Opens in a new tab
Back to Sanibel

Sanibel · Florida · 33957

Anchors Aweigh Homes for Sale in Sanibel, FL

Anchors Aweigh homes for sale: an unrecorded pocket of canal-front single-family homes on Anchor Drive and the Windlass Way cul-de-sac, with a deeded footpath to the Gulf beach. Recorded county sales, lots and docks, the bridge boaters pass under, flood and rental rules and the checks to run before you buy. Updated November 2026.

Aerial photo from January 16, 2023 of the Anchors Aweigh area of Sanibel, FL 33957: single-family homes with pools along narrow mangrove-lined canals south of Periwinkle Way, with more canal homes to the west and homes near the Gulf shore at the lower right

Anchors Aweigh is a small pocket of canal-front single-family homes on the East End of Sanibel homes for sale, ZIP 33957, Lee County, set on Anchor Drive and the Windlass Way cul-de-sac just south of Periwinkle Way. The 2026 county roll counts 44 homes on those streets plus three Periwinkle Way lots, every one coded as on a canal. Lee County recorded seven qualified home sales from May 2025 through August 27, 2026, from $850,000 to $2,850,000, at a $1,225,000 median. Updated November 2026.

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.

This page is only about the Anchors Aweigh pocket. It sits beneath our Sanibel real estate page, which covers the whole island. One point shapes everything below: Anchors Aweigh has no recorded plat. On the county roll it is an unrecorded block of lots inside Sanibel Estates Unit 5, Block 3, measured out by bearings from the corner of South Yachtsman Drive and Periwinkle Way, so listings may call a home "Anchors Aweigh," "Sanibel Estates" or both.

Key takeaways for Anchors Aweigh home buyers

Anchors Aweigh buyers tend to ask about the same few things before a first tour: how many homes there are, what they have sold for since Hurricane Ian, how the boat route and the footbridge to the beach work, and whether there is an association. Each point below comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale files, public broker pages, local news or City of Sanibel pages, with dates.

  • Anchors Aweigh is an unrecorded pocket of Sanibel Estates on the East End: 28 homes on Anchor Drive, 13 on Windlass Way and 3 on Periwinkle Way on the 2026 county roll, 44 in all. Brokers describe about 52 homesites, and only 9 county legal descriptions carry the name itself.
  • All 44 are single-family homes on canal lots of 0.29 to 0.73 acre, median 0.40 acre.
  • County year built runs 1965 to 2025: 17 homes from before 1979, 19 from 1979 to 1999 and 8 from 2000 on, including two new homes on the 2025 roll.
  • Lee County recorded seven qualified home sales from May 2025 through August 27, 2026, at $850,000 to $2,850,000, median $1,225,000. Across all recorded history since 1984 there are 75 qualified sales at an $850,000 median.
  • Listings describe a deeded beach path: a brick-paver lane at the end of Anchor Drive and a wooden footbridge over the canal toward East Gulf Drive.
  • The canals are narrow and man-made. Boats reach San Carlos Bay under the East Periwinkle Way bridge, which a city project put at 8.4 to 8.8 feet of vertical clearance today.
  • No mandatory homeowners association is documented in the sources read; published fee figures conflict, so confirm with the seller.
  • The flood zone is not confirmed lot by lot for this page; 17 of the 44 homes predate Sanibel's 1979 entry into the flood insurance program, and Lee County places the island in evacuation Zone A.

Anchors Aweigh homes for sale right now

Anchors Aweigh homes for sale are scarce because the pocket holds only 44 houses, and before 2026 the county recorded no more than five qualified sales in any year since 2019. A buyer who wants a dock behind the house and a walk to the beach here usually sets a saved search and acts when the right lot and elevation come up.

How many homes there are to buy

The 2026 roll shows 28 single-family parcels on Anchor Drive (655 to 748), 13 on Windlass Way (728 to 760) and 3 on Periwinkle Way (711, 719 and 727), all inside the City of Sanibel and ZIP 33957. Four more canal homes on Spoonbill Court adjoin the pocket but are not called Anchors Aweigh in any source we read.

Why brokers say 52 and the county says 44

Broker pages describe about 52 homesites, while the county roll supports 44, or 48 with Spoonbill Court. Which extra addresses the brokers count was not settled in the sources we read, so this page uses the 44 county parcels for every number.

How listings label these homes

The multiple listing labels are mixed. 748 and 751 Windlass Way have listed as Anchors Aweigh, 736 Windlass Way and 698 Anchor Drive as Sanibel Estates with Anchors Aweigh as the community name, and 734, 738 and 739 Anchor Drive as Sanibel Estates only. A saved search for one label alone will miss homes.

Asking prices seen on broker pages

Broker pages read in November 2026 (listing data, not county records) showed 660 Anchor Drive, a 1999 home of 4,021 square feet, asking $2,480,000 after a $15,000 cut on November 9, 2026. Separately, 738 Anchor Drive, a remodeled 1973 home of 2,692 square feet with 180 feet of canal frontage, was listed on May 11, 2026 at $2,450,000 under the Sanibel Estates label.

See current listings

To see what is on the market today, search current listings and filter for Sanibel, or ask us to set a saved search on Anchor Drive and Windlass Way that catches every label these homes carry.

Ready to tour Anchors Aweigh homes?

Tell us your boat length and height, whether you want a raised home or a ground-level ranch to renovate, and when you plan to move, and we will send each matching Anchors Aweigh listing with the recorded sales around it. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do Anchors Aweigh homes sell for?

Anchors Aweigh sale prices on the county record have moved from a pre-storm median of $1,550,000 to a $1,225,000 median since May 2025, with a wide spread that tracks each home's age and elevation. All figures here are Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sales on the 44 Anchors Aweigh parcels, index built November 18, 2026, newest sale August 27, 2026.

Window Qualified sales Median Low High
November 2024 to August 27, 2026 (24 months) 7 $1,225,000 $850,000 $2,850,000
January 2021 to September 2022 (before Ian) 5 $1,550,000 $1,200,000 $2,395,000
All recorded history, February 1984 to August 27, 2026 75 $850,000 $163,220 $2,850,000
Resales only, all history 71 $850,000 $163,220 $2,850,000
First sales of new homes (builder-direct estimate) 4 $875,000 $735,000 $1,650,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale index, qualified improved sales on the 44 Anchors Aweigh parcels (Anchor Drive, Windlass Way and 711 to 727 Periwinkle Way), ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026.

Every recorded sale since 2019

Date Address County year built and heated sq ft Price
June 2019 728 Windlass Way 1986, 1,924 $845,000
December 2019 747 Windlass Way 2005, 3,451 $2,400,000
January 2020 707 Anchor Dr 2003, 3,284 $1,150,000
January 2020 668 Anchor Dr 1972, 1,999 $885,250
May 2020 743 Windlass Way 1976, 1,527 $505,000
October 2020 756 Windlass Way 1978, 2,461 $810,000
October 2020 734 Anchor Dr 1969, 1,451 $830,000
February 2021 677 Anchor Dr 2005, 4,304 $1,895,000
March 2021 757 Windlass Way 1992, 2,346 $1,200,000
May 2021 751 Windlass Way 1983, 3,969 $1,500,000
August 2021 734 Anchor Dr 1969, 1,451 $1,550,000
January 2022 699 Anchor Dr 1986, 1,570 $2,395,000
February 2023 740 Windlass Way 1973, 1,492 $845,000
May 28, 2025 736 Windlass Way 1969, 2,096 $1,225,000
February 2, 2026 748 Windlass Way 1971, 2,849 $1,210,000
March 5, 2026 732 Windlass Way 1979, 3,003 $1,475,000
April 24, 2026 668 Anchor Dr 1972, 1,999 $1,100,000
June 15, 2026 739 Anchor Dr 1999, 2,209 $1,600,000
July 6, 2026 734 Anchor Dr 1969, 1,451 $850,000
August 27, 2026 751 Windlass Way 1983, 3,969 $2,850,000

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser sale files joined to the 2026 parcel roll for year built and heated area.

Sales by calendar year

The county file shows 2 qualified home sales in 2019, 5 in 2020, 4 in 2021, 1 in 2022, 1 in 2023, none in 2024, 1 in 2025 and 6 in 2026 through August 27. Six in eight months is more than any full year in that span, so 2026 has been an unusually active year for this small street.

Price per heated square foot

The seven sales since May 2025 worked out to about $425 to $724 per county heated square foot, median about $584. The low end is 748 Windlass Way, a 1971 home of 2,849 square feet, and the high end is 739 Anchor Drive, a raised 1999 home of 2,209 square feet. Listing sites often quote area under air or total area, which can differ from the county's heated figure.

The record sale

The highest qualified price in the file is $2,850,000 for 751 Windlass Way on August 27, 2026, a 1983 home of 3,969 heated square feet at the end of the cul-de-sac and the only three-story home on the roll. The same house sold for $1,500,000 in May 2021.

Resales that show the spread

734 Anchor Drive, a ground-level 1969 home of 1,451 square feet, sold for $1,550,000 in August 2021 and for $850,000 in July 2026 after a listing marketed it for remodeling following Helene and Milton. 668 Anchor Drive moved from $885,250 in January 2020 to $1,100,000 in April 2026. The same street can hold a near-land-value sale and a record in the same summer.

The one sale between Ian and 2025

Only one qualified sale was recorded from October 2022 through the end of 2024: 740 Windlass Way at $845,000 in February 2023. Several deeds in those years were recorded without county qualification, which is why they are left out of the medians above.

Value on the county roll

The 2026 roll sets just values of $629,171 to $2,547,175 across the 44 homes, median $1,210,972, with land alone at a median of $698,068. Just value is the county's tax estimate, not a sale price, and on this street the land is often more than half of it.

Three parcels at a $10 building value

698, 734 and 748 Anchor Drive carry a building value of $10 on the 2026 roll. That pattern often means the appraiser gives the structure no contributing value, but the reason for each is to confirm with the Lee County Property Appraiser and City permit records.

Anchors Aweigh home types, sizes and lots

Anchors Aweigh homes are detached single-family houses on canal lots, built one at a time over six decades, so a 1960s ground-level ranch can sit beside a raised 2025 home. The figures below come from the 2026 Lee County parcel roll for the 44 homes; where a listing adds detail, it is labelled as listing data.

Item Value
Property type Single-family only, 44 homes on the county roll
Year built 1965 to 2025; 17 before 1979, 19 from 1979 to 1999, 8 from 2000 on
Heated area 1,309 to 4,304 sq ft; median 2,364
Bedrooms 3 bed 24, 4 bed 11, 2 bed 4, 5 bed 3
Stories One story 31; 1.5 story 3; two story 6; 2.5 story 1; three story 1; 2 new homes not yet rated
Private pool 37 of 44 homes
Lot size 0.289 to 0.734 acre; median 0.40; 18.02 acres in all
Waterfront All 44 coded as on a canal

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, 2026 (export dated November 1, 2026).

Ranch homes from the 1960s and 1970s

The oldest homes on the roll are 748 Anchor Drive (1965), 721 Anchor Drive (1966) and three from 1969: 698 and 734 Anchor Drive and 736 Windlass Way. Fifteen homes date from the 1970s, and listings describe 698 and 734 Anchor Drive as ground-level homes.

Homes from the 1980s and 1990s

Twelve homes were built in the 1980s and more followed in the 1990s, among them 728 Anchor Drive (1991), 757 Windlass Way (1992) and 739 Anchor Drive (1999). A listing for 739 Anchor describes a raised Florida stilt-style home.

Homes built since 2000

Eight homes date from 2000 on: 687 Anchor Drive (2000), 707 Anchor Drive (2003), 677 Anchor Drive and 747 Windlass Way (2005), 718 Anchor Drive (2007), 659 Anchor Drive (2019) and two homes on the 2025 roll.

The two 2025 homes

676 Anchor Drive appears as a two-story 2025 home of 4,630 heated square feet and 729 Anchor Drive as a one-story 2025 home of 2,072 square feet. Their permits and elevations are to confirm with the City's permit portal.

Bedrooms and layout

The roll counts 24 three-bedroom homes, 11 four-bedroom homes, 4 two-bedroom homes and 3 five-bedroom homes. Thirty-one homes are coded one story, and 751 Windlass Way is the lone three-story house.

Pools

Thirty-seven of the 44 homes carry a private pool on the roll. There is no community pool in any source we read.

Lot sizes and frontage

Lots run 0.289 to 0.734 acre with a median of 0.40 acre. On the north leg of Anchor Drive, the odd-numbered lots from 655 to 699 run about 142 to 148 feet wide by 150 feet deep, and a listing for 738 Anchor Drive describes 180 feet of canal frontage.

Docks and seawalls on the roll

The county flags a dock on 9 parcels and a seawall on 9, but listings show docks and lifts on more lots than that, so treat the roll flags as incomplete and confirm each dock in person.

The street layout and the unrecorded plat

Anchors Aweigh is a named pocket inside the larger Sanibel Estates area rather than a subdivision with its own recorded plat, declaration or clubhouse. Understanding how the county describes these lots helps a buyer read a title commitment and a listing, and explains why a house number check matters before comparing prices.

Anchor Drive, north leg

The odd numbers 655 to 699 on the east side of the north leg hold 9 homes built from 1980 to 2019, from 1,348 to 4,304 square feet. Their legal descriptions cite Sanibel Estates Unit 1, Plat Book 9, Page 115.

Anchor Drive, west and south legs

The 19 parcels from 656 to 748 Anchor Drive run from 1965 to 2025 in county year built and from 1,309 to 4,021 square feet. They include the lots named in county records as Anchors Aweigh lots 5, 6 and 12.

Windlass Way

The Windlass Way cul-de-sac holds 13 homes from 728 to 760, built from 1969 to 2005 and ranging from 1,492 to 3,969 square feet. Most of the lots that carry the Anchors Aweigh name in county records (16, 17, 18, 21, 22 and 24) are here.

The Periwinkle Way lots

711, 719 and 727 Periwinkle Way front the main road with a canal at the rear. They were built from 1970 to 1987 and run 1,930 to 2,769 square feet; the roll describes two of them as Sanibel Estates Unit 5, Block 3, Lots 29 and 30.

How the county describes the lots

Most legal descriptions start at the intersection of South Yachtsman Drive and State Road 867, the old route number for Periwinkle Way, and run by bearing and distance, for example south 75 degrees 24 minutes 2 seconds west for 390.47 feet. Some deeds also cite Sanibel Estates Unit 3, Plat Book 13, Page 40.

No recorded declaration found

No recorded Anchors Aweigh plat, declaration or deed restriction was found online. Two lots refer to recorded deeds at Official Records Book 1979, Pages 1319 and 1321; any restrictions in them are to confirm with a title search.

Developer and builders

No public source we read names the original developer or any builder. The first recorded deed in the county sale file is from 1973, and the build years point to lot-by-lot custom building rather than one builder's program.

Neighbors that are not Anchors Aweigh

The canal homes on Beach Road and Bailey Road in the same section belong to Shell Harbor, and the four Spoonbill Court homes are described as lying south of Periwinkle Way and southwest of Anchor Drive. Neither is counted on this page.

The canals, the docks and the bridge

Anchors Aweigh is a boating street first: every home is coded as on a canal, and listings describe docks and boat lifts behind many of them. The canals are narrow and man-made, and the route to open water runs under a low bridge, so a boat owner should measure twice before falling for a house.

Narrow, mangrove-lined canals

At a February 2026 Planning Commission hearing, the canal behind 661 Anchor Drive was described as very narrow and possibly never dredged. A 2021 hearing on a lift at 686 Anchor Drive noted city-trimmed mangroves along the public canal.

The route to San Carlos Bay

Listings describe Gulf access through San Carlos Bay with one bridge to pass under. That this is the East Periwinkle Way bridge comes from resident testimony and listing wording rather than a chart, so confirm the route and depths with a local captain.

East Periwinkle Way bridge clearance

Santiva Chronicle reported the bridge at 8.4 to 8.8 feet of vertical clearance and 28.5 feet of horizontal clearance today, with the replacement design raising those to 9.4 to 9.8 feet and 56.4 feet. Clearance also changes with the tide.

The council's January 2026 decision

An Anchor Drive resident speaking for about 30 neighbors asked council for more height. On January 13, 2026, council kept the design with about one more foot of clearance, since added height was estimated to cost about $4 million more.

Replacement schedule

Reporting in October 2025 put the contract award in April 2026 and completion around February 2029. Current construction status, and any canal closures during work, are to confirm with the City.

Boat lifts and the variance process

City rules limit how far a dock or lift may reach into a canal, measured against its width. On February 24, 2026, the Planning Commission unanimously approved a lift at 661 Anchor Drive taking up to 36 percent of the canal width, with reflectors on the outer pilings; the earlier lift there had been destroyed in Ian. A 2021 variance at 686 Anchor Drive followed the same path.

Lifts named in listings

Listings name 10,000-pound lifts at 736 and 748 Windlass Way and 739 Anchor Drive, and a substantial private dock and lift at 738 Anchor Drive. Ask for the dock permit and any post-storm repair permits.

The deeded beach path and what is nearby

Anchors Aweigh has no clubhouse, golf or shared pool; what owners describe instead is a deeded path to the Gulf beach over a small footbridge, plus the island's bike paths and East End shops a short drive away. Broker pages list the amenities simply as canal waterfront and deeded beach.

The brick-paver lane and footbridge

A listing for 738 Anchor Drive describes Anchor Drive turning into a brick-paver lane that leads to a private footbridge, and a listing for 736 Windlass Way calls the footbridge charming and places it at the end of the street. A broker page describes a foot path with a wood bridge over the canal to East Gulf Drive.

Who maintains the footbridge

We did not find who owns or maintains the footbridge and paver lane in any public record read for this page. Ask the seller and the title company for the recorded beach access easement and any maintenance arrangement.

Lighthouse Beach and the fishing pier

Lighthouse Beach Park and the fishing pier at the island's eastern tip are about 1.2 miles in a straight line from the middle of the pocket.

Periwinkle Way shops and dining

A broker page puts the East End stretch of Periwinkle Way, with shops and restaurants, about 5 minutes away by car, and the shared-use path along Periwinkle Way connects by bike.

No gate and no golf

No gate appears in any source read for this page; Anchor Drive ends at the paver lane. There is no golf course or club in the pocket.

Ding Darling refuge

The J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge lies across the island off Sanibel-Captiva Road and is a regular drive or bike ride for East End owners.

Where is Anchors Aweigh on Sanibel?

Anchors Aweigh sits on the East End of Sanibel, south of Periwinkle Way and west of South Yachtsman Drive, between the main road and the homes along East Gulf Drive. County parcel centers run from about 26.4450 to 26.4488 degrees north, and the whole pocket is reached from Anchor Drive off Periwinkle Way.

Destination Distance Typical drive
Periwinkle Way shops and dining short drive about 5 min (broker page)
Sanibel beaches short drive about 5 min (broker page)
Lighthouse Beach Park about 1.2 mi straight line a few minutes
Sanibel Causeway short drive about 10 min (broker page)
Captiva across the island about 20 min (broker page)
The Sanibel School about 3.6 mi straight line about 10 min, to confirm
HealthPark Medical Center about 7.1 mi straight line to confirm
Downtown Fort Myers about 16.6 mi straight line about 25 to 35 min
Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) about 18.2 mi straight line about 40 min (broker page)

Sources: Pfeifer Realty drive times for Anchors Aweigh; straight-line distances computed from the county parcel centers in our research file; downtown Fort Myers time from our Sanibel research file, November 2026. Season traffic from January to April adds time.

The streets

House numbers run 655 to 748 on Anchor Drive, 728 to 760 on Windlass Way and 711 to 727 on Periwinkle Way. Windlass Way ends in a cul-de-sac, and listings describe 751 Windlass Way as sitting at its end.

The causeway and tolls

Coming onto Sanibel over the causeway costs a $6 toll with a transponder or $9 by plate, and leaving is free, per our Sanibel research file. Lee County sells an annual pass for frequent drivers.

Captiva

Captiva is reached by driving west the length of Sanibel; for homes there, see our Captiva Island homes for sale page.

Nearby East End neighborhoods

Other East End streets we cover include Ferry Landing homes for sale, bayside homes near the causeway, and Colony Beach Estates homes for sale on Bella Vista Way.

What does it cost to own an Anchors Aweigh home?

Anchors Aweigh ownership costs are mostly property tax, flood and wind insurance and the upkeep of a canal home, because no mandatory association is documented in the sources we read. Fee figures below are stated exactly as published, and where public sources disagree the table says so rather than choosing one.

Cost Figure Source
Association No mandatory association documented; two broker pages show no fees; a 2021 listing showed $50 a year Broker and listing pages
Community development district None; every parcel is in the City of Sanibel tax district (010) Lee County roll
2026 proposed millage, district 010 14.0021 mills proposed, against 14.0882 in 2025 Lee County Property Appraiser millage book (preliminary)
Property tax examples $11,168 (2024, 736 Windlass); $12,410 (2024, 748 Windlass); $14,968 (2024, 734 Anchor); $12,109 (2025, 738 Anchor); $18,118 (2025, 739 Anchor) Listing pages
Homestead share 21 of 44 parcels Lee County roll
Causeway toll $6 with a transponder, $9 by plate, inbound only Our Sanibel research file

Sources: Lee County Property Appraiser roll (export dated November 1, 2026) and preliminary 2026 millage book printed August 11, 2026; broker and listing pages read November 18, 2026.

The association question

Two broker pages show no association fees, and a listing for 739 Anchor Drive shows none. Against that, a January 2021 listing for 751 Windlass Way showed $50 a year and a listing for 736 Windlass Way said association fees covered internet, sewer and water. A voluntary fund is possible; ask the seller for any dues history in writing.

No CDD

No community development district appears on the roll. Parcels pay City of Sanibel millage alongside county, school and special district levies, including the Sanibel Fire and Rescue district and the Sanibel Public Library.

Property tax on a purchase

The listing tax figures above are past bills on specific homes. A buyer's first bill is set by the purchase-year assessment, and the 14.0021 figure is the August preliminary rate, so use the Lee County Tax Collector's estimator with your expected price.

Homestead and the Save Our Homes cap

Twenty-one of the 44 parcels carry a homestead exemption. Florida's homestead exemption can take up to $50,000 off assessed value for a full-time resident, and the Save Our Homes cap limits yearly growth in a homestead's assessed value to 3 percent or inflation, whichever is lower, resetting at sale.

If an association turns up

Florida's Chapter 720 covers homeowners associations. If a title search finds a mandatory association, section 720.401 calls for a disclosure summary and section 720.30851 lets the closing agent request an estoppel certificate showing any amounts owed.

Transfer or capital fees

No transfer or capital contribution fee was published in any source we read for this pocket.

Rules for renting, pets and changes at Anchors Aweigh

Anchors Aweigh rules come mainly from the City of Sanibel, which sets island-wide rental, building and dock rules, because no recorded deed restrictions for the pocket were found online. Read any restrictions that turn up in the title work before you buy, and treat the points below as the questions to ask.

Rentals and the 28-day minimum

A broker page for Anchors Aweigh and a rental registration guide citing Sanibel's dwelling-rental rules both describe a minimum rental period of 28 days for single-family homes. Some older exceptions exist, so confirm the current rule for any address with the City of Sanibel before you plan on rental income.

Rental registration

Sanibel requires owners who rent to register the dwelling with the City, and the current form and fee are to confirm with the City.

Pets and assistance animals

We found no pet rule for Anchors Aweigh in any public source, so any limit is to confirm with the seller's title work. An assistance animal for a person with a disability is not a pet under federal and Florida fair housing law, and a pet limit does not bar it.

Age

We found no age restriction for Anchors Aweigh in any record read for this page.

Docks, lifts and the City

New docks, lifts and repairs go through the City's permit review, and a lift that reaches past the standard limit into the canal needs Planning Commission approval, as the 2021 and 2026 Anchor Drive hearings show.

Changes, permits and the CityView portal

Additions, elevations, pools and demolitions go through the City's building and planning review, which applies the floodplain rules below. In March 2026 the City moved permitting to its CityView portal, so ask for the permit history of any home you consider.

Is Anchors Aweigh in a flood zone?

The FEMA flood zone was not confirmed for any single Anchors Aweigh lot in the sources read for this page, so treat every home as needing its own check. Sanibel's flood maps use Zones AE, AO, VE and X, these are canal lots near the East End Gulf shore, and Lee County places the island in evacuation Zone A.

Item Anchors Aweigh
FEMA zone per lot To confirm per address on the City's Forerunner portal or FEMA's Map Service Center
Zones used on Sanibel AE, AO, VE and X, with Coastal A areas
Homes built before 1979 (pre-FIRM) 17 of 44
NFIP entry Sanibel joined in 1979
Community Rating System Class 5, a 25% discount on NFIP premiums
Evacuation zone Lee County Zone A

Sources: City of Sanibel Flood Information page; Lee County Property Appraiser roll for years built; Lee County Emergency Management.

Check each address

The City's Forerunner portal shows the flood zone and any elevation certificate on file for an address, and the FEMA Flood Map Service Center is the official public source for flood maps. Pull both for any home you consider.

Pre-FIRM homes

Seventeen of the 44 homes were built before Sanibel joined the National Flood Insurance Program in 1979, so they were built before the first flood maps applied. Ground-level homes from that era rate very differently from raised homes.

Evacuation Zone A

Zone A is the first group Lee County orders out ahead of storm surge. All of Zone A, including Sanibel, was ordered to evacuate on September 27, 2022, the day before Ian.

Re-entry passes

After a storm the City controls access to the island. The City says re-entry passes issued in 2024 remain valid for 2026, and residential passes need identification with a Sanibel or Captiva address.

Flood insurance and the CRS discount

A lender requires flood insurance on a federally backed mortgage in a special flood hazard area. Sanibel's Class 5 Community Rating System rating gives a 25 percent discount on NFIP premiums, and each home's premium turns on how its lowest floor compares with the base flood elevation.

Storm history buyers ask about

Anchors Aweigh lies a short walk from the Gulf on an island that took heavy surge in 2022 and more flooding twice in 2024, and buyers rightly ask what that meant for this street. No home-by-home damage report is public, so the points below separate island-wide reports from what listings and the county roll show here.

Hurricane Ian, September 28, 2022

SCCF's high-water-mark analysis found water possibly up to 10 feet above ground in parts of Sanibel, with Gulf-facing shores flooding more than the bay side. Damage to any single Anchors Aweigh home is to confirm with the seller and City permit records.

The bridge and canal after Ian

Ian washed out the approaches to the East Periwinkle Way bridge, and in November 2022 Santiva Chronicle reported the canal there would close at times for repairs to the bridge abutments.

Signs on this street

The boat lift at 661 Anchor Drive was destroyed in Ian, per the 2026 hearing. A 2023 listing for 698 Anchor Drive said the home had been remediated from the effects of the storm. Two new homes reached the 2025 roll, and three parcels carry a $10 building value; the cause of each is to confirm.

Helene, September 2024

SCCF reported that Helene's surge, about 5 feet, caused flooding across the islands, including along Periwinkle Way.

Milton, October 2024

The City warned of surge up to 12 feet before Milton; SCCF and local reports after landfall described actual surge of about 3 to 5 feet, more than 5 feet in places. City staff told WGCU that surge overwashes the entire island and exceeds a stormwater system built for rain.

2025 and 2026

We found no storm in 2025 or 2026 through mid-November that damaged Sanibel in the sources read for this page.

Insurance, elevation and the 50 percent rule

Anchors Aweigh mixes ground-level 1960s homes with raised newer ones, so the City's substantial-improvement rule, elevation certificates and wind features shape what a buyer can change and what insurance costs. These are due-diligence facts for a purchase; this page is about buying a home here, not a guide to rebuilding.

The 50 percent rule

The City of Sanibel checks whether repair or improvement costs reach 50 percent of the structure's market value, using the Lee County roll or a licensed appraisal. Crossing that line brings a non-compliant building up to current floodplain standards, which usually means raising the lowest floor.

Docks and the 50 percent rule

The same 50 percent test applies to repairing a dock that does not meet current rules, including after hurricanes, so ask whether a dock was repaired or replaced since 2022.

The 2026 height exception

In June 2026 the City acted on an ordinance letting existing ground-level homes be raised up to 10 feet above grade without regard to height limits. Its final terms are to confirm with the City before you plan around it.

Rebuild windows

The City has extended its window for re-establishing nonconforming structures more than once since Ian. The current deadline is to confirm with the City Planning Department.

Elevation certificates

Insurers price flood cover on the elevation certificate. If none is on Forerunner for an address, a surveyor can produce one during your inspection period.

Wind features

Listings cite impact glass at 736 Windlass Way, 738 Anchor Drive and 698 Anchor Drive, and new metal roofs at 736 and 748 Windlass Way. A wind mitigation inspection documents features like these for insurance credits.

Roof age and insurability

Florida law limits an insurer's ability to refuse a homeowner policy based only on the age of a roof younger than 15 years; older roofs usually need an inspection. Ask for the roof permit date.

Not a condominium

These are single-family homes, so Florida's condominium milestone inspection and reserve study laws do not apply.

Schools serving Anchors Aweigh addresses

Anchors Aweigh addresses are served by the School District of Lee County, with The Sanibel School on the island for kindergarten through eighth grade and high school on the mainland. Listing zone labels give a starting point, but confirm any address with the district before you rely on it.

The Sanibel School

The Sanibel School is a public K-8 school at 3840 Sanibel-Captiva Road, phone (239) 472-1617, about 3.6 miles from the pocket in a straight line. The school describes itself as a National Blue Ribbon school and says off-island students may attend, and Florida graded it A again in 2026.

Listing zone labels

Listings for 736 Windlass Way and 739 Anchor Drive show Elementary Zone N, Middle Zone L and High South Zone 5. These are listing data, to confirm with the district.

High school

High school students attend on the mainland. Cypress Lake High School rose from a B to an A in 2026, per the Island Reporter; the zoned assignment for this pocket is to confirm with the district.

Use the locator

The district's School Site Locator confirms zones by address, and a zone sets eligibility rather than a guaranteed seat.

A short history of Anchors Aweigh

Anchors Aweigh grew lot by lot along its man-made canals from the mid-1960s onward, with no single builder program, and it is still renewing one house at a time. The milestones below come from the county roll and sale files and local news, with anything the records do not settle, such as the original developer, marked as such.

The first homes

The oldest homes on the roll date to 1965 and 1966: 748 Anchor Drive and 721 Anchor Drive. Who first cut the lots and dug the canals is to confirm from deeds at the Lee County Clerk.

The 1970s and 1980s

Fifteen homes were built in the 1970s and twelve in the 1980s. The earliest recorded deed in the county sale file is a 1973 transfer on 746 Windlass Way.

Joining the flood program

Sanibel joined the National Flood Insurance Program in 1979, which splits the street's homes into 17 built before and 27 built after.

Later homes

Infill homes followed from 1999 to 2007, one more in 2019, and two on the 2025 roll at 676 and 729 Anchor Drive.

After Ian

Since 2022 the pocket has seen lifts rebuilt under variances, two new homes, a run of six qualified sales in 2026 and a new recorded high at 751 Windlass Way.

What should you check before you make an offer on an Anchors Aweigh home?

Anchors Aweigh homes differ widely from one lot to the next in age, height and dock condition, so the checks that matter most are the house's own elevation, storm and permit history, the boat route and the beach access paperwork. Work through this list with your agent, inspector, insurer and a local captain before the inspection period ends.

Read the legal description on the tax bill so you know whether the home is one of the named Anchors Aweigh lots, another Sanibel Estates lot on the same street or a neighbor outside the pocket.

Pull the elevation certificate and flood zone

Check Forerunner and the FEMA Map Service Center for the zone and base flood elevation, and compare them with the home's lowest floor.

Get flood and wind quotes

Ask for an NFIP or private flood quote and a wind quote with a wind mitigation report before you commit.

Read the permit history

Ask the City for permits since 2022, any substantial-damage finding and the dock and lift permits.

Measure your boat against the bridge

Compare your boat's air draft with the 8.4 to 8.8 foot clearance at the East Periwinkle Way bridge, adjusted for tide, and ask a captain about canal depth at low water.

Get the beach access in writing

Ask the title company for the recorded beach access easement and who maintains the footbridge and paver lane.

Ask about any dues

Get any voluntary dues or footbridge fund history in writing from the seller, since published figures conflict.

Compare like homes

Compare a home with recorded sales of similar age, height and size on Anchor Drive and Windlass Way, not with island-wide medians.

Anchors Aweigh and other Sanibel neighborhoods buyers compare

Anchors Aweigh buyers often also look at the wider Sanibel Estates area, at Shell Harbor's boating canals nearby and at other East End streets with single-family homes. The table sticks to what our research files say about each, and the whole island is on our Sanibel homes for sale page.

Neighborhood How it compares with Anchors Aweigh
Sanibel Estates (wider area) Same East End canal setting and era; larger, with some lots on East Gulf Drive; nine 2023 to 2025 home sales at a $1,150,000 median in our research file
Shell Harbor East End Gulf-access canal homes; larger and more boat-oriented, with a wider price band
East Gulf Drive Gulf-front homes Same beach within walking distance; direct Gulf frontage at a large premium
Ferry Landing East End bayside single-family homes near the causeway
Colony Beach Estates East End single-family homes on Bella Vista Way

Source: Lee County roll and our Sanibel neighborhood research files, November 2026.

Sanibel Estates

The wider neighborhood shares the canal setting and the 1970s build era, but it is larger and some of its lots front East Gulf Drive. Compare sale prices lot by lot rather than by label.

Shell Harbor

Shell Harbor's canal homes on Beach Road and Bailey Road sit nearby in the same county section and are aimed squarely at boaters, at a wider price range.

Ferry Landing and Colony Beach Estates

For other East End single-family streets, see our Ferry Landing and Colony Beach Estates pages.

What Anchors Aweigh offers and what it does not

It offers canal frontage on every lot, a deeded footpath to the beach and no documented mandatory association. It does not offer a gate, golf, a clubhouse, a high-clearance boat route or short-term rentals under 28 days.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Anchors Aweigh specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows Anchors Aweigh and other East End Sanibel homes, and our Fort Myers office on College Parkway is the closest of our offices to the causeway. For this page we tracked every qualified sale on Anchor Drive and Windlass Way since 2019 and matched it to its year built and heated area on the county roll.

★★★★★ "Marc was really helpful throughout the long and drawn out shortsale process. He was very responsive whenever I had questions and was always friendly and professional. I highly recommend him for any real estate transaction."

Verified Zillow review. Nicola Foote, on buying a single-family home in Estero with Marc Comisar.

Talk to our team about an Anchors Aweigh home

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816 with your boat size, bedroom count and price range, and an agent will send matching listings, recorded sales on these streets and the flood and bridge questions for each home. You can also search current listings at any time.

Thinking of selling an Anchors Aweigh home?

Sellers on this street do best when a home is priced against recorded sales of similar age, height and dock on Anchor Drive and Windlass Way rather than an island-wide figure. Start with a free home valuation from our team, and for a seller's view of both islands, read McGreevy and Comisar's Sanibel and Captiva home selling page.

Frequently Asked Questions about Anchors Aweigh homes for sale

These are the questions buyers ask most about Anchors Aweigh homes for sale, answered from the Lee County roll and sale files, City of Sanibel pages, local news and public broker pages. Where something was not confirmed for this page, the answer says so plainly rather than guessing.

What is Anchors Aweigh?

A small pocket of canal-front single-family homes on Sanibel's East End, on Anchor Drive, Windlass Way and three Periwinkle Way lots, ZIP 33957.

Is Anchors Aweigh a recorded subdivision?

No. It is an unrecorded block of lots inside Sanibel Estates Unit 5, Block 3, described by metes and bounds on the county roll.

Is Anchors Aweigh part of Sanibel Estates?

Yes, it is a named pocket of the Sanibel Estates area, and some listings use only the Sanibel Estates label.

How many homes are in Anchors Aweigh?

The 2026 county roll shows 44 single-family homes on those streets. Brokers describe about 52 homesites.

What ZIP code is Anchors Aweigh in?

33957, inside the City of Sanibel in Lee County.

Where exactly is it?

South of Periwinkle Way and west of South Yachtsman Drive on the East End, reached by Anchor Drive.

Who built the homes?

No developer or builder is named in the public sources we read; the homes were built one at a time.

When were the homes built?

County year built runs 1965 to 2025: 17 before 1979, 19 from 1979 to 1999 and 8 from 2000 on.

How big are the homes?

Heated area runs 1,309 to 4,304 square feet on the county roll, median 2,364.

How many bedrooms do the homes have?

The roll counts 24 three-bedroom, 11 four-bedroom, 4 two-bedroom and 3 five-bedroom homes.

Are the homes one story?

Most are: 31 are coded one story, and 751 Windlass Way is the only three-story home.

Do the homes have pools?

Thirty-seven of the 44 homes carry a private pool on the roll.

How big are the lots?

Lots run 0.289 to 0.734 acre, median 0.40 acre.

Are all the lots on a canal?

Yes. All 44 parcels carry the county's canal code.

What do Anchors Aweigh homes sell for?

Seven qualified sales from May 2025 through August 27, 2026 ran $850,000 to $2,850,000, median $1,225,000, on Lee County records.

What is the highest recorded sale?

$2,850,000 for 751 Windlass Way on August 27, 2026.

What was the most recent sale?

751 Windlass Way on August 27, 2026, the newest sale in the county file.

What did homes sell for before Ian?

Five qualified sales from January 2021 to September 2022 ran $1,200,000 to $2,395,000, median $1,550,000.

Is there an HOA?

No mandatory association is documented. Two broker pages show no fees, while a 2021 listing showed $50 a year. Confirm with the seller.

Is there a CDD?

No. The parcels sit in the City of Sanibel tax district with no community development district.

Is Anchors Aweigh gated?

No gate appears in any source read for this page.

Is there golf?

No. There is no golf course or club in the pocket.

Does Anchors Aweigh have beach access?

Yes. Listings describe a deeded path over a canal footbridge at the end of Anchor Drive toward East Gulf Drive.

Can I keep a boat here?

Yes. Every lot is on a canal, and listings describe docks and lifts with Gulf access through San Carlos Bay.

How much bridge clearance is there?

The East Periwinkle Way bridge has 8.4 to 8.8 feet of vertical clearance today, rising to about 9.4 to 9.8 feet after replacement.

Can I add a bigger boat lift?

A lift reaching past the City's standard limit needs Planning Commission approval; one at 661 Anchor Drive was approved in February 2026.

Can I rent my home short term?

A broker page and a rental guide describe a 28-day minimum for single-family homes on Sanibel, with City registration. Confirm with the City.

Are pets allowed?

No pet rule was found in public sources. Assistance animals are not pets under fair housing law.

What flood zone is Anchors Aweigh in?

Not confirmed per lot for this page. Check each address on the City's Forerunner portal or FEMA's Map Service Center.

Is flood insurance required?

A lender requires it on a federally backed mortgage in a special flood hazard area. Sanibel's Class 5 rating gives a 25 percent NFIP discount.

What evacuation zone is it in?

Lee County evacuation Zone A.

Did Anchors Aweigh flood in Hurricane Ian?

No home-by-home report is public. Ian's surge reached up to about 10 feet above ground in parts of Sanibel, and at least one lift on Anchor Drive was destroyed.

Can I raise an older home?

A June 2026 City ordinance lets existing ground-level homes be raised up to 10 feet above grade regardless of height limits; confirm its terms with the City.

What schools serve Anchors Aweigh?

The Sanibel School, a K-8 public school rated A in 2026, about 3.6 miles away. High school is on the mainland; confirm with the district.

How far is the airport?

A broker page puts Southwest Florida International Airport about 40 minutes away.

Where do I see Anchors Aweigh homes for sale?

Our team posts active listings in our current listings search and sends new ones as they appear. Call 239-441-2816 or contact us to set up a search.

About Domain Realty Group on Sanibel

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team covering Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, and for buyers looking on Sanibel our nearest office is on College Parkway in Fort Myers, on the mainland side of the causeway. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, and its team production stands at $2.5 billion across 4,000+ transactions. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) lead it, with over 45 years of combined direct experience.

Meet the people who would show you a home on our agents page, read our client reviews or learn about our team. We tracked each recorded sale on these streets back to 2019 against the county roll, house by house, before writing this page.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Sanibel homes for sale, Ferry Landing homes for sale, Colony Beach Estates homes for sale, Captiva Island homes for sale and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to one of the sources below. No real estate portal is linked, by policy; facts attributed to "listings" or "broker pages" are labelled as such. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll and sale files, qualified sales on the 44 Anchors Aweigh parcels (Anchor Drive 655 to 748, Windlass Way 728 to 760 and 711 to 727 Periwinkle Way) in ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026. Web sources were read November 18 to November 21, 2026 unless another date is shown.

County records

City of Sanibel and Lee County

Canals, docks and the East Periwinkle Way bridge

Flood, storms and building rules

Insurance

Rentals

Florida law and fair housing

Anchors Aweigh listings and broker pages

Schools

Nearby