Opens in a new tab
Back to Sanibel

Sanibel · Florida · 33957

Herons Landing Homes for Sale in Sanibel, FL

Herons Landing homes for sale: 32 single-family homes, 8 townhomes and 2 lots on Osprey Court, My Tern Court and Shearwater Drive, listed as Herons Landings I and II. Recorded county sales, association dues, the flood zone and the questions to ask before you buy. Updated November 2026.

Aerial photo from January 16, 2023 of the Herons Landing streets on the West End of Sanibel, FL 33957: homes among trees on Osprey Court, My Tern Court and Shearwater Drive beside the waters of Clam Bayou, with Sanibel-Captiva Road, neighboring homes and the Gulf beach also in frame

Herons Landing is a deed-restricted neighborhood of 32 single-family homes, 8 attached townhomes and 2 vacant lots on Osprey Court, My Tern Court and Shearwater Drive on the West End of Sanibel, ZIP 33957, Lee County, among our Sanibel homes for sale. Listings file it as Herons Landings I and Herons Landings II. Homes were built from 1989 to 2017, and Lee County recorded six qualified sales here from December 2021 through June 2026, at a $1,135,000 median. Updated November 2026.

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.

This page is a child of our Sanibel real estate page and covers the whole Herons Landing neighborhood. One point to know first: "Herons Landings I" is the multiple listing service name taken from the county's subdivision record for Herons Landing Phase I, the 24 lots on Osprey Court and My Tern Court recorded in Plat Book 40, Pages 89 to 91. Phase II, recorded in Plat Book 44, Pages 6 and 7, holds 11 single-family lots and 8 townhomes on Shearwater Drive and is usually listed as Herons Landings II. Listings mix the two names, so this page covers both phases, which share one homeowners association. It is not Heron at The Sanctuary, the condominiums on Baltusrol Court, and it is not the White Heron subdivision nearby.

Key takeaways for Herons Landing home buyers

These are the points that matter most when you shop Herons Landing homes for sale. Each comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll, plat and sale files, federal and county map layers, the City of Sanibel's rental rules as published, or public broker pages, and each is covered further down with its source and date.

  • Herons Landing has 42 residential parcels: 32 single-family homes, 8 attached townhomes on small fee-simple parcels and 2 vacant lots, under one association, Herons Landing Homeowners Association of Sanibel, Inc.
  • Phase I, the source of the "Herons Landings I" listing name, is 24 lots on Osprey Court and My Tern Court: 23 homes and 1 vacant lot.
  • Phase II is 11 platted lots on Shearwater Drive (10 parcels, since two lots were combined) plus the 8 townhomes of Tract E.
  • Single-family homes were built from 1989 to 2017 on lots of about 0.44 to 1.13 acres. The townhomes were built in 1990, 2001 and 2002.
  • Lee County recorded six qualified sales from December 2021 through June 30, 2026, from $925,000 to $2,525,000, median $1,135,000.
  • The 2026 county just values run $647,207 to $2,125,174 for single-family homes, median $1,142,050, and $1,316,059 to $1,484,807 for townhomes.
  • Listing data put association dues at about $1,703 a quarter for a single-family home and $3,857 a quarter for a townhome; the association does not publish them.
  • Every point tested is FEMA Zone AE with a base flood elevation of 9 or 10 feet, and Lee County places the neighborhood in Evacuation Zone A.
  • Single-family homes on Sanibel may be rented for no less than four consecutive weeks, with a City of Sanibel rental license.

Herons Landing homes for sale right now

Herons Landing homes for sale come up only a few times a year, because 40 homes turn over slowly: Lee County recorded one qualified sale in 2025 and one in the first half of 2026. Most months there are none or one or two on the market, so a buyer who wants this neighborhood usually sets a saved search and waits for the right home type, lot and price.

How many homes there are to buy

The county roll counts 42 residential parcels: 23 homes and 1 vacant lot in Phase I, 9 homes and 1 vacant lot in Phase II and 8 townhomes in Tract E. One broker page counts 39 total units; we use the county count. The association also owns about 10.9 acres of common land, and the City of Sanibel owns Phase I Tract A, 6.385 acres.

Where Herons Landing homes are listed

Herons Landing homes appear in the multiple listing service under the development name Herons Landing and the subdivision names HERONS LANDINGS I and HERONS LANDINGS II. The labels are not clean: a Tract E townhome at 5438 Shearwater Drive was listed under Herons Landings I while its neighbor at 5423 Shearwater Drive was listed under Herons Landings II. We search both names and all three streets.

What has been on the market in 2025 and 2026

Public listing pages showed 5423 Shearwater Drive, a 2,621 square foot townhome, listed January 3, 2026 at $1,525,000; 5438 Shearwater Drive, a townhome, listed June 26, 2025 at $1,499,000; 1990 My Tern Court at $1,395,000 and 5422 Osprey Court at $1,095,000 on a broker page updated November 11, 2026. These are asking prices, not sales, and may have changed.

The vacant lot

The vacant Phase I lot at 5398 Osprey Court, 0.716 acres, asked $429,000 in August 2024 and $280,000 to $295,000 in 2025, per listing records. The county file shows a February 2024 transfer at $196,644 that the county did not mark as a qualified sale. The other vacant parcel is Phase II lot 8 at 5407 Shearwater Drive.

See current listings

To see what is on the market today, search current listings and filter for Sanibel, or ask us for a saved search on Osprey Court, My Tern Court and Shearwater Drive. We watch both the Herons Landings I and Herons Landings II names.

Ready to tour Herons Landing homes?

Tell us whether you want a single-family home or a townhome, a bayou lot or an inside lot, and how soon you plan to buy, and we will send every matching Herons Landing listing with the recorded sales of similar homes. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do Herons Landing homes sell for?

Herons Landing sale prices peaked at $2,525,000 in February 2022, the last qualified sale before Hurricane Ian, and the qualified sales since then ran $925,000 to $1,750,000. These figures count only sales the Lee County Property Appraiser marks as qualified on Herons Landing parcels, through the newest sale in the county file, June 30, 2026.

Window Qualified sales Median Low High
December 2021 to June 30, 2026 (60 months) 6 $1,135,000 $925,000 $2,525,000
All recorded history, April 1990 to June 30, 2026 76 $912,500 $360,000 $2,625,000
First sales of newly built homes, all years 12 $575,000 $440,000 $1,400,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale index, DOR-qualified improved sales on Herons Landing parcels in ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026.

Every qualified sale since December 2021

Date Address Built, county heated sq ft, beds and baths Price
December 1, 2021 5418 Osprey Ct 1991, 2,976, 4 and 3 $1,310,000
February 22, 2022 5415 Osprey Ct 1989, 1,818, 3 and 3 $2,525,000
June 6, 2023 5410 Osprey Ct 1992, 2,473, 3 and 2 $960,000
October 16, 2023 1990 My Tern Ct 2001, 2,146, 3 and 2 $925,000
October 7, 2025 1986 My Tern Ct 1989, 2,378, 3 and 2 $940,000
June 30, 2026 5427 Osprey Ct (on Clam Bayou) 1999, to confirm, 3 and 3 $1,750,000

Source: Lee County sale index joined to the Lee County parcel roll for year built, heated area, bedrooms and baths.

Sales by calendar year

Lee County recorded nine qualified Herons Landing sales in 2021, one in 2022, two in 2023, none in 2024, one in 2025 and one in the first half of 2026. The 2021 cluster ran $999,000 to $2,100,000 and included three townhomes. The drop after 2022 matches the island-wide slowdown after Hurricane Ian.

Sales the county did not qualify

Several recent transfers are not in the qualified count: 5387 Shearwater Drive at $1,875,000 (December 2024), 5414 Osprey Court at $1,257,000 (July 2024), the townhome at 5436 Shearwater Drive at $2,100,000 (March 2024) and 5435 Osprey Court at $1,100,000 (December 2022). The county excludes sales it judges not to reflect the open market, so treat these as context, not comparables.

Price per heated square foot

On county heated area, the qualified sales since 2023 ran about $388 a square foot at 5410 Osprey Court, $395 at 1986 My Tern Court and $431 at 1990 My Tern Court. The February 2022 sale at 5415 Osprey Court worked out to about $1,389 a square foot, so the lot and its setting, not the house size, drove that price; what drove it is to confirm.

Repeat sales on the same homes

1986 My Tern Court sold for $745,000 in September 2008 and $940,000 in October 2025. 5427 Osprey Court sold for $1,159,000 in December 2014 and $1,750,000 in June 2026. 5403 Shearwater Drive sold for $1,000,000 in 2013, $1,060,000 in 2018 and $1,599,000 in 2021.

Townhome sales

Three Tract E townhomes sold as qualified sales in 2021: 5424 Shearwater Drive at $999,000, 5431 Shearwater Drive at $1,148,000 and 5423 Shearwater Drive at $1,315,000. The 5424 unit had sold for $725,000 in 2015, and 5436 Shearwater Drive sold for $950,000 in January 2016.

Value on the county roll

The 2026 county just value, the appraiser's market estimate as of January 1, 2026, runs $647,207 to $1,444,970 in Phase I, median $1,115,046, and up to $2,125,174 in Phase II, median $1,414,254. One Phase II home, 5411 Shearwater Drive, carries $390,804 against a land value of $390,794, so the county assigns almost no value to the building; the reason is not public and is to confirm.

Herons Landing home types, sizes and lots

Herons Landing homes are custom-built single-family houses on large lots plus a small group of attached townhomes. No single builder or developer name appears in the public records we read; the spread of build years from 1989 to 2017 points to lots sold to individual owners and builders over three decades.

Section Streets Homes (county) Built County living area Lot size
Phase I ("Herons Landings I") Osprey Ct, My Tern Ct 23 homes, 1 vacant lot 1989 to 2017 1,476 to 3,315 sq ft 0.44 to 0.86 ac
Phase II lots Shearwater Dr, 5379 to 5419 9 homes, 1 vacant lot 1990 to 2011 2,544 to 4,437 sq ft 0.44 to 1.13 ac
Phase II Tract E townhomes Shearwater Dr, 5422 to 5438 8 units, A to H 1990, 2001, 2002 2,288 to 2,621 sq ft 0.066 to 0.077 ac

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser roll and GIS parcel layer, 2026.

Phase I single-family homes

Phase I's 24 lots ring Osprey Court (lots 1 to 9 and 16 to 24) and My Tern Court (lots 10 to 15). The 23 homes have 2 to 4 bedrooms and 1,476 to 3,315 square feet of county living area on lots of 0.44 to 0.86 acres.

Phase II single-family homes

Phase II's lots run along Shearwater Drive, odd numbers 5379 to 5419, toward Clam Bayou. The nine homes are the largest in the neighborhood, 2,544 to 4,437 square feet, on lots up to 1.13 acres; lots 5 and 6 are now one parcel.

The Tract E townhomes

The eight townhomes, units A to H, sit on parcels of about 0.07 acres along Shearwater Drive, 5422 to 5438. They have 3 bedrooms and 2,288 to 2,621 square feet. Units are paired by build year, C and D and E and F in 1990, G and H in 2001 and A and B in 2002, which suggests four two-unit buildings; that is to confirm on site.

A three-level townhome plan

A 2026 listing for 5423 Shearwater Drive, unit A, described three levels with an enclosed garage at ground level and an elevator to a top-floor primary suite, and a listing subtype of duplex. Other units may differ.

Build-out in waves

Single-family construction ran from 1989 to 1993, from 1996 to 2003, then 2011 and two homes in 2017, 5407 and 5439 Osprey Court, both on lots that sold vacant from 2013 to 2016.

Elevated and ground-level designs

One 2026 listing describes 5427 Osprey Court as elevated with an unfinished lower level, and the 5423 Shearwater townhome has its garage under two living floors. Whether a home meets today's flood elevation is a per-house question; ask for the elevation certificate.

Bayou lots and docks

Several lots back onto Clam Bayou, and some have private docks; 5427 Osprey Court was listed in 2026 with a private dock and boat lift on Clam Bayou. Dock permits and water depth are to confirm for each lot.

Upgrade lists in listings

Listings name recent work such as metal roofs, PEX plumbing and impact windows and doors at 1990 My Tern Court in 2023 and 2024, and a 2025 roof at 5427 Osprey Court. County permits show a 2023 roof and window and shutter permits at 5411 Shearwater Drive.

How Herons Landing is laid out

Herons Landing is two recorded plats under one association: Phase I on Osprey Court and My Tern Court, and Phase II on Shearwater Drive, with common tracts for the pool, courts, roads and bayou access. The layout matters because listing names, lot sizes and dues differ by section.

The Phase I plat

Phase I is recorded in Plat Book 40, Pages 89 to 91, with 24 lots, common Tract B for amenities, Tract D for the road and recreation Tract C at 1940 Sanibel Bayous Road. The county's header record for this plat reads "HERONS LANDINGS I HDR", the source of the listing name.

The Phase II plat

Phase II is recorded in Plat Book 44, Pages 6 and 7, with 11 single-family lots on Shearwater Drive, the eight Tract E townhomes and common Tracts A to F, about 7.51 acres. The county header for this area reads "HERONS LANDING HDR".

One association

The county roll names Herons Landing Homeowners Association of Sanibel, Inc., PO Box 100, Sanibel, as owner of the common parcels in both phases. Its state filing record is to confirm; the state corporation search did not answer our research request.

City land inside Phase I

Phase I Tract A, 6.385 acres, is owned by the City of Sanibel. What it is used for is to confirm with the City.

Neighbors on the map

Sanibel Bayous, including The Ridge, adjoins Herons Landing to the east, and Coastal Creek, a six-lot subdivision recorded in 2026 on Coastal Creek Lane, adjoins Phase I to the north. What will be built there is to confirm with City planning.

How to reach it

One listing gives the approach as Sanibel-Captiva Road to Sanibel Bayous Road, then into Herons Landing at Osprey Court. Shearwater Drive runs toward Clam Bayou from there.

The amenities that come with a Herons Landing home

Herons Landing owners share a community pool and spa, a tennis court, a small pool building and bayou access on Clam Bayou, all on association land, and brokers describe a deeded path to the beach. There is no golf course and no club membership in the neighborhood.

Pool and spa

County permits show pool and spa work on both common parcels: Phase I Tract B in 2012, 2018 and May 2023, and the Phase II tracts in 1993, 2012, 2017 and April 6, 2026. Whether there are one or two pools is to confirm. Brokers describe a large community pool and spa across the street from some Osprey Court homes.

Tennis and pickleball

Brokers list a tennis court, and some listings say tennis and pickleball. Court count and pickleball lines are to confirm on site.

Bayou dock and kayak launch

The Phase II common land carries dock and shoreline permits from 2014, 2020 and December 2023. Listings describe a kayak launch, a fishing pier and a community kayak and paddleboard dock on Clam Bayou.

The beach path

Brokers say owners have deeded beach access by a path from the east cul-de-sac of Shearwater Drive through state-owned preserve toward Bowman's Beach. We did not read the recorded easement, so confirm it on the Phase II plat before relying on it.

Pool building

The county lists buildings of 217 square feet on the Phase I common parcel, first on the roll in 2013, and 676 square feet on the Phase II common parcel, built 1993. One listing mentions pool restrooms.

Gate status

Sources conflict: one listing marks the neighborhood non-gated, while others describe it as gated or as a gated Shearwater community. Check on a visit or with the association.

No golf

There is no golf course in Herons Landing and no bundled membership. The nearest club is The Sanctuary Golf Club, a private member-owned course on Wulfert Road, about 1 to 2 miles north.

What does it cost to own a Herons Landing home each year?

Herons Landing owners pay association dues, City of Sanibel and Lee County property taxes, insurance and, because every point tested is Zone AE, flood insurance on a financed purchase. The association does not publish its dues, so the figures below are from listing data and are to confirm with the association before you buy.

Item Figure Source and date
Single-family association dues about $1,703 a quarter listing and portal data, 2025 to 2026
Townhome association dues about $3,857 a quarter 2025 townhome listing
Vacant lot dues $735 a quarter 2024 lot listing
Community development district none on the tax roll Lee County roll, 2026
Property taxes, 5427 Osprey Ct $20,648.82 (2025) 2026 listing
Property taxes, 5423 Shearwater Dr $24,365 (2025) 2026 listing
Property taxes, 5438 Shearwater Dr $10,583.55 (2024) 2025 listing

Why townhome dues are higher

Townhome dues run more than twice the single-family figure in listing data. That likely reflects exterior items the association covers for the attached units, but what each fee includes was not in the public record we read; ask for the budget.

Dues stated other ways

Portals restate the dues as about $568 a month for single-family homes and $1,265 to $1,286 a month for townhomes. One Osprey Court listing showed an HOA fee of $6,812 with no period, which matches about four quarters at $1,703.

Special assessments

We found no special assessment in public sources. The April 2026 pool permit and December 2023 dock permit on common land are projects to ask about.

No CDD

Herons Landing is in taxing district 010, City of Sanibel, and no community development district appears on the tax roll.

Transfer and capital contribution fees

We found no transfer fee or capital contribution in public sources; it is to confirm with the association.

Estoppel certificate

Florida law lets a buyer's closing agent request an estoppel certificate from a homeowners' association stating dues owed and any assessments. Order it early.

Property taxes on a Herons Landing home

Herons Landing homes are taxed by the City of Sanibel, Lee County and the other taxing districts on the 010 district bill, on the assessed value the Lee County Property Appraiser sets each January 1. Listing data show recent bills from about $10,600 to $24,400 a year depending on the home and its exemptions.

Recent bills from listings

Listings show $20,648.82 for 5427 Osprey Court (2025), $24,365 for the 5423 Shearwater Drive townhome (2025) and $10,583.55 for the 5438 Shearwater Drive townhome (2024).

Portal averages

Portals put average taxes at about $10,547 for Herons Landings I and $20,562 for Herons Landings II. These are portal estimates, not county figures.

Homestead and the Save Our Homes cap

A primary residence can qualify for Florida's homestead exemption, and the Save Our Homes rule caps yearly increases in its assessed value. Seasonal owners do not get either.

What resets at a sale

The capped value resets to market value when a home sells, so the seller's bill is not your bill. Estimate taxes on your purchase price.

Rules for renting, pets and age at Herons Landing

Herons Landing homes follow the City of Sanibel's rental code and the association's recorded covenants, which we did not read in full for this page. Read the declaration and rules before you buy; the points below are the ones buyers ask about most, with the gaps named plainly.

Rental minimum

Sanibel's code limits single-family dwellings to rentals of no less than four consecutive weeks, and brokers list a 28-day minimum for Herons Landing. Any association rental rule is in addition to the City's and is to confirm.

Rental license

Owners who rent need a City of Sanibel dwelling rental license, renewed each year, and the license number must appear in rental ads. A 2020-era City form listed $300 for a limited license and $100 for an unlimited one; the current fee is to confirm with the City.

Rental enforcement

The City uses software that scans rental sites for unlicensed short-term rentals, and local press reported about 360 noncompliant addresses under review; the article's date is not shown.

Pets and assistance animals

We did not find the pet rule in public documents, so number, size and breed limits are to confirm with the association. Assistance animals for a person with a disability are a reasonable accommodation under federal and Florida fair housing law, not a pet, and a pet limit does not bar them.

Age

We found no recorded age restriction for Herons Landing in the public sources read. Confirm with the association before relying on that.

Changes to a home

Architectural rules for additions, docks, fences and colors are in the recorded covenants, which are to confirm with the association. City of Sanibel permits apply as well.

Is Herons Landing in a flood zone?

Yes. Every Herons Landing point tested is FEMA Zone AE, the coastal floodplain, with a base flood elevation of 9 feet NAVD88 for most lots and 10 feet at the south end of Shearwater Drive. Lee County places the neighborhood in Evacuation Zone A, storm surge zone 1, so flood insurance and storm planning are part of owning here.

Item Herons Landing
FEMA flood zone AE, base flood elevation 9 ft NAVD88; 10 ft at 5379 Shearwater Dr
FIRM panel 12071C0508G, effective November 17, 2022
Evacuation zone Lee County Zone A, storm surge zone 1
Points tested Phase I lot 4, My Tern Ct, Tract E townhomes, Shearwater lot 1

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser GIS flood, FIRM and evacuation layers and the FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, read November 11, 2026.

What the screen covers

Four county map points and one FEMA point were tested, on Osprey Court, My Tern Court and Shearwater Drive. A screen is not a determination: confirm each address on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center.

Flood insurance

Zone AE is a special flood hazard area, so a lender will require flood insurance on a financed purchase. The elevation certificate drives the premium; get a quote before you make an offer.

Evacuation Zone A

Lee County orders evacuations by zone, so watch for Zone A orders before a storm. The Sanibel Causeway is the only road off the island.

Hurricane Ian in 2022

Hurricane Ian struck on September 28, 2022, and USGS and National Weather Service high-water marks put Sanibel's peak surge at about 13 to 14 feet. We found no Herons Landing damage report. County records show no recorded sale from the storm to December 15, 2022, and 2023 permits on the amenity tract, the dock and some homes that may be storm repairs; that is to confirm.

Helene and Milton in 2024

Helene and Milton brought surge to parts of Sanibel in 2024. We found no Herons Landing record for either storm; ask the association and the seller.

Elevation certificates

We found no elevation certificates for Herons Landing homes in public sources. Ask the seller, or the City of Sanibel floodplain office, for one.

Insurance and building rules for a Herons Landing home

Herons Landing homes and townhomes are fee-simple parcels in a homeowners' association, not condominiums, so the owner insures the home and the association insures its own common property. Flood elevation, roof age and wind protection are what insurers and the City ask about first.

Not a condominium

No condominium is recorded at Herons Landing. Florida's milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study rules apply to condominium and cooperative buildings of three or more habitable stories, so they do not apply to these homes.

The townhome question

The Tract E units are attached homes on their own small parcels. Whether the association insures their roofs or exteriors is not in the public record we read and is to confirm in the declaration and budget.

The 50 percent rule

The City of Sanibel enforces the FEMA 50 percent rule: if repairs or improvements to a home below current flood elevation reach half the structure's value, the whole home must be brought up to current flood rules. Ask the City for any substantial damage determination on a home before you buy.

Height and elevating a home

Sanibel's height limit has been 45 feet NAVD since November 2023, and a June 2026 ordinance lets existing homes be elevated up to 10 feet above grade if they meet FEMA elevation and the Florida Building Code.

The buildback deadline

The City extended rebuild rights for nonconforming structures destroyed by Ian to December 15, 2026; after that date, rebuilds must meet current zoning. Ask the City how this applies to any specific home.

Wind protection and roof age

Impact windows and shutters appear in permits and listings for several homes. Florida law limits when an insurer may refuse a policy for roof age alone, so a roof report and a wind mitigation report help your quote.

Where is Herons Landing on Sanibel?

Herons Landing sits on Sanibel's West End, south of Sanibel-Captiva Road off Sanibel Bayous Road, between the Sanibel Bayous neighborhood and Clam Bayou, about a mile by road from Bowman's Beach Park. The table gives free-flow driving estimates from the middle of the neighborhood with no traffic; add time in season and at the causeway.

Destination Distance Free-flow time
Bowman's Beach Park 1.1 mi 4 min
Turner Beach and Blind Pass 2.2 mi 5 min
The Sanibel School 3.3 mi 8 min
Sanibel Causeway toll plaza 13.0 mi 30 min
HealthPark Medical Center 18.6 mi 37 min
Downtown Fort Myers 26.8 mi 54 min
Gulf Coast Town Center 28.7 mi 55 min
Southwest Florida International Airport 30.5 mi 57 min
Coconut Point 31.4 mi 58 min
Downtown Naples, Fifth Avenue South 49.4 mi 86 min

Source: OSRM routing engine from 26.4675 N, 82.1590 W, run November 11, 2026; some destinations used an approximate map point.

The causeway and toll

The Sanibel Causeway is the only road on and off the island. The toll is charged only coming onto the island: $6 with a transponder and $9 without, rates in effect since October 1, 2021.

Causeway repairs

Ian washed out parts of the causeway in 2022. The $328 million restoration was substantially complete in June 2025, and the state transportation department lists final completion in 2027.

Beaches

Bowman's Beach Park is about 4 minutes by car, or by the deeded path brokers describe, and Turner Beach at Blind Pass is about 5 minutes. Clam Bayou lies between the Bowman's Beach parking area and the sand.

Clam Bayou

The Sanibel Captiva Conservation Foundation has run restoration work in Clam Bayou since a 2006 culvert project, with mangrove plantings as recent as May 2025.

Captiva and beyond

Captiva is reached by driving through Sanibel. See our Captiva Island homes for sale page for homes up the road, and our North Captiva page for the boat-access island beyond it.

Health care

The nearest full hospital, HealthPark Medical Center in Fort Myers, is about 37 minutes in free-flow traffic.

Schools serving Herons Landing addresses

Lee County uses a school choice system with proximity zones, so the school a Herons Landing student attends depends on the family's application as well as the address. The district's 2026 and 2027 layer places the neighborhood in elementary zone N, middle zone LL and high zone South 5.

The Sanibel School

The Sanibel School, a K to 8 public school at 3840 Sanibel-Captiva Road, is about 8 minutes away.

Elementary zone N and middle zone LL

These are the district's proximity zones for Herons Landing addresses. Confirm the school list for each zone with the district's Student Assignment office.

High school zone South 5

The specific high school assignment was not confirmed for this page; check with Student Assignment.

Private schools

Private schools are on the mainland in Fort Myers and beyond; ask us for drive times from Herons Landing.

A short history of Herons Landing

Herons Landing took shape from 1988 to 2017, with lot sales to individual owners rather than one production builder. The land behind Phase II was assembled years earlier, and both common parcels passed to the homeowners association in the late 1990s, according to county deed records.

The land

The Phase II common parcel's oldest deed in county records dates to November 1978, well before the plat.

First lot sales

Phase I's first recorded transfers date to June 1988; lot 14, 1986 My Tern Court, sold vacant then for $109,300. Phase II lot 9 sold vacant for $260,000 in May 1990.

First townhomes

Phase II townhome units E and F first sold in June 1990.

Turnover to owners

Both common parcels were deeded for $100 in December 1997 and April 1998, which looks like conveyance of the common areas to the association; that is to confirm.

The developer

No developer or builder name appears in the county pages, broker pages or news we read. The plat signature blocks would show the platting owner.

What should you check before you make an offer on a Herons Landing home?

Before you make an offer on a Herons Landing home, check the flood elevation, the storm history of the house, the association documents and the City's rental rules, because those drive insurance, resale and what you can do with the property. These are the checks we run with buyers here.

Get the elevation certificate

Ask for the elevation certificate and compare the lowest floor to the 9 or 10 foot base flood elevation. It drives the flood premium and future repair rules.

Ask about Ian repairs

Ask the seller and the City of Sanibel for the home's permit history and any substantial damage determination since 2022.

Order a full inspection

Have the roof, windows, plumbing, electrical and any dock or lift inspected, and order a wind mitigation report.

Get insurance quotes early

Quote wind and flood coverage before your inspection period ends.

Read the association documents

Ask for the declaration, rules, budget, reserves and minutes, and confirm dues, rental and pet rules and any planned assessment.

Confirm the beach path and dock rights

Confirm the deeded beach path on the plat and any dock rights for your lot.

Check the listing name

Confirm the lot and phase on the county record; listings mix Herons Landings I and II.

Herons Landing and other Sanibel neighborhoods buyers compare

Herons Landing buyers often compare it with other West End and island single-family neighborhoods that offer shared amenities or golf. The table sets out the honest differences, using the same public record types for each; ask us for recorded sales in any of them.

Neighborhood What it is Difference vs Herons Landing
Sanibel Bayous, including The Ridge 139 home sites next door, homes about 1982 to 2021 Bigger and older; separate associations; no shared pool and tennis like Herons Landing's
Gulf Pines 114 single-family sites with clubhouse, pool and tennis Much lower dues, about $1,780 to $1,825 a year; older homes; closer to the Gulf
The Sanctuary at Wulfert 189 homes and condominiums around a private golf course Golf with separate membership; includes condominiums
The Dunes 377 sites on an east-end golf course Low dues, about $275 a year; farther from Bowman's Beach

Sanibel Bayous

Sanibel Bayous adjoins Herons Landing to the east and is the most direct comparison by location.

The Sanctuary at Wulfert

Buyers who want golf look at The Sanctuary at Wulfert, a few minutes north.

What Herons Landing offers and what it does not

Herons Landing offers large lots, shared pool and tennis, bayou access and a West End location. It does not offer golf or short-term rentals.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Herons Landing specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows Herons Landing homes and the rest of Sanibel and Captiva, and our Fort Myers office on College Parkway is the closest to the causeway. We tracked every recorded Herons Landing sale of the past five years and matched each one to the county roll by year built, heated area and bedroom count to build this page.

★★★★★ "I recently sold property in Florida (I'm in Michigan). Marc was amazing to work with. Communication was excellent, as I was updated on items as they came up. Closing went smoothly and I am very happy that the property sold in 2 weeks! Thanks again to Marc and his team."

Verified Google review. Nicole Naji, on selling a Florida property with Marc Comisar.

Talk to our team about a Herons Landing home

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816, tell us the home type, bayou or inside lot and the budget you have in mind, and an agent will send matching listings, recent recorded sales and the association questions for the home. You can also search current listings any time.

Thinking of selling a Herons Landing home?

Herons Landing buyers price a home by its phase, lot, elevation and storm history, so a home priced against recorded Herons Landing sales of the same type sells faster than one priced against an island-wide median. For a seller's view of the island, see McGreevy and Comisar's Sanibel and Captiva home selling page.

Frequently Asked Questions about Herons Landing homes for sale

These are the questions buyers ask most about Herons Landing homes for sale, answered from the Lee County roll and sale files, federal and county map layers, the City of Sanibel's rental rules as published and public broker pages. Where a fact was not confirmed for this page, the answer says so in plain words.

What is Herons Landing?

Herons Landing is a neighborhood of 32 single-family homes, 8 townhomes and 2 vacant lots on Osprey Court, My Tern Court and Shearwater Drive, Sanibel, FL 33957.

What does "Herons Landings I" mean?

It is the listing name for Herons Landing Phase I, the 24 lots on Osprey Court and My Tern Court in Plat Book 40, Pages 89 to 91, taken from the county's header record.

Is there a Herons Landing II?

Yes. Phase II, Plat Book 44, Pages 6 and 7, holds 11 lots and 8 townhomes on Shearwater Drive. Listings mix the two names.

Is Herons Landing a condo?

No. The homes and townhomes are fee-simple parcels under a homeowners' association; no condominium is recorded.

How many homes are in Herons Landing?

The county counts 40 homes, 32 single-family and 8 townhomes, plus 2 vacant lots.

What ZIP code is Herons Landing in?

ZIP 33957, in the City of Sanibel, Lee County.

Where is Herons Landing on Sanibel?

On the West End, south of Sanibel-Captiva Road off Sanibel Bayous Road, beside Sanibel Bayous and Clam Bayou.

Who built the homes in Herons Landing?

No builder name appears in public records we read; homes look individually built from 1989 to 2017.

When were Herons Landing homes built?

Single-family homes from 1989 to 2017; townhomes in 1990, 2001 and 2002.

How big are Herons Landing homes?

County living area runs about 1,476 to 4,437 square feet for single-family homes and 2,288 to 2,621 for townhomes.

How big are the lots?

Single-family lots run about 0.44 to 1.13 acres; townhome parcels about 0.07 acres.

Are there bayou lots with docks?

Yes. Some lots back onto Clam Bayou and have private docks; confirm permits and depth for each lot.

What do Herons Landing homes sell for?

Six qualified county sales from December 2021 to June 2026 ran $925,000 to $2,525,000, median $1,135,000.

What was the most recent sale?

5427 Osprey Court, a qualified sale at $1,750,000 on June 30, 2026, per county records.

What is the highest qualified sale?

The county's highest qualified Herons Landing sale on record is $2,625,000; the highest since 2021 is $2,525,000 at 5415 Osprey Court in February 2022.

What do townhomes sell for?

Three townhomes sold as qualified sales in 2021 for $999,000 to $1,315,000; 2025 and 2026 listings asked about $1.5 million.

What is the county value of Herons Landing homes?

2026 just values run $647,207 to $2,125,174 for single-family homes and $1,316,059 to $1,484,807 for townhomes.

What are the HOA fees in Herons Landing?

Listing data show about $1,703 a quarter for single-family homes and $3,857 for townhomes; confirm with the association.

Is there a CDD?

No community development district appears on the tax roll.

What are property taxes?

Recent listing bills ran about $10,584 to $24,365 a year, depending on the home and exemptions.

Is Herons Landing gated?

Sources conflict; confirm on a visit or with the association.

What amenities does Herons Landing have?

A community pool and spa, a tennis court, a pool building and a kayak dock on Clam Bayou, per permits and listings.

Does Herons Landing have beach access?

Brokers describe a deeded path toward Bowman's Beach from the end of Shearwater Drive; confirm the easement on the plat.

How far is the beach?

Bowman's Beach Park is about 1.1 miles, about 4 minutes by car.

Is there golf in Herons Landing?

No. The nearest course is The Sanctuary Golf Club, a private club on Wulfert Road.

Can you rent out a Herons Landing home?

Yes, for no less than four consecutive weeks under Sanibel's code, with a City rental license; confirm any association rule.

Does Herons Landing allow pets?

The pet rule is to confirm with the association. Assistance animals are not pets under fair housing law.

Is Herons Landing a 55+ community?

We found no recorded age restriction; confirm with the association.

Is Herons Landing in a flood zone?

Yes, FEMA Zone AE with base flood elevations of 9 and 10 feet NAVD88.

Is flood insurance required?

A lender will require it on a financed purchase in Zone AE.

What evacuation zone is Herons Landing in?

Lee County Evacuation Zone A, storm surge zone 1.

Did Herons Landing flood in Hurricane Ian?

We found no Herons Landing damage report; 2023 permits suggest repairs. Ask the seller and the City for each home's record.

What schools serve Herons Landing?

The district places it in elementary zone N, middle zone LL and high zone South 5; The Sanibel School is about 8 minutes away.

How long is the drive to the mainland?

About 30 minutes to the causeway toll plaza in free-flow traffic.

Where do I see Herons Landing homes for sale?

Our team posts active listings on our current listings search and sends new ones as they come on the market. Call 239-441-2816.

About Domain Realty Group on Sanibel

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team working Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, and our Fort Myers office on College Parkway is the closest to the Sanibel Causeway. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. The team is led by Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671), who bring over 45 years of combined direct experience between them.

Reach any of our agents through our agents page, read our client reviews or learn more about our team. We tracked every recorded Herons Landing sale of the last five years, home by home, to build this page.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Sanibel homes for sale, Captiva Island homes for sale, North Captiva homes for sale, Fort Myers homes for sale and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to one of the sources below. No real estate portal is linked, by policy; facts attributed to "listings" or "broker pages" are labelled as such. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll and sale files, qualified sales on Herons Landing parcels in ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026, newest sale June 30, 2026. Web sources were read November 1 to November 21, 2026 unless another date is shown.

County records and plat

City of Sanibel and rentals

Flood, storms and insurance

Florida law and fair housing

Schools

Places, roads and services

Broker and listing pages

  • Broker page, My Sanibel Real Estate, About Herons Landing (Phase I and II, 39 units, amenities, beach path, 28-day minimum; read November 11, 2026; not linked by policy)
  • Broker page, My Sanibel Real Estate, About Heron's Landing (a conflicting record not used for facts; read November 11, 2026; not linked by policy)
  • Listing page, 5427 Osprey Court, listed March 23, 2026 (dock and lift, 2025 roof, 2025 taxes; read November 11, 2026; not linked by policy)
  • Listing page, 5423 Shearwater Drive, listed January 3, 2026 (townhome, elevator, 2025 taxes; read November 11, 2026; not linked by policy)
  • Listing page, 5438 Shearwater Drive, listed June 26, 2025 (townhome, dues $3,857 a quarter; read November 11, 2026; not linked by policy)
  • Broker page, Homes by Marco, Herons Landings I (build years, dues restated monthly, average tax; read November 11, 2026; not linked by policy)
  • Broker page, Homes by Marco, Herons Landings II (dues and average tax; read November 11, 2026; not linked by policy)
  • Portal page, Neighborhoods.com, Herons Landing (quarterly dues $1,703 to $3,857; read November 11, 2026; not linked by policy)
  • Broker page, Realty of Naples, Herons Landing homes (updated November 11, 2026; listings and upgrades; not linked by policy)
  • Broker pages, VIP Realty Group, Herons Landing listings (non-gated marking, HOA fee $6,812; read November 11, 2026; not linked by policy)
  • Listing records, 5398 Osprey Court vacant lot, 2024 and 2025 (dues $735 a quarter; read November 11, 2026; not linked by policy)
  • Broker page, Luxury Portfolio, home in Herons Landing (deeded beach access, kayak dock; read November 11, 2026; not linked by policy)