Opens in a new tab
Back to Sanibel

Sanibel · Florida · 33957

Signal Inn Condos for Sale in Sanibel, FL

Signal Inn condos for sale: 19 Gulf-front units in small two-story buildings raised over parking on Olde Middle Gulf Drive in mid-island Sanibel, from 527 square foot one-bedroom flats to 1,537 square foot three-bedroom beach houses. Recorded county sales by plan, rental and pet rules, flood and condo-law checks and the documents to request before an offer. Updated November 2026.

Aerial photo from January 16, 2023 of the Signal Inn condominium site at 1811 Olde Middle Gulf Drive on Sanibel, FL 33957: eleven small hip-roofed buildings grouped around a central pool court beside a paved lane, with coastal vegetation toward the Gulf

Signal Inn is a 19-unit Gulf-front condominium at 1811 Olde Middle Gulf Drive in mid-island Sanibel, ZIP 33957, in the City of Sanibel, Lee County, and one of the complexes we follow for our Sanibel homes for sale coverage. Its units sit in small two-story, bungalow-style buildings raised over parking between Middle Gulf Drive and the beach, and the county roll lists them from 527 to 1,537 heated square feet for all but one unit. Lee County recorded 6 qualified Signal Inn sales from January 2016 to the newest one on July 16, 2025, from $485,000 to $1,100,000. Updated November 2026.

By Jesse McGreevy and Marc Comisar, Domain Realty Group. Data updated: November 2026. Call Domain Realty Group at 239-441-2816.

This page covers only the Signal Inn condominium, recorded under the legal name "Signal Inn Condo" at Lee County Official Records Book 1506, Page 1828. Older lodging guides call it the Signal Inn Beach and Racquetball Club, and rental listings call it Signal Inn Pet-Friendly Island Condos. It is not the Sanibel Inn, a separate resort on another part of the island, and no figure from that property or from any neighbour appears here.

Key takeaways for Signal Inn condo buyers

The points below are the ones that most often decide a Signal Inn purchase. They come from the Lee County Property Appraiser roll and sale files, the resort's own site, the City of Sanibel, Florida statutes, island news and public listing records, and each one is expanded later on this page with its source and date.

  • Signal Inn holds 19 residential units plus one common-area parcel, all at 1811 Olde Middle Gulf Drive on the county roll.
  • The roll dates 15 units to 1979 and 4 larger units to 1982, so the complex was finished in two stages.
  • Twelve units are small flats: six one-bedroom, one-bath units of 527 square feet and six two-bedroom, one-bath units of 651 square feet.
  • Four 1982 beach houses carry 1,537 heated square feet each, two with two bedrooms and two with three.
  • Lee County recorded 50 qualified Signal Inn sales since August 1981, and only 6 since January 2016.
  • The newest qualified sale on the county file closed July 16, 2025 at $685,000 for a 651 square foot two-bedroom unit.
  • Most rental sources describe weekly rentals with a 7-day minimum, and a City of Sanibel rental license applies to any rental.
  • Pets are allowed for owners and for vacation guests, according to the resort and broker pages; get the written pet rules before you buy.
  • The buildings have two living levels over parking and no elevator, which matters for access and for Florida's milestone inspection rules.
  • No public report describes Hurricane Ian damage at Signal Inn, and an October 2026 island travel roundup lists it as back in operation.

Signal Inn condos for sale right now

Signal Inn condos for sale come up rarely, because the complex has only 19 units and owners tend to hold them for years. Lee County recorded one qualified Signal Inn sale in the 24 months from November 2024 through the newest sale on the county file, and none between May 2021 and July 2025, so most months show no closed Signal Inn sale at all.

Twenty parcels on the roll

The Property Appraiser lists 20 Signal Inn parcels: 19 unit parcels numbered 1 to 19 and one common-area parcel that carries the shared land. Every unit uses the street address 1811 Olde Middle Gulf Drive with its unit number after it.

How to read a unit number

The unit number tells you a lot at Signal Inn. Units 1 to 12 alternate between the 651 square foot two-bedroom plan on odd numbers and the 527 square foot one-bedroom plan on even numbers. Units 13 to 19 are the larger plans, with 16 to 19 the 1982 beach houses.

Few sales, long gaps

The county file shows Signal Inn sales arriving one or two a year at most in recent decades. After a sale in May 2021, the next qualified sale did not record until July 2025, a gap of about four years that covers Hurricane Ian and the island's recovery.

Asking prices and recorded prices

An asking price is what a seller hopes to get; a recorded sale is what a buyer paid. Every sale price on this page comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's qualified sale files, which can trail a closing by several weeks, so compare any asking price against recorded sales of the same plan.

Searching for a Signal Inn listing

To see what is available today, search current listings and filter for Sanibel, or ask us to watch 1811 Olde Middle Gulf Drive for you. Listings use "Signal Inn" and "Signal Inn Condo" in their titles, and a few write the street as Middle Gulf Drive without "Olde," so we search all three forms.

Ready to tour a Signal Inn unit?

Tell us whether you want a one-bedroom flat, a two-bedroom flat or one of the beach houses, and whether you plan to rent it, and we will send every matching listing with the recorded sales of the same plan. Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816.

What do Signal Inn condos sell for?

Recent Signal Inn prices depend mostly on the plan: since 2016 the county recorded 527 square foot one-bedroom units near $485,000 to $490,000, 651 square foot two-bedroom units at $685,000, the 1,284 square foot plan at $790,000 and 1,537 square foot beach houses from $1,045,000 to $1,100,000. The table below shows the county windows.

Window to the July 16, 2025 sale Qualified sales Median Low High
24 months, since November 2024 1 $685,000 $685,000 $685,000
60 months, since November 2021 1 $685,000 $685,000 $685,000
Since January 2016 6 $737,500 $485,000 $1,100,000
Since January 2010 14 $692,500 $330,000 $1,100,000
All recorded history, since August 1981 50 $367,550 $99,900 $1,100,000

Data updated: November 2026. Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll and sale files, qualified improved sales on the 19 Signal Inn Condo unit parcels, index built November 18, 2026; newest Signal Inn sale July 16, 2025.

A median across all plans says little at Signal Inn, because a 527 square foot flat and a 1,537 square foot beach house share the same address. Read the plan-by-plan sales below before you weigh any single unit.

Every recorded sale since 2016

These are all six qualified sales the county recorded from January 2016 to November 2026, matched to the roll for heated area and bedrooms. Unit numbers are left off.

Month recorded Heated sq ft Bedrooms Built Sale price Price per heated sq ft
May 2019 1,537 3 1982 $1,045,000 about $680
July 2019 527 1 1979 $490,000 about $930
March 2020 1,537 3 1982 $1,100,000 about $716
December 2020 527 1 1979 $485,000 about $920
May 2021 1,284 2 1979 $790,000 about $615
July 2025 651 2 1979 $685,000 about $1,052

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser qualified sale files and parcel roll, index built November 18, 2026. Price per square foot is our arithmetic on the county heated area.

Price per square foot by plan

The small flats carry the highest price per heated square foot, from about $920 to about $1,052 in the sales above, because the Gulf-front land and shared amenities are split over fewer square feet. The beach houses and the 1,284 square foot plan sold for about $615 to $716 per square foot.

One-bedroom flats at 527 square feet

The county recorded eight qualified sales of the 527 square foot plan since 2004. They ran from $330,000 in June 2012 to $650,000 in January 2006, and the two most recent, in July 2019 and December 2020, were $490,000 and $485,000.

Two-bedroom flats at 651 square feet

Seven qualified sales of the 651 square foot plan recorded from 2002 to 2025, from $400,000 in February 2014 to $715,000 in May 2004. The July 2025 sale at $685,000 is the newest Signal Inn sale on the county file and the only one recorded after Hurricane Ian.

The 1982 beach houses

The four 1,537 square foot units recorded six qualified sales since 2004: $1,020,000 and $1,070,000 in 2004, $1,065,000 in January 2011, $844,500 in March 2012, $1,045,000 in May 2019 and $1,100,000 in March 2020. That last sale is the highest Signal Inn price on the county file.

The mid-size plans

Three units fall between the flats and the beach houses on the roll. The 1,284 square foot two-bedroom unit sold for $512,500 in May 2009, $700,000 in October 2015 and $790,000 in May 2021. The 1,272 square foot three-bedroom unit last recorded a qualified sale in January 1997 at $335,100.

The largest unit on the roll

One 1979 unit is carried at 2,400 heated square feet with four bedrooms and three baths, far larger than any other Signal Inn unit. It recorded qualified sales at $405,000 in May 1993 and $800,000 in July 2011. Because it is so far outside the other plans, confirm its layout and living area on the parcel record and in person.

Asking prices seen in November 2026

Public listing records read on November 13, 2026 showed three Signal Inn units for sale, asking $525,000, $649,000 and $899,000 after price cuts in October 2025, and each had been on the market for more than a year. These are asking prices from listing records, not recorded sales.

Value on the county roll

The Property Appraiser also posts a 2026 just value for each unit. Our research read those values from the parcel pages but could not confirm the field label, so they are not quoted here. Open the parcel record for the unit you want and read the just value and taxable value yourself before you set a budget.

Signal Inn floor plans, sizes and unit types

Signal Inn is unusual among Sanibel Gulf-front condominiums because its 19 units come in at least six different plans on the county roll, from compact one-bedroom flats to a four-bedroom unit. The table sums the roll by plan; listings and rental pages sometimes show larger areas because they count lanais or lofts.

Plan on the county roll Units Built Bedrooms and baths Heated sq ft
One-bedroom flat 6 (units 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12) 1979 1 bed, 1 bath 527
Two-bedroom flat 6 (units 1, 3, 5, 7, 9, 11) 1979 2 beds, 1 bath 651
Three-bedroom unit 1 (unit 15) 1979 3 beds, 2 baths 1,272
Two-bedroom with den 1 (unit 14) 1979 2 beds, 2 baths 1,284
Large unit 1 (unit 13) 1979 4 beds, 3 baths 2,400
Beach house 4 (units 16 to 19) 1982 2 or 3 beds, 2 baths 1,537

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, index built November 18, 2026.

The 527 square foot flats

The six one-bedroom flats are the smallest units at Signal Inn and among the smallest Gulf-front condos on the island. One bath, an open living and kitchen area and a lanai are typical, according to rental listings; confirm the lanai size for the unit you tour.

The 651 square foot flats

The six two-bedroom flats add a second bedroom in 124 more square feet than the one-bedroom plan, with one bath. Rental listings show these units sleeping more guests than the one-bedroom flats, which is part of why they draw rental buyers.

Unit 14 and its area question

The county carries unit 14 at 1,284 heated square feet with two bedrooms and two baths, while a 2025 listing showed 1,684 square feet and a den, and a rental page listed it as a three-bedroom unit with a wrap-around lanai. The gap likely comes from lanai or loft space counted differently, so ask for a measured plan.

The 1982 beach houses

Units 16 to 19 were added in 1982 and carry 1,537 heated square feet each. The roll lists two of them with two bedrooms and two with three, all with two baths. Broker pages call these the three-bedroom beach houses and list maximum occupancy of up to eight guests in the larger units.

Floor plan drawings

One broker site posts four Signal Inn floor plans, and another posts a site plan and floor plan files. Those drawings are marketing material, so read them alongside the county area and the condominium declaration, which defines each unit's boundaries.

Stairs, not elevators

Every Signal Inn building has two living levels above ground-level parking and no elevator, according to broker surveys and listings. Expect stairs to reach any unit, and plan for that if anyone in your household needs single-level access.

Finish and condition

Signal Inn units are individually owned, so kitchens, baths, flooring and furnishings vary from unit to unit. Rental listings and the resort site show units furnished for vacation guests. Ask the seller for permits and dates for any remodel, and check them with the City of Sanibel.

The Signal Inn site on Olde Middle Gulf Drive

Signal Inn occupies a strip of Gulf-front land reached from Olde Middle Gulf Drive, the older road alignment just south of Middle Gulf Drive in the island's middle stretch. The aerial at the top of this page, taken January 16, 2023, shows eleven small hip-roofed buildings around a pool court beside a paved lane, with coastal vegetation between the buildings and the beach.

Buildings and layout

The buildings are small and close together, set around a central courtyard and pool rather than in one long row. One listing summary describes two units per building; the exact building count and which units share a building are not published, so ask the association for the site plan.

Parking under the buildings

Each building is raised over ground-level parking, and listings describe designated parking under the building for owners and guests. Ask how many spaces go with the unit you want and whether boat or trailer parking is allowed under the rules.

Boardwalks to the beach

Broker pages describe deeded beach access by more than one boardwalk. The walks cross the dune vegetation between the buildings and the sand, so ask the association who maintains them and whether any repair needs a City of Sanibel permit.

Neighbours on the same stretch

The county roll places Signal Inn between Clamshell, a six-unit condominium at 1801 Olde Middle Gulf Drive, and Sandpiper Beach, a 27-unit condominium at 1919 Olde Middle Gulf Drive. Sanddollar, a 36-unit complex at 1785 and 1795 Middle Gulf Drive, sits a short way east.

No gate

No source describes a gate at Signal Inn, and the property runs an on-site rental office for guests. Treat it as an open complex and ask the association how it controls parking and beach access for owners and renters.

Racquetball and the shared buildings

Older broker pages describe an air-conditioned racquetball court, which they call the only public one on Sanibel, along with a community room and an exercise room. The current resort site does not mention racquetball, so confirm which shared rooms still operate.

Amenities at Signal Inn in late 2026

Signal Inn keeps a short list of shared amenities built around the beach and the pool court. Sources do not all agree on every item, and some date from before the 2022 and 2024 storms, so use this list as a starting point and confirm each item with the association before you rely on it.

The heated pool

Every source we read lists a heated pool, and one describes it as solar-heated. The resort site described the pool as recently refurbished. In the January 2023 aerial the pool sits in the central court between the buildings.

Hot tub

Broker pages and rental listings list a hot tub, sometimes called a jacuzzi, beside the pool. Ask whether it is open year-round and who pays for its upkeep.

Grills, gazebo and picnic area

Gas or charcoal grills, a gazebo and a picnic area appear on broker and rental pages. These are common elements owned through the association, so their upkeep comes out of the shared budget.

Office on site

The resort site describes an on-site office, and rental guests check in through the rental manager. For an owner, that office matters because it handles guest arrivals, housekeeping and many day-to-day calls for units in the rental program.

Walking paths

Broker pages list nature walking paths through the grounds. Outside the property, the island's shared-use path network runs about 25 miles, according to island travel coverage, and links mid-island Sanibel to the shops on Periwinkle Way and the refuge.

No golf or marina

Signal Inn has no golf course and no boat docks. The nearest golf is the Sanibel Island Golf Club at The Dunes, within about three miles according to rental location notes. Buyers who need a slip will look on the bay side of the island.

The Signal Inn condominium association

Signal Inn is governed by a condominium association made up of the 19 unit owners, under the declaration recorded at Official Records Book 1506, Page 1828. Its corporate record and officers were not confirmed for this page, so a buyer should pull the record directly and request the governing documents before signing a contract.

The declaration

The declaration at Book 1506, Page 1828 is the document that created the condominium. It sets each unit's share of common expenses, the use and rental rules and the procedure for amendments. The Lee County Clerk holds the recorded copy.

Two building stages

The roll dates units 1 to 15 to 1979 and units 16 to 19 to 1982. The first qualified sale on the county file is from August 1981, after the 1979 buildings were finished, which suggests the earlier buildings were in use before they were sold as condominium units. The declaration recitals would settle that history.

The developer

No public source we read names the developer. The declaration and the first deeds at the Lee County Clerk are the place to look if the original builder matters to you.

The corporate record

A search index points to an entity named Signal Inn Condominium Association, Inc., but the state corporate record could not be opened for this page. Search the Florida Division of Corporations by name to confirm its status, officers and registered agent.

Management

Gulf Coast Vacation Rentals, with its main office at 1101 Periwinkle Way on Sanibel, manages many Signal Inn units for rental owners, and the resort site names it as manager. Who manages the association itself, as opposed to the rental program, is a separate question to ask.

Documents to request

Ask for the declaration, bylaws, rules, the current budget, the reserve schedule, the last two years of minutes, the master insurance policy, any engineering reports and a written list of special assessments. Florida law gives a buyer the right to review these documents before closing.

What does it cost to own a Signal Inn condo each year?

Ownership costs at Signal Inn come from association dues, property taxes, insurance on the unit interior and contents, the City of Sanibel rental license if you rent, and any special assessment. The association does not publish its fees, and the figures in public listings disagree, so treat every number below as a starting point.

Association dues

Listing records show $1,686 and $2,745 labelled as annual dues for two different units, and real estate portals show ranges up to about $3,600 with no billing period. Several of those figures may be quarterly amounts shown as annual. Ask the association for the current budget, the billing period and the amount for the specific unit.

What the dues are said to cover

Portal pages say the dues cover grounds, irrigation, the master property insurance, water, sewer, trash, pest control and the shared recreation facilities. That list comes from portals, not the association, so check it against the budget.

Special assessments

No public record of a Signal Inn special assessment was found for this page. Storm repairs, insurance deductibles and rising premiums are common reasons for a condominium assessment, so ask for a written statement of any assessment levied or planned, and for the minutes where it was discussed.

The estoppel certificate

Before closing, the association issues an estoppel certificate that states what the seller owes and any assessments due. Florida Statutes 718.116 governs that certificate and its fee. Read it carefully, because it is the document that shows any balance you could inherit.

Transfer and capital fees

No transfer fee or capital contribution was found in public sources. Many condominiums charge one at sale, so ask the association and check the declaration and bylaws.

No CDD

No community development district was identified for Signal Inn. Confirm on the tax bill, where any district assessment would appear as a separate line.

The City of Sanibel rental license

The City of Sanibel requires a dwelling rental license for rentals. A copy of the city form dated February 26, 2020 listed a Limited license with a 28-day minimum at $300 and an Unlimited license with no minimum at $100. Those terms come from a third-party copy, so confirm current fees with the city.

Property taxes on a Signal Inn unit

Property taxes on a Signal Inn unit are set by the Lee County Property Appraiser's assessed value and the City of Sanibel, county, school and district millage, and they are collected by the Lee County Tax Collector. Because most units are second homes or rentals, few carry a homestead exemption, so taxes reset at each sale.

Taxes reported in listings

Listing records showed 2024 taxes of $6,395.71 for a two-bedroom flat and $12,747 for the 1,284 square foot unit. One portal reported a median of about $6,639 a year across six listings. These are listing-reported figures, not tax bills.

Checking the bill

Look up the unit on the Lee County Tax Collector's site for the last bill and on the Property Appraiser's parcel record for the current assessed and taxable values. A buyer's tax is figured on the new assessment after the sale, not the seller's bill.

Homestead and Save Our Homes

A Florida resident who makes a Signal Inn unit a permanent home can apply for the homestead exemption under Florida Statutes 196.031, and the Save Our Homes cap in 193.155 then limits yearly assessment increases. A unit used as a rental does not qualify.

Taxes on rental income

Short-term rental stays are taxed separately from the property itself. Ask the rental manager which rental taxes it collects and files for the unit, and ask your tax adviser how rental income and expenses will be reported.

Rental rules, pets and occupancy at Signal Inn

Signal Inn runs much like a small resort, with many units in a vacation rental program, so the rental and pet rules matter to almost every buyer. The facts below come from broker surveys, the resort site, rental listings and City of Sanibel coverage; confirm every rule in writing with the association and the city.

The 7-day minimum

Most broker sources describe weekly rentals with a 7-day minimum at Signal Inn, and one survey lists a 3-day minimum off season. That conflict is one reason to read the current rules and the declaration rather than rely on a summary.

How Sanibel's rental code fits

The City of Sanibel's Land Development Code allows rentals of no less than four consecutive weeks except in the resort housing district, according to January 2026 island news coverage. Which category and zoning district apply to Signal Inn units is not public, so ask the City of Sanibel Planning Department and the association before you plan a rental schedule.

Rental license checks

In January 2026 the Santiva Chronicle reported that the City of Sanibel was using software to flag unlicensed or non-compliant rentals. Any owner who rents should hold the correct city license and display it as the city requires.

The rental program

Gulf Coast Vacation Rentals manages many Signal Inn units and markets them through the resort site, which lists Units 01 to 19. Ask the association whether owners may use another manager or rent on their own, and ask the manager what commission it charges.

Rental income claims

Two listings cited gross rental income of about $70,000 for a two-bedroom flat and about $136,000 for the 1,284 square foot unit, without stating the period or expenses. Ask the seller for rental statements from the manager and tax records, not a summary.

Pets for owners and guests

Signal Inn markets itself as pet-friendly for owners and vacation guests, and broker pages say the rules allow pets. Booking listings mention limits of up to two pets on some units and a non-refundable pet fee paid to management. Get the written pet rules, including size, number and breed limits, before you buy.

Assistance animals

Any pet limit in the association rules does not apply in the same way to an assistance animal. Federal fair housing law and Florida Statutes 760.27 require housing providers to consider requests for assistance animals, so a buyer or renter who needs one should make that request to the association.

Occupancy

One broker site lists a maximum occupancy of eight in the larger units, and a rental page shows the 1,284 square foot unit sleeping seven. Occupancy limits come from the rules, the building code and the rental license, so ask the association for the limit that applies to each plan.

Age rules

No public source describes Signal Inn as a 55 or older community, and nothing we read suggests an age restriction. Ask the association to confirm in writing.

Is Signal Inn in a flood zone?

Signal Inn sits on the Gulf beach, and all of Sanibel lies in FEMA flood zones that require flood insurance on a financed purchase. The exact zone and base flood elevation for the Signal Inn buildings were not confirmed for this page, so check the FEMA map and the unit's elevation certificate before you make an offer.

What the city map shows

The City of Sanibel's flood depth map shows Gulf-front coastal high hazard bands marked VE, with base flood elevations of about 11 to 16 feet, and AE zones of about 8 to 10 feet inland, according to the city's published map. A Gulf-front site like Signal Inn may fall partly in a VE zone; confirm on the map.

Finding the zone for a unit

Search the FEMA Flood Map Service Center or the City of Sanibel flood information pages using 1811 Olde Middle Gulf Drive. The Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel record also has a flood section that can show the zone for the parcel.

Raised buildings

The Signal Inn buildings put their living levels over ground-level parking, and listings describe the units as elevated. The height of the lowest floor above the base flood elevation drives flood insurance cost, so ask for the elevation certificate for the building.

Flood insurance

Flood insurance is required for a mortgage on a property in a special flood hazard area. The association's master policy may cover the building, while each owner insures the interior and contents. Ask the association for the master flood policy and get a quote for your unit early.

Evacuation Zone A

Sanibel lies in Lee County Evacuation Zone A, the first zone ordered to leave when a storm threatens. Lee County ordered Zone A to evacuate on September 27, 2022, the day before Hurricane Ian made landfall.

The 50 percent rule

FEMA's substantial improvement rule, which applies in National Flood Insurance Program communities such as Sanibel, means that if repairs or improvements to a building cost 50 percent or more of its market value, the building must be brought up to current flood rules. Ask whether any Signal Inn building is close to that line.

Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton at Signal Inn

Hurricane Ian struck Sanibel on September 28, 2022, and Hurricanes Helene and Milton brought more flooding to the island in 2024. No public report describes storm damage, repairs or reopening dates specific to Signal Inn, so the history below is limited to public facts, and the rest is a question for the association.

What is on record

The county file shows no qualified Signal Inn sale between May 2021 and July 2025. A rental review written after the hurricanes shows guests staying at Signal Inn in 2024.

The October 2026 travel roundup

Florida Rambler's island recovery roundup, updated October 30, 2026, lists Signal Inn among the recent additions to places to stay on Sanibel and Captiva. That places the property back in rental use by late 2026.

What to ask about repairs

Ask the association for the scope of storm repairs to each building, the dates of the work, the permits on file with the City of Sanibel and any insurance claims. A unit's own repairs should also carry permits.

Assessments after the storms

Ask whether the association levied any special assessment after Ian, Helene or Milton, whether any is still being collected and whether the board expects more. Get the answer in writing.

The 2025 and 2026 seasons

No storm damage at Signal Inn was reported for the 2025 or 2026 seasons in the sources we read. That is not a statement about condition; inspect the unit and the buildings before you buy.

Florida condo law and insurance at Signal Inn

Florida's condominium laws changed several times after 2021, and the changes shape what a Signal Inn buyer should ask for. Some rules depend on building height, and the Signal Inn buildings are low-rise, so the questions below focus on whether each rule applies and on the documents that prove it.

Milestone inspections

Florida Statutes 553.899 requires milestone structural inspections for condominium buildings of three or more habitable stories. Under the 2025 changes in House Bill 913, ground floors used only for parking or storage do not count as habitable stories.

Structural integrity reserve studies

Florida Statutes 718.112 requires a structural integrity reserve study for the same class of buildings. Signal Inn's buildings have two living levels over parking, so they may fall below the three-story line for both rules. That is our reading, not a published finding, so ask the association for its counsel's or engineer's written position.

Reserves still matter

Even if the buildings are exempt from the reserve study, Florida's condominium law still requires a budget and allows reserves. Ask for the reserve schedule and how much is set aside for roofs, painting, decks and the pool.

The master insurance policy

Florida Statutes 718.111 sets the association's duty to insure the buildings. Ask for the current master policy, its carrier, the wind and flood coverage, the deductibles and how a deductible would be shared among owners after a storm.

Disclosure before a sale

Florida Statutes 718.503 lists what a seller must give a buyer of a resale condominium unit, including the declaration, bylaws, rules, the budget and the most recent financial report. A buyer has a short window to review those documents and cancel.

Renovation permits

Work inside a unit, from a new kitchen to new windows, usually needs a City of Sanibel permit and association approval. Ask the association for its alteration rules, and check the city's permit records for the unit you are buying.

Where is Signal Inn on Sanibel?

Signal Inn sits on the Gulf side of Sanibel's middle stretch, reached from Olde Middle Gulf Drive, with the beach on one side and Middle Gulf Drive and the shared-use path on the other. The approximate distances below come from rental location notes and broker pages, not a routing check of our own.

Destination Approximate distance or time Source type
Gulf beach On site, by boardwalk Broker pages
Gulfside City Park About a 3-minute walk Rental location notes
Periwinkle Way shops Within about 3 miles Rental location notes
Sanibel Island Golf Club Within about 3 miles Rental location notes
Page Field, Fort Myers About 16 miles Broker pages
Southwest Florida International Airport (RSW) About 20 miles, about 50 to 59 minutes by car Broker pages and rental notes
Punta Gorda Airport About 34 miles Broker pages

Sources: public broker and rental listing records read November 13, 2026. Times exclude causeway toll lines and winter traffic.

Getting on the island

Sanibel is reached from the mainland over the Sanibel Causeway, which carries a toll collected by Lee County. From the causeway, Periwinkle Way and then Middle Gulf Drive lead west to Olde Middle Gulf Drive.

Gulfside City Park

Gulfside City Park, also called Algiers Beach, is about a three-minute walk from Signal Inn according to rental notes. It is a city beach park with parking by permit or fee, so check the City of Sanibel's parking rules.

The refuge and preserves

The J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge and its Wildlife Drive lie on the bay side of the island, and island travel coverage lists the drive as reopened. The Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation runs preserves and trails across the island.

Shops and dining

Grocery, dining and shops cluster along Periwinkle Way. Rental notes put Doc Ford's Rum Bar and Grille about six minutes away by car and list a grocery store nearby.

Health care

There is no hospital on Sanibel. The nearest hospitals are on the mainland in Fort Myers, run by Lee Health. Plan for the causeway drive in any medical emergency.

Captiva to the north

Captiva Island lies at the northwest end of Sanibel, past Blind Pass. If you are comparing the two islands, see our Captiva Island homes for sale.

Schools serving Signal Inn addresses

Signal Inn is in the School District of Lee County, which assigns students through school zones and a choice process. Sanibel has one public school on the island, and high school students travel to the mainland. Confirm the assignment for 1811 Olde Middle Gulf Drive with the district before you rely on it.

The Sanibel School

The Sanibel School is the island's public school for kindergarten through grade 8. Check its current enrollment rules and calendar with the district.

High school

Sanibel students attend high school on the mainland. One portal lists Lee school-choice zones for Signal Inn as Elementary Zone N, Middle Zone L and High South Zone 5; confirm those with the district's lookup tool.

Private schools

Private schools are on the mainland in Fort Myers, among them Canterbury School and Fort Myers Christian School. Visit each school and check admission and transport for an island address.

Checking school grades

The Florida Department of Education publishes school grades each year. Look up any school you are weighing on its site, since grades change.

A short history of Signal Inn

Signal Inn's recorded history starts in the late 1970s, when the first buildings went up on the Gulf beach in mid-island Sanibel, and continues through the 1982 beach houses, decades as a beach resort and the storms of 2022 and 2024. The county sale file tracks its prices from the first sale in 1981 to the most recent one in 2025.

The 1979 buildings

Fifteen units carry a 1979 build year on the county roll: the twelve small flats and three larger units. The first qualified sale recorded on the county file was a 651 square foot flat in August 1981 at $154,900.

The 1982 beach houses

Units 16 to 19 carry a 1982 build year. The county file marks three first sales of those units, from August 1982 to March 1983, at $225,000 to $240,000.

Prices in the 1980s

The county recorded 19 qualified Signal Inn sales from 1981 to 1989, from $99,900 for a one-bedroom flat in May 1982 to $253,000 for a beach house in June 1986, at a $154,900 median.

Prices in the 1990s

Six qualified sales recorded from 1990 to 1999, from $190,000 to $405,000, at a $271,250 median.

Prices from 2000 to 2009

Eleven qualified sales recorded from 2000 to 2009, from $512,500 to $1,070,000, at a $650,000 median. The beach houses first crossed $1,000,000 in 2004.

Prices since 2010

Fourteen qualified sales recorded from 2010 to July 2025, from $330,000 to $1,100,000, at a $692,500 median.

A long-running beach resort

Signal Inn has operated as a small beach resort for decades, listed in an older Lee County visitors bureau document as the Signal Inn Beach and Racquetball Club. Island news in February 2024 reported a junonia shell found on the beach in front of Signal Inn by guests who had stayed there for years.

What should you check before you make an offer on a Signal Inn condo?

A Signal Inn offer goes better when the buyer has the right documents in hand before the inspection period runs out. The list below follows the questions this page could not answer from public records, and each one should be put to the seller, the association or the City of Sanibel in writing.

Get the budget and the minutes

Ask for the current budget, the reserve schedule, the last two years of minutes and the most recent financial statement. Those show what the dues pay for and what the board expects to spend.

Ask about assessments

Ask for a written list of every special assessment levied since 2022 and any under discussion. The estoppel certificate will show amounts due, but the minutes show what may be coming.

Read the rental and pet rules

Read the declaration and rules for the rental minimum, the number of rentals allowed, guest registration, pet limits and parking. Then check the unit's City of Sanibel rental license.

Get insurance quotes early

Get quotes for the unit's interior, contents, liability and flood coverage before the inspection period ends. Insurance cost on a Gulf-front unit can change a budget.

Confirm the plan and the area

Compare the county heated area, the listing area and what you measure. At Signal Inn the plans differ so much that a few square feet or a second bath can change the price you should pay.

Order an inspection

Hire a licensed home inspector to check the unit, and ask the association for any engineering reports on the buildings, the stairs, the decks and the roof.

Signal Inn and other Gulf-front condos buyers compare

Buyers who look at Signal Inn often look at the other Gulf-front condominiums along Middle Gulf Drive and Olde Middle Gulf Drive. The table below uses the Lee County Property Appraiser roll for unit counts, build years and heated area, so each complex is measured the same way.

Complex Units on the roll Built Heated sq ft on the roll
Signal Inn 19 1979 and 1982 527 to 2,400
Clamshell 6 1979 1,159 to 1,844
Sandpiper Beach 27 1979 1,005 to 1,071
Sanddollar 36 1978 and 1979 1,348 to 1,458
Gulfside Place 83 2005 and 2006 1,628 to 2,131

Source: Lee County Property Appraiser parcel roll, residential condominium unit parcels in ZIP 33957, index built November 18, 2026.

Sandpiper Beach next door

Sandpiper Beach condos sit just west of Signal Inn on Olde Middle Gulf Drive, with 27 units on the roll, all dated 1979. Its units fall in a narrow size band, while Signal Inn mixes very small flats with larger beach houses.

Sanddollar to the east

Sanddollar condos sit a short way east on Middle Gulf Drive, with 36 units in three-story buildings. A buyer weighing Signal Inn's small flats against a larger two- or three-bedroom flat will often tour both.

Gulfside Place

Gulfside Place condos are newer, with build years of 2005 and 2006 and larger units on the roll. The difference in age and size shows up in price, so compare recorded sales plan by plan.

What Signal Inn offers and what it does not

Signal Inn offers small Gulf-front flats that have recorded sales below $700,000 on the county file, a pet-friendly rental program and a small setting of 19 units. It does not offer elevators, golf, docks, new construction or large flats in every building.

Talk to a Domain Realty Group Signal Inn specialist

Domain Realty Group, the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, shows Signal Inn and other Gulf-front condominiums on Sanibel, and our Fort Myers office on College Parkway is the nearest of our offices to the causeway. We tracked every recorded Signal Inn sale since 2016 to the county roll by plan, and we can pull that record for any unit you are considering.

★★★★★ "Great experience! Marc went the extra mile to ensure you were happy. He kept in touch and was always available for any questions that can come up."

Verified Zillow review. Audrey Haas, on selling a condo in Bonita Springs with Marc Comisar.

Talk to our team about a Signal Inn unit

Contact Domain Realty Group or call 239-441-2816 with the plan, budget and rental plans you have in mind, and an agent will send matching listings, recorded sales of the same plan and the association questions for that unit. You can also search current listings at any time.

Thinking of selling a Signal Inn unit?

Signal Inn buyers compare a unit against recorded sales of the same plan, its rental history and its condition, so pricing a flat against the beach houses, or the other way round, can cost a seller time on the market. To plan a sale, start with selling a home on Sanibel or Captiva with McGreevy and Comisar.

Frequently Asked Questions about Signal Inn condos for sale

These are the questions buyers ask most about Signal Inn condos for sale, answered from the Lee County roll and sale files, the resort site, Florida statutes, City of Sanibel sources and public listing records. Where a fact could not be confirmed for this page, the answer says so in plain words.

What is Signal Inn on Sanibel?

Signal Inn is a Gulf-front condominium of 19 units at 1811 Olde Middle Gulf Drive in mid-island Sanibel, ZIP 33957. Its units sit in small two-story buildings raised over parking, and many of them are rented to vacation guests through an on-site rental program.

Where is Signal Inn?

Signal Inn is on the Gulf side of Sanibel's middle stretch, reached from Olde Middle Gulf Drive, between Clamshell and Sandpiper Beach. Rental notes put Gulfside City Park about a three-minute walk away and the Periwinkle Way shops within about three miles.

What ZIP code is Signal Inn in?

Signal Inn is in ZIP code 33957, the ZIP for all of Sanibel. It lies inside the City of Sanibel in Lee County, so city zoning, rental licensing and building rules apply along with the county's.

Is Signal Inn the same as the Sanibel Inn?

No. Signal Inn is the 19-unit condominium at 1811 Olde Middle Gulf Drive. The Sanibel Inn is a separate resort on another part of the island, with its own owners and records.

How many units does Signal Inn have?

Signal Inn has 19 units, numbered 1 to 19 on the Lee County roll and on the resort site, plus one common-area parcel for the shared land and amenities.

When was Signal Inn built?

The Lee County roll dates units 1 to 15 to 1979 and units 16 to 19 to 1982. The first qualified sale on the county file was recorded in August 1981.

Who built Signal Inn?

No public source we read names the developer. The declaration at Lee County Official Records Book 1506, Page 1828 and the first deeds at the Lee County Clerk are where to look.

How big are Signal Inn units?

The county roll lists six one-bedroom flats at 527 square feet, six two-bedroom flats at 651 square feet, units of 1,272 and 1,284 square feet, four beach houses at 1,537 square feet and one unit at 2,400 square feet.

How many bedrooms do Signal Inn units have?

Signal Inn units range from one bedroom to four on the county roll. Six units have one bedroom, nine have two, three have three and one has four, according to the roll.

Is Signal Inn on the beach?

Yes. Signal Inn is a Gulf-front property, and broker pages describe deeded beach access over boardwalks from the grounds to the sand.

Does Signal Inn have elevators?

No. The buildings have two living levels over ground-level parking and no elevator, according to broker surveys and listings, so every unit is reached by stairs.

Is there a pool at Signal Inn?

Yes. Every source lists a heated pool, one calls it solar-heated, and the resort site described it as recently refurbished. A hot tub is listed beside it.

Does Signal Inn still have a racquetball court?

Older broker pages describe an air-conditioned racquetball court. The current resort site does not mention it, so ask the association whether it still operates.

Is Signal Inn gated?

No source describes a gate at Signal Inn. It runs an on-site office for rental guests, so treat it as an open complex and ask the association about access rules.

What do Signal Inn condos sell for?

Lee County recorded six qualified Signal Inn sales from January 2016 to July 2025, from $485,000 for a one-bedroom flat to $1,100,000 for a three-bedroom beach house, at a $737,500 median. Price depends mostly on the plan.

What was the most recent Signal Inn sale?

The newest qualified sale on the Lee County file is a 651 square foot two-bedroom flat that sold for $685,000 on July 16, 2025.

What is the highest recorded Signal Inn sale?

The highest qualified sale on the county file is $1,100,000 for a 1,537 square foot three-bedroom beach house in March 2020.

How often do Signal Inn units sell?

Rarely. The county recorded 6 qualified sales from January 2016 to November 2026 and one in the 24 months from November 2024, with none between May 2021 and July 2025.

What are the Signal Inn association fees?

The association does not publish its fees. Listings show $1,686 and $2,745 labelled as annual for two units, and portals show other ranges, so the billing period is unclear. Ask for the current budget.

What does the association fee cover?

Portal pages say the fee covers grounds, irrigation, master property insurance, water, sewer, trash, pest control and the recreation facilities. Confirm the list against the association's budget.

Are there special assessments at Signal Inn?

No public record of a special assessment was found for this page. Ask the association for a written list of assessments levied since 2022 and any under discussion.

Is there a CDD at Signal Inn?

No community development district was identified for Signal Inn. Check the tax bill to confirm.

Who manages Signal Inn rentals?

Gulf Coast Vacation Rentals, based at 1101 Periwinkle Way on Sanibel, manages many Signal Inn units for rental owners and is named on the resort site.

Can I rent my Signal Inn unit?

Yes, many owners do. Most sources describe a 7-day minimum, and a City of Sanibel rental license is required. Confirm the minimum in the current association rules and the license type with the city.

What is the minimum rental at Signal Inn?

Most broker sources list a 7-day minimum, meaning weekly rentals, and one survey lists 3 days off season. Read the current rules to settle it.

Are pets allowed at Signal Inn?

Yes, according to the resort and broker pages, for owners and for vacation guests, with limits such as two pets on some units. Get the written pet rules before you buy. Assistance animal requests follow fair housing law, not the pet limits.

Is Signal Inn a 55 or older community?

No public source describes Signal Inn as a 55 or older community. Ask the association to confirm in writing.

Is Signal Inn in a flood zone?

Yes. All of Sanibel lies in FEMA special flood hazard areas, and a Gulf-front site may fall partly in a VE zone. The exact zone for Signal Inn was not confirmed for this page, so check the FEMA map and the elevation certificate.

Was Signal Inn damaged by Hurricane Ian?

No public report describes Ian damage at Signal Inn. Guests were staying there by 2024, and an October 2026 travel roundup lists it back in operation. Ask the association for the repair and assessment history.

Does Signal Inn need a milestone inspection?

Florida's milestone inspection and reserve study rules apply to condominium buildings of three or more habitable stories, not counting parking-only ground floors. Signal Inn's buildings have two living levels over parking, so they may be exempt; ask the association for written confirmation.

What are property taxes on a Signal Inn unit?

Listing records show 2024 taxes of about $6,396 for a two-bedroom flat and $12,747 for the 1,284 square foot unit. A buyer's tax is based on the new assessment after the sale, so check the Property Appraiser's record.

What schools serve Signal Inn?

Signal Inn is in the School District of Lee County. The Sanibel School serves kindergarten through grade 8 on the island, and high school students attend on the mainland. Confirm the assignment with the district.

How far is Signal Inn from the airport?

Southwest Florida International Airport is about 20 miles away, roughly 50 to 59 minutes by car, according to broker and rental pages. Causeway traffic in season can add time.

Where do I see Signal Inn condos for sale?

Our team posts active Signal Inn listings on our current listings search and sends new ones as they come on the market. Call 239-441-2816 or contact us to set up a search.

About Domain Realty Group on Sanibel

Domain Realty Group is a Southwest Florida real estate team covering Lee, Collier and Charlotte counties, Sanibel and Captiva included, and our Fort Myers office is the nearest of our offices to the Sanibel Causeway. Domain Realty Group has been the #1 team in Southwest Florida since 2012, with $2.5 billion in team production and 4,000+ transactions. Jesse McGreevy (SL3101296) and Marc Comisar (BK3060671) lead the team and bring over 45 years of combined direct experience.

Meet the team on our agents page, read our client reviews or learn more about our team. We tracked every recorded Signal Inn sale since 2016 to the county roll, plan by plan, to build this page.

Domain Realty Group 239-441-2816

Offices in Bonita Springs, Naples and Fort Myers:

  • Bonita Springs: 24031 S Tamiami Trl #101, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
  • Naples: 9180 Galleria Ct #200, Naples, FL 34109
  • Fort Myers: 8290 College Parkway, Unit 201, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Brokered by Domain Realty, a licensed Florida real estate brokerage. Florida Real Estate Commission (FREC) licensed. All agents are licensed Florida real estate professionals.

Where to go next: Sanibel real estate, Captiva Island homes for sale, Fort Myers homes for sale and current listings.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to one of the sources below. No real estate portal or other brokerage is linked, by policy; facts attributed to "listings", "broker pages", "portals" or "rental notes" come from public listing, broker and rental records read November 13, 2026 and are labelled as such. County sale data comes from the Lee County Property Appraiser's parcel roll and sale files, qualified sales on the 19 Signal Inn Condo unit parcels, index built November 18, 2026. Web sources were read November 13 to November 21, 2026 unless another date is shown.

County records

The resort, management and state records

Local news and travel coverage

City of Sanibel

Florida condominium law, taxes and fair housing

Flood, storms and insurance

Schools

Places, roads and services