Opens in a new tab
Back to Fort Myers Beach

Fort Myers Beach · Florida

Ostego Bay II Condos for Sale, Fort Myers Beach, FL

Ostego Bay II condos for sale in a 36-unit, nine-building condominium on Lenell Road at the south end of Estero Island in the Town of Fort Myers Beach: three-bedroom residences of 1,623 to 1,781 square feet over ground-level garages, built 1996 to 2002 beside a mangrove canal. Recorded sales by plan, fees, boat slips, rental rules, flood zone, Hurricane Ian history and what to check before an offer. Updated November 2026.

Aerial view of Ostego Bay II on Lenell Road, Fort Myers Beach, with the condominium's nine buildings, pool and canal outlined against the mangroves behind them

Ostego Bay II condos for sale are three-bedroom residences in a 36-unit condominium on Lenell Road, a short side street off Estero Boulevard at the south end of Estero Island in the Town of Fort Myers Beach. Nine buildings of four units each stand in one row on the north side of the road, with a pool in the middle of the row, a canal along the back and mangrove wetland beyond it. The living areas are 1,623 to 1,781 square feet, raised over ground-level garages, and the Lee County roll dates the buildings from 1996 to 2002.

Lee County recorded 3 qualified sales at Ostego Bay II in the 12 months to October 21, 2026, from $425,000 to $575,000 at a $545,000 median. With only 36 units, a handful of sales a year is normal here, so this page prints the county's qualified sale counts and every recorded price rather than a market trend. It covers those sales, the floor plans, the association and fees, boat slips, rental rules, the flood zone, Hurricane Ian and what to check before an offer. It is one of the condo communities we track for buyers looking at Fort Myers Beach homes for sale.

Updated November 2026. Data updated: November 2026.

Key takeaways for Ostego Bay II buyers

  • One condominium of 36 units in nine buildings at 181 to 301 Lenell Road, declared in Lee County Official Records Book 2657, Page 92, on a common-elements parcel of about 7.14 acres.
  • Every unit has three bedrooms on the county roll: 18 end units of 1,623 square feet and 18 interior units of 1,720 to 1,781 square feet.
  • Buildings date from 1996 (three), 1997 (two), 1998 (one) and 2002 (three).
  • Lee County recorded 3 qualified sales in the 12 months to October 21, 2026, at a $545,000 median; over 60 months, 6 sales at a $582,500 median.
  • The highest qualified sale in the county file is $745,000, in August 2023.
  • No boat slip comes with a unit; slips nearby belong to the separate Ostego Bay Yacht Club.
  • FEMA maps eight of the nine buildings in Zone AE at 11 feet and the east end building in Zone VE at 12 feet; Lee County evacuation zone A.
  • 12 of the 36 units carry a homestead exemption on the 2026 roll, and 23 owners have mailing addresses outside Florida.

Ostego Bay II condos for sale right now

Ostego Bay II listings are rare at any one time. Six different units changed hands in qualified sales over the last 60 months, and the October 2026 MLS export showed one active listing. Because the complex has only two basic layouts, a listing's price tracks the plan, the building's age, the view toward the canal or the road, and how much was renovated after Hurricane Ian.

Price band, last 60 months Qualified sales
Under $550,000 2
$550,000 to $649,999 2
$650,000 or more 2

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales of Ostego Bay II unit parcels, October 22, 2021 to October 21, 2026.

Listings have taken a long time to sell lately. Listing records show the two most recent closings took 349 and 406 days on the market and sold at 92.4 and 80.3 percent of their list prices. To see what is available today, search current listings and filter for Fort Myers Beach, or ask us to watch Lenell Road for you.

Ready to tour Ostego Bay II condos?

Tell us which plan you want and how you would use the garage, and we will send each matching listing with the recorded sales of the same plan. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do Ostego Bay II condos sell for?

Ostego Bay II condos sold at a $545,000 median in the 12 months to October 21, 2026, the last date in the county sale file, against $653,500 on 2 sales in the 12 months before. The newest qualified sale was September 10, 2026. Only sales that Lee County codes as qualified are counted.

Window to October 21, 2026 Qualified sales Median sold Low High Median per sq ft
12 months 3 $545,000 $425,000 $575,000 $323
24 months 5 $575,000 $425,000 $717,000 $336
36 months 5 $575,000 $425,000 $717,000 $336
60 months 6 $582,500 $425,000 $745,000 $350

Data updated: November 2026. Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and sale files (sales through October 21, 2026), qualified sales over $1,000 on the 36 residential units on Lenell Road. Per square foot figures divide each sale price by the unit's heated area on the roll.

The 24 and 36 month windows hold the same five sales because no qualified sale closed between August 31, 2023 and January 17, 2025. In the last 12 months the two sales of the 1,623 square foot plan had a $485,000 median, and the one 1,781 square foot sale closed at $575,000.

Every qualified sale since 2021

Unit numbers are left off; the building and plan come from the county roll.

Month Building Plan Sale price Per sq ft
January 2021 191 Lenell 1,623 sq ft $513,750 $317
April 2021 201 Lenell 1,623 sq ft $640,000 $394
April 2021 181 Lenell 1,781 sq ft $555,000 $312
July 2021 291 Lenell 1,781 sq ft $700,000 $393
September 2021 281 Lenell 1,623 sq ft $700,000 $431
August 2023 291 Lenell 1,781 sq ft $745,000 $418
January 2025 201 Lenell 1,623 sq ft $717,000 $442
June 2025 181 Lenell 1,623 sq ft $590,000 $364
January 2026 181 Lenell 1,781 sq ft $575,000 $323
May 2026 281 Lenell 1,623 sq ft $545,000 $336
September 2026 221 Lenell 1,623 sq ft $425,000 $262

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales and parcel roll.

A $790,000 sale in building 201 in March 2022 is coded not qualified by the county and is left out of the counts; the MLS shows the same unit closing at that price. The $745,000 sale of a 1,781 square foot unit in building 291 in August 2023, the first qualified sale after Hurricane Ian, is the highest in the county file. The $425,000 sale in September 2026 is the lowest qualified price since 2018.

Sales by calendar year

Year Qualified sales Median Low High
1996 9 $260,000 $252,900 $280,000
1998 5 $275,000 $235,000 $290,000
2002 6 $355,000 $300,000 $360,000
2003 7 $334,700 $285,000 $405,000
2005 3 $545,000 $540,000 $550,000
2008 1 $599,000 $599,000 $599,000
2013 3 $340,000 $338,000 $360,000
2017 7 $430,000 $395,000 $510,000
2019 3 $480,000 $479,000 $554,000
2020 3 $524,000 $460,000 $535,000
2021 5 $640,000 $513,750 $700,000
2023 1 $745,000 $745,000 $745,000
2025 2 $653,500 $590,000 $717,000
2026, partial 3 $545,000 $425,000 $575,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales. The table shows selected years; the county file holds 81 qualified sales from February 1996 through September 10, 2026.

The first units sold in 1996 at $252,900 to $280,000, and the last phases sold in 2002 and 2003 at about $300,000 to $405,000. Prices passed $500,000 in 2005, fell to a single $294,000 sale in 2012 and climbed to a $640,000 median in 2021. Lee County coded no sale here as qualified in 2022 or 2024. The 2026 median of $545,000 is the lowest calendar-year median since 2020, which is where recorded prices sit today.

What is Ostego Bay II? Nine buildings on Lenell Road

Ostego Bay II is one condominium. Its declaration is recorded at Lee County Official Records Book 2657, Page 92, and the association's common-elements parcel at 253 Lenell Road covers about 7.14 acres of grounds, pool and canal edge. The state condominium record lists 36 units under project number PR1P023325, dated December 5, 1995, and the association, Ostego Bay II Condominium Association, Inc., was filed with the state on November 20, 1995.

Not Ostego Bay Village, and no "Ostego Bay I"

Two different condominiums carry the Ostego name on Lenell Road. Ostego Bay II, this page, holds the nine buildings on the north side. Ostego Bay Village is a separate 16-unit condominium on the south side of the road, with its own declaration at Book 2344, Page 997 and its own association filed in 1993. The Lee County roll holds no condominium named "Ostego Bay I." The MLS files every Ostego Bay II sale under the development name "Ostego Bay," so check the legal description on any listing that uses the short name.

Built in phases

Building Address Built Units and plans
1 181 Lenell Rd 2002 2 of 1,623 and 2 of 1,781 sq ft
2 191 Lenell Rd 1998 2 of 1,623 and 2 of 1,781 sq ft
3 201 Lenell Rd 1997 2 of 1,623 and 2 of 1,781 sq ft
4 211 Lenell Rd 1997 2 of 1,623 and 2 of 1,781 sq ft
5 221 Lenell Rd 1996 2 of 1,623 and 2 of 1,720 sq ft
6 271 Lenell Rd 1996 2 of 1,623 and 2 of 1,781 sq ft
7 281 Lenell Rd 1996 2 of 1,623, 1 of 1,720 and 1 of 1,773 sq ft
8 291 Lenell Rd 2002 2 of 1,623 and 2 of 1,781 sq ft
9 301 Lenell Rd 2002 2 of 1,623 and 2 of 1,781 sq ft

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, 2026, and unit records.

The condominium was declared in phases, so the buildings went up in the middle of the row first: buildings 5, 6 and 7 in 1996, then 3 and 4, then 2, and finally 1, 8 and 9 at the two ends in 2002. The developer's name does not appear in any public source we checked; the declaration at the Lee Clerk would show it.

Where the name comes from

Ostego Bay is the back-bay water between Estero Island and San Carlos Island, and the canal behind the buildings drains toward it. Ostego Bay II is on Estero Island inside the Town of Fort Myers Beach, not on San Carlos Island, and the name has no tie to the Ostego Bay Foundation marine science center.

The condos: three-bedroom plans over garages

Every Ostego Bay II unit has three bedrooms on the county roll. Each building has four units lettered A to D: the A and D units at the ends are 1,623 square feet with two baths, and the B and C units in the middle are mostly 1,781 square feet with two baths. Buildings 5 and 7 differ, with three-bath interior units of 1,720 and 1,773 square feet. Listings describe the residences as raised over ground-level garages, with vaulted ceilings, split bedroom plans and screened lanais.

Values on the 2026 roll

Plan Units Baths on the roll Median 2026 just value
1,623 sq ft 18 2 $425,958
1,720 sq ft 3 3 $442,612
1,773 sq ft 1 3 $453,376
1,781 sq ft 14 2 $455,333

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser 2026 roll. Just value is the county's market value estimate, not a sale price.

Across all 36 units the 2026 just value runs from $388,236 to $478,857, with a median of $443,264.

End units and interior units

The roll records the 1,623 square foot end units as one story and the 1,781 square foot interior units as two stories, which suggests the interior plans have a second level or loft. One MLS listing calls an interior unit in building 8 a penthouse. Whether each plan has stairs inside is unverified; ask to walk the plan before an offer.

Garages and elevators

The roll flags a garage on every unit. Listings describe tandem garages of four to six cars with storage or workshop space, though those counts are unverified. State elevator records list one elevator at 201 Lenell Road and one at 221 Lenell Road under the association's name; whether all nine buildings have one is unverified.

Square footage in listings

Listing square footage can differ from the roll. An October 2026 listing in building 6 advertised 1,973 square feet against 1,623 on the roll, counting an air-conditioned bonus area. Use the roll's heated area to compare sales.

Boat slips and the Ostego Bay Yacht Club

An Ostego Bay II unit does not include a boat slip. The roll codes a boat dock on every unit, but no slip parcel carries the Ostego Bay II name; the docks nearby belong to a separate association, Ostego Bay Yacht Club Association, Inc., filed with the state in 1993. Listings say owners may buy or lease a slip there.

How slips change hands

A 2023 listing for a slip in the yacht club described a wet slip on the main canal behind Santini Marina Plaza with Gulf access, said the piers were being replaced and said a buyer had to own property on Lenell Road. Those terms come from one listing and are unverified; ask the yacht club for its rules, dues and pier condition.

Getting to open water

The canal behind the buildings is lined with mangroves on the far side. The route from the yacht club slips to Estero Bay and the Gulf passes, and any depth limits on it, are unverified; check depth at low tide and ask a local captain.

The association, fees and condo law

The association is Ostego Bay II Condominium Association, Inc., document N95000005518, active on the state record, in care of Suitor, Middleton, Cox and Associates. The roll lists the association's mailing address at 1661 Estero Boulevard. The current manager and officers are unverified; confirm them on the Division of Corporations site before you rely on a contact.

Association fees

No Ostego Bay II budget is posted online, so the fee figures below come from listing records and are unverified. Condo fees entered on closed MLS listings rose steadily over four years.

Sale on the listing Condo fee per quarter Yearly total
March 2022 $2,293 $9,172
August 2023 $2,686 $10,744
January 2025 $3,763 $15,052
June 2025 and January 2026 $4,400 $17,600
May and September 2026 $4,360 $17,440

Source: Southwest Florida MLS closed listings, export of October 7, 2026, fees as entered by listing agents.

At $4,360 a quarter the fee is about $1,453 a month. One listing says the fee covers the master insurance, management, water, sewer, trash, irrigation, grounds, pest control, the pool and the reserves. Listings show a $175 application fee. The current budget and an estoppel certificate govern.

Milestone inspection and SIRS

Florida's milestone inspection and structural integrity reserve study rules apply to condominium buildings three stories or more. The roll codes these buildings at one or two stories, and listings call them two-story low-rise buildings with the living level over the garages. Whether the state treats them as three stories is unverified; ask the association whether it commissioned either report.

Special assessments

No special assessment for Ostego Bay II was published. Permit records on the common elements show a run of repair and electrical permits from 2023 to 2025 and a roof permit in May 2025, and whether they were paid from insurance, reserves or an assessment is unverified. Ask the association, in writing, about every assessment since 2022.

Rental rules and pets

Ostego Bay II rental and pet rules are set by the recorded declaration and the association's rules, which are not published online, so the terms below come from listing records and are unverified. The Town of Fort Myers Beach adds its own rental registration on top of the association's approval.

Rentals

One listing says rentals of at least two weeks are allowed in the complex; no source says nightly rentals are. Any stay under 30 days also needs a Town registration through the Rentalscape portal, with a state license, a fire district inspection and a 24-hour contact. For the 2027 cycle the Town charges $400 per unit, and renewal runs November 15 to December 15, 2026. The Town began issuing violation notices in January 2026 after identifying about 500 unregistered rentals.

Pets

Listings conflict: one says pets are allowed on conditions, an aggregator says cats and dogs are allowed, and another listing site says no pets. The declaration and rules govern; unverified.

Amenities at Ostego Bay II

The aerial shows one pool with a small cabana between buildings 5 and 6. Listings describe the pool as heated and add a spa; one aggregator lists tennis, which no listing confirms. There is no gate, clubhouse, golf course or club membership. Santini Marina Plaza, with a pharmacy, shops and restaurants that reopened in stages after Ian, is next to the condominium.

Is Ostego Bay II in a flood zone?

Yes. FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer puts the roll points of buildings 1 through 8 in Zone AE, coastal floodplain, with a static base flood elevation of 11 feet. Building 9, at 301 Lenell Road on the east end, falls in Zone VE with a base flood elevation of 12 feet. VE polygons at 12 and 13 feet lie about 0.12 and 0.20 miles from the middle of the complex. All of it is on panel 12071C0567G, effective November 17, 2022. The building's elevation certificate and FEMA's address lookup decide the rating for any one unit.

Coastal High Hazard Area and evacuation

Ostego Bay II is inside Lee County's Coastal High Hazard Area, and every building is in Lee County evacuation zone A, storm surge zone 1, the first zone called to leave.

Living over the garage

The design puts the garages at ground level and the living areas above them. That is the main reason a unit here can sit above water that floods the street, but the garage contents, mechanical equipment and elevators at ground level stay exposed.

Rebuilding rules

The Town treats a building as substantially damaged or improved when the repair or improvement cost reaches 50 percent of its market value, and it measures compliance against the base flood elevation plus 1 foot of freeboard. That works out to about 12 feet for the AE buildings and 13 feet for building 9.

Insurance

The association's master policy insures the buildings; owners carry an HO-6 policy. A lender will usually require flood coverage in Zone AE or VE, and Citizens has required flood coverage for its policies in special flood hazard areas since 2023. The Town regained a Community Rating System Class 5 rating, worth a 25 percent discount on most flood policies issued or renewed on or after April 1, 2026. Ask for the master policy's wind and flood limits and deductibles, which are not public.

How did Hurricane Ian affect Ostego Bay II?

Hurricane Ian made landfall on September 28, 2022, and the Town put its surge over Estero Island at about 15 feet. No damage report specific to Ostego Bay II was published, so the county roll, the sale record and the permits on the common elements are the best evidence of how the buildings came through.

What the record shows

All 36 units are still on the roll with their original heated areas, and qualified sales resumed in August 2023 at $745,000, the highest in the county file. Permit records on the common elements show building repair permits in 2023 and early 2024, eight electrical permits in February 2024 and a roof permit in May 2025, a pattern consistent with ground-level flood repairs. The permit scopes are unverified.

Helene and Milton

In 2024 the National Weather Service estimated coastal Lee County water at 2 to 5 feet above normal high tide in Helene and 3 to 6 feet in Milton. No storm report for these buildings was found.

What to ask

Ask the seller and the association for the repair history since 2022, the insurance claim outcome, how the work was paid for and whether any repair is still open. For the unit itself, ask what was replaced at garage level, such as the air handler or garage door.

What does it cost to own an Ostego Bay II condo?

The yearly cost of an Ostego Bay II condo is property tax at the Town of Fort Myers Beach rate, the association fee, an HO-6 policy and flood coverage, plus rental registration and taxes if you rent and slip dues if you buy or lease a slip.

Property tax

The 2026 total millage for the Town of Fort Myers Beach district is 13.3108 mills. At the $545,000 12-month median that is about $7,254 a year before exemptions and non-ad valorem charges, if the assessed value equaled the price; it is an illustration, not a bill. A recent listing showed $7,093 of tax for 2026 on one unit. A buyer's assessed value resets to market value after a sale.

Fees and insurance

Add the association fee, about $17,440 a year on 2026 listing records (unverified), plus HO-6 and flood premiums, which vary by unit and building and need quotes by address.

Owners and homestead share

The 2026 roll shows 12 of the 36 units at Ostego Bay II with a homestead exemption; the other 24 carry none, so most buyers should budget for the non-homestead tax rate. Owner mailing addresses: 13 in Florida, 20 in other states and 3 abroad, in Austria, Germany and Canada. Illinois, Minnesota, Ohio and Michigan lead the out-of-state addresses, and no owner holds more than one unit.

Schools near Ostego Bay II

Lee County's 2026 to 2027 proximity zones place Ostego Bay II in Elementary Zone T, Middle Zone MM and High School South Zone 4. The island's only public school, Fort Myers Beach Elementary on Oak Street, is about 3.47 miles away in a straight line; it closed after Milton flooding in October 2024, and its students were bused to Heights Elementary in Fort Myers while the Town and the School Board negotiated its future. Confirm assignment by address with the School District of Lee County.

Where is Ostego Bay II?

Ostego Bay II sits on the bay side of Estero Boulevard at the south end of Estero Island, on Lenell Road beside Santini Marina Plaza. Lenell Road is one of the streets of the Bay Beach condominium area, and the Gulf shore is on the other side of Estero Boulevard. Every distance below is a straight line from the middle of the 36 unit roll points.

Distances from Ostego Bay II

Place Straight-line distance
Estero Island Beach Access 11, 68 Flamingo St 0.87 mi
Estero Island Beach Access 12, 106 Gulf Dr 0.99 mi
Lovers Key State Park, mapped point at 8700 Estero Blvd 2.04 mi
Newton Beach Park 2.15 mi
Lovers Key State Park boat ramp 2.36 mi
Fort Myers Beach Elementary 3.47 mi
Coconut Point, Estero 5.59 mi
NCH Bonita Springs emergency room 5.60 mi
Southwest Florida International Airport terminal 12.05 mi

Source: Lee County GIS park, hospital and school layers, measured from the median roll point of the 36 units. The park layer maps only the Town's numbered public accesses. Road distances are longer.

Ostego Bay II and nearby choices

Choice Units Built What sets it apart from Ostego Bay II
Ostego Bay II 36 1996 to 2002 Three-bedroom units over garages, canal behind
Ostego Bay Village 16 State record 1992 Separate, smaller condominium across Lenell Road
Royal Pelican Townhouse 144 1986 to 1991 Two-bedroom units, slips sold in the same complex
Grandview at Bay Beach 58 2023 New 11-story tower built to current flood code

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser roll and Florida condominium records, as recorded for each page.

What Ostego Bay II offers a buyer, and what it does not

It offers a three-bedroom condo of 1,623 to 1,781 square feet in a small, low-rise complex, with a garage under the unit and recorded 2026 prices of $425,000 to $575,000. It does not offer Gulf frontage, a slip bundled with the unit, a gate or amenities beyond the pool, and its fee has nearly doubled since 2022.

What should you check before you make an offer at Ostego Bay II?

An Ostego Bay II condo is easy to compare by plan, but the deal turns on the association's money, the post-Ian repairs, the building's flood zone and the garage level. Here is the checklist we use with buyers on Lenell Road.

For any unit

  • The county record, to confirm the building, plan, baths and build year.
  • The recorded sales of the same plan in the last 12 and 60 months, from the tables above.
  • The seller's flood disclosure, the building's elevation certificate, and HO-6 and flood insurance quotes; building 9 is in Zone VE.

For the association

  • The estoppel certificate, with the current fee, any special assessment and any transfer or capital contribution fee.
  • The declaration, bylaws, budget and rules, with the leasing and pet sections.
  • The master insurance policy, the reserve schedule and the permit history for post-Ian work.

For the garage, slip and rentals

  • What sits at garage level and what was replaced after Ian.
  • The yacht club's slip rules, dues and pier condition, if you want a boat.
  • The rental minimum in the declaration and the unit's Town rental registration.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Ostego Bay II specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows condos at Ostego Bay II, and our Bonita Springs office on US 41 is a short drive from the Big Carlos Pass end of the island. We tracked every recorded sale on Lenell Road against the county roll and the flood map to build this page, and we can pull the same record for any unit you are weighing.

★★★★★ "Working with Lindsey at Domain Realty was so great. It gave me so much peace of mind using her services. She’s so knowledgeable and helpful. The whole process she was on it. I am not local and I didn’t have to worry about a thing. I highly recommend her and am so grateful to have found her!"

Verified Google review. Durbin Fam, an out-of-area client, on working with Lindsey Moffat-Ridge of Domain Realty Group.

Talk to our team about an Ostego Bay II condo

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816, tell us which plan you want, how you would use the garage and whether you need a slip nearby, and an agent will send matching listings, recent sales of the same plan and the association, insurance and disclosure questions for the unit. You can browse current listings at any time, or go back to all Fort Myers Beach homes for sale.

Thinking of selling a condo at Ostego Bay II?

Buyers here weigh the plan, the building's flood zone, the post-Ian updates and the fee, so a unit priced against recorded sales of the same plan sells faster than one priced against the complex median. For a figure on your own unit, start with a Fort Myers Beach home valuation from McGreevy and Comisar.

Frequently Asked Questions about Ostego Bay II condos for sale

What is Ostego Bay II?

A condominium of 36 three-bedroom units in nine buildings on Lenell Road, built 1996 to 2002, in the Town of Fort Myers Beach.

Where is Ostego Bay II?

At 181 to 301 Lenell Road, on the bay side of Estero Boulevard at the south end of Estero Island, beside Santini Marina Plaza, ZIP 33931.

Is Ostego Bay II on San Carlos Island?

No. It is on Estero Island, inside the Town of Fort Myers Beach taxing district. Ostego Bay is the water between the two islands.

Is there an Ostego Bay I?

The Lee County roll holds no condominium by that name. The other Ostego condominium on the street is Ostego Bay Village, a separate 16-unit association.

How many units are there?

36 units, four in each of nine buildings, lettered A to D.

How big are the condos?

1,623 square feet for the end units and 1,720 to 1,781 square feet for the interior units, on the county roll.

How many bedrooms do the units have?

Three bedrooms in every unit; 32 units have two baths and 4 have three.

When was Ostego Bay II built?

In phases: three buildings in 1996, two in 1997, one in 1998 and three in 2002.

What is the median price at Ostego Bay II?

The median qualified sale was $545,000 in the 12 months to October 21, 2026, on 3 sales recorded by Lee County.

What is the highest recorded sale?

$745,000, a 1,781 square foot unit in building 8, in August 2023.

What do Ostego Bay II condos sell for per square foot?

About $323 a square foot at the median over the last 12 months and $350 over 60 months.

How often do units sell?

Six different units sold in qualified sales over the last 60 months, and Lee County recorded 4 transfers of any price in the last 12 months.

What are the association fees?

Listing records show $4,360 to $4,400 a quarter in 2025 and 2026, about $17,440 to $17,600 a year. The estoppel certificate gives the current figure.

What does the fee cover?

One listing says the master insurance, management, water, sewer, trash, irrigation, grounds, pest control, the pool and reserves; confirm with the budget.

Does a unit come with a boat slip?

No. Slips nearby belong to the separate Ostego Bay Yacht Club and are bought or leased in their own transaction.

Does each unit have a garage?

Yes. The county roll flags a garage on every unit, and listings describe large tandem garages under the living areas.

Can I rent out an Ostego Bay II unit?

Listings report a two-week minimum. Stays under 30 days also need a yearly Town registration, $400 per unit for 2027.

Are pets allowed?

Listings conflict. The declaration and rules govern, so ask the association before you buy with a pet.

Is there a CDD?

No community development district was found, and none appears in the county legals.

Is Ostego Bay II gated?

No. There is no gate, clubhouse or golf course.

Is Ostego Bay II in a flood zone?

Yes. Eight buildings are in Zone AE at 11 feet and building 9 is in Zone VE at 12 feet, on panel 12071C0567G.

Which hurricane evacuation zone covers Ostego Bay II?

Lee County evacuation zone A, storm surge zone 1.

Was Ostego Bay II damaged by Hurricane Ian?

No building-specific report was published. Permit records show repair and electrical work on the common elements from 2023 to 2025, and sales resumed in August 2023.

Do the milestone inspection and SIRS rules apply?

They apply to buildings of three stories or more. The roll codes these buildings at one or two stories, so ask the association how it reads the rule.

How are Ostego Bay II property taxes set?

At the Town of Fort Myers Beach district rate, 13.3108 mills for 2026, about $7,254 a year on a $545,000 assessed value before exemptions.

How many owners have a homestead exemption?

12 of the 36 units on the 2026 roll.

What schools serve Ostego Bay II?

The proximity zones are Elementary T, Middle MM and High School South 4. Fort Myers Beach Elementary has been closed since Milton, so confirm assignment with the School District of Lee County.

How far is Ostego Bay II from RSW airport?

About 12.05 miles in a straight line to the Southwest Florida International Airport terminal; the drive is longer.

How far is the beach?

The Gulf shore is across Estero Boulevard. The nearest numbered public access in the county's park layer, Beach Access 11 on Flamingo Street, is about 0.87 miles away.

Where do I see Ostego Bay II condos for sale?

Our team posts every active listing on our current listings search and sends new Ostego Bay II listings as they come up. Call 239-441-2816 or contact us to set up a search.

About Domain Realty Group around Fort Myers Beach

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team working Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, with offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. The team is led by Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671), who bring over 45 years of combined direct experience between them.

Reach any of our agents through our agents page, read our client reviews or see our team's story. We tracked every recorded sale at Ostego Bay II on the county roll to build this page.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816 info@domainrealtygroup.com

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Fort Myers Beach homes for sale, Royal Pelican Townhouse, Grandview at Bay Beach, Fort Myers homes for sale and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to one of the sources below. No real estate portal or other brokerage is linked, by policy. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll and sale files (sales through October 21, 2026; newest qualified sale at Ostego Bay II September 10, 2026). Flood, evacuation, school and distance figures come from public GIS layers queried November 20, 2026. Fee figures come from Southwest Florida MLS listing records exported October 7, 2026, labeled as listing records. Web sources were read November 11 to 21, 2026.

Figures on this page

Association and state records

Town of Fort Myers Beach

Flood, storms and evacuation

Schools

Laws, taxes and places

Building, storm and recovery records