Sanibel · Florida · 33957
Butterknife Homes for Sale in Sanibel, FL
Butterknife homes for sale: 34 single-family homesites on Starfish Lane and Butterknife Place, a gated street on the bay side of West Gulf Drive with deeded beach access, a pool and a court complex. Recorded county sales, association facts, flood and storm notes and the questions to ask before you buy. Updated November 2026.

Butterknife is a gated subdivision of 34 single-family homesites on Starfish Lane and Butterknife Place, on the bay side of West Gulf Drive in the City of Sanibel, ZIP 33957, Lee County, one of the smaller enclaves among Sanibel homes for sale. Lots run about 0.45 to 1.52 acres, owners hold deeded beach access across West Gulf Drive, and Lee County recorded three qualified home sales from May to August 2026 at $1,470,000 to $1,806,000. Updated November 2026.
By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.
This page covers only the Butterknife plat: Lots 1 to 34 of BUTTERKNIFE S/D, Plat Book 48, Pages 56 to 57, plus the association's common tracts. House numbers on Starfish Lane run from 2118 to 2349, and Butterknife Place carries number 133 and the common-area parcel at 140. The figures below come from the Lee County Property Appraiser's certified roll and sale files, the research dossier behind this page, public listing pages and city, county and federal records, each named in the source list at the foot of the page.
Key takeaways for Butterknife home buyers
Butterknife homes for sale are few, large-lot and mostly custom-built, and the facts that shape a purchase here are the lot, the elevation of the house, the storm record and the association that owns the gate, pool, courts and roads. Each point below is covered in its own section further down, with the source and date beside it.
- The plat holds 34 single-family homesites. The 2026 county roll shows 30 improved homes, one of them a 2025 build not yet on the certified roll, and 4 vacant lots.
- Lots measure about 0.45 to 1.52 acres on the roll, and seven carry the county's lake code for a pond or lake exposure.
- County heated area runs 1,926 to 6,040 square feet, median about 3,214, with 3 to 5 bedrooms; most homes went up from 2001 to 2007.
- Lee County recorded 34 qualified sales on the plat from December 1997 to August 11, 2026, median $1,375,000. The three in the 12 months to the newest record ran $1,470,000 to $1,806,000.
- The record high is $2,240,000 for 2323 Starfish Lane in October 2020.
- Butterknife Property Owners Association owns the common tracts: a gatehouse, a heated pool and spa and a court complex with tennis, pickleball and basketball.
- A listing aggregator shows an association fee of $2,662 with no period stated, so the current assessment is to confirm.
- Broker pages give a 28-day minimum rental period, in line with Sanibel's rule for most single-family homes.
- Every Sanibel address is in Lee County evacuation Zone A, and the FEMA flood zone for each Butterknife lot is to confirm by address.
Butterknife homes for sale right now
Butterknife homes for sale appear only a few times a year, because 34 lots and a long-holding owner base turn over slowly: Lee County recorded three qualified sales in 2026 through August and two in 2024. A buyer who wants this street usually sets a saved search, watches Starfish Lane for a season and is ready to move when the right lot comes up.
How many homes can change hands
The plat has 34 homesites. The roll counts 30 improved parcels with use code 01 (single-family) in ZIP 33957 and 4 vacant lots, so at most 30 finished homes can come to market, and a vacant lot is a separate, rarer purchase.
Recent asking prices on broker pages
A Pfeifer Realty Group listing for 133 Butterknife Place, posted August 18, 2026, asked $1,699,000 for a 3,634-square-foot home built in 2015 with an elevator, a rooftop deck and a 2023 standing-seam roof. Asking prices are the seller's figure, not a recorded sale, and they change; check the current status before you plan around one.
What a listing in this subdivision usually shows
Listing pages for Starfish Lane homes describe elevated construction, pools, and the walk or cart ride across West Gulf Drive to the beach. One 2026 listing for 2312 Starfish Lane described a home on oversized pilings with a 2023 metal roof on 1.185 acres.
Where Butterknife homes are listed
The multiple listing service files these homes under the development name BUTTERKNIFE in the Sanibel area. Addresses on Starfish Lane outside 2118 to 2349 are not on this plat, so check the house number before you assume a listing belongs here.
See current listings
To see what is on the market today, search current listings and filter for Sanibel, or ask us to set a saved search on Starfish Lane and Butterknife Place.
Ready to tour Butterknife homes?
Tell us the lot size, bedroom count and whether you want a newer elevated home or land to build on, and we will send every matching listing with the recorded sales of similar homes on the street. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.
What do Butterknife homes sell for?
Butterknife sale prices peaked in 2020 and 2021, fell sharply in the first sale after Hurricane Ian and have run between $1.4 million and $1.9 million since 2023. The figures below count only sales the Lee County Property Appraiser marks as qualified on the Butterknife plat, through the newest record in the county file, August 11, 2026.
| Window | Qualified sales | Median | Low | High |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| December 1997 to August 11, 2026 (all recorded history) | 34 | $1,375,000 | $289,000 | $2,240,000 |
| Resales in that window | 30 | $1,375,000 | $465,000 | $2,240,000 |
| First sale of a new home in that window | 4 | $1,117,500 | $289,000 | $1,699,000 |
| November 2025 to August 11, 2026 (12 months) | 3 | $1,800,000 | $1,470,000 | $1,806,000 |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale index, DOR-qualified improved sales on the Butterknife plat, use code 01, ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026.
Recorded sales since 2020
| Date | Address | Notes from the roll and listings | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| October 19, 2020 | 2323 Starfish Ln | Highest recorded sale | $2,240,000 |
| March 1, 2021 | 2336 Starfish Ln | 4,603 sq ft recorded | $2,100,000 |
| May 26, 2021 | 2311 Starfish Ln | $1,900,000 | |
| March 14, 2022 | 2276 Starfish Ln | Six months before Ian | $1,800,000 |
| December 15, 2022 | 2287 Starfish Ln | Eleven weeks after Ian | $1,100,000 |
| February 23, 2023 | 2324 Starfish Ln | 1,926 sq ft, built 2017 | $1,536,000 |
| September 13, 2023 | 2228 Starfish Ln | 3,814 sq ft, built 1992 | $1,444,000 |
| March 15, 2024 | 2239 Starfish Ln | 2,572 sq ft, built 2002 | $1,650,000 |
| May 18, 2024 | 2300 Starfish Ln | 4,727 sq ft, built 2001 | $1,600,000 |
| May 21, 2026 | 2312 Starfish Ln | 1.185 acres, on pilings | $1,800,000 |
| June 25, 2026 | 2179 Starfish Ln | 2,450 sq ft, built 2007 | $1,470,000 |
| August 11, 2026 | 2287 Starfish Ln | 3,802 sq ft, built 2003 | $1,806,000 |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale records as summarized in research dossier N13-0017, read November 11, 2026.
The 2287 Starfish Lane resale
The same house at 2287 Starfish Lane sold for $1,100,000 in December 2022 and for $1,806,000 in August 2026, a gain of $706,000 in under four years on the county record. What work was done between the two sales is to confirm from the City of Sanibel permit file for the address.
Asking prices against recorded prices
Two 2026 sales closed below their published asks. 2312 Starfish Lane was listed at $1,995,000 in January 2026 and recorded at $1,800,000 in May; 2179 Starfish Lane was listed at $1,499,000 and recorded at $1,470,000 in June. Those asks come from listing pages, the sale prices from the county.
Vacant lot sales
Two vacant lots sold in 2021: 2299 Starfish Lane, 0.989 acre, for $554,000 in June, and 2133 Starfish Lane, 0.592 acre, for $475,000 in October. Earlier lot sales on the plat, from 1997 to 2002, ran about $175,000 to $396,000.
Price per heated square foot
Because lots here are large and homes vary from under 2,000 to over 6,000 heated square feet, price per foot swings widely. The 2026 sales of 2179 Starfish ($1,470,000 on 2,450 square feet) and 2287 Starfish ($1,806,000 on 3,802 square feet) work out to about $600 and $475 per county heated square foot. Compare a home with sales of similar size and elevation, not with a street average.
Value on the county roll
The 2026 Lee County roll sets just values for improved Butterknife homes from about $0.40 million to $3.39 million, median about $1.73 million. Just value is the county's tax estimate, not a sale price, and a low figure can reflect a building the appraiser values at almost nothing.
Butterknife home types, sizes and lots
Butterknife homes are detached custom houses on some of the larger lots on Sanibel's Gulf side, built over three decades rather than in one push, so two neighbors can differ in age, height and style. Every figure in this section is from the 2026 certified Lee County roll for the plat unless another source is named.
| Item | Butterknife figure |
|---|---|
| Property type | Single-family, 34 homesites |
| Improved homes | 30, including one 2025 build not yet on the certified roll |
| Vacant lots | 4 |
| Year built | 1992 (1), 1994 (1), 2001 to 2007 (18), 2010 to 2019 (8), 2023 (1), 2025 (1) |
| Heated area | 1,926 to 6,040 sq ft; median about 3,214 |
| Bedrooms | 3 to 5 |
| Living levels on the roll | 1 to 2 |
| Lot size | 0.446 to 1.517 acres |
| Pools | 27 of 34 parcels |
| Garages | 29 of 34 parcels |
| Lake-coded lots | 7 |
Source: Lee County Property Appraiser certified roll, 2026, as summarized in dossier N13-0017.
The build years
Eighteen homes date to 2001 to 2007, the main build-out, and eight more to 2010 to 2019. The oldest homes on the roll are from 1992 and 1994; 2142 Starfish Lane, 6,040 heated square feet, was completed in 2023, and 2155 Starfish Lane, 4,882 heated square feet, is carried as 2025 new construction.
Heated area
The smallest heated area on the roll is 1,926 square feet at 2324 Starfish Lane, built in 2017, and the largest is 6,040 square feet at 2142 Starfish Lane. The median sits near 3,214 square feet.
Bedrooms
The roll records 3 to 5 bedrooms. Listing counts can differ: one 2026 listing for 133 Butterknife Place advertised 5 bedrooms where the roll shows 4, so use the county figure unless the listing agent confirms the change.
Elevated construction
The county counts living levels, so a home raised on pilings over a garage and storage level may show as one or two stories on the roll. Several listings describe homes on pilings, and the newest builds were designed to current flood rules.
Pools and garages
Twenty-seven of the 34 parcels carry a pool on the roll and 29 a garage. A vacant lot carries neither, so those counts include the 4 lots without homes.
Lot sizes
Lots run from 0.446 to 1.517 acres. For comparison, the two 2021 lot sales were 0.592 and 0.989 acre. Large lots give room for a pool, parking under the house and native landscaping between neighbors.
Lake-coded lots
Seven lots carry the roll code for single-family residential with lake frontage: Lots 12, 13, 15, 16, 17 and 20 on the west plat page and Lot 23 on the east page. Walk the lot to see what the water looks like in the dry season.
Builders named in public sources
One 2026 listing names Seacoast Cottage Company as the builder of 133 Butterknife Place in 2015. No other builder names appeared in the public sources read for this page, and no source names the original developer.
The Butterknife plat and the land around it
The Butterknife plat is one street with two plat pages, a set of association tracts and a ring of protected land, and knowing which parcel belongs to whom explains much of what a buyer sees from the street. The roll ties every parcel to Sections 25, 35 and 36, Township 46 South, Range 22 East.
Plat Book 48, Pages 56 to 57
Page 56, in Section 35, holds Lots 1 to 21: 133 Butterknife Place and 2228 to 2349 Starfish Lane on the west half. Page 57, in Section 36, holds Lots 22 to 34: 2118 to 2202 Starfish Lane on the east half. Further tracts appear on Plat Book 47, Page 51 and Plat Book 48, Pages 58 and 60.
Starfish Lane and its two cul-de-sacs
Broker pages describe Starfish Lane as a single street with a north and a south cul-de-sac, reached through a gatehouse off West Gulf Drive. Butterknife Place is the short spur that carries the common-area parcel.
The association tracts
Common Tracts C and D and the road right of way, about 4.10 acres at 140 Butterknife Place, belong to Butterknife Property Owners Association. The roll shows a 234-square-foot structure from 2002 and a pool on that parcel.
The SCCF conservation land
Plat Tracts A and H, joined with Sanibel Highlands Block 21 Lots 1 to 12, form a 77.85-acre parcel owned by the Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation under a conservation easement, with a 2019 parcel-creation date on the roll. SCCF holds more than 1,800 acres on Sanibel. Whether any part of the tract is open to the public is to confirm with SCCF.
City of Sanibel tracts
Tracts F (22.83 acres) and G (10.22 acres) are owned by the City of Sanibel. Plat Tract B, 6.63 acres at 403 to 420 Airport Way, is also city property, with 1992 buildings on the roll. How the city uses each tract is to confirm with the city.
Taxing district and zoning area
All parcels sit inside the City of Sanibel taxing district and the Sanibel Fire District, with the roll's zoning area code COS. There is no community development district on the parcels reviewed.
Butterknife amenities and beach access
Butterknife amenities are owned by the property owners association rather than a club, so there is no membership tier, initiation fee or golf. Owners share a gatehouse entry, a heated pool and spa with a pool house, a court complex and deeded beach access across West Gulf Drive.
Deeded beach access
Broker pages and listings describe deeded access to the Gulf beach across West Gulf Drive, used on foot or by golf cart. One 2026 listing put the beach about 344 feet from 133 Butterknife Place. The beach in front of the access is the stretch facing Casa Ybel Resort.
Pool and spa
The association's heated pool and spa sit on the common parcel with a pool house. Hours, guest rules and heating dates are to confirm with the association.
Tennis, pickleball and basketball
A 2026 listing describes a newly completed sports and fitness facility with tennis, several pickleball courts, a basketball and sports court and a shaded viewing area. The completion date and cost are to confirm with the association.
The gatehouse
Starfish Lane is reached through a gatehouse entry, and broker pages describe Butterknife as the only gated community on West Gulf Drive. Ask the association how guest and contractor access works.
Bike paths
Sanibel's shared-use path system runs along West Gulf Drive outside the gate, so the island's path network starts at the entrance.
No golf
Butterknife has no golf course. Beachview Golf Club mid-island and The Dunes on the east end are the nearby public courses; The Sanctuary is private and member-owned.
What does it cost to own a Butterknife home each year?
Butterknife ownership costs are the association assessment, property tax, homeowner and flood insurance and upkeep of a large lot and an elevated house. The association's current budget is not public, so the firm figures here are listing-reported taxes and a listed fee, each labelled, and every figure is to confirm before you write an offer.
| Cost | Public figure | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Association fee | $2,662, period not stated | Listing aggregator; to confirm |
| 2025 property tax, 133 Butterknife Pl | $15,360 | Listing-reported |
| 2025 property tax, 2312 Starfish Ln | $14,481 | Listing-reported |
| City limited rental license | $300 | Ordinance 19-007 form |
| CDD | None found | Roll review |
| Capital contribution or transfer fee | Not published | To confirm |
Sources: listing aggregator and listing pages, City of Sanibel rental registration form, Lee County roll, as summarized in dossier N13-0017.
The association
The association of record is Butterknife Property Owners Association, with a mailing address on the county roll of 2323 Wooster Lane #5, Sanibel 33957. Its corporate filing could not be read for this page, so its status and registered agent are to confirm with the Florida Division of Corporations.
The listed fee
A listing aggregator shows "HOA Fees $2,662" and a second line of $2,562, with no billing period or year stated. Treat both as unconfirmed and ask for the current budget and assessment schedule.
The estoppel certificate
Florida law sets the estoppel certificate fee for a homeowners' association at $250, with more allowed for a delinquent account or an expedited request. The estoppel shows the current assessment, any balance owed and any special assessment.
Special assessments
No public report of a Butterknife special assessment or lawsuit was found. Ask whether the court complex, gate or pool work after the 2022 and 2024 storms was funded by reserves or by an assessment.
Upkeep on a large lot
Lots near an acre carry landscaping, irrigation and pool costs that small lots do not, and two listings cite 2023 replacements of roofs, doors and irrigation. Budget for the lot as well as the house.
Property taxes on a Butterknife home
Butterknife homes are taxed by Lee County, the City of Sanibel and the Sanibel Fire District, the taxing district on every parcel of the plat. A buyer's bill follows the purchase price and homestead status, not the seller's history, so plan from your own price.
Two listed tax bills
Listings report 2025 taxes of $15,360 on 133 Butterknife Place and $14,481 on 2312 Starfish Lane. Look up the current bill for any address with the Lee County Tax Collector.
Homestead on the roll
Twelve of the 34 parcels carry a homestead exemption on the 2026 roll, so most owners hold these homes as second or seasonal homes.
What resets at a sale
Florida's Save Our Homes cap limits yearly increases in a homestead's assessed value, and the cap resets at a sale. Your first full bill is usually based on a value near the price you pay.
Non-homestead property
A home that is not your homestead is assessed under a separate, higher cap on yearly increases, so a seasonal owner's bill can rise faster than a homesteaded neighbor's.
Is Butterknife in a flood zone?
Butterknife flood zone status is not published per parcel by the property appraiser, because its parcel pages state that FIRM data is not available for parcels inside a municipality. Lee County FIRM panels for the West Gulf Drive corridor show AE zones with base flood elevations of about 7 to 10 feet inland of the road and VE zones of about 11 to 15 feet at the Gulf, so each address needs its own check.
| Item | What the record shows |
|---|---|
| FEMA flood zone | To confirm by address; corridor panels show AE (EL 7 to 10) inland of West Gulf Drive |
| Gulf-front zone nearby | VE (EL 11 to 15) on the Gulf side |
| Evacuation zone | Lee County Zone A, all of Sanibel |
| Per-lot elevation certificates | Not found in public sources |
Sources: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel page, Lee County FIRM panel 12071C0537G and flood hazard area notes, Lee County Emergency Management.
Where to check a lot
Check the address on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center and with the City of Sanibel building department, which keeps flood records for city parcels. Ask the seller for an elevation certificate.
Flood insurance
A lender requires flood insurance in an AE or VE zone when the mortgage is federally backed. Broker estimates in the parent research put non-waterfront flood premiums on Sanibel at about $3,000 to $5,000 a year and combined home and flood coverage on a $1.5 million home at $15,000 to $25,000 a year in 2026; those are estimates to replace with your own quote.
Evacuation Zone A
Every Sanibel address is in Lee County evacuation Zone A, the first zone ordered out when a storm threatens.
The western Sanibel River
After Ian the city lowered the western Sanibel River by up to a foot to reduce flooding. In October 2026 SCCF linked that change, with the 2025 drought, to drying interior wetlands; whether the conservation tract behind Butterknife is affected is not stated.
Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton on West Gulf Drive
Butterknife storm history on the public record is thin: no published report covers damage inside the subdivision, so this section gives the island-wide surge figures, what happened on West Gulf Drive and what the county roll shows, and leaves each home's history to the seller and the permit file.
Hurricane Ian, September 28, 2022
The National Hurricane Center reported storm surge of roughly 10 to 15 feet above ground from Sanibel to Bonita Beach, with about 13 feet cited for Sanibel, and a USGS sensor on eastern Sanibel recorded 12.58 feet.
West Gulf Drive in Ian
A local history of West Gulf Drive reports that the surge crossed the road from the Gulf, flooding ground-level space and filling pools with sand, while elevated homes on pilings generally kept their upper floors.
What the roll shows
The county record shows a $1,100,000 sale in December 2022 against $1,800,000 for a nearby home in March 2022, new homes completed in 2023 and 2025, and two homes, 2336 and 2191 Starfish Lane, carrying a building value of $10. Why those two carry that value is to confirm with the property appraiser or the city.
Helene and Milton, 2024
Helene and Milton brought surge flooding to parts of the island again in 2024, mostly on golf courses and Gulf-front property in the parent research. No Butterknife-specific report was found.
Across the road
Casa Ybel Resort, across West Gulf Drive, closed after Ian and reopened with its Thistle Lodge restaurant in December 2025.
What to ask the seller
Ask for the home's flood and wind claim history, any substantial-damage determination from the city, the permits for repairs since 2022 and the dates of roof, door and mechanical replacements.
Permits, elevation and the 50 percent rule on Sanibel
Butterknife buyers looking at an older ground-level home, or planning a large remodel, should read three Sanibel rules before an offer: the FEMA 50 percent rule, the city's height exception for elevating homes and the rebuild deadline for nonconforming structures. They are due-diligence facts for a purchase, not a reason to buy.
The FEMA 50 percent rule
When repairs or improvements to a building below base flood elevation cost 50 percent or more of its market value, the whole building must be brought up to current flood rules, which usually means elevating it. Lee County and the city apply the rule through the building permit.
Elevating an existing home
A June 2026 City of Sanibel ordinance lets existing homes be raised up to 10 feet regardless of the usual height limits.
Rebuild rights after Ian
The city extended rebuild rights for nonconforming structures destroyed by Ian to December 15, 2026, and staff may approve some long-form development permits through December 31, 2026.
Permit history
The City of Sanibel building department holds the permit file for each address. Read it for any home built before 2010 or any home sold since 2022.
Insurance and construction for a Butterknife home
Butterknife homes are fee-simple single-family houses in a homeowners' association, so the owner insures the house and the association insures its gate, pool and courts. Insurers on the island ask first about elevation, roof age, opening protection and the flood zone.
Not a condominium
Florida's milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study rules apply to condominium and cooperative buildings, not to Butterknife homes.
Rating features in listings
Listings for 133 Butterknife Place and 2312 Starfish Lane cite impact glass and metal roofs; homes completed in 2023 and 2025 were built under current codes. An elevation certificate is the document that most affects a flood quote.
Roof age
Florida law bars an insurer from refusing to write or renew a homeowner policy only because a roof is under 15 years old. Ask the seller for the roof date and permit.
Wind mitigation
A wind mitigation inspection records roof shape, roof-to-wall connections and opening protection and can lower the wind premium. Order one with the home inspection.
Association coverage
No public data was found on the association's coverage for the gatehouse, pool or courts. Ask for the current policy declarations.
Rules for rentals, pets and changes in Butterknife
Butterknife homes follow the association's recorded documents and the City of Sanibel's rental rules, and the documents themselves were not public for this page. The points below are the ones buyers ask about first; confirm each with the association and the city before you sign.
Rental minimum
Broker pages list a 28-day minimum rental period for Butterknife, matching Sanibel's rule for most single-family homes. Nightly and weekly rentals are not the model here. Confirm any grandfathered status for a specific address with the City of Sanibel.
City rental registration
A City of Sanibel limited rental registration for 28-day minimum rentals costs $300 under Ordinance 19-007. The city has been stepping up short-term rental enforcement, with about 360 suspect addresses reported island-wide.
Pets and assistance animals
The pet rules were not in the public sources read for this page, so the number, size and breed limits are to confirm with the association. An assistance animal for a person with a disability is a reasonable accommodation under federal and Florida fair housing law, not a pet, and a pet limit does not bar it.
Architectural changes
Exterior changes, pools, fences and landscaping in a Florida homeowners' association usually need the association's written approval. Ask for the architectural guidelines and the application form.
Age
Nothing in the public record read for this page shows an age restriction on Butterknife. Confirm with the association.
Where is Butterknife on Sanibel?
Butterknife sits on the bay side of West Gulf Drive on the middle-to-west stretch of Sanibel's Gulf shore, across the road from Casa Ybel Resort, with Casa Ybel Road and Airport Way just to the east. Parcel centroids fall between about 26.4244 and 26.4274 degrees north and 82.0704 to 82.0758 degrees west.
| Destination | Broker-published time |
|---|---|
| Gulf beach (deeded access) | About 2 min |
| Bailey's Shopping Center, Periwinkle Way and Tarpon Bay Road | About 5 min |
| Periwinkle Way | About 10 min |
| J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge | About 15 min |
| Sanibel Causeway | About 15 min |
| Southwest Florida International Airport | About 45 min |
Source: Pfeifer Realty Group Butterknife community page, read November 11, 2026. Times are broker estimates; add time in season.
Off-island trips
The parent research gives about 35 to 40 minutes from this part of the island to downtown Fort Myers and about 30 to 40 minutes to HealthPark and the Lee Health campus on the Summerlin corridor. Those are estimates to check at the hour you plan to drive.
The causeway
The Sanibel Causeway is tolled inbound. FDOT's permanent restoration after Ian was substantially complete by June 2025.
Shopping and dining
Bailey's General Store and the Bailey's Shopping Center are about 5 minutes away. Thistle Lodge and the Coconuts bar at Casa Ybel are across the road, and Periwinkle Way restaurants are about 10 minutes away.
Parks and nature
SCCF's conservation land lies behind the homes, the Sanibel Recreation Center is near the Casa Ybel Road area, and the Ding Darling refuge is about 15 minutes away.
Health care
Sanibel has no hospital; the nearest Lee Health hospitals are on the mainland.
Other Sanibel and Captiva pages
For other single-family streets on the island, see our pages on Gulf Ridge homes for sale on the west end and Southwinds Estates homes for sale on the East End. North of Blind Pass, our Captiva Island homes for sale page covers the next island.
Schools serving Butterknife addresses
Butterknife addresses are zoned to The Sanibel School, the island's public K-8 school, and high school is off the island. Lee County assigns students by address, so confirm the assignment with the School District of Lee County before you rely on it.
The Sanibel School
The Sanibel School is a public K-8 school at 3840 Sanibel-Captiva Road with about 225 students.
High school
Broker pages say many Sanibel students attend Cypress Lake High School in Fort Myers, but no official zone assignment was found; check the address with the district.
Private schools
Canterbury School in Fort Myers and Fort Myers Christian School are the closest private options named in the parent research.
A short history of Butterknife
Butterknife history runs from an island airfield to a 1992 plat and a slow, lot-by-lot build-out over three decades, and the record has gaps a buyer should know about, starting with the developer's name, which no public source read for this page gives.
The Casa Ybel airfield
A grass airfield with a 2,600-foot runway operated off Casa Ybel Road, near today's Airport Way, for more than two decades. The FAA closed it in 1979 after a series of accidents.
Plans in 1984
The Islander reported in April 1984 a proposed project on the former Casa Ybel air strip and a separate proposal for a golf course, clubhouse, tennis courts and 160 homes on a 315-acre tract around it. Whether Butterknife descends from either plan is not confirmed.
The plat and the land deal
The roll gives 1992 as the creation year for the 34 lots and Tract B, and 1994 for the association tract. One common-element parcel carries a 1988 recorded sale of $2,000,000, which may be the original land assembly; that is to confirm at the Lee County Clerk.
The first lot sales
Recorded lot sales cluster from 1997 to 2002 at about $175,000 to $396,000, and most homes went up from 2001 to 2004.
The conservation deal
The 77.85-acre conservation parcel behind the homes took its current form on the roll in 2019, under SCCF ownership and a conservation easement.
What should you check before you make an offer on a Butterknife home?
Butterknife homes differ more from each other than homes in a production subdivision, so the offer checklist here focuses on the house's elevation and storm history, the lot and the association. Each item comes from the gaps the records on this page leave open.
Get the elevation certificate
Ask for the elevation certificate and the flood zone for the address before you price flood insurance.
Read the permit file
Pull the City of Sanibel permit history for repairs since 2022, and ask whether the city made a substantial-damage determination.
Order a full inspection
Inspect the pilings, breakaway walls, roof, elevator if any, pool equipment and air conditioning, and price anything near the end of its life.
Get insurance quotes early
Get homeowner, wind and flood quotes during the inspection period, with the roof date and opening protection stated.
Ask for the association documents
Ask for the declaration, the rules, the current budget, the reserve schedule and the latest minutes, and order the estoppel certificate early.
Confirm the rental rules
If you plan to rent, confirm the 28-day minimum, the city registration and any association limit in writing.
Walk the lot
Check the lake exposure on the seven lake-coded lots, the line to the conservation land and the path to the beach access.
Compare like with like
Compare a home with recorded Butterknife sales of similar size, age and elevation, not with an island-wide median.
Butterknife and other Sanibel communities buyers compare
Butterknife buyers often weigh it against the island's other private enclaves, larger single-family neighborhoods and the Gulf-front condos nearby on the same beach. The comparison below sticks to differences the research dossier records, and the table is a starting point for your own tours, not a ranking.
| Community | How it compares with Butterknife |
|---|---|
| The Sanctuary at Wulfert | Bayside golf community with separate golf membership; not near the Gulf beach |
| Beachview Country Club Estates | Much larger, around a public golf course; older 1960s and 1970s homes; not gated |
| West Gulf Drive Gulf-front estates | Same road with direct Gulf frontage at about $1.5 million to over $8 million; VE zones; no shared amenities |
| Sanibel Bayous | Wooded west-end single-family homes at a lower price range, farther from the beach, not gated |
| The Dunes | East-end golf and lakes neighborhood, larger and not gated |
| Gulf-side condos near Casa Ybel | Same beach for less money; condominium law and building rules apply |
Source: research dossier N13-0017 section 15 and its sources.
The Sanctuary
The Sanctuary at Wulfert is the island's other well-known private enclave, but it is a golf community on the bay at the west end, with its own membership.
Gulf-front homes on West Gulf Drive
A Gulf-front lot puts the beach at the back door at a higher price and in a VE zone; Butterknife trades that for an across-the-road walk and shared amenities.
Condos on the same beach
A condo on the Gulf side gives the same beach for less money, with condominium inspection and reserve rules and, in some buildings, shorter rental options.
Talk to a Domain Realty Group Butterknife specialist
Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows Butterknife and other Sanibel homes. We tracked every recorded sale on Starfish Lane and matched it to the county roll by lot, heated area and year built to build this page. A small subdivision rewards patience and quick action in equal parts, and we watch it for both.
★★★★★ "Marc was a very professional agent. He provided great insight and experience to sell our home quickly and for a good price. Throughout the entire process he was involved and followed up with us to ensure we did not have any questions, concerns or issues. Any time there was a potential item that could cause delays he was on top of it and made sure the process continued smoothly. Would definitely recommend and use in the future."
Verified Zillow review. Nathan, on selling a single-family home in Fort Myers with Marc Comisar.
Talk to our team about a Butterknife home
Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816 with the lot size, bedroom count and budget you have in mind, and an agent will send matching listings, the recorded Starfish Lane sales behind them and the association questions for the home. You can also search current listings at any time.
Thinking of selling a Butterknife home?
Buyers here price a home by its lot, its elevation and its storm and permit record, so a home priced against recorded Butterknife sales of similar size and age stands out against one priced from an island average. Start with a free home valuation from our team, and for a seller's view of the islands, see McGreevy and Comisar's Sanibel and Captiva home selling page.
Frequently Asked Questions about Butterknife homes for sale
These are the questions buyers ask most about Butterknife homes for sale, answered from the Lee County roll and sale files, public listing and broker pages, and city, county and federal records. Where a fact was not confirmed for this page, the answer says so plainly and names who to ask.
Where is Butterknife on Sanibel?
On Starfish Lane and Butterknife Place, on the bay side of West Gulf Drive across from Casa Ybel Resort, Sanibel, FL 33957.
Is Butterknife a gated community?
Yes. Starfish Lane is reached through a gatehouse entry, and broker pages call it the only gated community on West Gulf Drive.
How many homes are in Butterknife?
The plat has 34 homesites; the 2026 roll shows 30 improved homes, including a 2025 build, and 4 vacant lots.
What is the legal name of the plat?
BUTTERKNIFE S/D, Plat Book 48, Pages 56 to 57, Lots 1 to 34, in Lee County.
What do Butterknife homes sell for?
The three qualified sales recorded from May to August 2026 ran $1,470,000 to $1,806,000, median $1,800,000.
What is the median Butterknife sale price?
$1,375,000 across 34 qualified sales recorded from December 1997 to August 11, 2026.
What is the highest Butterknife sale on record?
$2,240,000 for 2323 Starfish Lane on October 19, 2020.
What was the most recent Butterknife sale?
2287 Starfish Lane, $1,806,000, recorded August 11, 2026.
What do vacant lots sell for?
Two 2021 lot sales recorded $475,000 and $554,000. Four lots on the plat were vacant on the 2026 roll.
How big are Butterknife lots?
About 0.446 to 1.517 acres on the county roll.
How big are Butterknife homes?
County heated area runs 1,926 to 6,040 square feet, median about 3,214.
When were Butterknife homes built?
Mostly 2001 to 2007, with a second wave from 2010 to 2019 and new homes in 2023 and 2025.
How many bedrooms do the homes have?
The roll records 3 to 5 bedrooms.
Do Butterknife homes have pools?
Twenty-seven of the 34 parcels carry a pool on the roll.
Are there homes on the lake?
Seven lots carry the county's lake code: Lots 12, 13, 15, 16, 17, 20 and 23.
Does Butterknife have beach access?
Yes. Owners have deeded beach access across West Gulf Drive, on foot or by golf cart.
What amenities does Butterknife have?
A gatehouse, a heated pool and spa with a pool house, tennis, pickleball and a basketball court, plus the beach access.
Is there golf in Butterknife?
No. The nearest public courses are Beachview Golf Club and The Dunes.
What are the association fees in Butterknife?
A listing aggregator shows $2,662 with no period stated; confirm the current assessment with the association.
Who runs the association?
Butterknife Property Owners Association, which owns the common tracts, gate, pool, courts and roads.
Is there a CDD?
No community development district was found on the Butterknife parcels.
What are property taxes on a Butterknife home?
Listings report 2025 taxes of $15,360 and $14,481 on two homes; your bill depends on the price and homestead status.
Can you rent a Butterknife home short term?
No nightly or weekly rentals; broker pages list a 28-day minimum, and the city requires a $300 limited rental registration.
Does Butterknife allow pets?
The pet rules were not public for this page; confirm with the association. Assistance animals are a reasonable accommodation, not a pet.
Is Butterknife age-restricted?
No age restriction appears in the public record read for this page; confirm with the association.
What flood zone is Butterknife in?
Not published per parcel; corridor panels show AE zones of about EL 7 to 10 inland of West Gulf Drive. Confirm by address.
Is flood insurance required?
A federally backed mortgage requires it in an AE or VE zone. Price it before you make an offer.
What evacuation zone is Butterknife in?
Lee County evacuation Zone A, like all of Sanibel.
Did Butterknife flood in Hurricane Ian?
No public report covers damage inside Butterknife. Ian's surge crossed West Gulf Drive; ask the seller and the city for the home's record.
Who built the homes in Butterknife?
Custom builders, lot by lot; one 2026 listing names Seacoast Cottage Company for 133 Butterknife Place. The developer is not named in public sources.
What schools serve Butterknife?
The Sanibel School, a public K-8, with high school off the island; confirm with the School District of Lee County.
How far is Butterknife from the causeway?
About 15 minutes, by broker estimate.
How far is the airport?
About 45 minutes to Southwest Florida International Airport, by broker estimate.
What is behind the homes?
A 77.85-acre SCCF conservation parcel under a conservation easement.
Where do I see Butterknife homes for sale?
On our current listings search, or ask us for a saved search on Starfish Lane; call 239-441-2816.
About Domain Realty Group and Sanibel homes
Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team working Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, and our Fort Myers office on College Parkway is the closest of our offices to the Sanibel Causeway. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. The team is led by Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671), who bring over 45 years of combined direct experience between them.
Reach any of our agents through our agents page, read our client reviews or learn more about our team. We tracked every recorded Butterknife sale on the county file, home by home, to build this page.
Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816 info@domainrealtygroup.com
Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:
- Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
- Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
- Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919
Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.
Where to go next: Sanibel real estate, Captiva Island homes for sale, Gulf Ridge homes for sale, Southwinds Estates homes for sale and current listings.
Sources
Every figure on this page traces to one of the sources below. No real estate portal is linked, by policy; facts from listings and broker pages are labelled that way. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll and sale files for the Butterknife plat (use code 01, ZIP 33957), index built November 18, 2026. Web sources were read November 11 to November 21, 2026 unless another date is shown.
County records and plat
- Lee County Property Appraiser, parcel and sale records
- Lee County Property Appraiser, parcel page for the Butterknife common elements (Folio 10024820)
- Lee County Property Appraiser, sale data files
- Lee County Property Appraiser, tax roll data (certified parcel file and field list)
- Lee County Property Appraiser, exemptions
- Florida Department of Revenue, property tax data portal
- Lee County Tax Collector, property taxes
- Lee County Clerk, Official Records search (Plat Book 48 Pages 56 to 60; OR 3605 PG 1384)
- Florida Division of Corporations, entity search (Butterknife Property Owners Association, not confirmed)
Listings and broker pages
- Broker page, Pfeifer Realty Group, About Butterknife community page (gate, amenities, drive times, rental minimum; not linked by policy)
- Listing, Pfeifer Realty Group, 133 Butterknife Place, listed August 18, 2026 (not linked by policy)
- Listing, Pfeifer Realty Group, 2312 Starfish Lane, 2026 (not linked by policy)
- Listing record, Weichert, 2287 Starfish Lane, off market (not linked by policy)
- Portal and aggregator pages for Butterknife and 2179 and 2287 Starfish Lane, including the listed association fee (search snippets; not linked by policy)
- Broker article, Lifestyle and Luxury Living, West Gulf Drive history from the 1880s to 2026 (not linked by policy)
- Broker guide, Pfeifer Realty Group, below-market-rate housing on Sanibel (not linked by policy)
- Broker guide, Sanibel Real Estate Guide, how Lee County schools operate (not linked by policy)
History and news
- Pfeifer Realty Group, Before the Causeway: Airplanes on Sanibel (local history)
- The Islander, April 25, 1984 issue, via Digifind-It
- Island Reporter, Casa Ybel Resort and Thistle Lodge reopen post-storm, December 12, 2025
- Island Reporter, affordable housing provided by CHR, January 2016
- Santiva Chronicle, Council allows height limit exception for home elevations, June 2026
- Santiva Chronicle, three hearings result in ordinances on buildback, traffic and multifamily uses, September 12, 2025
- Santiva Chronicle, in other news from Sanibel Council, December 2, 2025
- Santiva Chronicle, dealing with short-term rental enforcement
- Florida Rambler, after damage from three hurricanes, Sanibel and Captiva near normal, updated October 30, 2026
- Equipment World, Sanibel Causeway restoration completed, June 16, 2025
- WGCU, storm surge flood control and drought suspected in drying Sanibel wetlands, October 14, 2026
Flood, storms and insurance
- FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer
- FEMA Flood Map Service Center
- FEMA, flood insurance
- FEMA, substantial improvement and substantial damage
- FEMA, elevation certificate
- FEMA, Hurricane Ian disaster declaration DR-4673
- FEMA, Hurricane Milton disaster declaration DR-4834
- Lee County GIS, FIRM panel 12071C0537G
- Lee County, flood hazard areas explained
- Lee County, understanding the 50 percent rule
- Lee County Emergency Management, know your evacuation zone
- WGCU, evacuations in Lee and Collier counties ahead of Hurricane Ian, September 27, 2022
- National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Ian
- National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Helene
- National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Report, Hurricane Milton
- NBC Miami, Ian is costliest hurricane in Florida history, April 2023
- Local 10, what new data reveals about Ian's storm surge, October 13, 2022
- Citizens Property Insurance, flood insurance requirement
- Florida Statutes 627.7011, homeowner policies and roof age
- Florida Office of Insurance Regulation
- My Safe Florida Home, wind mitigation
City of Sanibel
- City of Sanibel
- City of Sanibel, building department
- City of Sanibel, Code of Ordinances (rental rules)
- City of Sanibel dwelling rental license and registration form, Ordinance 19-007 (PDF copy)
- Stay With Stay, Sanibel Island's 28-day rental rule explained
Florida law and fair housing
- Florida Statutes Chapter 720, homeowners associations
- Florida Statutes 720.30851, estoppel certificates
- Florida Statutes 720.401, disclosure summary before sale
- Florida Statutes 553.899, milestone inspections (condominiums and cooperatives)
- Florida Statutes 718.112, condominium reserves and structural integrity reserve studies
- Florida Statutes 760.23, fair housing
- Florida Statutes 760.27, emotional support animals
- HUD, assistance animals
- Florida Statutes 196.031, homestead exemption
- Florida Statutes 193.155, Save Our Homes assessment cap
- Florida Statutes 193.1555, non-homestead residential assessment cap
Schools
- School District of Lee County
- School District of Lee County, school enrollment zones
- The Sanibel School
Places, land and services
- Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation (SCCF)
- SCCF, preserve the land
- J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge, US Fish and Wildlife Service
- Lee County Department of Transportation, Sanibel Causeway and toll
- Lee Health, HealthPark Medical Center
- Southwest Florida International Airport
- Microsoft Planetary Computer, USDA NAIP collection (hero image: USDA NAIP, January 16, 2023, public domain)
239-441-2816Search homes