flood hazard area, either coastal Zone VE or Zone AE. These zones come from the effective FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer (DFIRM 12071C) checked against each county parcel point in November 2026; a parcel point is a center, not a building footprint.

Zone Base flood elevation (NAVD88) Lots by parcel center
VE 13 ft Lots 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 10, 16, 17, 18 and Tract B
AE 12 ft Lots 8, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15
VE 15 ft Beach and nearshore seaward of the community

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, Esri-hosted copy, DFIRM 12071C version 2.4.3.5, point-in-polygon on Lee County parcel points, November 18, 2026.

Zone VE lots at 13 feet

The VE 13 lots are 445, 443 and 439 Bella Vista Way West and 435, 431, 429, 425, 427, 407, 403 and 401 Bella Vista Way East. Zone VE is the coastal high hazard area, where wave action sets stricter building and insurance rules.

Zone AE lots at 12 feet

The AE 12 lots are 430, 428, 418, 417, 413, 411 and 408 Bella Vista Way East. These include all four interior lots and three Gulf-tier lots on the east end of the street.

Points are not a determination

A building can straddle two zones. The City's Forerunner flood portal shows the most restrictive zone on each parcel and any elevation certificate on file, and a lender's flood determination is the one that counts for a mortgage.

Evacuation Zone A

Sanibel is in Lee County evacuation Zone A, which county officials called very vulnerable at a May 2026 island storm seminar. The City says 2024 residential re-entry permits remain valid for 2026.

Flood insurance and the CRS discount

Sanibel holds a Community Rating System Class 5, which gives NFIP policyholders a 25 percent discount, and the City has been in the NFIP since 1979. In Zone VE the premium depends heavily on the elevation of the lowest horizontal structural member, so the elevation certificate matters.

Storm history buyers ask about

Colony Beach Estates sits on the Gulf side of the island's East End, so buyers ask about Hurricane Ian in 2022 and the 2024 storms first. No public report names Colony Beach Estates, so this section uses island-wide sources and what the county roll itself records on these 18 lots.

Hurricane Ian, September 28, 2022

SCCF's high-water-mark analysis found Sanibel flooding possibly up to 10 feet above ground in places, with Gulf-facing shores hit harder than bay shores. How each home here fared is to confirm with the seller and the permit file.

What the 2025 roll records

The 2025 tax roll carries the state's hurricane disaster code on Lots 2, 5, 9 and 13 with disaster year 2022, and on Lots 15 and 16 with disaster year 2024. That is six of 18 lots flagged for storm damage in county records.

431 Bella Vista Way East

Lot 5 was valued on the 2025 roll at $1,447,102 against a land value of $1,447,092, meaning the house itself was carried at about $10. The 2026 roll adds $897,256 of new construction value and lifts its just value to about $2.24 million, consistent with a full interior rebuild; the permit scope is to confirm.

Post-storm work recorded on seven homes

The 2026 roll records new construction value on seven homes: Lot 5 ($897,256), Lot 12 ($64,777, with a demolition value of $58,011), Lot 1 ($27,351), Lot 14 ($14,000), Lot 2 ($5,380), Lot 16 ($4,895) and Lot 15 ($4,366).

Helene and Milton, 2024

The 2024 disaster-year codes on Lots 15 and 16 point to damage in the 2024 season. Island-wide, Helene and Milton also pushed water onto parts of Sanibel; specific effects on this street are to confirm.

Special assessments

No special assessment, lawsuit or association dispute involving Colony Beach Estates was found in news or court indexes searched. That is not proof none exists; the estoppel certificate is where an assessment would appear.

Insurance, elevation and the 50 percent rule

Colony Beach Estates homes date from 1988 to 1990 and sit in Zones VE and AE, so insurance and any large remodel both turn on elevation. This section explains the rules a buyer meets, from the City of Sanibel's flood pages and Florida law, without guessing at any one home's numbers.

The 50 percent rule

The City applies FEMA's substantial-damage and substantial-improvement rule at permit time: if repair or improvement cost reaches 50 percent of the structure's market value, the whole building must meet current flood rules. The City uses the appraiser's value or a private appraisal.

What it means for a 1988 to 1990 house

A buyer who plans a large remodel of one of these homes may trigger a full elevation requirement under the 50 percent rule. Price the remodel against the building value, not the land value, before you write an offer.

Rebuild deadlines after Ian

Nonconforming structures destroyed by Ian could be rebuilt under a City deadline extended to December 15, 2026. The code's base rule is two years from destruction, extended for long emergencies. These homes were built after the 1976 Sanibel Plan, and their own conformity status is to confirm.

Elevation certificates

An elevation certificate shows the floor and structural elevations against the base flood elevation. Check the Forerunner portal first; if none is on file, a surveyor can prepare one before closing.

Wind and homeowners cover

Gulf-side homes in evacuation Zone A sit in Florida's hardest insurance market, and Citizens Property Insurance is the common fallback. Premium figures for these homes were not found; get quotes during the inspection period.

Association insurance

Listing remarks say the dues include association insurance on the common areas only. Each owner insures the house; confirm the split in the declaration.

Not a condominium

Florida's condominium milestone inspection and structural reserve rules apply to condominium and cooperative buildings, not to these fee-simple single-family homes. The association falls under Chapter 720 instead.

Schools serving Colony Beach Estates addresses

Colony Beach Estates addresses are served by the island's public K-8 school and mainland high schools. The details below come from the school's own site and district references; zones can change, so confirm each address on the district locator before you rely on it.

The Sanibel School

The Sanibel School, a K-8 school at 3840 Sanibel Captiva Road, calls itself "A" rated, a Florida School Recognition Award recipient for over twenty years and a Nationally Recognized Blue Ribbon School. It says you do not need to live on the island to attend.

High school

High school is off the island in Fort Myers. A school data site lists Cypress Lake High as a usual next school for Sanibel School students; the zoned high school for a Bella Vista Way address is to confirm.

Private schools

Private options on the mainland include Canterbury School and Fort Myers Christian, each with its own admissions.

Use the locator

The School District of Lee County's school site locator gives the assigned schools for a specific address. Run it for the exact house number before you count on any zone.

A short history of Colony Beach Estates

Colony Beach Estates grew from a stretch of East Gulf Drive that was once resort cottage country, then filled with 18 houses in about three years. The dates below come from the county roll and sale file, with older history marked where it rests on secondary sources.

Resort cottages before 1988

A broker page cited in our research says many beachfront duplex cottages of the old Colony Beach Resort were relocated elsewhere on the island to make room for Colony Beach Estates. That account is to confirm. Sanibel's code still names the Colony Resort and the Colonnades condominium in a subsection on nearby rental programs, without naming Bella Vista Way.

The two plats

Phase 1 came first, with lot parcels created on the roll in 1988, and Phase II followed with lots created in 1989. Kinzie Island next door was platted in the same plat book run.

First sales and build-out

The first recorded sale was Lot 2 as vacant land in February 1988 at $875,000. Builder-era sales ran from February 1988 to November 1989 at $865,000 to $1,300,000, and the last four homes, Lots 8, 9, 11 and 15, carry a 1990 year built.

The 2000s peak

Qualified sales from 2003 to 2006 ran $2,350,000 to $2,725,000, including the record $2,725,000 for Lot 18 in May 2006.

After Ian

The roll shows six lots flagged for storm damage, a near-total rebuild at 431 Bella Vista Way East and smaller new-construction entries on six other homes. One qualified sale has recorded since Ian: $2,000,000 in May 2024.

What should you check before you make an offer on a Colony Beach Estates home?

Colony Beach Estates offers are best written after a short list of checks that this page cannot do for you. Each item below points to the record that settles it, from the county card to the association's documents, and each one has changed a price conversation on Sanibel before.

Confirm the lot number and tier

Check the county legal description for the lot number and the appraiser's land tier. A Gulf-tier price on an interior lot is the easiest mistake to make on this street.

Pull the elevation certificate

Look for one on Forerunner. If none is on file, order one; in Zone VE it drives the flood premium.

Get flood and wind quotes early

Ask for flood and wind quotes in the first days of the inspection period, before appraisal and financing deadlines.

Read the permit history

Look up the address in EnerGov and CityView. Post-Ian work should show permits and final inspections, especially on the six lots the roll flagged.

Ask the association for its papers

Request the declaration, rules, budget, reserves, the estoppel certificate, the beach access terms and how the gate works.

Inspect the pool, roof and ground level

Have the pool equipment, roof, windows and the ground-level storage areas inspected, and ask about any water intrusion in 2022 and 2024.

Compare like lots

Compare a home only with recorded sales on the same tier and of similar condition, not with a blended Sanibel average or a nearby condo.

Colony Beach Estates and other Sanibel neighborhoods buyers compare

Colony Beach Estates buyers often also look at Kinzie Island next door and at other small single-family enclaves on the island with a walk to the water. The table sticks to what our county and research files say about each, and the full island is on our Sanibel homes for sale page.

Neighborhood How it compares with Colony Beach Estates
Kinzie Island S/D (next door) 22 homes, larger (2,228 to 5,711 sq ft); qualified sales 2023 to 2026 of $1.8M to $2.975M, more recent trades
Ferry Landing (East End, bay side) 18 homes in a cluster plan the City also cites; bay side, smaller 1983 to 1986 homes, 2025 to 2026 sales $995,000 to $1,300,000
Butterknife (West Gulf Dr) 34 larger homesites (0.45 to 1.52 acre), newer 2001 to 2025 homes, deeded beach access; 2026 sales $1.47M to $1.81M
Sanibel Estates (East End) Mostly canal homes for boaters, voluntary association, no gate
Colonnades / Colony Inn (next door) 36 condo units, a separate association and a far lower price band

Source: Lee County roll and sale files and our Sanibel research files, November 2026.

Kinzie Island

The neighbor to the east was platted in the same era and plat book run, with bigger homes and more recent qualified sales, so it is a useful price check for a Gulf-tier house here.

Ferry Landing

The City named Ferry Landing beside Colony Beach Estates as a cluster layout. Our Ferry Landing homes for sale page covers that bay-side street of 18 smaller homes.

Butterknife

For a small west-end subdivision with deeded beach access and larger, newer homes, see our Butterknife homes for sale page.

Southwinds Estates

Buyers who want another short East End street of single-family homes can read our Southwinds Estates homes for sale page.

What Colony Beach Estates offers and what it does not

It offers Gulf-side houses with private pools on a short private street with shared land to the beach. It does not offer docks, golf, a clubhouse, large yards or homes built after 1990.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Colony Beach Estates specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows Colony Beach Estates and other East End Sanibel homes, and our Fort Myers office on College Parkway is the closest of our offices to the causeway. For this page we tracked each qualified sale since 2013 to its lot, land tier and heated area on the county roll.

★★★★★ "Marc was a dynamo! He found the perfect home for us, and our requirements were many. He was there for us every step of the way and we leaned on his expertise very heavily. Always ready with advice and support through the foreclosure purchase, which was quite a challenge. The final success was the sale of my condo. Marc worked the listing with open houses, tips on making the unit more marketable and his final suggestion got it sold. Cannot say enough about what a great agent he is. It has been a pleasure to work with him."

Verified Zillow review. user0780192, on buying and selling a home in Florida with Marc Comisar.

Talk to our team about a Colony Beach Estates home

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816 with the lot tier, bedroom count and price range you want, and an agent will send matching listings, recorded sales on the street and the flood and association questions for each home. You can also search current listings at any time.

Thinking of selling a Colony Beach Estates home?

Sellers on this street do best when the price is set against recorded sales on the same land tier and in similar condition, not a figure that blends in condos next door. Start with a free home valuation from our team, and for a seller's view of both islands, read McGreevy and Comisar's Sanibel and Captiva home selling page.

Frequently Asked Questions about Colony Beach Estates homes for sale

These are the questions buyers ask most about Colony Beach Estates homes for sale, answered from the Lee County roll and sale files, the FEMA flood layer, City of Sanibel rules and listing remarks. Where something was not confirmed for this page, the answer says so in plain words rather than guessing.

What is Colony Beach Estates?

An 18-home single-family subdivision on Sanibel's East End, on Bella Vista Way East and West between East Gulf Drive and the Gulf, ZIP 33957.

Where is Colony Beach Estates on Sanibel?

On the Gulf side of East Gulf Drive, between the Colonnades condominium and Kinzie Island, about 0.8 road mile from Lighthouse Beach Park.

Is Colony Beach Estates the same as the Colonnades or Colony Inn?

No. The Colonnades / Colony Inn at 409 to 431 East Gulf Drive is a separate 36-unit condominium with its own association and sales.

How many homes are in Colony Beach Estates?

Eighteen single-family homes, Lots 1 to 18, plus the association's 4.50-acre Tract B. There are no vacant lots.

What are the two plats?

Phase 1 is Plat Book 40, Page 41 (Lots 1 to 3) and Phase II is Plat Book 42, Page 17 (Lots 4 to 18 and Tract B).

Why does one record say "Conlony"?

It is a typo on the county roll for Lot 16, 407 Bella Vista Way East. It is the same subdivision and is counted here.

What ZIP code is Colony Beach Estates in?

33957, inside the City of Sanibel in Lee County.

Who built the homes?

No builder or developer name appears in the public sources read. The recorded plats at the Lee County Clerk would name the owner of record.

When were the homes built?

From 1988 to 1990: twelve in 1988, two in 1989 and four in 1990.

How big are the homes?

Heated area runs 2,949 to 3,340 square feet and total area under roof 5,340 to 6,445 square feet on the county roll.

How many bedrooms do the homes have?

The roll counts ten three-bedroom homes, seven four-bedroom homes and one two-bedroom home, each with three or four baths.

Are the homes two stories?

Yes. All 18 are two-story single-family houses on the county roll.

Do the homes have pools?

Seventeen of 18 carry a private pool; 417 Bella Vista Way East does not. There is no shared pool.

How big are the lots?

Lots run 0.083 to 0.209 GIS acre. Most of the open land is in the shared Tract B.

Which lots are interior lots?

Lots 8, 9, 11 and 15, at 430, 428, 418 and 408 Bella Vista Way East. The other 14 are in the Gulf land tier.

What do Colony Beach Estates homes sell for?

Eleven qualified sales since 2013 ran $1,350,000 to $2,700,000, median $2,000,000, on Lee County records.

What was the most recent sale?

417 Bella Vista Way East at $2,000,000 on May 15, 2024, the newest qualified sale in the November 2026 county index.

What is the highest recorded sale?

$2,725,000 for 401 Bella Vista Way East in May 2006, the record qualified sale.

What did the homes first sell for?

Builder-era qualified sales in 1988 and 1989 ran $865,000 to $1,010,000.

What are the HOA fees?

Listing remarks give about $2,000 to $2,500 per quarter. The association does not publish its budget, so confirm with an estoppel certificate.

What do the dues cover?

Listing remarks list landscaping, pool care, a gazebo, roads, street lights, irrigation water, pest control, common-area insurance and reserves.

Is there a CDD?

No. The parcels pay City, fire district and county levies only.

Is Colony Beach Estates gated?

Listing remarks say it is. No city or county record confirms the gate, so check the association documents.

Does Colony Beach Estates have beach access?

Listing remarks describe deeded beach access across the association's Tract B. Confirm the recorded terms.

Is there golf?

No golf course or bundled membership is part of the community.

Are there docks?

No docks or seawalls appear on the roll for these lots.

Can I rent my home short term?

Outside the Resort Housing District, Sanibel allows rentals of no less than four consecutive weeks. The district status of these lots and any association limit are to confirm.

Are pets allowed?

No pet rule was found in public sources; confirm with the association. Assistance animals are not pets under fair housing law.

Is Colony Beach Estates in a flood zone?

Yes. Eleven lot centers and Tract B are in Zone VE with a 13-foot base flood elevation, and seven are in Zone AE at 12 feet.

Is flood insurance required?

A lender requires it on a federally backed mortgage in Zones VE and AE. Sanibel's Class 5 rating gives a 25 percent NFIP discount.

What evacuation zone is it in?

Sanibel is Lee County evacuation Zone A.

Was Colony Beach Estates damaged in Hurricane Ian?

The county roll flags hurricane damage on six lots, and 431 Bella Vista Way East was carried at about $10 of building value in 2025 before a rebuild. Ask each seller about the home's own history.

Can I remodel or raise an older home?

Yes, with City permits, but a remodel costing 50 percent or more of the structure's value triggers current flood rules. A June 2026 ordinance lets existing homes be raised up to 10 feet.

What schools serve Colony Beach Estates?

The Sanibel School, K-8, on Sanibel Captiva Road; high school is on the mainland. Confirm with the district's locator.

How far is the airport?

Southwest Florida International Airport is about 23.1 miles and 41 minutes away in free-flow traffic.

Where do I see Colony Beach Estates homes for sale?

Our team posts active listings in our current listings search and sends new ones as they appear. Call 239-441-2816 or contact us to set up a search.

About Domain Realty Group on Sanibel

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team covering Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, and for Sanibel buyers our nearest office is the one on College Parkway in Fort Myers, on the mainland side of the causeway. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and its team production stands at $2.5 billion across 4,000+ transactions. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) lead it, with over 45 years of combined direct experience.

Meet the people who would show you a home on our agents page, read our client reviews or learn about our team. We tracked every qualified sale on Bella Vista Way since 2013 to its lot and land tier before writing a word of this page.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Sanibel homes for sale, Ferry Landing homes for sale, Butterknife homes for sale, Southwinds Estates homes for sale, Captiva Island homes for sale and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to one of the sources below. No real estate portal is linked, by policy; facts attributed to "listing remarks" are labelled as such. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll and sale files, qualified sales on the Colony Beach Estates plats (including the record spelled "Conlony") in ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026. Web sources were read November 18 to November 21, 2026 unless another date is shown.

County records and plats

Flood maps and evacuation

Storms and recovery

Building and city rules

Taxes and island costs

Insurance

Florida law and fair housing

Association and listing remarks

  • Island Management Group, Sanibel, company profile
  • Listing remarks for Bella Vista Way East homes, 2025 to 2026, describing the gate, deeded beach access, pools and quarterly fees (read November 18, 2026; not linked by policy)
  • Domain Realty Group research files on the Colonnades condominium, Ferry Landing, Butterknife, Sanibel Estates and the Sanibel and Captiva island dossier (November 2026)

Schools

Nature and nearby