An annual rental brings steady monthly rent from one tenant on a lease longer than six months, with no rental tax. A seasonal rental earns more of the year's rent in a few winter months from a furnished home you can still use yourself, and the guest pays 11% to 11.5% rental tax. The right one depends on whether you use the home, whether it is furnished and what your association allows.
Side by side
| Question | Annual | Seasonal |
|---|---|---|
| Length of stay | Written lease longer than 6 months, usually 12 | 30 consecutive nights to 6 months |
| Florida rental tax | None from day one (s. 212.03) | Lee 11.5%, Collier 11% in 2026, paid by the guest |
| Law that applies | Chapter 83, Part II | Usually Chapter 83 too, when the home is not a licensed vacation rental |
| Furnished | Usually not | Yes |
| Your own use | None while it is leased | The months it is not booked |
| How rent arrives | Monthly | Usually a booking deposit, then the balance before arrival |
| Turnover | Once a year or less | Every stay: cleaning, inventory, check-in |
| Association rules | Minimum lease and approval | Minimum lease, approval and often a limit on rentals per year |
| Flood disclosure | Required on leases of 1 year or longer (s. 83.512) | Not required under 1 year; still wise |
| Our manager | Matt Liguori | Jack Breyman |
When annual is the better choice
- You do not use the home yourself.
- You want the same rent every month and fewer turnovers.
- The home is unfurnished, or you would rather not furnish it.
- Your association requires leases longer than six months.
When seasonal is the better choice
- You spend part of the year in the home and want it earning while you are away.
- The home is furnished and in a community winter visitors look for.
- Your association allows stays of 30 days or more and enough rentals per year.
- You are comfortable with a booking calendar, turnovers and the guest's rental tax.
Questions owners ask before choosing
Does a seasonal rental earn more than an annual one?
It can collect more rent per month in season, but it rents for fewer months and carries furnishing, cleaning and utility costs that an annual tenant usually covers. Run both with your own numbers on the annual estimator and the season estimator.
Can I switch from seasonal to annual later?
Yes, between tenancies. A tenant already in place keeps the lease they signed.
What about stays shorter than 30 nights?
Those are transient vacation rentals under Chapter 509, with state licensing and different rules. Many associations do not allow them. They are not part of our annual or seasonal services.
Not sure yet?
Tell us about the home and we will lay out both. Jesse McGreevy reads every management request himself. Send a request, or call or text the team line, 239-441-2816.
Statutes: 2025 Florida Statutes on flsenate.gov; tax rates: Florida Department of Revenue DR-15TDT and DR-15DSS; checked 2026-10-07. Collier voters were asked on November 3, 2026 whether to raise the tourist development tax to 6% from January 1, 2027. General information, not legal or tax advice. Domain Realty Group, part of McGreevy and Comisar, a team at Domain Realty.
239-441-2816Search homes